8 ms·
Whoever Is Leaking Trans-Pacific Partnership Drafts: Please Leak More
- zxcvcxz 12y agoWhen did secret global laws become a thing?
- eli 12y agoThe negotiations and drafts are secret (except to Congress), but it's public when it's signed and debated/ratified by Congress.
- Maken 12y agoThe drafts will be secret for everyone not involved directly in the negotiations until it'll have to be passed in the national Congresses. Which is of course how things work in a democratic society.
- higherpurpose 12y agoActually, some parts of TPP won't be public until 4 years after being signed. http://economyincrisis.org/content/public-wont-be-allowed-to-see-some-of-the-text-until-4-years-later http://economyincrisis.org/content/public-wont-be-allowed-to...
- pgrote 12y agoFrom what I understand, only certain members of congress have access to it before it is finalized. "Congress, and the American public, will be fully informed of what’s in the Trans-Pacific Partnership before lawmakers vote to make the agreement part of United States law. But he has a point that lawmakers won’t know what’s in the Trans-Pacific Partnership before they cast a separate, precursor vote -- the vote to authorize Obama to negotiate the Trans-Pacific Partnership on a fast-track basis in the first place." http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/apr/23/martin-omalley/martin-omalley-says-congress-wont-see-pacific-trad/ http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/apr/...
- jasonkolb 12y agoThe negotiations and drafts are in fact secret even from Congress at this point, and there's a movement underway to give "fast-track authority" to the president which would also remove the debate from the bill. "Obama has asked Congress to pass so-called Trade Promotion Authority legislation that would prohibit congressional amendments before an up or down vote on the Trans-Pacific Partnership" http://www.abqjournal.com/582278/news/nms-dems-oppose-trade-deal-fasttrack-deal.html http://www.abqjournal.com/582278/news/nms-dems-oppose-trade-...
- jbuzbee 12y agoCongress has access, but it is quite limited. Unlike industry representatives, they are only allowed to read the document in a special sealed room, but may not make copies, may not take notes and may not bring along any staffer, even those would be in a better position to interpret the opaque and complex legal terms used. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120622/23220319444/ustr-gives-mpaa-full-online-access-to-tpp-text-still-wont-share-with-senate-staffers.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120622/23220319444/ustr-... [edit for clarity}
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago>and may not bring along any staffer // Where are these rules written down, surely such anti-democratic actions have to be unconstitutional? Plus where does USA get off in trying to impose laws on the rest of the world through secret treaty negotiations the details of which are only open to a very limited and controlled politically chosen group and a second group chosen entirely on wealth. Land of the Free my arse - plutocratic hegemony more like it. TPP is the most blatant "we're rich we'll decide the rules" that I think I've ever come across. From the OP: >"is there any way to look at this situation and not judge it to be a case of massive corruption?" // No there isn't.
- themartorana 12y agoThe move towards profit at all costs to the general public is seemingly global at this point. There's not much escaping it. We all know the trouble with the U.S. Harper's government in Canada has silenced scientists who would speak out about the negative impacts of government policies, the UK is seeing university tuitions triple and then some, with student loans becoming more and more normal, despite the huge flashing warning sign the U.S. is about student debt... All over - stories about propping up the rich on the backs of anyone not rich. The thing is, the middle and lower classes are complicit in their own demise, voting in conservative governments or lackey liberals who don't even make attempts to keep their corporate connections secret anymore - let alone their desires to make life easier on those that already have it the easiest. Just toss a few "abortion" quotes around and the public will distract themselves with infighting while their standards of living are being destroyed, and for the first time in modern history, your kids won't be better off or live longer than you. Used to be we could say that at least there were scientists and other altruistic professions out there fighting the good fight. But even they are being actively stifled in order to boost corporate profits (US, Canada, others.) I don't even know. I hate being pessimistic. Apologies. End rant.
- derptacos 12y agoSeems very dystopian, but truth in it. Is a revolution really the only answer?
