29 ms·
Self-Driving Trucks Are Going to Hit Us Like a Human-Driven Truck
- jpollock 12y agoNo, they won't anymore than an autopilot that can take off, fly and land has gotten rid of pilots.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThat won't take that long.
- vdaniuk 12y agoI agree and I believe that at first automation won't be integrated in the boeings and airbuses but will grow and evolve from inside the drone industry.
- vdaniuk 12y agoThat's not a good comparison due to the difference in risks and returns. Airplanes are expensive, are subject to international regulations and possess extreme damage potential. Trucks can be confined to desert roads (like in Australia), are relatively cheap and are subject to national regulations. Also AFAIK drivers are relatively more expensive than pilot in comparison with total cost of ownership.
- greendesk 12y agoI find myself in the strange situation where I both agree and disagree with this sentiment. The source of disagreement can be described as "time" - I consider not only the past, but the delay that happens after a technology is described to when it makes changes in our lives. It all takes time, and in the time to come, there is a chance that autopilots can take more responsibility from the pilot. Would you really be confident that in 20 or 30 years time, pilots will have the same job description as of today? Of course, a pilot in a passenger plane has a lot more responsibility than simply piloting the plane. For example, dealing with passengers or talking to ground control. The autonomous trucks will not take driver's seat overnight - the truck in question will be a decade-long testing phase, according to the article. What happens afterwards is anyone's guess.
- ubernostrum 12y agoWould you really be confident that in 20 or 30 years time, pilots will have the same job description as of today? Yes. "Autopilot" systems are, in terms of capabilities, well behind even current widely-deployed technology in ground vehicles. In the air, an autopilot system is essentially glorified cruise control, and nobody asks when cruise control in cars will take over for humans. Autoland systems are pretty far behind automatic parallel-parking features in modern cars; autoland requires significant human decision-making, human input and human oversight to function. And the purpose of autopilot/autoland is not to replace the pilot, but to relieve the pilot of mundane tasks the software can do perfectly well, freeing the pilot to do things software still is -- and likely will continue to be -- bad at. Unless, of course, you think friendly human-serving general-purpose AI will be available within the next two or three decades (I don't).
- greendesk 12y ago>>Unless, of course, you think friendly human-serving general-purpose AI will be available within the next two or three decades (I don't). /sigh. A decade ago I started my bachelors. When I was in college, I expected that general-purpose AI will be readily available by this point. How naive I was! Currently, I doubt it will be available by that point in time. /sigh I do not know how much progress will be achieved within the next two or three decades. In the circumstances of passenger flights, keeping current solutions is likely a conservative and more pragmatic approach. With regards to my comment, I do not expect autopilots to substitute pilots. Instead, I expect that they should be able to handle additional tasks assigned from the pilots. For example, it was not a passenger flight, but a helicopter crashed in Nepal during the rescue from the earthquake. I wonder if its pilot had fore-warning from sensory information prior to the crash; and if they had not, how to design its warning system and if an autopilot could take control of the helicopter to land it safely. The sources I have read on passenger pilots use of autopilots is: http://flyingforeveryone.blogspot.com/2012/01/autopilot-myth-what-your-pilot-really.html http://flyingforeveryone.blogspot.com/2012/01/autopilot-myth... http://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/why-do-we-still-use-pilots-to-fly-airplanes http://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/why-do-we-s...
- x0054 12y agoYou are right, just like AI that writes finance and sports articles would never displace journalists. Oh, hold on, it has. But surely a robotic assembly line would never replace honest and hard working American automotive workers..... just don't look at Detroit for conformation of that theory. At least all of our secretary and typist jobs are still safe..... well, not so much, but still, surely one can always go to a pharmacist school and get a high paying job after that. Right. What, AI is doing that now too, and better than humans ever could? Na.... Change is coming, and there are too many people who wish to hide their head in the sand rather then embrace this change, and figure out how to deal with it. We need a new economic model, because capitalism isn't going to work in a world where everything is created by machines (capital) and consumers have nothing of value to exchange for the goods that capital is producing. I am not arguing for communism, because we all know how well that has worked in the past. We need another solution. Unless, if AI is going to replace all the labor, why not also replace the consumers with AI :)
- cturner 12y ago> I am not arguing for communism, because we all know > how well that has worked in the past. We need another > solution. Do you have any ideas? Capitalism uses the market to allocate resources. Typically, when someone pitches an alternative it will boil down to some variation of government reallocation. This has many names, but all of them are a breeding ground for corruption and injustice. Maybe we haven't been looking hard enough. What if we start with your premise: capitalism is failing some regions. To avoid ending back at government-reallocation, we could add to it a second premise: the purpose of government is to enforce live-and-let-live and do absolutely no more. Within these rules, can we find something new? It might help to stop seeing government as a God-Object to stick new functionality into, and instead consider whether there should be other objects in play. So far I've got nothing. But I find myself thinking of business models, rather than social reform.
- kolinko 12y agothe problem with communism was that it tried almost 100% government management and planning. Private iniative was forbidden, even in the areas in which it would be useful. (source: I grew up in a socialist/communist country) In that manner, capitalism with guaranteed income is different. You want to be rich, go ahead amd try your chances at trade, entrepreneurship etc. You see a market opportunity - go ahead and kickstart it. On the other hamd, if you lack a capability, or you prefer to do things that nobody will want to pay you for (art, raising children etc), the govrnment will keep you covered. Obviously there are problems to it, especially today when production costs are expensive. And there are implementation problems as well. But still, one system is the ultimate oppression, another one is ultimate freedom. Btw. The running joke in communism was: "yeah, our system is perfect, it's just the implememtation that sucks". I believe that communism was impossible to get implemented correctky, whereas capitalism + minimum income can be. Not today, but in a few years when the goods will be even cheaper.
