10 ms·
EFF, CloudFlare Asks Court Not to Force the Internet to Enforce Trademarks
- rdl 11y agoI had no idea there was no concept of "safe harbor" with respect to trademark. The especially bad part here is while copyright seems to benefit small and large players alike (while imposing costs on small and large players), trademark benefits accrue primarily to big players, and costs to small players and individuals.
- asift 11y agoWhy do you feel copyright benefits small and large players alike? I agree the relative advantages of some forms of IP are greater than others, but the scales seem to be tipped towards large players in most cases.
- eli 11y agoCopyright is the basis of GPL and similar open source licenses, for one example.
- shard972 11y agoBut if copyright didn't exist then there would be no purpose for the GPL.
- eli 11y agoBut I want to be able to require that people who redistribute my code also provide the source.
- beedogs 11y agoMost of the time, GPL code is stolen without the person who wrote it even being aware. And most of the time they become aware of it, there isn't a whole lot they can do to stop it.
- thrownaway122 11y agoPlease define stolen here? I highly doubt that most GPL code is 'stolen' according to the actual terms laid out in the GPL.
- arfar 11y agoI don't understand this. If there were no copyright, people would be able to copy everything they see anywhere and never be forced to disclose their changes like they do with the GPL, which is at least one intention of GPL. GPL relies on copyright completely, if it didn't exist, I would guess the FSF would come up with some alternative like basing contribution/releases/disclosure/etc around contract law.
- Dylan16807 11y agoThe ideal outcome for that point of view is that it would be a direct legal requirement that software is distributed in preferred modifiable form. No licenses or contracts necessary.
- briandear 11y agoI highly disagree. My little company, iCouch has a registered trademark. With that protection, we've been able to easily fend off infringement and potential infringement from some rather large players. If, hypothetically, Apple were to attempt to use that name, it would instantly destroy our brand value that we've spent over 5 years building (in the behavioral health tech industry.) a little guy having IP protection prevents and has prevented getting steamrolled by a much better funded company. Without that protection we'd have a huge exposure to our brand being co-opted either intentionally or not by another company. Copyright and trademark protection is especially valuable for the little guy; even more so that someone who could 'win' by simply having a massive marketing budget. There's an almost visceral opposition to IP protection among some factions on HN; but imagine if every time you start a company, a competitor instantly starts using your name. Imagine if every piece of content you create is instantly cloned by a competitor. You'd never be able to succeed because you'd have no way to differentiate yourself from the other company of the exact same name doing the exact same thing as you using your exact code and selling to your customers using your information. It's kind of like a world with absolutely zero friction.
- arfar 11y agoIANAL, but I know I do know a little bit about this stuff. Don't take this as legal advice. I'm sorry to say this, but the Apple scenario you've set out isn't always going to be true. There's a thing called "Reverse Confusion" which says effectively (in my non-lawery words): Why should some tiny wee company stop the well established brand reputation of a larger company? Big company has so much goodwill and reputation under this mark (from overseas or something like that), they should be able to use it. On the face of it, it doesn't make much sense, but there's case law around it. If you're worried about something like that, definitely talk to a lawyer. Obviously this depends entirely on where you live and your local laws, but this case has come up in New Zealand very recently (I think it might still be being tried) with Uber. The taxi company were still able to use their trade mark, even though someone already had a mark in a vaguely similar domain before Uber were even around. here's the first link I found on it if you wanted to read up about it more. http://definitions.uslegal.com/r/reverse-confusion-trademark/ http://definitions.uslegal.com/r/reverse-confusion-trademark...
- rdl 11y agoI didn't mean that it benefits them equally, just that both players can accrue some benefits; vs. trademark which necessarily only applies to entities with a trademark. The consumer-protection aspect of trademark (preventing deceptive goods) is clearly not what this is about. It is using a thin layer of trademark veneer to force this into an already-rejected legal hole.
