3 ms·
Not defending apple for not paying artists, but I will defend their 'weaseling' out of US taxes. U.S. Corporate taxes are among the highest in the world and unt
by briandear 11y ago
Not defending apple for not paying artists, but I will defend their 'weaseling' out of US taxes. U.S. Corporate taxes are among the highest in the world and until Washington starts lowering their confiscatory tax rates, I would encourage all businesses to avoid repatriating earnings. A 10% tax rate is high enough.
- logicchains 11y agoUS taxes contribute more to violent deaths and unnecessary punishments/imprisonments per dollar than taxes paid in most other countries. The US spends a greater proportion of GDP on "defense" than almost all other Western countries, so a tax dollar paid in the US is more likely to contribute to "defense" and less likely to contribute to education, healthcare or whatnot than a tax dollar paid in e.g. Sweden or Holland. Similarly, the US has 25% of the world's prison population yet only 5% of its total population, so necessarily spends a relatively higher percentage of tax dollars on incarceration. There are actually people who do everything they can to minimise their tax liability in order to reduce the money spent on things they consider unjust: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_resistance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_resistance. Every dollar not paid in US tax is a dollar that won't contribute to blowing up people in the Middle East who have the misfortune of being in proximity to suspected terrorists (tens of thousands of people over the past decade) [1]. Similarly, every dollar not paid in US tax is a dollar that won't be spent putting poor people in prison for smoking a weed that causes less violence in a decade than alcohol causes in a day. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualties_in_the_war_in_Afghanistan_%282001%E2%80%93present%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualties_in_the_war...
- programmernews3 11y agoI hope the people who are avoiding tax are donating their avoided taxes to their local schools and hospitals.
- sanswork 11y agoWhere is the western world has lower tax rates than the US? Edit: answered above.
- fordh 11y agoI was curious and looked up this claim. Turns out PolitiFact looked into it: http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/sep/09/eric-bolling/does-us-have-highest-corporate-tax-rate-free-world/ http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/sep/09/... The conclusion: Bolling said the United States has "the highest corporate tax rate in the free world." He was referring to the statutory rate, meaning the rate before deductions. On that score, he’s right: The United States does have the highest statutory rate among developed countries. However, the United States’ corporate tax rate doesn’t appear to be the highest once deductions and other exclusions are taken into account. I found it an interesting article so I decided to share.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nicolas_t 11y agoThere's also some countries that have relatively "low tax rate" but very high social security costs which are not always counted as tax rates by studies.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoAnd not all those costs can be credited against US taxes on repatriation, so double taxation scenarios exist.
- adventured 11y agoThe US effective corporate tax rate tends to be 25% to 27% in normal times, which is still one of the highest effective tax rates in the world. The median S&P 500 effective tax rate is 30%, also one of the highest rates in the world. You often see 12% or 13% bandied about as the effective rate, but that's intentional intellectual fraud: they refer to 2010 numbers, when the US was coming out of the great recession and corporations had lost a ton of money.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- RexRollman 11y agoI agree with corporations who attempt to legally pay as little taxes as possible. That's what I do. If someone doesn't like it, then get the laws changed.
- jjoonathan 11y agoChanging the laws requires a sizable investment in lobbyists and bribe money before any ROI can be achieved. Most individuals simply don't have enough taxable income to make the investment worthwhile. Megacorps do. The situation is not morally symmetrical and not practically symmetrical.
- hobs 11y agoYeah, why dont the poor and downtrodden just pay their lobbyists to change the law of the land... what? The corporations have the money and the drive to get the laws changed, who else does?
- WorldWideWayne 11y agoI was hoping someone would start a popular kickstarter style site for this. It seems pretty simple to me. If you want your laws changed, pool your money and go lobby the gov't just like every other corporation.
- nona 11y agoYeah! None of this one-man-one-vote crap, back to some good old fashioned plutocracy. After all if the top 10-20% own 90% of the wealth, it's only right and proper that they also own an equivalent share of the political power. ;-)
- icebraining 11y agoNobody said it was right, just that it's less bad than having just the rich lobbying.