- anigbrowl 12y agoAll of this is absolutely true. But what we need for the idea of basic income to take off is a positive rationale for it, as opposed to a negative one of the 'if we don't we're fucked' kind. The reason this matters is that the disruption won't be overnight, so you're looking at more of aobiling-frog scenario where the pace of job loss is slow enough that politicians can blame it on other sources for a while, like whoever is in the White House at the time, furriners taking our jawbs, workers being too lazy to retrain...basically the same bullshit we've heard over most of the last decade as an excuse not to engage with the deeper structural problems in our economy. Politicians excel at this; look at how Japan has been in an economic stall for 20 or so years, with politicians tinkering round the edges and shying away from fundamental change, because opportunist opponents can leverage change to mobilize political power by making empty promises. The problem is that a basic income to (say) the 150m people in the civilian labor force x the ~$23k poverty line income would be about $3.4 trillion, which is not far off the entire federal government budget. That's (very roughly) $10,000 worth of redistribution for everyone in the country, which is going to be an incredibly tough sell politically, for reasons that I hope are obvious. People in general are terrible at doing sensible things to stave off a distant-seeming catastrophe, viz the relatively poor progress on lowering/mitigating/managing the effects of climate change (whether or not you believe it's humanity's fault) or any number of other topics. I do agree with the writer's conclusion and reasoning, I'm just pessimistic about our ability to manage the accelerating pace of disruption.
- afarrell 12y agoBut in theory won't the poverty line decrease since the cost of everything but rent and medical care will go down?
- geon 12y agoWhy would cost go down?
- maxerickson 12y agoI think the other commenter meant that self driving trucks will likely reduce the cost of shipping. Shipping doesn't add a whole lot of cost to goods already though, an awful lot of bananas fit on a pallet (I think bananas are a reasonable example here, they are shipped overseas, cheap, bulky and somewhat fragile).
- afarrell 12y agoThere may be labor resistance to self-driving trucks, but you know who is in favor of[1] self-driving cars? the American Association of Retired Persons. They are the most powerful lobbying organization in the US because in addition to their $232 million[1] lobbying budget, they can deliver the thing that politicians on state and federal levels care most about: votes. People age 65 and older consistently vote at higher rates than the rest of the population [3]. At least, until their inability to drive a car keeps them from the polls... [1] http://www.aarp.org/home-family/personal-technology/info-2014/google-self-driving-car.html http://www.aarp.org/home-family/personal-technology/info-201... [2] http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2014/3/22/is-the-aarp-the-900poundinvisiblegorillaintheroom.html http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2014/3/22/is-the-aarp-... [3] http://money.usnews.com/money/retirement/articles/2012/03/19/why-older-citizens-are-more-likely-to-vote http://money.usnews.com/money/retirement/articles/2012/03/19...
- dbpokorny 12y ago> until their inability to drive a car keeps them from the polls... According to http://www.mtvoters.org/node/356 http://www.mtvoters.org/node/356 If you're unable to drive to the polls yourself, you have several options: You can vote by mail. You can catch a ride with a friend or neighbor. You can get a ride from one of numerous organizations and agencies that offer voter transportation. Call your local election office to find out who is providing transportation in your community.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- s_q_b 12y agoThe elderly have organized pickups to drive them to the polls, absentee ballots, relatives, etc. The scariest thing I've seen was a Facebook conversation in which no less than a dozen of my classmates, all finance sector employees, were openly mocking an article about the massive disruption self-driving cars will have, as if it were a Jetson's fantasy rather than a one to two year prospect and ten year inevitability. We're in for a massive bumpy disruption. Smart investors stand to make a fortune right now. But a lot of people are going to lose their shirt in the process.
- ck2 12y agoWhat happens with sensor interference when there are "54 million self-driving vehicles in 2035" ?
- greendesk 12y agoI expect a constant review of the sensor performance and adjustment. The truck in question is part of a decade-old testing phase, according to the article. This will provide a lot of information, which can help navigate the issue of sensor interference. Sensor malfunction was a constant worry when I worked on small robotics projects. I hope that car companies, which have much bigger resources than I can afford on my projects, will spend sufficient effort on making sensor interference and various malfunctions not degrade the operation of an autonomous vehicle.
- danpat 12y agoThere are techniques for reducing the effects of active sensor interference, for example: http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~motionplanning/papers/sbp_papers/integrated3/kleeman_sonar_reject.pdf http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~motionplanning/papers/sbp_papers/inte... As long as the usable sensor density is higher than how tightly we can pack these vehicles, then we're probably OK.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hspak 12y agoSo the concern is the economy slowing down due to the large number of current truck drivers who are going to be out of jobs in the near future. I don't expect there to be a sudden drop. First comes the autopilot trucks where they still need to be manned. Sure the drivers will likely take a hit in pay, they'll still have a job. Then comes the fully autonomous trucks, removing the drivers although. I see this being a gradual transition, not a cliff like the article mentions. "Basically, the only real barrier to the immediate adoption of self-driven trucks is purely legal in nature, not technical or economic." I feel like this is such a huge assumption considering any type of autonomous driving has not been seen use anywhere yet.
- x0054 12y ago> I feel like this is such a huge assumption considering any type of autonomous driving has not been seen use anywhere yet. It has, Google has openly admitted to have driven more than 100k miles fully autonomously. The technology IS here, it's going to be widespread in 15-20 years.