- grabeh 11y agoThere is a safe harbor (s.230 Communications Decency Act), however that would protect you in relation to a direct allegation of infringement. Here there is no allegation, rather the record company is bypassing the above section by suggesting Cloudflare are in active participation/concert with the owner of the site. I think the error in the case is really determining that CF are in active concert with Grooveshark. Like EFF say, it shifts the obligation to determine infringement on to the wrong person. Even the proposed solution (having a record company notify CF regarding infringement) is flawed. CF are still in the position of either a) automatically complying or b) expending resources determining whether it is appropriate to take down, leaving you in a similar position to previously.
- rayiner 11y agoThe EFF is fighting for the right thing here, but it loses credibility when it mischaracterizes legal procedure to make things look extra-scary. E.g. > Often this order is initially drafted by the entertainment companies. Courts usually require parties making a motion for some relief to submit a proposed order that has the desired effect. It saves time and makes it clear to the court exactly what the party is asking it to do. The article also uses the phrase "secret order" like a million times. Obviously they're not secret because links are posted right in the article. What they're talking about is a (temporarily) sealed temporary restraining order. 15 USC 1116(d)(8) states: "An order under this subsection, together with the supporting documents, shall be sealed until the person against whom the order is directed has an opportunity to contest such order, except that any person against whom such order is issued shall have access to such order and supporting documents after the seizure has been carried out." If you read two provisions before that, 15 USC 1116(d)(6), you find why the order is sealed: "The court shall take appropriate action to protect the person against whom an order under this subsection is directed from publicity, by or at the behest of the plaintiff, about such order and any seizure under such order."
- eli 11y agoI noticed this with another EFF post earlier this year. I'm sure this sort of dire tone plays well on Reddit, but I hope it's not becoming a strategy.
- urda 11y ago> I'm sure this sort of dire tone plays well on Reddit Same here too, Hacker News is not invulnerable to the same tactic. To think otherwise is foolish.
- wmf 11y agoRemember when SOPA was "breaking the Internet"? There's nothing new about the EFF's sky-is-falling rhetoric. It's just activists being activists.
- Karunamon 11y ago
- leereeves 11y ago> the court said that CloudFlare has to block every user with a domain name that contains “grooveshark,” no matter who owns the site What is the legal basis for this? "Grooveshark" is long and unique, but by this principle, could King.com shut down every domain that contains the word "candy"?
- JohnTHaller 11y agoThey've gone after every game that uses the word 'saga', so they might try to.
- themartorana 11y agoAs have Zynga with "With Friends" and Scopely with "With Buddies" and Microsoft with "Windows" or MikeRoweSoft [0]... You can quickly lose a trademark if you don't actively defend it (weird, considering patents and copyrights) so companies quickly get over zealous. That said... For reasons that defy explanation, courts have been known to uphold trademark protections for common words ("Windows") even though trademark law explicitly forbids trademarks on common language words and phrases. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_vs._MikeRoweSoft https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_vs._MikeRoweSoft
- grabeh 11y agoTrade mark law does not forbid trade marks on common language words and phrases. It generally prevents people from registering 'descriptive' or 'non-distinctive' words/phrases as trade marks. "Windows" is descriptive for glazing supplies so wouldn't be registrable. "Windows" for software is distinctive and there is no public interest in it remaining free for anyone to use, unlike the case with the glazing example.
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>You can quickly lose a trademark if you don't actively defend it (weird, considering patents and copyrights) so companies quickly get over zealous. // It's oft repeated but not true AFAICT. Genericisation can be a problem, but another company using something as a trademark for a distinct type of good/service won't make your mark more generic. You lose a registered trademark by not paying your renewal fee. If you wanted to codify someone else's use then you could grant them a license, you don't have to sue them or start infringement proceedings or whatever. You're free to ignore one infringement and pursue another. This is like saying you have to prosecute every person who steps on your land or you lose the right to prosecute trespassers; if you allow a right of way to be established then yes that's probably not going to help you. But you're allowed to let someone in to your garden and you're allowed not to sue people who make incidental incursions.
- istvan__ 11y agoI would just add a rule into the loadbalancer config, if the request is coming from the music industry or a government agency redirect them to an empty website. (I am kidding).
