5 ms·
"The problem with these sorts of statements is that nearly everything is insignificant compared to something else." Yes. Yes it is. Welcome to reality, and eng
by jerf 17y ago
"The problem with these sorts of statements is that nearly everything is insignificant compared to something else."
Yes. Yes it is. Welcome to reality, and engineering. The problem with your statement is that if you're burning a lot of time and mental energy on the insignificant things, then you are wasting your time.
If you, personally, have already taken the time to secure your housing's heating situation, already have an energy-efficient car and minimize driving anyhow, then maybe for you worrying about your kid's diapers is the lowest hanging fruit. I mean that completely straight, not sarcastic at all. However, if you're sitting here encouraging others to worry about their diapers while their homes sit there blowing 75% of their heat out a leaky door, then you're just wasting time.
It's the 80/20 principle, only when it comes to things like energy budgets it's more like the 95/5 principle; one or two things make up 95% of your energy budget and the rest is fiddling around the edges. Optimize the 95% first. Worry about the 5% later, if at all.
(Fiddling around making optimizations smaller than the noise threshold is also a waste of time. "Noise threshold" may sound like a weird concept to apply here, but it does; making a small food optimization that, even if applied by a million people, is still less than the daily variation in the amount of food thrown out by restaurants daily would be a complete waste of time. This is an example, I have no specific optimization in mind. The temptation is to say "Well, these things add up", but in fact when you're dealing with these sorts of distributions, sometimes they don't! Even ten .001% optimizations don't add up to much, and for the effort of getting those you probably missed out on a 1% somewhere else. These distributions can be very counter-intuitive, we don't do well with such large order-of-magnitude ranges.)
- run4yourlives 17y agoThis is a brilliant comment. You should rework it into a blog post so that it can be shared with a broader audience. (That is, of course, if you don't consider it a waste of time!) Well done.
- sp332 17y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=964020 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=964020 Share away!
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoThe problem with your statement is that if you're burning a lot of time and mental energy on the insignificant things, then you are wasting your time. One has to buy nappies*, as a minimal impact example, and one has to choose the brand and type. I don't really think there is any greater thought-cost, if you will, in choosing the more ecologically sound option provided proper scientific research has been performed - amazingly it doesn't appear to have been (note major problem with UK gov study which is now widespread used as a reason not to have reusable despite them being lower impact; I'm assuming big pharma corps are invested against proper research). Things like turning off the tap as you brush your teeth are just habitual it doesn't need thought once it has been done for a few days, ditto turning out lights. These are not major lifestyle changes and so, I'd argue, don't impact at all the possibility of promoting better resource use in the large scale situations. Finally, ten 0.001% optimisations that compound over a zero change threshold can be extremely important - ask anyone who is in debt and bumping the bottom of their agreed overdraft, a few pence is all it takes to cycle you down instead of up. Food optimisation: in the States, I read today, 40% of purchased food is wasted. That's got to be at least half of all food production when you allow for spoiling and other waste (I'd reckon more). A small change in lifestyle, simply choosing to care, can lead to a huge drop in this figure - there are 300 million people in the USA. Ultimately I see that the 95% I don't have direct control over, eg building of renewable energy capture in favour of fossil fuel based systems, the 5% I do. If I've got a cup and my boats sinking I'm still going to bail-out until someone else comes along and helps.
- rjurney 17y agoPeople who concern themselves with turning the water off while they brush their teeth also buy more fuel efficient cars, take public transportation, insulate their homes more efficiently, etc. The market responds to make the expression of environmental concern more efficient - but it only does so when it takes note of people wasting time on insignificant acts of efficiency.
- jerf 17y ago[citation needed] - certainly I hear a lot of bitching about people who think economizing in small things gives them the right to take a plane flight to Tahiti. I would neither be surprised if you were right nor surprised if you were very wrong. In particular, people in the social classes wherein being "green" carries some sort of cachet are also very likely to do things like flying a lot more than those who don't, since that social class tends to have more money than most other social classes.
- rjurney 17y agoOk - but they're also the same people that click the little button to plant a tree to offset their carbon footprint for the plane ride :) Products are driven by people's concerns, and so concern about the environment is a good thing - it impacts products, it drives policy.
- teeja 17y agoConservation is (in America at least) definitely at the top of what most people can do. And they will, given time and good arguments. Water heaters used to be the #1 energy sink appliance in the average US home (early 1970s). But drafts, single-glazing and inadequate wall/ceiling insulation continue to waste enormous energies every winter. And car engines, like light bulbs, continue to be about 15-20% efficient.
- holygoat 17y agoAs soon as the calendar flicks over and you switch from using the air conditioner to using your heater, your lightbulb is 100% efficient. (Indeed, if you have a furnace for your central heating, and the ductwork passes outside the heated volume of your house, it's more efficient for you to leave the TV on than it is for the furnace to heat your house, because none of the TV's waste heat escapes the heated volume.) Most of what people consider to be "green" is irrational during the winter. They'll turn the lights out but run a space heater.
- imurray 17y agoThis is a common misconception. 1) reducing electricity consumption will reduce use of fossil fuels in power stations (in most parts of the world). Burning fuel in your own home bypasses the inefficient conversion to electricity. 2) if you are going to heat your home with electricity you can be more than “100% efficient” by using a heat pump, so you still wouldn’t want to do it with light bulbs and TVs.
- holygoat 17y agoHow does using an electric heater instead of waste heat from electrical appliances reduce the use of fossil fuels? Same transport mechanism, same source, same efficiency. The only way to reduce electricity consumption is improved insulation. I agree with you if you have a wood-burning stove.
- imurray 17y ago