- tomcart 12y agoMore than that, autonomous driving is being used increasingly in industries like mining: http://www.smh.com.au/business/mining-and-resources/caterpillar-says-autonomous-trucks-are-not-just-about-cutting-jobs-20140924-10lb25.html http://www.smh.com.au/business/mining-and-resources/caterpil... The technology developed in these situations for fleeting etc. is just as likely to find its way into road going trucks as that from Google.
- prawn 12y agoHaven't Delphi auto-driven three cars across the US?
- gwern 12y agoGoogle's up to 1.7m miles, apparently; this came up earlier in discussions of the accident rate: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9526602 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9526602 (Always in motion, the future is...)
- huuu 12y agoRelated: In The Netherlands they are testing linked trucks. A kind of road train: http://www.nltimes.nl/2015/02/10/self-driving-trucks-tested-dutch-highway/ http://www.nltimes.nl/2015/02/10/self-driving-trucks-tested-...
- mrec 12y agoNot physically linked; they're talking about platooning. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platoon_%28automobile%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platoon_%28automobile%29
- adventured 12y agoThis article claims that truck driver is the most common job in more than half of all states. That's obviously false. There are as many registered nurses as truck drivers for example. And there are seven million teachers in the US. "About 2.8 million workers drive trucks around. That’s a big number, but it pales in comparison to other occupations. More than 21 million people work in office and administrative support, more than 14 million work in sales and more than 11 million work in food services. Nine million work in transportation or material-moving occupations. Heck, there are nearly 9 million production workers who actually make things." http://www.marketwatch.com/story/no-truck-driver-isnt-the-most-common-job-in-your-state-2015-02-12 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/no-truck-driver-isnt-the-mo...
- ska 12y agoI don't know if the claim is correct or not, but you have not demonstrated that it is false. The occupations you describe (nurses, teachers, office workers) can be expected to correlate with population density in a way that just doesn't seem to be necessary for truck drivers, or at least for many of them. Given that population is very non uniformly distributed amongst the states, it is very plausible to have a high proportion of long distance truck drivers living in low population states, so this claim could be true.
- djrogers 12y agoLook at some of the states in the map that claim truck driver as the highest - CA, TX, MI, IL; these are not low-population states. What's happened here is that the statistics are very poorly represented. Jobs like 'teacher' and nurse are broken down to fine-grained distinctions, while seemingly everyone who touches a truck steering wheel is lumped in as a truck driver. Lies, damned lies, and...
- ska 12y agoThat's plausible, but the parent analysis doesn't hold; I wasn't addressing the article. I could have worded it better.
- 12y ago
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoEver seen the movie "Hoffa"? Recall the scene when he's being transported to prison.
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoThe great thing about self-driving suicide bombs is how many lives will be spared.
- josephagoss 12y agoIs "Software Developer" really the most common job in several US states? I'm really finding that hard to believe.
- bsaul 12y agoI'm still very skeptical on self driving vehicules to react correctly in non traditional events happening on the road... Like, fraying your way in a traffic jam to reach the correct lane, which sometimes involve slow but untraditionnal paths. Or Waiting half an hour for an accident to be cleaned, then looking at the police officer signs telling you to move on the lane coming in the other direction, because they've secured it for a while, etc. I'm pretty sure we'll have a lot of autonomous vehicles stuck on the roads in a " wait for a human driver to unlock me" mode at the beginning.
- espadrine 12y ago> fraying your way in a traffic jam to reach the correct lane That is what makes Elon Musk's branding of his technology so smart. He is not replacing you the driver by a label such as “driverless car” or even excluding you from the driving experience with a “self-driving car” label. Mr Musk's offer, an “autopilot”, is an opt-out to driving, an aid. Great branding, same technology. Besides, people consider autopilots to be an old and well-known technology, because it has been used on airplanes.
- smackay 12y agoI'm sure the electronic equivalent of traffic cones will appear pretty quickly - the cost won't be much more and the existing ones will be easy to retrofit. I'm sure there will be a lot of interesting consequences and side-effects of this. I'd be very interested to see the result on the natural environment in 100 years time - with great concentration of people in cities there might be need to restore former wetlands and riverine habitats to ensure sufficient retention of water throughout the year. The shutting down of a myriad of small towns would take a lot of people out of the environment leaving more space for plants and wildlife. The possibilities are endless.
- jellicle 12y agoSo you can just put a couple of cones across a highway and stop all traffic for a few hours? Cool! I'll bet you can even camouflage the transmitter so that no one can figure out why all traffic has stopped until they come out with a really sensitive detector and realize that there's something stuck 30 feet up in the tree branches instructing all vehicles to go into emergency stop mode.
- guard-of-terra 12y agoLand between large cities increasingly turns to human desert in many places of the world. People find no reason to continue living in small settlements and no ecomonical backing for doing so. Places where people lived for thousand years now become deserted. This might be another nail in the coffin after rail (only stops at large cities) and air (flies over entirely).
- waterlesscloud 12y agoWhat if it works the other way round? What if automation eliminates most, if not all, jobs, and thus reduces the appeal of living in cities where work is easily found? What if land remains expensive in urban areas, but the economic support for people to afford it isn't there? What if automated delivery makes it cheaper to deliver to anywhere, so that it becomes easier and more practical to live far apart from others?
- guard-of-terra 12y agoThis might as well happen. I think that decent Basic Income will cause just that: millions of people leaving expensive cities to live cheaply in the country. This thought is backed by Russian dacha phenomenon.
