8 ms·
Can the Swiss Watchmaker Survive the Digital Age?
- pothibo 11y agoNot only they will, but I bet they will remain unaffected. Style and architecture of a mechanical watch will never be outmatched by its digital counterpart. The mechanic of a watch is mind boggling. All those little pieces moving together in harmony. It's beauty.
- amenghra 11y agoYou mean the mechanic of a timepiece is mind boggling, right? ;)
- buster 11y agoThat's why i love my automatic watch, where you can see (and hear!) all those tiny pieces moving. It's fascinating and a master work of centuries of engineering and craftsmanship. Why should i buy a watch made by some mid-20s computer engineers, manufactured by some chinese slave, when i can wear the testament of centuries of finest engineering!
- timrichard 11y agoI completely agree with you and the parent. Sometimes (developer) friends haven't understood my attraction to automatics, but became interested in the mechanics when I showed them videos like these : http://youtu.be/dao0mbAbNLE http://youtu.be/dao0mbAbNLE http://youtu.be/qtgAJBPPefM http://youtu.be/qtgAJBPPefM
- carsongross 11y agoOf course. They survived the quartz crisis, they will survive this. Smart watches will eat some quartz watch market share and some mid-range mechanical, but the cogent smart watch criticism applies: that it doesn't provide enough of a functional delta over a phone. People who want mechanical watches want mechanical watches. Otherwise they'd already be wearing a more accurate, more functional and less fussy quartz watch. As an aside, in an ironic development, a Belgian mechanical watch maker (Ressence) has produced the best design I have ever seen for a smart watch: http://ressence.eu/collection/type-3/ http://ressence.eu/collection/type-3/ https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CGmnh0_UYAANb_j.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CGmnh0_UYAANb_j.jpg Available for the bargain price of 20-40k... If a smart watch maker ripped this design off, and made the bezel touch-rotatable... Well, I might change my tune a bit.
- Eric_WVGG 11y ago“The ‘quartz crisis’ killed off so many Swiss watchmakers that by the end of the 1970s, the number of workers in the industry had shrunk to 30,000 from 90,000.” Define “survive.” The article doesn’t state what to what extent the industry recovered, but surely not to pre-seventies levels. [edit damn but that Ressence is dope]
- raverbashing 11y agoThe first graph is pretty enlightening (Market Share by units and volume) http://www.wthejournal.com/en/pages/swiss-watch-industry-figures http://www.wthejournal.com/en/pages/swiss-watch-industry-fig... Also the Most Valuable brands graph
- Zigurd 11y agoThat would be an interesting study. As China develops a significant upper middle class, lots of niche pursuits, like handmade shoes, fine wines and distilled spirits, hand-made clothes, fine art, etc. should experience a global boom. The expansion of pursuits like keeping horses should boost, literally, the buggy-whip industry. So maybe fine mechanical watches will come back the same way, on the wave of wealth in populous countries.
- gaius 11y agoThe Chinese boom has already happened, and busted. The market over there is saturated with Omegas and Audis and cases of fancy French wines.
- amyjess 11y agoThing is, smartwatches are going to mostly eat market share from quartz watches; the people who stuck with mechanicals during the quartz crisis are going to stay with mechanicals now.
- akhatri_aus 11y agoIt's also that a Swiss watch isn't really designed to be replaced, rather endlessley maintained. A lot of the higher end Swiss watches have lifetime guarantees, meaning you could even pass it down to your kid and have it fixed for free. The mechanical movements also mean they don't need batteries replaced. This is a barefaced opposite to the 'Smartwatches'. Next year there'll be an iWatch 2 or something. Next to the smaller issue of charging many people adore these Swiss watches for their ability to 'just work' for decades and decades. Another thing I guess, is they're likely to retain their value.
- ctdonath 11y agoWhen asked about paper vs e- books, lots of people will comment about preferring the former because of the "smell" etc. But...nobody walks into a bookstore and buys one because it smells nice. The linked article says similar about watches: lots of obsession about preserving the elegant mechanical essence...which has practically nothing to do with the reason a watch is bought, that being to tell time. Sure, given a desire to buy a book, or a watch, one may opt for the embossed leather-bound edition printed with a movable-type press, or the 300-component hand-carved self-winding watch, but the driving point is to read The Hobbit, or tell when to leave work. We went thru this with music and photography. Tape & vinyl gave way to CDs which gave way to MP3 & AAC & FLAC. Film gave way to terabyte hard drives & multi-gigabyte flash cards. Sure, there's an occasional nostalgic resurgence of vinyl and film, but those technologies are largely relegated to artisan use. I was at Kodak when the photo industry pivoted; it's little more than a brand and a mostly-sold patent portfolio now. There's the old line that when a news headline asks a yes/no question, the answer is invariably "no". So...no, the Swiss watchmaker won't, on the whole, survive the digital age. The Movado on my desk and the Apple on my wrist cost about the same, but one's on my desk and the other is used every few minutes for a variety of purposes (from accurate-to-50ms-and-50m time to up-next calendar to notifications to backup telephone to exercise monitor to mapping to ...). Yeah, the mechanical version (even a mere quartz movement, akin to an old literal-pulp novel) appeals more to the base senses, but given which will actually get near-constant use, well, ask Kodak how their film business is holding up.