- lugg 11y agoI wish you weren't. Seriously, if we can't vote people in to make sane choices with policies, lock them out. It might sound stupid, but they would at least have to learn a little bit about the internet before they made their next move.
- Natsu 11y agoIf you want to do one better, put up something like "website blocked" as if it were some overzealous corporate firewall deciding that the site was bad. With any luck, they'll think it's their own fault.
- istvan__ 11y agoThis is brilliant!!! :)
- Natsu 11y agoBonus points if you have the site blocked under the 'file sharing' category or something like that :)
- istvan__ 11y agoI was kinda curious, is it legal to put that picture on your website on your own?
- Natsu 11y agoIf you're copying logo or using someone else's trademark from a real firewall page, that's a bad idea. But it can't be too hard to create a generic 'block' page that looks similar enough to real ones without using anyone else's images or logos to be convincing.
- cbr 11y agoTrademarks are generally restricted to a single domain [1], which would mean that these music companies would only have rights to the Grooveshark mark when used in a music context. If there's a company out there that sells a product for grooving pavement that they call "Grooveshark" and sell it on groovesharkpaving.com then there's no domain overlap, but the court's order still asks CloudFlare to block them. [1] Business context, not domain name. So "computers", or "food".
- briandear 11y agoYou are absolutely correct, however one would need to examine the filing classes to be sure because if any part of the trademark class includes "xyz delivered over the Internet," then they could potentially have a claim to any possible use. However, I would love to start a mountaineering equipment company called GrooveShark and see what would happen when I file a trademark. I could potentially then have ISPs block the so-called 'real' GrooveShark for infringing on my equally valid mark. I could potentially use the case law from the current case as a legal argument to block the other GrooveShark. That might be fun.
- jfoutz 11y agok.c seems like a much cooler trademark. you can still take a swing at grooveshark.com, and if you have any money left, you can head over to facebook.com
- MichaelCrawford 11y agoThe Supreme Court of Canada ruled that any business may call itself "McDonalds" provided it not sell hamburgers. Perhaps you can see where I am going here.
- kriro 11y agoThis is correct in theory but in practice the "specific context" is often ignored when suing or has been overruled. Apple has sued all sorts of companies that are not even in the broad IT domain (e.g. restaurants) for supposed trademark violations. Legislature is quite different in Germany (Roman Law vs Common Law etc. but AFAIK this clause also exists in German law) but they sued Apfelkind, a mom and pop restaurant business, for example.
- smutticus 11y agoI don't know why the EFF is praising ICANN for not becoming the Internet's trademark enforcer. Every new gTLD must deal with the Trademark Clearinghouse. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trademark_Clearinghouse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trademark_Clearinghouse
- bcg1 11y ago"I would encourage you to support any proposal that would result in the maximum engagement by the MPAA in Internet governance. Of all the things we do to protect our industry, this one is fundamental. Ron Wheeler put it well when he said if we’re not there we don’t count." - https://wikileaks.org/sony/emails/emailid/112456 https://wikileaks.org/sony/emails/emailid/112456
- contingencies 11y agoFor context, that was one (US) Sony Pictures and Entertainment (which is specifically the US wing of Sony dealing with content production and licensing) executive emailing another in June 2014, as leaked via Wikileaks. IIRC Sony is not one of the larger studios, so if we learn anything it is that this degree of scheming is present even in the tiny cutesy wee little megacorps. Incidentally, in another of Wikileaks' public interest projects, consider pledging some cash to uncover TPP @ https://wikileaks.org/pledge/ https://wikileaks.org/pledge/
- digital-rubber 11y agoIt would be nice if cloudflare would take some responsibility for all the crap they transport and then say 'Oh but we don't host it' so we are not the right party to contact. Take some responsibility for the customers you take on and the crap they pump out to the internet. But everything for some $$ i guess.
- yabatopia 11y agoThis case is another example that secret court orders have no place in a democracy. This practice has to stop before it becomes even more widespread in the USA, the UK and other European countries.