- zaroth 12y agoThere are many programs which together provide a significant economic baseline. It's not all in the form of direct cash deposits, although much of it is, it's just that the programs are a disparate and tangled mess. That $40k trucker's salary nets out to only about $5k more than the baseline benefits for an unemployed adult citizen. [1] It's barely better than not working, and you have to spend the whole week on the road! Staying home and fixing up the house [2] while taking the subsidies will always be a better bet. The only difference between what we have today and "Basic Income" is currently we phase the benefits out as you start to work, obviously to disincentivize working. You could think of "Universal Healthcare", for example, a lot like eliminating the phase-out for Medicaid. ACA already eliminated the asset test, now it's just an income test, so maybe that will go next. (mostly depends who's elected in 2016) [1] http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/11-15-2012-MarginalTaxRates.pdf http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/11-15-2012-MarginalTa... [2] http://imgur.com/a/Bnacv http://imgur.com/a/Bnacv
- adventured 12y agoThat's not the only difference. We have a massive bureaucracy to handle all the various aspects of the distribution of those benefits. Most of which is not necessary in a basic income system. The cost savings by eliminating that bureaucracy would be substantial.
- icebraining 12y agoOf course, by "cost savings" you're essentially talking about a whole new lot of jobs lost.
- Programmatic 12y agoIt's cool, they'll get a basic income too. ;P
- ams6110 12y agoAll those eliminated bureaucrats are now on basic income. What have you saved?
- InclinedPlane 12y agoEventually someone will be smart enough to figure out how to build an automated package delivery network in a city. Just imagine the economic benefit that will have. Imagine if every company could offer shipping services similar to Amazon Prime but at a fraction of the cost. Automated trucks would significantly aid long haul shipping legs in such a network.
- remarkEon 12y agoAnd with that, the elimination of entire industries built up around the existence of car ownership like: mechanics, car washes, parking, valets, body shops, rental companies, car insurance, car loans, and on and on. I'm not so sure that's true. If a truck/car breaks down on the road, it doesn't matter if there's a human behind the wheel or a software program. It still needs to get fixed. There will still need to be financing of these vehicles, ostensibly because they might be more expensive because of the software/hardware allowing it to be autonomous in the first place. We haven't really worked through how insuring these things will work, but just because they're autonomous does not mean that all of a sudden the entire automotive insurance industry evaporates. On the whole, however, I agree with the initial point about how the peripheral economies built around servicing human truck drivers on their routes will take a hit. I'm thinking of all the towns on the way to Watertown from Minneapolis that would probably evaporate if they didn't have the trucks running the daily on the 212.
- peletiah 12y agoBut there will be far fewer cars, as it's no longer necessary to own one. Less parking space, narrower paved roads (Traffic will also be more efficient), less car sustained industry overall.
- JetSpiegel 12y agoUnless you carve out the existing infrastructure, roads won't magically get narrower jsut because they are not used.
- ceejayoz 12y agoThe roads around here seem to get redone every 5-10 years at most, which provides plenty of opportunity to narrow them.
- akira2501 12y ago> On the whole, however, I agree with the initial point about how the peripheral economies built around servicing human truck drivers on their routes will take a hit. I'm thinking of all the towns on the way to Watertown from Minneapolis that would probably evaporate if they didn't have the trucks running the daily on the 212. Are they going to stop the trucks? Are self driving trucks going to be able to carry more load? Are we going to change highway rules to allow more than 80k pounds total weight for a single tractor/trailer? Are the trucks going to be electric or have vastly improved MPG? No. So there will still be the same amount of truck traffic as well as the same amount of fuel being sold in nearly the same locations. Perhaps restaurants will take a hit, but fuel and servicing will still be utilized for quite some time.
- tomohawk 12y agoIs it just me, or does anyone else think that if 'truck driver' was the most prevalent job in DC (instead of 'lawyer'), we would all be better off?
- camillomiller 12y agoThe Simpsons were way ahead of their times: Maximum Homerdrive (S10.E17). First aired March 28, 1999. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maximum_Homerdrive http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maximum_Homerdrive "During the [trucking] trip [from Springfield to Atlanta], Homer falls asleep and wakes up abruptly at the wheel of the truck due to taking a combination of pep pills and sleeping pills that he bought at a general store. He awakes to discover that the truck drove by itself with its Navitron Autodrive system. He informs other truck drivers, who inform him that he cannot let anyone know about the Autodrive system because it would make all truck drivers lose their jobs. However, Homer tells a passing bus about the system which causes an angry mob of truckers to get in a showdown with Homer, and he survives without the autodrive system. Homer and Bart arrive in Atlanta to finish the shipment on time, and then commandeer a train full of napalm to Springfield."
- s_q_b 12y agoThe blackboard in a particular episode also contains the correct mass of the Higgs boson. There were several maths PhDs on the writing staff, so there's a lot of intelligent humor that flies over the average viewer's head (and often mine for some of the hidden math jokes.)
- cbd1984 12y agohttp://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat/2013/10/29/the_simpsons_and_fermat_s_last_theorem_wizard_of_evergreen_terrace_has_brilliant.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat/2013/10/29/the_simpsons_... "The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace", 1998.
- golergka 12y agoOf course Simpsons did it.
- jmcgough 12y ago"One further important detail to consider is that truck drivers are well-paid. They provide a middle class income of about $40,000 per year. That’s a higher income than just about half (46%) of all tax filers, including those of married households." Or, in other words, they make slightly less than the average tax filer.
