8 ms·
Is Social Rejection the Key to Creativity?
- smil 11y agoPursuing original ideas, aka creativity, leads to social rejection. There's only so many times you can stand ridicule and disbelief before you disengage.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sridca 11y agoIt was the other way around for me. Early childhood to high-school social rejection (via peer-bullying and such) naturally led me to focus on "things" and ideas thereby being creative with them. However, being creative with "things" as opposed to people does lead to further social rejection thus reinforcing the formed identity. I guess this is how the nerd/geek identity is formed and maintained?
- sliverstorm 11y agoAh yes, the "They reject me because they are too stupid to appreciate my brilliance" theory. Occasionally accurate, usually ego-stroking.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoAh yes, the "he/she must think they are rejected because others are too stupid to appreciate their brilliance" theory. Occasionally accurate, usually just used to bully those who think a bit differently.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- holdenc 11y agoThis article deals with a romanticised and populist interpretation of creativity. Linking creativity and rejection is likely comforting to many isolated and rejected creatives. And while the Van Gogh archetype is a familiar one, it's important to understand that Van Gogh is the exception not the rule. Within the fine arts there are few similar examples. Picasso and Matisse were popular, social and anything but rejected or isolated (even in the beginning). Since 1945 hardly a single contemporary artist has achieved significant fame after death, with the vast majority of great contemporary artists actively engaged in dialogue with others.
- waterlesscloud 11y ago"Since 1945 hardly a single contemporary artist has achieved significant fame after death, with the vast majority of great contemporary artists actively engaged in dialogue with others." Doesn't that have a great deal more to do with the art industry than creativity itself?
- voidz 11y agoI thought so too! Well then, I suppose at least we're both creative enough to come to the same question.
- Animats 11y ago"Since 1945 hardly a single contemporary artist has achieved significant fame after death..." Elvis dead has made more money than Elvis alive. (Leading to litigation amongst the heirs.)
- coldtea 11y agoHe means artist as in "fine arts" as he explains above.
- dang 11y agoPopular artists can be solitary too. Consider Rilke.
- mpdehaan2 11y agoYep. Free time might be required, and there's danger in groupthink absolutely, but you can just ignore the noise of the group, rather than avoid the group. Be with the crowd sometime but not all the time. As there's also things to be learned from other people too. And it's great being able to be your own person and ignore that crowd. Given, I greatly prefer Van Gogh to Picasso and Matisse, it's probably just as likely his mental state were an influence of his art, not the whole loneliness thing. Drawing the conclusion the other way seems dangerous, to encourage isolation. However it's good to say it's not ok, or not one's fault. It's hard especially due to 'fake socialization' like Facetube and such, smartphones, and people's busy isolated schedules involving central air conditioning to expand a circle of people you know. It seems dangerous to say to be creative you must be lonely, it's very wrong. Yet it's also wrong to say it's wrong to be lonely, because of factors that make it a really hard thing. I think we need to suggest to other people that aren't so isolated to reach out and be friendly to more people. In the south (of the US) it used to be increasingly common for people to say hi to people they met out walking, and increasingly as people move in from other places, it's rare when someone says hi back. Then people go back into their houses and you don't see them again. The problems that cause society to be isolating are somewhat improveable, but it requires awareness of it. I think it's possible Van Gogh didn't really want to be isolated, but that was his way of justifying it and being ok with it, and that his feelings of isolation were rooted in deeper problems. We'll never know. But if you are feeling isolated or whatever, don't feel you have to be that way. It's not your fault though something you have to fight for (because everybody is caught up in doing whatever they are doing), it's everybody else's fault to a degree, and you can be creative either way.
- karmacondon 11y agoInteresting ideas, but Betteridge wins again. No hard data is provided, so anecdotes can be answered with anecdotes and the whole thing's a wash. From everything I've read about creativity, one of the keys seems to be thinking about things differently than one normally thinks about them. This can mean intense states of depression, mania, loneliness or relationship. Any state of mind that's different and extreme can shift perspective enough to cause some people to be exceptionally creative, at least for a time. It's herding cats, though. There are no proven techniques that will make someone more creative, only strategies that will work some times for some people. The best way to be more creative is to constantly try to create new things. Social rejection isn't a prerequisite for that.
- cJ0th 11y agoI agree. The article has to lack data as that's the reason for why we are so impressed by creativity. 'True creativity' (as opposed to opposed to the shallow "We have to think outside the box" type of creativity) can not be measured by definition. That's what makes it so intriguing! As soon as something can be fully measured it becomes debatable whether it is still a creative effort or not. If you accept what I wrote above then the headline of the article appears even more bonkers: How can something that is so complex that we can not fully measure it (yet) be caused (mostly) by a one-dimensional factor? I mean, sure, you could find a single factor if it is very vague one but that's not helpful. I.e. I could say: Being alive is a key factor for creativity. What's more, social rejection is surely also a key factor for becoming a dull person who watches TV all day.
