7 ms·
Japan Bicycle Parking Technology [video]
- ekianjo 11y agoNote for those not living in Japan. It's not everywhere like that :)
- shawnps 11y agoI'm in Tokyo and I've never seen one before :) but I might start looking just to try it out.
- ekianjo 11y agoIn Osaka the standard is just to drop your bicycle on the side of the street, to the point that people can't walk anymore on that side :P
- snogglethorpe 11y agoI think in most areas of Tokyo these things really aren't necessary, despite the high popularity of bicycle transport, because bicycle parking is fairly simple to cram in various nooks and crannies (lots of bike parking underneath train viaducts), and bikes are more popular in more less dense (suburban, outlying) areas than in the densest parts of the city core, which means there's usually a bit more space available too. When you're going to do major construction anyway, you may as well build a human-accessible bike-parking structure or underground bike-parking area, which can probably be equally dense, and are almost certainly less of a maintenance burden. The main advantage of robo-parking seems to be that it lets them use a very vertical space, which wouldn't work so well with "manual" bike parking.
- shawnps 11y agoDanny Choo did a post on this: http://www.dannychoo.com/en/post/26963/Japan+Underground+Bicycle+Parking+Systems.html http://www.dannychoo.com/en/post/26963/Japan+Underground+Bic... Looks like you can find one of these in Shinagawa
- dogma1138 11y agoFrom what i can tell i think it's actually the only one, been to Japan several times since these were initially posted online and I've never seen them, or any other type of an automated bike storage service. Heck from what i can tell all the pictures and video seem to cover exactly the same bike storage, and for some odd reason it's always empty when they film it. While it's a nice idea i think it's way too impractical. This seems to be less dense than what turns out of most traditional bike parking systems, it's also much more expensive to build and maintain, and i don't even want to start thinking of how easy for it to just get stuck, miss read the tag on your bike, or heck for that RFID tag to simply just die / fall off during storage. If you use something like a Santa Cruz racing frame with every part made out of carbon to commute to work, yeah the extra security is probably worth the costs when you deal with 10K$+ bikes, but as far as most commuting bikes I've seen in Japan and Asia in general nope, they aren't worth it.
- w00kie 11y agoI know a couple in Tokyo: one in Shinagawa (the Danny Choo one), one in Roppongi. The one is this video is a different one. This is a company that makes such systems: http://cycle-tree.jp/ http://cycle-tree.jp/ They have more examples of installations.
- cskau 11y agoWhere's the one in Roppongi?
- ProZsolt 11y agoIf you watch the camera's footage that mounted on the bike, you can see there are several bikes in the storage.
- jacquesm 11y agoThe Dutch low-tech but ugly equivalent: http://www.citi.io/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/483-3.jpg http://www.citi.io/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/483-3.jpg
- lucb1e 11y agoThat's not stacked though, I think this comes closer to an "equivalent": http://www.haldo.com/images/CYCLE%20SHELTERS/optima-1-640.jpg http://www.haldo.com/images/CYCLE%20SHELTERS/optima-1-640.jp... (source: http://www.haldo.com/optima.php http://www.haldo.com/optima.php ) Edit: Lol, HN replaces ".jpg" with ".jp...". So much for shortening the link.
- gkop 11y agoYes, this is similar to what BART uses: http://sf.streetsblog.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2012/05/192363640_76de74261c.jpg http://sf.streetsblog.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2012/05...
- aaron695 11y agohttp://www.copenhagenize.com/2015/02/worlds-first-automated-underground-bike.html http://www.copenhagenize.com/2015/02/worlds-first-automated-...
- ygra 11y agoJapan has very little space to devote for such things. Such a solution won't work or scale there.
- lindig 11y agoWhat are the economics of this? The student rate is about $10/month which seems worth it given that your bike is safe and dry. But how long would it take to recoup just the cost to build something like this? Just for comparison, a conventional parking spot in a car parking garage (with no robotic access) costs about $15.000 or $500/m^2 for the building.
- aaron695 11y agoPretty sure it's only possible because of the way the Japanese subsidise things so much. I think building down is generally as expensive as building up. Could be $1.5 million per 200 bikes - http://www.therecord.com/news-story/3901727-a-gateway-to-underground-bicycle-parking/ http://www.therecord.com/news-story/3901727-a-gateway-to-und...
- lindig 11y agoThat would mean about $7500 per bike or half as much as a conventional parking garage costs per car. There is no way this can be operated profitably at $10/month/bike or even $20/month/bike as it would take 30+ years to recoup the costs before running costs.
