4 ms·
My own view was that I was fairly happy with the status quo after the referendum and before the general election - but it turned out that keeping that wasn't an
by arethuza 12y ago
My own view was that I was fairly happy with the status quo after the referendum and before the general election - but it turned out that keeping that wasn't an option.
The rUK has swung decisively to the right (e.g. UKIP 12%), the Conservatives have a majority on their own without the moderating influence of the Lib Dems - which is fine as we are a democracy but the people of Scotland clearly have wildly different views (SNP 50%, UKIP 1.6%).
Then of course there is the prospect of BoJo as PM - which I think would pretty much guarantee a rapid dissolution of the UK.
- s_kilk 12y agoAgreed on all counts. For those who don't know what we're talking about: this map of the recent UK election results should illustrate the huge divide between Scotland and England: https://flipchartfairytales.files.wordpress.com/2015/05/screen-shot-2015-05-11-at-10-03-33.png https://flipchartfairytales.files.wordpress.com/2015/05/scre... They are two very different cultures.
- gsnedders 12y agoI don't think that's really fair — that makes it look like Scotland almost unanimously voted SNP, which they didn't. While yes, the SNP got 50% of the vote, that's far from the 94% of constituencies they won. Similarly, it also overstates the Tories' success in England — actually only 41% of the vote. (And it doesn't look like Labour has anywhere near the same number of seats that the Tories do, even though they're only a hundred off, out of 650.) Being disenfranchised with Westminster is far from a Scottish phenomenon: the SNP's success one can easily argue comes in significant part from the fact they've managed to position themselves as a viable winner in a large number of constituencies, not least through leading the Scottish Government since 2007, as a large proportion of voters end up voting for one of the two largest parties in their constituency given a single-winner system. Convincing the electorate a vote for your minor party isn't a wasted vote is a major part of the challenge of making a small party a real challenge in a large number of constituencies.
- IshKebab 12y agoThat's a very misleading image. Here's a better one: http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/03297/2010-vs-2015_3297055a.gif http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/03297/2010-vs-20...
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoThat image is a screencap from the BBC website AFAICT, http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election/2015/results/scotland http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election/2015/results/scotland - 50% of voters in Scotland voted SNP. >They are two very different cultures. // You might be able to show that but not with these election results - is Edinburgh a different culture to the rest of Scotland (well it is, but not any more than Glasgow is different to Aberdeen), is Orkney & Shetland a different culture (same thing applies)? Bradford and Bridlington [2 conurbations in the region of Yorkshire in the UK] are probably more culturally diverse than most random pairs of Scottish and rUK places.
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago>but the people of Scotland clearly have wildly different views // Really? Having lived in Scotland, Wales and England this doesn't seem to be true. The swing to the right I think is in part due to apparent immigration pressures and in part [much more speculatively] a selfish response to poverty (someone has to be poor make sure it's someone else and not me). Scotland doesn't have the same immigration issues as other parts of the UK as far as I can tell in this [1] map you can see the areas with major cities are clearly home to more migrants - Glasgow, Edinburgh and I'm guessing that's Dundee and Perth and Aberdeen [which might be skewed by oil workers?]. Same in England and Wales except that some areas have seen a huge increase in migrant populations [2] indeed in 2012 the migrant population in Scotland was ~7% vs ~13% in the rest of the UK [3]. [Note I'm trusting the stats here, please provide corrections if they seem wrong.] Personally I don't think that Scotland will react more gracefully with similar immigration patterns. Indeed if Scotland secedes from the UK and is successful in gaining entry to the EU then they will be outside the Schengen Area [4, it's been agreed that all new applicants will be accepted as outside the Schengen Area]. That would mean Scotland would likely get a big increase in immigrants too and I suspect the response would be similar. >Then of course there is the prospect of BoJo as PM - which I think would pretty much guarantee a rapid dissolution of the UK. // So there's not much difference between BoJo and SNP then? /s - - - [1] http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/ampp3d/immigration-map-britain-foreign-migrants-4669250 http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/ampp3d/immigration-map-britain-... [2] http://www.migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/data-and-resources/maps/census-map-non-uk-born-population-increase-2001-v-2011-england-and-wales http://www.migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/data-and-resources/... [3] http://www.migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/briefings/global-international-migrant-stock-scotland-international-comparison http://www.migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/briefings/global-in... [4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area
- arethuza 12y ago"this doesn't seem to be true" So why have 50% of Scots voted for a political party with notably different policies to UK-wide parties? Presumably if we thought the same way as everyone in the UL (excluding NI) we'd have picked Labour or Conservative like the good old days?