- VLM 11y ago"the whole thing's a wash" Truth. However, alternative theoretical models can be constructed for possible experimental tests or at least anecdote collection. Surely all progress comes from the unreasonable man. Also we only hear about the most famous / rich creative geniuses. I have no particular problem switching off creativity and hanging out (going hiking or something), I am also not famous, not even internet famous. That would lead to the theoretical model that famous people can't shut off their unreasonableness, perhaps at all, which makes them completely cantankerous and anti-social yet also somewhat more productive than better balanced individuals. All kinds of interesting experiments could be devised. Are they able to shut anything at all off, or are they OCD/addicted personalities? If someone who can shut off is converted intentionally or otherwise into someone who looses control of their creativity, are they more successful? College binge drinking to emulate an alcoholic might be monkey see monkey do emulation of creatives... does someone naturally somewhat creative who gains an uncontrollable addiction have the bleed over into uncontrollable creativity? Another interesting model revolves around the only socially rejected people the general public ever hears about, are the top of the line creatives. That probably tells a lot more about our culture than about the individuals. For example, I suspect the panhandler at my freeway onramp is socially rejected, at least by most, its just "we" will never hear about him unless he becomes a famous painter or poet. Given his cardboard signs I think he's not creative at all, at least not WRT the graphical arts, yet he's got more rejection than most of us. IF most people are socially rejected to some extent or another, thats kind of the purpose of mass media and big cities after all, and the only rejects we hear about are creatives, then a very weird conclusion could be drawn that creativity only comes from rejection, although the reality is almost everyone is somewhat rejected. Much like they all drink water and all creatives drink water so creativity obviously comes from drinking water.
- gopalv 11y agoNo. Those that try to "fit in" might not be the right people to produce revolutionary ideas. And those who don't already fit in have the least to lose by inviting rejection by being off-the-norm. Add those two together, you have an intersection of those folks who don't fit in today and have nothing to lose by chasing their dream, choosing to chase their dreams instead of potential social acceptability. Orthogonal and rational choices, even if those that always did this wasn't being rational.
- onislandtime 11y agoand this what we see in most tech companies, they go out of the way to hire people that "fit". I wonder how much talent we leave out because of people's natural tendency to hire people like themselves...
- untog 11y agoNo. At best maybe indirectly - having a lot of time on your hands and being very bored is often the key to creativity, and being socially rejected will give you that. But I wouldn't start using this article a way to convince yourself it's OK to be antisocial because you're an undiscovered genius.
- Kiro 11y agoYou make it sound like it's not OK to be antisocial.
- eivarv 11y agoIt's not, though. Being asocial, on the other hand, is not quite as frowned upon;)
- Kiro 11y agoOh, I see. I thought antisocial was the same thing as asocial. My mistake, sorry!
- eivarv 11y agoNothing to be sorry about, it's a very common mistake. And to be completely frank, "antisocial" seems to be losing the battle against descriptivism, much like "literally" [0, 1] :P [0]: "1.1 informal" http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/literally?q=literally http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/literal... [1]: "2 : in effect" http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/literally http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/literally
- wemysh 11y agoThis title speaks to me, because lonely and creative are two of my main traits. I created so many projects, mostly startups, that people often can hardly believe it. Some of these have been successful, so I am leading an financial independent life. People constantly say that my work is based on unbelievable creativity. Yet, I am completely isolated. With people, it just does not work. In no setting. Love, friends, business, family - you name it. I do not have a single person I am close with. The strange thing is - even though I consider myself very smart - I never was able to figure out why. People just disappear. Do not have time for me. Do not call me back. When I ask them straight away "is it because I am a somehow unpleasant person?" they say stuff like "No, I was just busy. And I am still busy. Bye.". I wonder if I will ever find out, what the underlying cause is.
- onislandtime 11y agoYou are not alone in feeling lonely. I suggest you try talking to a psychotherapist to help you answer those questions.
- wemysh 11y agoI did that a couple of times. It helped me to understand myself and others a bit better.
- fit2rule 11y agoMaybe you're just too brilliant, and when people are around you the light shines brightly in their eyes, so they hide to shield themselves from it ..
- tekacs 11y agoIn a perverse way this is a succinct restatement of what others have said in sibling comments about the GP needing to make themselves more vulnerable (and less intimidating, when they are seeing successes most people never see). Whether or not the sibling commenters are right, I won't opine on. :)
- mercer 11y ago
- afro88 11y agoWell, no. I've been reading this book about the daily schedules of the greats [1] and there are many artists who had very active social lives while in their prime. Some more so than others - Francis Bacon would wake at 7am and work hard until lunchtime, when he'd share a bottle of wine with a friend in his studio and then drink, eat and party until the middle of the next morning, getting to bed at 3am. Rinse and repeat. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Daily-Rituals-How-Artists-Work/dp/0307273601 http://www.amazon.com/Daily-Rituals-How-Artists-Work/dp/0307...
