12 ms·
RadioShack Sold Consumer Data to Pay Off Its Debts
- carlmcqueen 12y agoI can't say this is a big surprise. My first job was at a chicagoland radioshack so I have followed their news and watched their fall with mixed feelings. It felt very odd in 2001 to try and sell electricians that would come in the store at opening to buy 10-11 fuses if they wanted a cell phone, and bother people just getting batteries for their first and last name so they could 'return their item'. We got dinged for each person who refused us. So there is potentially a LOT of data this company is getting.
- crusso 12y agoYou just triggered my earliest Radio Shack memories of being annoyed at a company for asking for my personal information when making small purchases. Radio Shack was definitely in the vanguard of data collection.
- konsptheory 12y agoThese occasions are never-miss for my alter egos to shine through and dazzle my interlocutors :)
- waterlesscloud 12y agoIndeed. They were the first company I ever gave a fake name to.
- carlmcqueen 12y agoAt least at my store, Johnny Cash made a LOT of battery purchases in 2001-2002. A close second was Jonny Cash and one employee used Jony Cash for women.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThe last CEO cancelled that policy as their first act. So for some years, that data was not collected. I wonder what data they had to sell? Anyway, this is a warning to all of us. No matter what promises that honest startup gives you, the minute they are sold (and most sell in the end) the new owners are free to do whatever they like with your 'private' information. In fact it will be hawked in the marketplace like a chicken.
- claudius 12y ago> Anyway, this is a warning to all of us. No matter what promises that honest startup gives you, the minute they are sold (and most sell in the end) the new owners are free to do whatever they like with your 'private' information. In fact it will be hawked in the marketplace like a chicken. Is that really the case in the US? In Germany, I don’t see why simply transferring ownership of the data should not also transfer ownership of the agreements bound to that data. If I agree to let company X use my data for purpose A under terms T and company Y buys company X, in my view company Y would still be bound to stick to terms T and purpose A. Otherwise any leaked/stolen and subsequently published personal data could be used by anyone for anything…
- spydum 12y agopretty much any agreement by major companies comes with a wonderful disclaimer of something like this: We reserve the right to revise, amend, or modify this Agreement and any other policies and agreements at any time and in any manner. We may modify this Agreement by placing a notice of such modification on our website, and User's continued use of the Service following notice of such modification shall be deemed to be User's acceptance of any such modification. User agrees to check this on-line area regularly to determine whether this Agreement has been modified. If User does not agree to any modification of this Agreement, User must immediately stop using the Service.
- Vespasian 12y agoStill if you actually stop using the service (aka not longer subscribing or logging in) that shouldn't grant them any more rights on data from the past. However IANAL so I might be wrong here.
- Raphmedia 12y agoThis is very anecdotal, but I swear that the minute I gave my email address to Radio Shack, I started to receive heavy spam.
- pki 12y agoI bought one <$10 item. Once. http://i.imgur.com/4ztWmxW.png http://i.imgur.com/4ztWmxW.png
- Raphmedia 12y agoI got those, but I meant as in unrelated spam, viagra ads, etc. This was a new email account I was trying out made for when I got asked what my email account is by retailers, and I swear that the spam started once I gave the address to them.
- jhallenworld 12y agoI'm sure they have no choice but to sell assets with value. But is the original privacy policy equivalent to a license (that we consumers grant Radio Shack)? If it isn't, maybe this will be a chance to set a precedent for this to be the case.
- joelgrus 12y agoWow, this really sucks for whoever has the phone number that I had in 1991.
- ja27 12y agoAnd for whatever numbers they typed in when I refused to even make up one myself.
- imglorp 12y agoWhen I visit the hair cutting place, they refuse to serve you without a phone number. So I always give them the standard TV placeholder: xxx-555-1212. The stylist is often confused why there are 20 people with that phone number.
- nitrogen 12y agoAt one point that number was universally owned by TellMe/Microsoft iirc.
