8 ms·
> Look at a site like YouTube today. And yet any media player beats it at its core functionality: video playback. Often I find myself using youtube-dl to fetc
by the8472 11y ago
> Look at a site like YouTube today.
And yet any media player beats it at its core functionality: video playback.
Often I find myself using youtube-dl to fetch a youtube video and just play it in a regular media player because it just works better than what browsers have to offer.
There even are addons to export YT playlists to VLC and stream them.
pdfjs is great. but every 3rd scientific paper I read tends to be somewhat broken (missing diagrams/images) or sometimes fails to render completely. native readers provide a better experience and better render times.
>And mimicking native can often lead to bad results. But to go from that and say that we shouldn’t try.
Maybe sometimes it would be better to provide better integration with native applications?
Native applications and browsers really don't like talking to each other.
- mreiland 11y ago> Maybe sometimes it would be better to provide better integration with native applications? That's it exactly. The author claims it's an unsolved problem, I think it's the inevitable solution (that web and native will merge).
- jsingleton 11y agoYou can always use custom protocols much like mailto: e.g. a link with sms: can send a text message from a mobile web browser.
- pjc50 11y agoOr Android intents, whereby applications can intercept particular URL schemes to e.g. play Youtube videos in the app rather than in the browser.
- mreiland 11y agomisses the point by a mile. web and native will eventually merge to the point that for most intents and purposes the user can't distinguish between them. It'll never be perfect, but it'll be "good enough", that whether an app comes from the web or from the HD, the user won't really notice except perhaps in the initial startup time, and probably not even then (everyone expects to "install" an app).
- baldfat 11y agoshhhhssss there is no such thing as youtube-dl! I believe that the tool should be like Fight Club or it gets noticed and gets shut down through a drawn out war of changing code and apis.
- dj-wonk 11y agoTo modify the Fight Club rules to ensure X (whatever topic you mention) does not get discussed: 1. There is no X. 2. There are no comments about X. 3. There are no comments about comments about X. 4. (recur away) Oh, wait. This sounds like censorship.
- baldfat 11y agoOr just get down voted to where no one can see the comments.
- aangjie 11y agoNow I am conflicted do I down vote or upvote? Hmm.. what a dilemma.
- stephengillie 11y agoIt's not a Puffin meme. Just downvote.
- adamc 11y agoI think media playback is only part of the core functionality. The other key piece is discoverability, and on that front, YouTube is far, far better than a native media player. It also benefits hugely from urls, which allow users to share what they've found. So, arguably, YouTube's success is more about what the web does well than about it's media playback -- it just has to be "good enough" on that front.
- the8472 11y ago> It also benefits hugely from urls, which allow users to share what they've found. how about http://some.storage.service.tld/path/to/video.mkv http://some.storage.service.tld/path/to/video.mkv or even rtmp://some.streaming.service.tld/path/to/stream ? For sharing that would be sufficient. Of course there are some business realities (ads, copyright, paying for storage) that make direct, free access to videos unlikely. But that's basically arguing that the web is a superior platform for monetizing things, not necessarily a superior platform as far as user-experience goes. > The other key piece is discoverability, and on that front, YouTube is far, far better I'll give you that one. But then again there are dedicated media-discovery-sites (imdb, last.fm) that do not have playback as their core functionality, even though they may offer some playback.
- msl09 11y agoI would like to complement that native youtube(the one used on mobile) is far better at playback while keeping nearly every other advantage that it has on the web.
- monsterix 11y ago> that native youtube(the one used on mobile) is far better at playback. No, it is not. Playback would get stuck, sound would go away for no rhyme or reason and what not. Better experience? - no - quite the opposite. I got rid [1] of the native nuisance completely. And the experience of search, comment and history on native was simply terrible. Much lesser control on ad-blocking too, and really the ads on YT are sometimes seriously irritating. [1] Evidence: https://twitter.com/marvindanig/status/598701509963083777 https://twitter.com/marvindanig/status/598701509963083777
- wernercd 11y ago> And yet any media player beats it at its core functionality: video playback. And at it's core, BetMax is better than VHS. HD-DVD is better than Blu-Ray. Often, it's not about what is "better". It's about who has the most moment, is easier, less encumbered by DRM, etc. Sometimes it's better to download Youtube... more often than not, Youtube "just works".
- insertnickname 11y agoHow is HD DVD better than Blu-Ray?
- pjmlp 11y agoMaybe because it doesn't use Java for some people, :)
- Symmetry 11y agoI don't think that you can call BetaMax's somewhat superior picture quality objectively better than VHS's factor of two advantage in storage.
- Yizahi 11y agoHD-DVD was cheaper and required less immediate infrastructure changes, but rather allowed a staged switch from DVD. Blu-Ray is the one that was better. Actually this is exact reverse of a Betamax story - better and more expensive long term improvement won over short term and cheaper one.