- evunveot 11y ago
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoHow come 10% is high enough for corporations but I pay a lot more than that in income taxes. Shouldn't it be the other way around?
- jannotti 11y agoI think it could be either way, but many object to the fact that it is both. In other words, corporate tax is seen as double taxation, since the earnings (after taxes) are then passed on to shareholders, who pay tax on it again. I could see a coherent tax code that taxes corporations, but not individuals, or one that taxed individuals, but not corporations (Of course with either of these there would no doubt be all sorts of new loopholes to deal with). But taxing both seems odd to me.
- jjoonathan 11y agoIf there are loopholes allowing corporations to not actually pay their taxes and the capital gains tax rate is a fraction of the income tax rate, is it really fair to call it double taxation?
- samuellevy 11y agoI'm not sure how the tax system works in the US, but I was just talking to my accountant about this issue the other day. In Australia, my company gets taxed at a flat 30% on all profits in a year. If I want to take cash out of the company after that tax has been taken, I pay "top-up" tax that brings the total tax paid to the level of my income tax rate. For example, if the company earned $10000, after all expenses, then it would pay $3000 in tax, leaving $7000 left that I can take out. If I earned no money in the year, my income tax rate is 0%, so the top-up tax is -$3000 (I.e. I get a tax refund for $3000). If I earned $50000 in the year, then my income tax rate is 32.5%, so I would have to pay top-up tax of $250 (I.e. 2.5% of the original $10000, which has already been taxed 30%). Double taxation shouldn't happen, and while my company was set up for tax minimisation purposes, international corporations are able to do an insane level of fuckery to avoid almost all taxation.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y ago
- yequalsx 11y agoNice usage of the word 'confiscatory'. My experience with people who use this word in relation to taxation is that they use it in derogatory sense and is used primarily by conservatives and libertarians. I don't know if that is the case for you. What do you consider the optimal corporate tax rate? You said 10% is high enough. Do you think it should be 0%? If you are in the libertarian and/or conservative branch of U.S. politics why do you look to other countries' tax rates for guidance on what our tax rates ought to be? I have been under the impression that looking to other countries for guidance on our social policy is bad and contrary to the notion of exceptionalism. The U.S. uniquely, I believe, considers corporations persons. Hence the Citizens United decision. Given this shouldn't the tax rate on these citizens be the same as on other citizens with like earnings?
- comex 11y agoThere is no sense setting up a strawman about a topic, exceptionalism, which the parent did not even raise or mention. Blaming Citizens United (certainly a harmful decision) on corporate personhood is, while popular, unduly reductive; the actual ruling was more about freedom of association. Even in the context of the debate about corporate personhood, your rhetorical question about tax rate is pure demagogy.
- yequalsx 11y agoHave you ever heard of someone refer to taxes as confiscatory and it be the case that that person is not a conservative or a libertarian who holds the beliefs mention in my post? I haven't but I did acknowledge that perhaps those beliefs were not shared by the person I responded to. Thus the questions I asked. It was not demagoguery. The argument was quite rational. People who refer to taxes as confiscatory rather than as being too high are attempting to frame the topic of taxation as it being, necessarily, wrong. It's a ridiculous starting point. These same people almost always scoff at arguments that the U.S. ought to adopt some social policies because all other industrialized nations have them. It is, with this fact in mind, quite rational to ask why looking at the corporate tax rate of other countries is a good argument. Why is it demagoguery to ask why a person in the form of a corporation should pay less in taxes than a person in the form of a human?
- toddmorey 11y agoI think in some ways, you have a fiduciary responsibility to your shareholders to use reasonable means to maximize the value of your company. It seems to me that includes both operational efficiency and prudent use of available tax breaks. I'm uncomfortable with the line of reasoning that we "can't do anything until we change the system," but I do wonder how Wall Street would react to a company that decided for moral reasons to avoid the schemes and pay more taxes.
- cdash 11y agoExcept you actually don't and this has been a myth that has continued to plague any type of discussions like this.
- TYPE_FASTER 11y agohttps://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_Effective_Corporate_Tax_Rate_1947-2011_v2.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_Effective_Corpora...