- joshstrange 12y agoHmm, it looks like the number is used for directory assistance [0] in North America at least. >Throughout North America, 1-XXX-555-1212 will connect to directory assistance for the specified XXX area code I wasn't able to find a link between that number and TellMe/MS. They appear to have had the 1-800-555-TELL (8355) [1] number but no mention of the 1212 number. Though a google for the number +"Microsoft" reveals they appear to use that number in a couple of their SQL server books [2] [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/555_%28telephone_number%29#Real_usage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/555_%28telephone_number%29#Real... [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tellme_Networks http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tellme_Networks [2] https://books.google.com/books?id=8OxGcCJViU4C&pg=PA68&lpg=PA68&dq=555-1212+microsoft&source=bl&ots=WMR6P0mvpX&sig=C6W93tYahhhSxZL00dF8WAxO_PM&hl=en&sa=X&ei=plRbVaf7JcebNtXWgNgE&sqi=2&ved=0CEAQ6AEwBg#v=onepage&q=555-1212%20microsoft&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=8OxGcCJViU4C&pg=PA68&lpg=P...
- matwood 12y agoApple and AT&T tried/is trying to stop them: http://gizmodo.com/apple-sues-to-prevent-radioshack-selling-customer-data-1704644494 http://gizmodo.com/apple-sues-to-prevent-radioshack-selling-...
- devcpp 12y agoApple "I-want-all-your-data" and AT&T "you-have-to-opt-out-of-tracking". Of all companies. We have to count on our enemies to protect us because we are powerless. Let's just hope they start privacy wars.
- rsynnott 12y agoIs _Apple_ known for being "I-want-all-your-data"? Historically, they don't seem to have been terribly interested, certainly not as compared to the web-centric companies.
- CountSessine 12y agoThat's really a lazy mischaracterization of Apple. They've never been especially interested in your personal data. The only service they have where they maintain any sizeable, persistent consumer information seems to be the iTunes store, and as far as I can tell, they've never tried to monetize/share that information with anyone. I'm more curious why you would think of Apple this way - "I-want-all-your-data"? Maybe Apple "you-didn't-really-buy-your-hardware", but "I-want-all-your-data"? If anything, I would liken Apple to a jealous and abusive boyfriend - they'll beat and abuse their customers with sometimes arbitrary controls over what they can do with their hardware, but God help you if you try to do the same to their customers. Whether you're a third-party developer, an accessory manufacturer, or anyone with a relationship with those customers, Apple will come down on you HARD if they think that you're harming their platform or exploiting their customers. From that point of view, Apple's action here - trying to interfere with RS' sale of Apple customers' personal data - is typical of Apple.
- SloopJon 12y agoSlate puts rather a different spin on this than other articles I've read. Slate: > The FTC is so displeased that Jessica Rich, its consumer protection director, has written to the bankruptcy court handling RadioShack’s case, asking that consumers' personal data be protected. Ars Technica: > The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) sent a letter to the bankruptcy court presiding over RadioShack's supervised asset sell-off suggesting a compromise that would allow RadioShack to sell its database of information from 117 million customers. Previous coverage portrayed Apple as intervening to protect customers (although it seems to have more to do with enforcing their reseller agreement): http://www.imore.com/apple-wades-radioshack-sale-protect-customer-data http://www.imore.com/apple-wades-radioshack-sale-protect-cus... http://daringfireball.net/linked/2015/05/14/apple-radioshack-privacy http://daringfireball.net/linked/2015/05/14/apple-radioshack... http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/05/apple-asks-court-to-block-the-sale-of-some-radioshack-data/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/05/apple-asks-court-...
- brudgers 12y agoOf all the things I'm supposed to be outraged about as a consumer of news, this one rises to the whoopdie fucking so what? level. Radio shack was collecting in their best ever year maybe half a dozen data points on me. It's not like they had my DNS requests over the past ten years or my history of cell tower signals or my click history following searches for "painful rectal itch" or how long I typically watch dwarf porn before closing the browser...if I were to do such a thing. There are big privacy issues and little ones and this is definitely the latter. How revealing the Radio Shack's data is of people's behavior should be measured by the outcome of Radio Shack during the period in which it had exclusive access...and here the context is a bankruptcy proceeding.