- cubix 11y agoI wish I could function competently on 4 hours of sleep, let alone write world changing philosophical treatises.
- krrrh 11y agoNot to get off track, but the book looks at Francis Bacon the 20th century painter, not the 16th century philosopher. I once had a confusing conversation with a room full of artists before I realized that we had no idea who the "other" Francis Bacon was.
- golergka 11y agoI would like to imagine what that conversation be like for the "France is Bacon" guy.
- ssalazar 11y agoIf we're talking strictly about artists, he probably means [1] rather than [2]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Bacon_(artist) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Bacon_(artist) [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Bacon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Bacon
- orph 11y agoI cannot recommend this simple book enough.
- voidz 11y agoFrom van Gogh to Huxley, and lots of subjective questions but it's lacking data. So we can't answer this empirically, or at least, the article doesn't. And it's hard to read because of it, just jumping around the various, well, anekdotes. I guess the only really valid answer that follows is this: "who knows..."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- enedil 11y agoSocial rejentom is highly connected with creativity - and not because one has more time to make art. Creativity is something which means the ability of creating new things. And there's the key. The person living around others will most probably think in a similar manner, therefore cannot be really creative. Lonely people are not affected by the society. That's why they are truly creative.
- Filthy_casual 11y agoCould it be because solitude back then was similar to meditation? That you had no interruptions, no internet to make your mind run around like a puppy chasing the next tasty bone, and this in turn made you listen to thoughts and ideas rising from the subconscious more often?
- hyperpallium 11y agoI find when I'm developing my own view on something, and I discuss it with someone (or think about discussing it, or even be near someone), that I somehow feel a compulsion to either agree with them or disagree with them along the dimension they conceptualize it - and my own perspective/terms are lost. Like being interrupted when building up a model of code in your mind. I think this is our herd instinct, needing to fit in, in how a situation is conceived, disagreeing only in terms of that conception. Changing the theory is deeply anti-social.
- jokoon 11y agoNot if schools punish students for not socializing, which is what happenned to me for a stupid technical french degree.
- ignoramous 11y agoThe best quote on this topic I've read has come from the eccentric French Mathematician, Alexander Grothendieck: "To state it in slightly different terms: in those critical years [roughly from age 17 to 20] I learned how to be alone. This formulation doesn't really capture my meaning. I didn't, in any literal sense learn to be alone, for the simple reason that this knowledge had never been unlearned during my childhood. It is a basic capacity in all of us from the day of our birth. However these 3 years of work in isolation, when I was thrown onto my own resources, following guidelines which I myself had spontaneously invented, instilled in me a strong degree of confidence, unassuming yet enduring, in my ability to do mathematics, which owes nothing to any consensus or to the fashions which pass as law... By this I mean to say: to reach out in my own way to the things I wished to learn, rather than relying on the notions of the consensus, overt or tacit, coming from a more or less extended clan of which I found myself a member, or which for any other reason laid claim to be taken as an authority. This silent consensus had informed me, both at the lyé and at the university, that one shouldn't bother worrying about what was really meant when using a term like "volume", which was "obviously self-evident", "generally known", "unproblematic", etc. I'd gone over their heads, almost as a matter of course, even as Lesbesgue himself had, several decades before, gone over their heads. It is in this gesture of "going beyond", to be something in oneself rather than the pawn of a consensus, the refusal to stay within a rigid circle that others have drawn around one - it is in this solitary act that one finds true creativity. All others things follow as a matter of course." source: michael_nielsen @ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8604814 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8604814
- crystalchen 11y agoThe title speaks the truth, at least on some level. I can't help but think how talented my cousin is in creating 3D characters, and how she recently objected to filing her taxes.
- dschiptsov 11y agoIs one meme is the key to another meme?) Like it was suggested in The Programmers Stone and elaborated in The Art Of Scientific Investigation, there are different modes of training of certain areas of the brain (clusters of Neural Networks or whatever crude model you like). The common sense term for resulting structures is "mental maps". Notice the correct intuition about having a structure (made out of neurons) and that it supposed to be traversed (insight from the AI spring). In other words, you will traverse (or pattern match against) what you have managed to train, and different resulting structures will result in different processes - different modes of "thinking". Social rejection (which usually an effect, not a cause) is beneficial due to much less distraction and more time for myself, but unless you have appropriate habits of reflective thinking (to understand hows and whys and realizing multiple causation) no amount of social rejection will make it. The benefits of solitude has been noticed even by Vedic seers but it is definitely not enough. BTW, creativity is a packer's term. For mappers it is a default mode which need not to be named.