- rockdoe 11y agopdfjs is great. but every 3rd scientific paper I read tends to be somewhat broken (missing diagrams/images) or sometimes fails to render completely. Do you report these? It's been ages since I saw a PDF that pdf.js misrendered.
- codingdave 11y agoYou seem to be under the misunderstanding that video playback is YouTube's core function. No, the core functionality is to drive traffic to Google-owned sites, to be monetized as they see fit. Remember, on the web, you are the product.
- pyre 11y ago> Remember, on the web, you are the product. The same goes for many other things: - Movie theatres in the last few years (commercials before movies) - Television since the days of black-and-white TVs. - Radio dramas "sponsored by X" before TVs existed. How has anything changed?
- c22 11y ago"On the web you get to choose what kind of product you want to be."
- flowless 11y agoYoutube's HTML5 video playback on my 3Ghz i7 is so bad that I rarely watch videos in browser. Now it's even worse as all videos play in low quality unless you use DRM enabled "tech". This is what I use instead: mplayer -fixed-vo $( youtube-dl -gf mp4 $* "$link" )
- syshax 11y agoIf you have philosophical objections over H.264 because of patents etc., then this won't help. If you have the HTML player enabled, and if your GPU supports hardware H.264 decoding (most do these days), this plugin may help: https://github.com/erkserkserks/h264ify https://github.com/erkserkserks/h264ify Otherwise Youtube might send VP8, which your CPU has to decode.
- gnaritas 11y ago> And yet any media player beats it at its core functionality: video playback. That isn't its core functionally, it's a social video sharing site, not a video playback site. It's core functionality is social sharing and all that goes with that, comments, related videos, channels, etc.
- Nadya 11y ago>And yet any media player beats it at its core functionality: video playback. I would argue YouTube's core functionality is "making it easy to share videos with family, friends, and the world". Allowing playback of the videos on the page makes this functionality easier. >Often I find myself using youtube-dl to fetch a youtube video and just play it in a regular media player because it just works better than what browsers have to offer. I do this too - although only because an addon I have causes Firefox to memleak if I leave a YouTube tab open too long. Rather than finding the problem and fixing it - I download a video I want to watch and close the YouTube tab. Honestly my video player of choice (MPC-HC) does exactly what the YouTube player does. It plays the video. Not a whole lot of bells and whistles needed to do that.
- Too 11y agoYoutube used to be better before at video playback, not as good as VLC but much better than what it is today. I think they have to deliberately hamper the user experience in order to save bandwidth, just imagine how much bandwidth youtube must cost with the amounts of users they have. Even their native android app isn't exactly the greatest which makes the web vs native comparison a bit easier. Examples of this hampering is that they only stream 20sec ahead instead of the whole clip in one shot. There are many other annoyances like this, like not giving you the HD version even though it says the video is HD and you've selected HD, or when it re-streams the movie when you switch from windowed to fullscreen, probably because the windowed version was too low quality.
- baddox 11y agoYouTube's video playback problems might have nothing to do with the web. Despite having an iPad app that is otherwise mostly great, their iPad video player itself is abysmal. It's just flat-out broken, and they're presumably not going to fix it. If you start playing a video, the timeline at the bottom will start turning grey from left to right to indicate the part of the video that is buffered. But if you scrub to a position in the timeline that is buffered, the video player will spin for a rather long time, and sometimes just spin forever until you scrub to a new spot or manually change the video quality. Bizarrely, if you scrub to a position in the timeline beyond the buffer, the video will load nearly instantly like one would expect. Somehow the buffered video loads slowly, while unbuffered video loads quickly. It's a huge bug, it's been in the iPad app for as long as I can remember.
- gusmd 11y agoThat happens frequently on the desktop website YouTube too. It also happens on my Android phone using the native app. Related to that, if you try to scrub to a position BEFORE what you are watching right now (say, 1 minute before), which is obviously buffered since you have just watched it, it goes full loading-retard again. It's like it just throws away the data it buffered and showed you. It is insanely infuriating.
- dubrocks 11y agoBeen like this for months for me. I've found the way to fix it is to manually select a video resolution.
- baddox 11y agoYes, that is my workaround as well. I also sometimes use the jailbreak utility VideoPane to extract the iOS-native video from the YouTube app and play it in a popup. You get the native video player and controls, and funny enough, it works wonderfully. https://rpetri.ch/cydia/videopane/ https://rpetri.ch/cydia/videopane/
- mattLummus 11y agoCorrect, YT issues are more often caused by server/network latency rather than the client.
- dbpokorny 11y ago> And yet any media player beats it at its core functionality: video playback. But can you build a democratic 24/7 music/video feed with a native video playback app? Maybe, but it is much easier with the web. And it has already been done: http://botwillacceptanything.com:3000/video http://botwillacceptanything.com:3000/video https://github.com/botwillacceptanything/botwillacceptanything https://github.com/botwillacceptanything/botwillacceptanythi... I invite anyone with the time and inclination to submit a pull request that changes the content of the video feed.