- tsieling 12y agoWhile RS had no real data on me, what this story points out is that companies will do this in bankruptcy, maybe even after carrying a no-share/no-sell policy for years. The wider issue it illuminates is that there seem to be few general protections for these cases, where having your data sold wasn't part of the bargain you were asked to make, until they changed the deal.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nsxwolf 12y agoThis is the quaint 1990s kind of privacy concern - when the privacy experts of the day warned us we would receive a lot of junk mail and credit card offers if we weren't careful with our data.
- ascagnel_ 12y agoThis case can be used to test how binding a privacy statement can be. If Radio Shack is allowed to sell the data to a third party over AT&T & Apple's objections, basically every privacy policy is worthless. There are always increasing amounts of data collected with increasingly invasive means, but this can make bulk data collection less intrinsically valuable.
- 12y ago
- tsieling 12y agoBattery Card Club, you've turned against me.
- driverdan 12y agoThis is exactly why you should never give your data to someone unless it's absolutely necessary. If someone asks for your contact info just so you can buy batteries just say no.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoMaybe with new AR devices coming out soon, maybe you can quickly do a picture to social media lookup, and then use that to see if the employee has their address/phone number online. The look on their face as you give them their own personal info would be priceless. The investigation for stalking, not so much.
- madaxe_again 12y agoI see this kind of thing all too frequently. Our clients are retailers. From time to time, one goes pop, and goes into administration. The liquidators look at all of their assets - initially, at things like stock and other physical assets - but then look at their other less tangible assets, like user data, as selling it can be the difference between settling with creditors or not. Typically, when you license your data to a company you accept that they can sell that data as part of the sale of the business, in the event of administration or liquidation, and a variety of other situations in which you don't want to have to ask the permission of your N million users to go ahead with a merger or other essential business activity. Further to this, we've also seen client service agencies who are processors of data seizing user data as an asset if a client goes into administration and leaves their service providers as unsecured creditors (i.e. "you're up the creek, we'll pay you £0.000001 for every £ we owe, your £80,000 is now £0.80"), as they also have a responsibility to mitigate their own losses, and again, contracts usually allow for the seizing of assets in the case of default. So, long story short, this is not even slightly abnormal, and something consumers should consider before providing their data to anyone.
- dm2 12y agoThe "we will never sell your data to anyone" in a Privacy Policy effectively means nothing at all. Why are there not consumer protection laws in place to prevent this? In my opinion, in order to sell customer data you should have to go to court and have a judge look over the data to determine what can be sold.
- ascagnel_ 12y agoThis is an instance where a judge can create a consumer protection common law.
- madaxe_again 12y agoI've little faith that any judge would do anything other than "ah. This is something... computer. don't know. Yes?". It's the same "shutters coming down with a bang!" phenomenon as one sees with most non-technical folks the moment they think something technical might be coming their way. Either way, this is a very grey area, as if you tie up corporate affairs with every single one of your customers, it would make your business unsaleable, and make liquidation impossible, so while consumer protection is desirable, there also have to be measures that allow businesses to operate without the explicit consent of each and every one of their customers for any action.
- oldmanjay 12y agowell, "your" data in perhaps some rhetorical sense. "data about you" would be more intellectually honest, but slate is nothing is not manipulative. it's okay, they know they're promoting correct opinions so little tiny manipulations in service of that is okay.
- deong 12y ago> well, "your" data in perhaps some rhetorical sense. In this context, "your data" is 100% of the time used to indicate data you've provided to someone else about you. Have you ever seen an article saying "Facebook to target ads based on their photos" or "Google using their data to make money"?
- tedunangst 12y agoI think you've overshot with the Facebook photos. They are, in fact, not their photos and remain the property of the uploader.
- oldmanjay 12y agoWell yes, as I indicated, the author is using a phrase in a rhetorical sense to frame the narrative emotionally. I'm sorry if I wasn't clear that I understand what the technique is accomplishing. I am merely pointing out the essential dishonesty in its use.