- oh_sigh 11y agoYou're assuming that every customer has a unique slot assigned to them. I'm sure that they have many more customers than actual bike slots, banking on the fact that at any given moment maybe only 2% of their customer base is using a given station. With that complete guess, the subscription fee would bring in $100k/month, which puts it at a reasonable timeframe to recoup costs. Also, I think that I would slightly modify the subscription fee to prevent people from parking their bikes in there long term. Like, you get 3 hours of parking for free with your subscription, and anything after that is $2/hour, or something along those lines. And non-subscribers could park for 3 hours for a one time fee of $5, plus $2/hour after that. With that in place, I could definitely seeing something like this be profitable if it is placed at a popular retail destination where it is possible to bike to.
- rasur 11y agoI'm sure the end of the video shows the doors closing on the front wheel of the bike!
- joosters 11y agoI'd love to know the reliability rate of the system. If just one bike jams up or falls over during the loading/unloading, everyone's bikes become completely inaccessible. Maybe it works flawlessly, but it looks so fragile to me.
- tim333 11y agoCool eh? I think the Japanese have a culture for this stuff. It reminds me off about 30 years ago I visited a Toyota engine making plant in Nagoya and it was unremarkable apart from there being almost no people on the line. Just engine parts trundling from one machine to another on automated conveyers. I don't think there was much computer control - it was pretty much mechanical mechanisms.
- kalleboo 11y agoJapan is very much a land of contrasts. You have things like this and their precision manufacturing. And then you enter an office and you're caught in a whirlwind of paper and faxes. And don't get me started on their banking. ATMS with opening hours...
- ekianjo 11y ago> ATMS with opening hours... Yeah, ATMs closing during the evenings and holidays! This kind of things has pissed me off more than once, but it's getting slightly better nowadays. The office situation is pretty much like you described, and faxes are still very much in use everywhere. Stuck in the 70s.
- oh_sigh 11y agoDo you know the reason for that? It takes more effort to program a machine to turn off during certain hours than it does to just let it run 24/7, so someone must have thought there was a compelling reason to disallow it. Maybe to prevent drunk people from overdrawing their account on horrible purchases?
- dazbradbury 11y agoMaybe to stop a rush on cash deposits in the case of a banking scare out of hours? ie. rumour / announcement that the bank has run out of money. Seems unlikely. More likely is that it's to save money - if there is a cost incurred in supplying money for other banks or keeping the machine filled with cash, perhaps reducing hours is simply a cost saving measure.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoThroughput is not really mentioned here, which is the key bottleneck I think. Nobody really has huge issues parking their bike at home. Humans are sufficiently spread out around a city, and so bike density is similar to human density, which is not that bad. The problem areas for storage solutions for bikes is at areas with very high density. Here in the Netherlands that's the train stations. At the Central Station of big cities like Amsterdam or Rotterdam, hundreds of thousands of people pass every day, relatively small areas. Many of those arrive or leave by bike. Storing those bikes is tricky, not only because of space concerns, but also because the vast majority of people (probably 80%) arrive/leave during two periods of about 90 minutes of peek travel time in the morning and evening. In other words at any one point during those periods, you have hundreds of people storing or retrieving their bicycle at the same time. That is totally incompatible it seems with this device, which retrieves at most 2 bikes or so per minute. A person has to walk up, enter his card, his password, then the device has to do some stuff, then he has to retrieve it from the device, walk away. Compare storing your bicycle at a train station for example with buying train tickets. At the Central Station you'll easily find dozens and dozens of machines to buy a ticket, and lots of booths to do so as well, and still you see rows of people at peek times. Even after we've had subscription based tickets for decades (e.g. take any train and pay x per year) and card based systems (if the balance on your card drops below $10 it can get automatically refilled. Just swipe your card to enter the train) for years which means most travellers don't even need to purchase a ticket. So you'd need quite a lot of these machines and I don't really see how that'd make economic sense. We've had a lot of good experiences with manual underground, cheap, low-maintenance facilities now that are a better alternative. And for low-throughput areas, storage of bicycles isn't a very big issue, meaning the economics (premium price, no doubt) make even less sense when there are plenty of free storage opportunities (on the street). For certain bikes it makes sense (those costing $10k). But that's not the norm in countries with high per-capita rates of bikes. I and everyone I know have had bikes costing at most 200, I tend to buy them for 80 or so second hand with 20 of annual maintenance. I can store it infront of my house just fine, it's never a problem. The rate of theft means it's cheaper to buy a new one / insure the bike for a fraction of its cost, than to pay $100+ a year for storage like this (and even that rate is unlikely to be profitable for this facility). And at the central station where it is hard to park a bike without adequate facilities, retrieval would be too slow, and manual underground facilities are fine.
- lordnacho 11y agoAm I missing something here? Don't you have to dig a massive hole for this to work? Why not a tower that sticks up instead?
- lotu 11y agoYou don't want a massive tower in the middle of the street. It interferes with traffic.