- cgs1019 12y agoThey make slightly less than the median tax filer. The difference is potentially significant (I have no idea what the statistics are)
- barrkel 12y agoaverage != median. They make slightly less than the median tax filer.
- EliRivers 12y agoMedian is an average. There are typically three averages in common use; mode, median and (arithmetic) mean. That people generally use "average" as short for "(arithmetic) mean average" is a colloquial shorthand.
- sologoub 12y agoMode and median are not averages, just mean is. Mode: "Like the statistical mean and median, the mode is a way of expressing, in a single number, important information about a random variable or a population. The numerical value of the mode is the same as that of the mean and median in a normal distribution, and it may be very different in highly skewed distributions." [1] [1] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mode_(statistics) http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mode_(statistics)
- pzxc 12y agoI'm pretty sure that mode and median are considered averages. Average: "In colloquial language, an average is the sum of a list of numbers divided by the number of numbers in the list. In mathematics and statistics, this would be called the arithmetic mean. However, the word average may also refer to the median, mode, or other central or typical value. In statistics, these are all known as measures of central tendency." [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Average https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Average
- lovelearning 12y agoI don't believe truck drivers will become jobless. They'll just become truck operators. Trains are far more easy to automate, but even bullet trains in japan still have "train drivers" to supervise them.
- Nullabillity 12y agoOn the other hand, the Copenhagen subway does not have any drivers.
- minthd 12y agoTrain drivers are a small part of the cost of a train delivery. Truck drivers are a substantial part of the cost.
- cheald 12y agoYup. 3.5 million professional truck drivers at $40k income (+ $3,600 in payroll taxes + ~$12,000 in health insurance premiums + ~$2,000 in 401(k) matches) is $200b in annual costs that potentially go away. A huge portion of the cost of many goods is in transportation, and a large amount of that cost is human capital (as it is in any industry). Auto insurance rates will likely drop, as well. The supply-side effect of this is that goods will get a lot cheaper, and because robots can drive 24 hours/day, shipping gets faster and easier. Anything that isn't locally produced will become cheaper and more available than it is now.
- prawn 12y agoEven then, one operator could control ten trucks simultaneously. Lots of jobs lost.
- lordnacho 12y ago1. The heck? Software Dev is the most common job in WA, VA, UT and CO but not California? 2. I'm coming round to the idea of a non-means-tested basic income. This would mean there are no marginal effects. For instance, in many countries, if you get paid unemployment you lose it when you find employment. This means you might need a very high income to make it worthwhile, because you'll be losing the benefits as well as your free time. If it was simply a non-dependent income/tax break (if you have an income) you wouldn't get this high effective tax rate. You could work or not work, totally up to you. You can take a side job, try new industries, etc. There would also be less of a circus about controlling that you're sending job applications (adds up to a LOT of apps for jobs people may not actually want), courses about how to write a CV, and staff to send out the money. 3) Other benefits of self-drive: a) You don't need to drive as fast. These things won't need to sleep, so that's a good few hours a day extra. You can drive slower, saving fuel, and still arrive on a current logistical schedule. Driving slower also means you can have a bunch of trucks really close to each other to save on aerodynamics. You could write software to plan truck trains for this purpose. b) They're all going to be electrical. I know, they aren't currently. But electric is just taking off now, while ICE has had plenty of development. A lot of complication in modern cars is the ICE. You need to lug a transmission with you. You need to mix the fuel with air. With electric, you have regenerative breaking, engines are smaller, and batteries will only get better. You'll use less energy, which will push the economics towards slow moving land-trains.
- k-mcgrady 12y ago>> "For instance, in many countries, if you get paid unemployment you lose it when you find employment. This means you might need a very high income to make it worthwhile, because you'll be losing the benefits as well as your free time." Obviously I don't know which countries you're referring to but in the UK the way it works is that while on job seekers allowance you can work up to 16 hours per week and still receive the benefit. It's not perfect but I think it's designed to prevent the problem you're describing.
- ape4 12y agoSoftware Dev is the most common job in some states?! Really.
- noreasonw 12y agoI don't know how a machine program is going to drive in my city, many times you have to read the other driver face to know if he is going to respect the norms. I propose the following challange for those cars, try to cross Arc de triomphe in Paris, or any similar place in my city and prove you risk your life reasonably, it is not so far a experience from poker.
- return0 12y agoIt will require a big leap of technology for this to work in europe. American roads are ready for robot drivers though.
- icebraining 12y agoThat's not a problem for trucks, most of them don't go into the city centers anyway. And in any case, they can just drive themselves until they reach the city borders, then park themselves and wait for a human driver to pick them up. Instead of having hundreds of drivers on the roads, companies can just have a few on each endpoint. But I think you overestimate the difficulty of dealing with other drivers. Remember that self-driving cars have essentially immediate reactions and much better awareness of their surroundings. You can avoid a lot of accidents when you can track every car around you, millisecond by millisecond.
- foobarian 12y agoIt's not necessary for the automation to solve the most difficult environments. As long as it can handle the majority of the distance it would be quite useful. For example a small number of operators could get the trucks to a depot near a highway, trucks could drive autonomously non-stop across the country, and then another operator could manually move them from a receiving depot to a local destination.
- pandler 12y agoI wonder how a ubiquitous self-driving car "cloud" will affect motorcycles. I don't think I speak only for myself when I say that I don't just ride my motorcycle to get from point a to point b; rather I choose to ride it for the thrill of riding a motorcycle. I don't imagine you can completely remove the human element from transportation without killing the thing that makes motorcycles most enjoyable.