- Silfen 11y ago> ...which has practically nothing to do with the reason a watch is bought, that being to tell time. It seems to me that most watches already fall into the "artisan use" category that you mention. Phones already tell time. There are accurate clocks everywhere. Wearing a watch seems to be much more about style, design, and status signaling than anything else.
- kstenerud 11y agoThere are two purposes to a timepiece: 1. To tell the time. 2. To make a fashion statement. Digital watches (and now smart watches) add to that various functions, but, for most people, the fashion statement aspect of a watch trumps the functionality. Analog watches will survive because they are, first and foremost, jewelry.
- leanthonyrn 11y agoI would love to have an e-Strap that coordinates with my $1000 mechanical Robert Weil watch. If the e-strap came from Montblanc, Google, Apple, or pebble I would not mind. As long as it matched and gave me usable functionality. Also, when I sent it in to Robert Weil for service, they respected the e-Strap, even if it was from Montblanc.
- hauget 11y agoWow. I just found out about the e-strap. Sadly I don't think Montblanc will get it right unless developers embrace it. This is exactly the kind of innovation watchmakers should embrace though! I'd love to keep wearing my trusty G-Shock while taking advantage of everything smartwatches/fitness trackers have to offer.
- leanthonyrn 11y agoI wish Apple, Google, and pebble would embrace the e(i)-strap and leave the timepiece, front-facing jewelry, to the watchmakers.
- niuzeta 11y agoWatches are male equivalent of jewellery; so long as vanity exists, and there isn't an alternative, easy-to-discern display of wealth/style, they will stay. Also the Rolexes are almost artificially made scarce; adding to the allure of wealth.
- fla 11y agoMore than survive, I'm persuaded it can innovate by taking the best of both worlds.
- 27182818284 11y agoHilariously I know a clocksmith that pivoted from repairing watches to repairing Apple products (iPhones, MacBooks, etc) Now he is poised to be right back in his old business :)
- krisroadruck 11y agopeople who are interested in one of these: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lmxLAZZ2fhM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lmxLAZZ2fhM don't give a crap about the apple watch.
- atmosx 11y agoYou can buy a Tesla but you can not match the beauty and 'statement' this babe[1] makes when entering the scene. Accordingly, you'll probably be wearing something like this [2] instead of ugly digital watch. Well put, people who can afford a Rolex, a Breguet, etc. Don't give a damn about some silly digital toy. [1] http://www.astonmartin.com/en/heritage/past-models/db5 http://www.astonmartin.com/en/heritage/past-models/db5 [2] http://www.breguet.com/en/timepieces/classique/5140 http://www.breguet.com/en/timepieces/classique/5140
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fizixer 11y agoSwiss watchmaking will definitely survive. (See also: flint-knapping)
- mpdehaan2 11y agoI definitely like mechanicals, and I don't think smart watches are going to kill them. Swiss pricing however is something that exists because someone found out how to get crazy amounts of money from folks with too much of it. Good mechanicals need not be swiss, of course. On the lower reasonable end where people aren't making their own movements, there's still a lot of expense in what folks like ETA are doing to things, and there's a lot of price padding in Swiss stuff (and even rising prices from German companies like Sinn and Nomos, though a lot more affordable, still not cheap). There are plenty of smaller US watch-companies too (Lum-tec is a good example) making reasonable margins. These things tell time without a battery, and aren't something that will distract you and cut into your attention like a smart watch. I use my phone, I appreciate it, but I also realize it cuts into attention and concentration, and in some ways, liked it better when it did not exist. I don't want a second phone doing the same thing to the way I think in long-form, and I definitely don't want a watch I have to remember to check the battery on every day. There are times when I'd like to have a dumb phone again, really.
- mariodiana 11y agoSeiko makes good mechanical watches and uses in-house movements, no?
- snambi 11y agoCome on. A rolex is a rolex is a rolex. Apple watch and Google watches will be dirt cheap in 10years time. These digital stuff cannot and will not withstand the impact of time.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoAndroid Watches can be had brand new for $50 on sale today. Smart watches are designed to be disposable, just like smart phones are. Your average <$100 automatic watch will be functional, useful, and good looking longer than the $10,000+ Apple Watch Edition.
- Atropos 11y agoI guess it depends on how productive the smart watches become. Maybe 10-15 years ago, you could still find politicians openly state that they do not use computers, that they never read emails but only get them printed out by their secretaries, that they do not own or use a mobile phone... Nowadays, that is not very common anymore, and I don't believe it is the generational change alone, I believe it is due to a change of the cultural attitude, not engaging with technology like email or mobile phones makes you seem backwards and even a bit incompetent. Maybe "smart watch" vs "dumb watch" will turn out the same? But I guess nothing precludes the Swiss watchmakers from producing expensive smart watches, that will be both functional and a fashion statement.
- wereHamster 11y agoJust a few hours ago I was sitting in a Starbucks in Zurich and a group of american tourists came in to enjoy some coffee and present each other the new watches they had bought just before. I have no idea why they decided to buy those watches... but, I guess, I should say thanks for helping to save the watch businesses?
- SeanLuke 11y agoI don't understand. This article is essentially a veneration of someone who's proposing a virtually identical copy of the Withings Activite. Does Withings really have no patent or copyright protection here? Did the article author purposely ignore the fact that what's being proposed not only is not new, but already exists in a well-regarded product?