- mordocai 11y agoI was unfamiliar with the terms(packers, mappers) you used in your last sentence. Having done a quick read on them, I find the concepts interesting. It looks like at least a couple books talk about these concepts. Where would you recommend reading more about them? It must be noted that I am not convinced from my <1 page of reading that people are truly divided into only two camps in this category, like the philosophy seems to suggest so far.
- dschiptsov 11y agoThere are a lot of support for this crude model. Look at writings of J. Krishnamurti, Nabokov, Huxley, Chomsky, the guys who invented NLP (before it has been ruined by adopters), there are a lot of consensus among insights of thinkers with completely different background..
- 2510c39011c5 11y agoIf by "creativity" we mean to do things in the most informative way, in the sense of high entropy, (creativity is thus by this assumption equivalent to the capability of producing the most information), I feel "thinking independently" is the key to creativity -- as an event independent of all other events would produce the highest amount of information, for this matter... Quite often, "thinking independently" could lead to social rejection, as being independent means being non-related with other people's thinking, and hence with much less likelihood of being agreeable with other people's opinion. If we define (roughly) social acceptance as the property of sharing common opinions among the crowd, then we can infer that thinking independently would unlikely lead to social acceptance. Hence creativity would unlikely lead to social acceptance. Perhaps that's why a tolerant environment that allows different ideas and different opinions (even those you don't agree with) to coexist is also very crucial to creativity -- as otherwise intolerance would simply kill it.
- logicchains 11y ago>If we define (roughly) social acceptance as the property of sharing common opinions among the crowd, then we can infer that thinking independently would unlikely lead to social acceptance. Thinking independently doesn't necessarily entail sharing one's independent opinions with whomever one meets. Creativity implies the ability to create humour, and making people laugh is one of the easiest ways to get them to like you. Combined with intelligence, which makes it easier to work out what people want to hear, I'd argue that creativity actually brings a significant social advantage, at least when it's consciously directed towards achieving social ends. Feynman represents a good example of this, achieving social success by using his creativity as a fount of humour.
- 2510c39011c5 11y ago> Creativity implies the ability to create humour, and making people laugh is one of the easiest ways to get them to like you... Well, regarding jokes, if all people are making a same joke repetitively, so you heard about it many many times, do you still feel that you could laugh out naturally? (I mean laugh not for the sake of laugh, alone) I just feel that the reason why a joke is a joke, is because you have never heard of it (or at least have never got it) in the past...So this difference -- or this independence from the past -- is the creativity in your sense... > Feynman represents a good example of this, achieving social success by using his creativity as a fount of humour. If, there have already been 500 people making jokes in the same way as Feynman did -- for instance, if before reading his book, everyone already played prank on some waitress girl in a restaurant by putting the tips under an upside-down filled cup, would they still find the description in the book funny? Just like what I typed, do you still find this re-description of Feynman's joke funny, like the first time you read about it?
- Htsthbjig 11y agoIn the past I would say yes. The best work of my life, nobody around me understood. I was crazy while doing it against everybody around me. When you succeed it is obvious in retrospect, but while doing it you doubt in yourself if everybody doubts about you because they can't see what does not exist yet like you do. But at the time I didn't know what I know now: That there is other crazy people out there, and you have to find them. With Internet is not that hard. Hollywood, Silicon Valley or even YC is all about putting crazy enough creative people together so saying something like "I am going to change the world" sounds totally normal.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoTwo crazy geniuses walk into a bar; minutes later they both storm out claiming the other is a crazy crackpot. Two people are not similar just because they are both different. Ya, we can find allies, but these relationships are fragile and often limited. The problem is that we often cannot find common ground to explore our ideas together (though we can and do offer moral support). When working with other creatives, someone or all of them have to tone it down a few notches to get anything done at all. Studio models attempt to deal with this by providing a decent balance between independence and review.
- ashleyp 11y agoThe article may be fudged. I studied creativity and found from journals/papers with social rejection we see higher levels of divergent creativity, it's as if the brain does everything it can to think about how to socially include. With social inclusion we see higher levels of convergent creativity. We need both in society!
- SQL2219 11y agoThis gives perspective to the phrase "peaked in high school." High schools tend to be incubators of social rejection.
- pitt1980 11y agot
- k__ 11y agoIt's just a question of time. You can have an active social life and be creatively productive. But you have to schedule. The more time I poured into IT, the better I got. When it was a 24/7 thing, I left all my mates at school behind. When I started playing guitar, going to parties and play too many games, the others caught up. Now I'm mediocre at all of those things, but I've seen a bit more of the world. If you put your time in as few things as possible, one can be "social activity" and you still can be a creative mastermind.