- deong 11y agoBut if everyone uses the phrase that way, then it's not dishonest for this person to do it too. That's how language works. If I tell my student, "the early bird gets the worm", it's idiotic to call me stupid because I confused a human with a bird. I didn't in fact do that. I used a common idiom in the language that we all understand. The fact that you can recognize there's a literal meaning that wasn't accurate is pointless. I'm not dishonest or a liar either. I used language in a non-literal way, just like all of us do hundreds of times every day. When someone says "company X is using your data", there's a common understanding in play. We all know what they mean. They mean "data they've collected about you". If you want to call everyone names because, taken literally, it's incorrect, then go ahead, but you're beating a dead horse here. And I'm not actually accusing you of pummeling the carcass of an equine. I'm saying you're spending your energy on a pointless task, but doing so in a way that relies on you understanding that the meaning of a sentence isn't strictly determined by the meaning and order of the individual words in it.
- mc32 12y agoI hope the FTC wins its case and establishes precedent that consumer data is non transferable and most importantly not a good to be bought and sold unregulated. I understand there are circumstances when data has to shared, transferred etc. (health networks, but this regulated) But consumer data needs to be well regulated and not treated as a commodity and "asset", that's not a desirable incentive. Consumer data should be one of those things which most companies consider something toxic but necessary so they handle it with care and use the least amount possible rather than collect as much as possible and worry about things later. RadioShack may not have the reams of data an ISP has, but still need a precedent for future data handling and ownership resolution. It'd be great to see this kind of data devolve back to the consumer, i.e. destroyed, once its original user is no longer there to use it in support of ongoing business operations and should not be a mainline of business per se.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- legohead 12y agoI thought user data was one of the most valuable assets of a business. When I worked at Company X, one of our competitors was failing and offered us to buy them out. The most expensive part of the buyout was calculated basically by #users*<some price>. And really that's all we wanted, was their userbase, since we already had the product they wanted. We could absorb their users and immediately grow our business.
- mc32 12y agoI think there's a difference between we'll sell you all this data we have on our users, some of which is related to conducting business with them, and here are our paying customers who you can acquire and continue to provide goods and services to.
- dm2 12y agoCan you better explain the difference please?
- kevando 12y agoThis is why Google's "Don't be evil" mantra freaks me out. Yeah they're not evil now, but who knows in 15 years? That mantra is gonna be like a slap in the face.
- jcadam 12y ago> Yeah they're not evil now Oh come on, I was drinking coffee when I read that :(
- iamcurious 12y agoThey can always redefine evil... Merriam-Webster defines evil[1] as: : morally bad : causing harm or injury to someone : marked by bad luck or bad events Google defines evil[2] as: profoundly immoral and malevolent. Surely Google isn't profoundly immoral and when they happen to be I'm sure they can add a few hyperbolic adjectives to their definition. [1] http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/evil http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/evil [2] http://google.com/search?hl=en&q=evil http://google.com/search?hl=en&q=evil
- new_hackers 12y agoare you sure they aren't evil now?
- c22 12y agoIt's possible Google has always been evil. What better motto for an evil entity to have?
- ck2 12y agoIt is one thing for private corporation to sell their sales data. Some people don't have a problem with that, though I think they should. You might be outraged however to discover that your state DMV will happily sell your license/cartag data to corporations.
- fiatmoney 12y agoIt is standard in bankruptcies to dissolve existing contracts (after all, the point of bankruptcy is that you can't fulfil all of your existing contractual obligations). So it's not surprising on face that privacy policies would be included in this. (This is distinct from "selling / buying the company" which usually means assuming all obligations). For a class of contractual obligation to be "special" in the context of bankruptcy you typically need some kind of legislative protection (some states have rules about "outstanding payroll gets paid first", student loans are nondischargable, etc). Or some kind of bankruptcy cour ruling that liquidating the assets in this way would be somehow inefficient or against the public interest, which looks like how the FTC is approaching it. But in a circumstance where a huge portion of the business's assets were "private information", I could see a bankruptcy court ruling the other way - this doesn't necessarily establish binding precedent.
- chris_wot 12y agoIn Australia, we have a set of clear privacy principles outlined in law. These are called the Australian Privacy Principles, and there are 13 of them. The first principle is "Australian Privacy Principle 1 — open and transparent management of personal information", and it states that every organisation must publish a privacy policy and it must state "the purposes for which the entity collects, holds, uses and discloses personal information". That's legally binding. If the company violates it, there are massive fines and the Privacy Commisdioner can investigate.