- rejschaap 12y agoTake the motorcycle to the race track. Better yet, just leave it there and use a driver-less car to visit the race track. Autonomous driving is about minimizing cost and maximizing safety. Not maximizing motorcyclist happiness.
- vinbreau 12y agoI don't think autonomous driving will kill recreational driving. Enthusiasts will still buy motorcycles and drive the open road. I'm not a rider, but have many friends who do and I understand the appeal. Those types are not going to give up that lifestyle. The industry around recreational driving may shrink a little, but will still be there to provide vehicles for those who want them.
- TulliusCicero 12y agoThey will continue to drive recreationally until manually driven vehicles are banned.
- tomjen3 12y agoHopefully not. I get the appeal but that is no reason to risk murdering other people. If you want to experience the thrill of adrenaline then jump out over a cliff or out of an (autonomous) airplane, don't risk other peoples life.
- eosrei 12y agoRecreational driving will continue, but become more expensive. Car insurance companies aren't going away. Less drivers = higher premiums.
- peteretep 12y agoNew rule: if you want to write about how mechanisation and automation will affect the people, you need to - at absolute minimum - have read the entirety of the Wikipedia article about The Industrial Revolution, and know where the term Luddite comes from.
- copsarebastards 12y agoOkay, so what's your actual criticism? You realize the vast majority of textiles are produced by machinery, right? The luddites lost, and sank into irrelevance.
- gggmaster 12y agoIf they had had basic income, maybe they would not have become Luddites?
- copsarebastards 12y agoMaybe, but I don't know why the original author should be obligate to demostrate knowledge about that in order to talk intelligently about basic income. Remember, I'm responding to: > "New rule: if you want to write about how mechanisation and automation will affect the people, you need to - at absolute minimum - have read the entirety of the Wikipedia article about The Industrial Revolution, and know where the term Luddite comes from." Luddism is certainly interesting, but it's relatively small in terms of its effects and one can certainly talk about basic income without talking about luddism.
- chiaro 12y agoThe way they are normally referenced glosses over the fact that the Luddites were a group of people with actual, real concerns about their future. The industrial revolution was good overall, in net, but it was not a pareto improvement and people did suffer. While it's very likely that the continuation of automation will increase global wealth, some efforts to identify the winners and losers and redistribute will be necessary to minimise societal disruption. I'd say the US hasn't done spectacularly on this front in the past.
- blumkvist 12y agoGreat article until the very end... Basic income is not the answer to this. Basic income will lead to terrible social decay caused by apathy and laziness, fueling even more government corruption and ultimately, totalitarianism. I can't help but think all of this talk and rhetoric in recent years is deliberate propaganda, conditioning left-leaning people. I have seen a number of websites posted on HN, especially in comments, which are overly rhetoric and nudge the reader towards utopian left ideas. The sites are well developed both in the application and in the information architecture sense. They don't seem to have revenue model and saying that tracking their financing proved difficult, would be an understatement. Please remember that changing the social framework is a VERY delicate matter. Oftentimes things sound very good on paper, but are not practical at all. Basic income sounds dangerously close to "From each according to his ability, to each according to his need". When people believed this can happen, it ended terribly. Not because of the specific people in charge at the time. Socialism/Communism as a model is doomed to fail because of human nature. When you make social policy, you have to think about the lowest common denominator and currently, it is very low indeed.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoI'm not even vaguely "left leaning", at least not economically. I think capitalism has done a fantastic job of improving living conditions in the West. But I can see that capitalism is coming to its end in the next several decades. Things change. That's the constant. There must be something that's post-capitalist, because capitalism is very close to becoming unsustainable. It's not going to be the old leftist ideas, but it's not going to be capitalism either. We need to adapt. Not like we have a choice, really.
- blumkvist 12y agoI'm not advocating against reforms. I'm advocating against people tripping over ideas who sound too good. The majority of people I've talk to, who believe in basic income, have put very little thought about the ramifications of it. They have very little understanding of politics and social sciences. They read a bunch of articles, like this one, and thought "Hey, that's great, gimme free monies, I read an article that says people are more productive when they are not motivated by money". Next thing you know, they are advocating for it, convincing their friends how great it is. Politicians are always ready to ride the wave, chasing their grandiosity. The conservative way has proved to be a very stable path towards improvement. Slow, but stable. Stability and balance, are in my opinion, the most important characteristics of meaningful improvement.
- tzs 12y agoFor those like me who looked at that map and thought "no way is truck driver the most common job in so many states!", click the NPR link below the map to get to the source for the map. They explain the truck driver thing there. One big factor is that their source doesn't subdivide truck drivers, but does subdivide most other common jobs, such as teachers (split into primary and secondary school teachers). Also, the map on the NPR site is interactive, showing changes over the years. For instance, you can see a lot of states where you probably would have guessed farmer is most common were that way 10 to 20 years ago, but now fewer farmers are needed to grow the same or more food, and so the number of farmers declined.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- the8472 12y agoIn other words: the "most common job" statistic is quite arbitrary due to non-uniform binning of job types. The question is, is this somehow fixable? I don't see a way because those categorizations themselves seem arbitrary and you could lump anything somewhat related together while dividing down anything else if you want to show it's "the most common".
- Schwolop 12y agoPresumably if you took the top 100, and manually merged then into the top 25? 50? job "categories", you'd have a more stable grouping and more interesting time-series statistics.
