7 ms·
This paperwork is standard. I strongly disagree. It's not unusual for a new employer to try to pull a fast one here, but IME the actual standard among reasonab
by Silhouette 11y ago
This paperwork is standard.
I strongly disagree. It's not unusual for a new employer to try to pull a fast one here, but IME the actual standard among reasonable employers and employees involves wording like "in the course of your employment" or the local equivalent. In short, what you do on company time, with company resources, or in connection with your work at the company is theirs, but anything else is yours by default. This sort of arrangement protects their interests just fine without granting them unnecessary and unreasonable control over their employees' lives outside work, at which point whether the employer is trying to screw the employee on this or not is academic because they have no contractual ability to do so.
- pvg 11y agoWell, I guess I strongly disagree that it's 'not unusual' for employers to try to 'pull a fast one'. This sort of agreement is standard precisely because it gives both parties a way to protect themselves and delineate what belongs to whom. Bad things happen when you don't have such an agreement. Perhaps things are different in the UK, but I'll echo what 'borksi said downthread - just about every software job in the US will come with such an 'Assignment of Inventions' bit of paper.
- Silhouette 11y agoThis sort of agreement is standard precisely because it gives both parties a way to protect themselves and delineate what belongs to whom. But it doesn't. What it does is make the employer win by default, even for things that have nothing to do with the job. Given the dramatic power imbalance that almost certainly exists between employer and employee anyway, this is the wrong way around. In fact, it's such a bad idea that there is now statute law on the books in various jurisdictions -- including, as I understand it, some states in the USA -- explicitly to nullify such terms in employment contracts.
- pvg 11y agoThis is such a bad idea [...] I'm afraid this matches neither my experience and, I'm willing to bet, the experience of just about everyone who's worked in the field in the US in the last couple of decades. Again, I know nothing about how things work in the UK. In the US, this stuff is a formality akin to all the other formalities of an employment contract, say, your tax, 401k and health insurance forms.
- crdoconnor 11y ago"Just a formality" or "standard" is how 100% of abusive contractual terms are described. The fact it is common (and, sadly, it is) does not mean it is right.
- pvg 11y agoI'm not entirely sure of your statistics but I'd urge you to consider that 'standard' and 'just a formality' is also how very nearly 100% of things that are actually standard and a formality are also described.
- crdoconnor 11y ago"Just a formality" = "it's meaningless" Well, if it's meaningless you can take it out. So suggest that. You'll quickly find out when you suggest that, that "just a formality" usually translates as "ok, maybe it's not such a formality after all, but just sign the damn thing already please". Red flag, in other words. Similarly, "standard" is another ridiculous term to use in contracts. There are no "standard" contractual clauses, there are only common contractual clauses, and "common" does not necessarily mean "reasonable". There are plenty of very common and highly unreasonable clauses like the one the OP complained about. Both terms are examples of weasel words when used in the context of contracts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weasel_word https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weasel_word
- pvg 11y ago"Just a formality" = "it's meaningless" I never said that. So your rephrasing my words into something I did not say and then wikipediaing me about 'weasel words' seems particularly ill-placed and insulting.
- gkop 11y agoSilhouette's point is that the good employers use language that qualifies the inventions to which they are entitled: on company time or equipment and relevant to the company's business, etc..
- pvg 11y agoOr, instead of that, they hand you a piece of paper where you get to list your inventions. Which is much simpler, less prone to misinterpretation and perhaps a reason why everyone does it that way.
- gkop 11y agoHehe, my point was that both qualifying language and an explicit list are not mutually incompatible; in fact we have both in my current assignment of inventions agreement.
- pvg 11y agoOh, I have no trouble believing that. It's certainly possible to write a more humane AoI. But the purpose of these is mostly to make sure that they don't matter, so I was hoping to reassure the OP that (with basic care) such agreements don't matter and that the 'get a lawyer' and 'this isn't how it is in the UK' pitchfork crowd is simply wrong. If you have a nicer, professionally-vetted, less scary-sounding AoI, that's terrific. I'd encourage you to post it somewhere as a template.
- crdoconnor 11y agoPerhaps instead of that, they should give you a list of inventions which they own and you sign that, and anything else that you come up with on your own time is yours. It's ultimately about power. You rely upon the company for sustenance, it doesn't rely upon you. That manifests in contractual terms which are basically designed to give the company license to completely screw you.
- Silhouette 11y ago
- rmc 11y ago> it gives both parties a way to protect themselves and delineate what belongs to whom Some contracts state "The company owns everything you do, even in your spare time". I can't see how this protects the employee at all.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoAs will the UK and if the contract is silent custom and practice applies.
- arethuza 11y agoJust because something is in an employment contract doesn't mean it is enforceable.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoTrue but 1 how do you as a civillain know which ones aren't enforceable (justicable) 2 can you afford to fight an employers
- arethuza 11y agoSorry - I should have mentioned I'm married to a litigation lawyer. Mind you - I still got a separate employment lawyer from her firm that she recommended to help me negotiate a separation from a previous employer and that worked out really well. So yes - I'd strongly agree with the overall sentiment that anyone with contractual issues with an employer speak to a employment lawyer. Interestingly enough in some situations UK law requires that the employer pays for the legal advice...