- lazyjones 12y agoI don't know the case's specifics, but doesn't typically the bankruptcy court decide what assets are to be sold? The former management and staff (what we are thinking of when slate.com writes "RadioShack Sold...") has no influence over this and should not be blamed. The bankruptcy court is the new management, they can do what they want and must according to law to satisfy creditors, blame them.
- agwa 12y agoThey collected and stored data unnecessarily, so former management absolutely shares blame.
- jmkni 12y agoI have worked a company where this has happened, and it wasn't even the company themselves really. They went into administration, and the administrators came in and wanted to see if they had anything of value. Data is of value, so they sold it to a rival company. Not a lot you can do about it really, apart from not store the data in the first place.
- kefka 12y agoThe answer is: Do not have a privacy policy. If you have a privacy policy and you violate it, the FTC comes after you. No policy? No harassment from FTC. Aside that fact, it's not like they really matter. Right?
- matthewmcg 12y agoThe laws of many jurisdictions require you to have a privacy policy if you are going to collect personally identifiable information from residents of that jurisdiction. See, for example, the California Online Privacy Protection Act.
- rglover 12y agoSO that's why I just got a random call from Michigan selling me a security system.
- JackFr 12y agoThe question comes down to is the private equity group a successor organization. If Best Buy had swooped in and bought Radio Shack, maintaining it as an ongoing concern I don't think anyone would have objected to them getting the data and honoring Radio Shack's original agreement. That is, they are not a third party, they are the successor to the party of the first part, viz Radio Shack. Also had a private equity group come in and bought Radio Shack and taken them private, few would have objected to the now private Radio Shack under new management, maintaining the data and the agreements they held. But by dragging Radio Shack through bankruptcy, they begin to lose the appearance of a successor organization, and begin to look more like a third party.
- strathmeyer 12y agoIt's pretty hilarious this is being 'reported' on a site that won't let you read the article unless you give them your personal information.
- bcheung 12y agoDid they sell the data or the company? I'd be curious to know if the new owner is still obligated to follow the same privacy statement? In either case, I'm not going to lose any sleep over this.
- jms703 12y agoIsn't everyone doing this in some form?
- anigbrowl 12y agoAnd people wonder why I am less exercised about government snooping than most, when it arguably has much less impact on most people's lives. (This is not the same as saying that it's OK; I just don't think it's the #1 tech-social problem).
- gcb0 12y agoJust makes you wonder, what if Google, Apple or Facebook go broke tomorrow?
- cmdrfred 12y agoNever gave them a fucking scrap of data, in fact I actively gave them bad but valid enough looking information so they (and now whoever they sold it to) will waste time and money.
- bhartzer 12y agoLuckily, I've ditched my landline since I bought stuff at Radio Shack. So any calls to my old landline phone number won't get through. Is there any indication that what you bought there, along with your contact info was sold? Or just your contact info?
- kw71 12y agoThose calls may not get through to you, but they'll get through to a bloke like me, who happened to get your old number, hates marketing calls and will play games with the callers (Billy speaking, Yes your ridiculous offer is relevant to my interests, I'll take it) and extracting data from them bit by bit (My address? I still live in Pratville and haven't moved. OK, Fine, I'll confirm the details you read to me.) If I had fewer scruples I'd actually use the data for criminal acts, but I simply amuse myself by seeing how far I can get with callers.
- antidaily 12y agoOh fuck. Someone knows I bought some RJ45 connectors!?!
- dredmorbius 12y agoMaciej Cegłowski "The Internet With a Human Face" http://idlewords.com/bt14.htm http://idlewords.com/bt14.htm As a wise man once said, if you have something that you don’t want anyone to know, maybe you shouldn’t be doing it in the first place. But there are also dangerous scenarios that don't involve government at all, and that we don't talk enough about. I'll use Facebook as my example. To make the argument stronger, let's assume that everyone currently at Facebook is committed to user privacy and doing their utmost to protect the data they've collected. What happens if Facebook goes out of business, like so many of the social networks that came before it? Or if Facebook gets acquired by a credit agency? How about if it gets acquired by Rupert Murdoch, or taken private by a hedge fund? What happens to all that data?