- yitchelle 12y agoI was actually blown away that software developer is the most common jobs in four US states. Software developer jobs are becoming a commodity, if not already. edit: grammar
- MaulingMonkey 12y agoDriving's just the fun part of being a trucker. Securing and balancing loads, verifying manifests, preventative maintenance and safety inspections... Still, plenty of opportunities for job loss.
- ryanmarsh 12y agoExactly, truck safety is the most important part of being a driver and it is the biggest risk to the company of course. The problem is safety inspections and securing a load properly apparently are harder to do than drive (from my experience shadowing a safety officer). Perhaps if we have less drivers we could transfer the responsibility of certifying the truck/load as "safe" to a surrogate safety officer better trained for that task than your typical driver who frankly doesn't care and will say things like "it's not my trailer" "I didn't load that pallet" or "running the scales"
- mariusz79 12y agoThe Basic Income ship has already sailed, and it's not coming back any time soon. The main reason for this is the fact that automation is here to stay. Every day new systems are being automated, first replacing low-skilled, low-wage jobs. People in these job don't really have much power, knowledge, will nor money to push the BIG agenda. Often times, they are not even aware that such thing is being proposed. People in better paying jobs are also being slowly replaced, but they rarely see this as threat to their jobs, but more like productivity improvement. When some tradesmen, or engineer loses a job because of automation, they first try to work on their skills to stay relevant in the field. They usually won't blame automation for being unemployed, but instead they blame their age, lack of specific new skills, outsourcing or the economy. Without a well paying job, they quickly drop from the affluent middle class to a poor low class. In the mean time, their peers don't see what the real reason for this is, and they happily continue working, hoping that it's not going to happen in their case. They have no incentives to support BIG as they already believe that a lot of taxes go to support the lower classes, and put unfair strain on them. This shift from middle to low class, is already happening. To keep themselves safe, the high middle class, and the 1%'s will support militarization of police, and push even more entertainment options to the masses. People will rarely revolt, as it's easy to imagine that if you're a father and see your kids starving, you will either work even harder trying to support your family, or you'll drink, do drugs and abuse the kids because you may feel that you failed, and you will try to hide this feeling not only from them but from yourself.
- placeybordeaux 12y agoWhat you describe is worryingly reasonable, however I don't see how it leads to the conclusion that the basic income ship has sailed. Current US politics is still very "job creation" centered. Some think tanks need to start churning out pieces to shift public opinion that the number of over all jobs has permanently decreased and separate that from the idea that this is an indicator of our economy doing poorly. From there it is fairly simple to start convincing people that with a good economy and not enough jobs to go around we need to still ensure that everyone has the basic necessities of life.
- 12y ago
- TheHippo 12y agoSome parts of the text look like the author just made a transcript for CPG Grey Video "humans need not apply" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU)
- EGreg 12y agoRobot trucks also don’t need salaries — salaries that stand to go up because fewer and fewer people want to be truckers. Doesn't that kind of contradict the beginning ofthe article? In any case I've been in favor of Unconditional Basic Income for a long time as a result of increased automation and to mitigate demand shocks for local labor. Even anarcho-capitalist libertarians can admit that transitions within the economy can take time that will cause massive contractionsin the money supply of a city/state/country.
- copsarebastards 12y ago"Apple already has technology that may lend itself to an electric car and expertise managing a vast supply chain. The company has long researched battery technology for use in its iPhones, iPads and Macs. The mapping system it debuted in 2012 can be used for navigation…" The mapping system Apple debuted in 2012 cannot reliably be used for navigation.
- chestervonwinch 12y agoWhat is the state of autonomous driving tech in terms of (semi)hazardous weather conditions? Isn't this still a major barrier? Are roadside RFID chips viable?
- Retric 12y agoDifferenchal GPS + Good maps is really all you need for navigation.
- Bulkington 12y agoJournaist who covered the Freightiner/State of Nevada annuncment last week here. The article's summary of the current state of truck autonomy is quite cogent There's an explainer link below for those looking for more detail, but the point Daimler Trucks execs and engineers emphasized is that they have no plans to pursue Level 4 (no driver needed) autonomy. (Although I don't recall that they were pushed on a timeframe for that commitment.) So, as is, this is very much a tool to benefit drivers; i.e., cruise control with steering. But the critical point, as the article notes before taking the leap truck drivers are soon to disappear, is that trucking is big business (collectively) and if this technology can be suppoerted by the business case, then it will be adopted as rapidly as pubic policy permits. However, the author doesn't take into consideration a couple of things: 1: The trucking industry is having a very hard time finding drivers (waaaay tough gig for over-the-road guys). While this may support the notion that trucking companies will rush to adopt autonomus vehicle tech, it takes away some of the punch of his basic income thesis: people don't want to do this job. Truck drivers come from the same pool as construction laborers and factory workers, and when the economy is good there's a driver shortage because workers prefer jobs that let them go home every night compared to sleeping in a truck for weeks at a time. So in this case, basic income is, at best, a trucking industry subsidy. Otherwise, it's make-work. 2: The trucking industry is very fragmented. We're all familiar with many of the big fleet names we see on trailers every day, and while these mega-carriers haul a large percentage of the freight, they're far outnumbered by the number of companies with five or fewer trucks. And there's a great deal of conflict between the policies sought by well-capitalized larger firms (with money to invest in new tech and often lobby to have it manadated) and the Joe's Trucking Cos who are one breakdown or accident from going out of business. But Joe stays in businees because because he fills a niche the big guys aren't interested in. And Joe ain't going to buy a robot, not that he'd mind staying in the office while his truck deivers freight without him, but because he can't afford it. So either the fully driverless truck is going to become so operationally efficient that big trucking companies can move into these niches and fill spot demand, or the technology is going to be so affordabe that the little guy adopts it and then uses his niche expertise to grow is business. Both are wins for the overall economy, with the latter actually staving off a further concentration of capital--which I guess would be a good thing for the basic income crowd. (And as a journlist, I assure you I'm not averse to the concept.) http://news.trucker.com/technology/freightliner-s-autonomous-truck-explained-drawing-board-road http://news.trucker.com/technology/freightliner-s-autonomous...
- henrya 12y agoThis article seems vaguely similar to the Luddite's destroying automated manufacturing equipment because of the belief that it would take their jobs (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite). It seems that there is a fundamental misunderstanding of basic economics. Yes truck driver jobs will go away but this does not mean the loss of jobs and income on the aggregate. The economy will change and shift resources to the now more efficient modes of transportation, which will benefit everyone.
- pat2man 12y agoMedian wages went down right after the luddites lost to manufacturing. Its going to be hard to employ people who have been driving their whole lives and now need to learn a new skill.
- jwecker 12y agoIn addition to ignoring the big picture economics, it makes rather silly claims such as "And with that [the elimination of the need to own cars], the elimination of entire industries built up around the existence of car ownership like: mechanics, car washes, parking..." I think he's confusing eliminating the need to buy a whole car (dubious in the first place even if/ especially if they're automated) with the elimination of cars in general (???) Or he somehow thinks that part of "self-driving" means also self-fixing, self-washing, and cars that never park... roaming the streets in packs I suppose, ganging up on people when the cops aren't looking and stealing their jobs...
- loganmhb 12y agoSometimes there are misunderstandings of economics involved, but just as often that kind of resistance stems from factors that "basic economics" glosses over or abstracts away. There's a lot of economic friction involved in shifts like this, and the pain tends to fall on people who have less power to do anything about it -- it's not trivial for a truck driver to go get a new job in a different industry, and our economic system is not very well set-up to encourage that kind of retraining and shifting, nor to support the basic needs of people who don't have much to contribute to "the economy". (All that's vaguely related to the fact that we've been (in the US) working more and more hours collectively despite higher and higher productivity, so that Keynes's prediction of a 15-hour workweek looks crazy even though his estimation of productivity increases was basically on point...)
- whoisthemachine 12y agoI would not be surprised if the next car I buy is the last car I buy. Personally, I think it will change humanity for the better, we just do not quite grasp how or what yet.
- andrewmutz 12y agoTechnological change obsoleting jobs is not new and has been going on for hundreds of years: bookbinders, scribes, lamplighters, milkmen, town crier, etc. As each profession sunsets, these individuals find new ways to contribute to society. Change isn't easy, but these are "people" not "truck drivers" and will adapt. Basic income is a separate discussion from technological change, unless there is a clear argument why technological progress now is fundamentally different than it always has been.
- wcummings 12y agoI'm pretty fed up with all the people pushing UBI. There is never not enough work for labor to do, labor is just misallocated. I feel like every third piece I read has some poorly thought out UBI slant thrown in for no reason.
- titanomachy 12y agoI think you're right. I would really like to read the opinions of some respected economists on the issue of automation and basic income. The question we should be asking isn't "how do we make sure these people can still consume", it's "how do we find a way for these people to remain valuable to society". Or something along those lines.
- zo1 12y agoOr "Let's imagine how these individuals will adapt to such a big change" ?
- ncallaway 12y agoEd Dolan has a pretty good series on UBI from an economists perspective: http://www.economonitor.com/dolanecon/2014/01/03/the-economic-case-for-a-universal-basic-income/ http://www.economonitor.com/dolanecon/2014/01/03/the-economi...
- rorykoehler 12y agoI always understood that to be the main power of the idea of UBI. Economically liberated individuals will be able to choose how to be valuable to society instead of 'choosing' to work their asses off in a dull repetitive job that they need to survive. There are so many things that need to be done in the world that aren't because they are not profitable. Maybe we can get stuck into them for a start once we aren't worried about feeding the family and keeping the lights on anymore.
- chisleu 12y ago"These horseless carriages are going to ruin the horse carriage economy!" "These Semis are going to ruin the train economy!" Eventually, there will be no need of humans to work at all for the basics of life. Oh what a terrible time that will be...
- redblacktree 12y agoWonderful or terrible, depending on who and how many see the benefits of that transformation.
- SomeStupidPoint 12y agoGiven the stall of real wages for the lower ends of the wealth spectrum, the replacement of human labor by machines seems slated for hunger and riots, since the human jobs aren't actually being replaced. So yes, I expect it actually will be a rather terrible time.
- pnathan 12y agoSelf driving trucks are going to be a real bomb in the economy, make no mistake. I personally suspect we'll really see some labor unrest as it hits. Millions of people will lose their jobs, and they aren't going to be prepared to find an entirely new career. I'm very much a bull on technology, but this is something we (technologists) need to start talking to policy makers about. Incredible disruption is coming down the pipe, and good policy needs to be designed to cope with it. Manufacturing automated the jobs away, by the by - it didn't really send them overseas. That's a popular error, but wrong. The US was #1 in manufacturing until last year.
- analog31 12y agoWe can’t stop there though, because the incomes received by these 8.2 million people create the jobs of others. ... going further, the income of wage earners is what creates demand for the goods being transported by the trucks. Once nobody can earn an income, there will be no need for trucks.
- cja 12y agoIt's a shame that the author felt the need to add the basic income proposal onto an excellent article about autonomous vehicles. They are both very big topics and warrant individual analysis.