- jjoonathan 12y agoGod I hope not. Revolution has always been a shitshow and I don't even want to think how it would look given technological advancement since the last time around. There's reason to hope. As a nation we have faced bigger issues than this and come out on top. Besides, there are still a handful of decent ways out. Social policy like reducing the workweek to restore supply/demand balance in the labor market could work. So could basic/minimum income, although I suspect that it's politically untenable even though it would be cheaper in the big picture. The least efficient but most probable (IMO) approach would be to grow the size of our creaking, bloated menagerie of inefficient social programs. So far, capitalist societies have generally been far better than Marx assumed at figuring out how to implement the minimum possible social policy to stave off rebellion. I don't know whether to call it optimistic or pessimistic, but I suspect the trend will continue. Hopefully we won't go full Orwell in the process, but I wouldn't put money on it. We're already turnkey-Orwell and I think most of us can tell which way the wind is blowing. More optimistically, I think there's also a chance that market dynamics will shift for the better due to technological change. Sure, 3D printing has been overhyped to the moon and back, but if rents are increasing while the inefficiency of distributed production is decreasing, then eventually there's going to be a crossing point. Once everyone has self-replicating farms, power shifts back to the people and free market dynamics start working for the masses instead of against them. It'll require a ton of effort and investment to make it happen, but that makes it just the sort of thing to provide opportunity to the HN crowd :) /crazy speculation
- xnull2guest 12y agoI've been an advocate of transparent discussion for some time. The TPP represents a huge constellation of laws and it is absurd that the negotiations are done so secretively. But discussion about the TPP, too, is done in an opaque way. Everyone seems to have their favorite issue with it - for example information and piracy advocates will point to how grossly IP law is expanded internationally - others questions why only 5 or so chapters of a couple dozen have to do with trade if it's merely a trade deal - others will alarm at international corporate tribunals, worried that the largest and most aggressive corporations may abuse the liberal world order's tools to concentrate wealth and control. But to understand the TPP - why it has few trade chapters relative to international law chapters and why IP and American corporate legal capabilities are strengthened as well as all of the secrecy - one needs to understand why the US has been pushing it on the Asia-Pacific region. Washington Thinktanks and Defense Officials have come to the conclusion that the meteoric rise of China represents an existential threat to the supremacy of US hegemonic world order. The US's grand defense strategy has always been to 'balance' regions of the world where one country may otherwise dominate so that they can not then 'grow up' to play the global power game. Take Blackwill's recent publication: Revising US Grand Strategy Toward China. http://www.cfr.org/china/revising-us-grand-strategy-toward-china/p36371 http://www.cfr.org/china/revising-us-grand-strategy-toward-c... Blackwill suggests a series of measures: the first being to get the TPP out the door to isolate China from international trade in its region. He goes on further to suggest that the DoD should invest in cyberwarfare and other capabilities - indeed these measures are being taken, as the DoD is now partnering with VC firms inside the Valley to steer funding toward national defense. https://foreignpolicy.com/2015/04/23/defense-department-silicon-valley/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2015/04/23/defense-department-sili... Secretary of Defense Carter penned his interest in the TPP, publicly stating that he would rather have the TPP than another aircraft carrier. Prime Minister Shinzo Abe just visited Congress, whereupon he spoke to them about the new unprecedented collective defense pact (think Asian NATO) being entered into by the two countries which required Japan to reinterpret its constitution. In the speech he discussed the importance of the TPP for defense purposes, and took questions about the rise of China. None of this is a defense of the TPP. What it is is a call for transparent discussion. We can do one better than those discussing the TPP behind closed doors. We can speak openly about what it gets the US and its allies.
- bko 12y agoI never understood why you need an agreement for free trade. Free trade should be the default. What is being negotiated is a perversion of free trade used to mask corporate subsidies and crony capitalism.
- lumberjack 12y agoThey're are called "free trade agreements" because they do away with protectionism, thereby liberalizing those markets. There are no absolutes in the real world but markets do usually become freer as a result of these trade negotiations. People don't have beef with FTAs because they aren't liberal enough. I know that liberals like to get in on board the hate train but it's a bit disingenuous to pretend that you're on the same page as most of the folk protesting FTAs when you stand at odds on the basic question of whether protectionism can be economically beneficial or not.
- akhatri_aus 12y agoLots of countries aim for protectionism. The reason is they need to boost their manufacturing base or else they'll be stuck exporting raw materials to import manufactured goods to no end.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoFree trade is the default, but practically every country has passed laws that override that default, which is what makes free trade agreements necessary.
- redwood 12y agoNot to defend potentially terrible policy (the lack of transparency makes cynicism the only reasonable reaction): But the elephant in the room with the TPP is China. Ultimately at a high level East Asia has about as many Chinese as Non-Chinese. This means that a strong economic block uniting non-China East Asia and granting it strong market access actually has a chance of fending off China's economic domination of the region. Will a C
- beastofthefield 12y agoThis is more about military domination of the region and strengthening economies of non-Chinese Asian countries so they can defend themselves from a potentially aggressive China.
- Maken 12y agoIf this is about controlling China, and China obviously knows it, then I don't see any reason for hiding it from the public instead of saying "this all is in order to combat China". Or maybe the means proposed are something that most of us aren't ready to accept in order to guarantee the economic supremacy of the West enterprises?
- redwood 12y agoThis is all about ensuring China isn't the only game in East Asia: Giving the non-Chinese half of East Asia's population a chance of fending off Chinese economic domination by creating a market union. I don't want to defend it considering the lack of transparency which requires us to be cynical... BUT we need to keep this in mind. This isn't all about the US or business per se. Rather, East Asia, the US, and big business all are in political alignment here, and that's how you build policy that happens... We're not the center of this. East Asia is
- xnull2guest 12y agoThis is true except that the US would not be getting involved unless it aided US security or other interests. In this case the US would like to contain China from becoming too large a global player (the US Grand Strategy for defense for the past few decades has been to prevent any other superpower from rising). http://www.cfr.org/china/revising-us-grand-strategy-toward-china/p36371 http://www.cfr.org/china/revising-us-grand-strategy-toward-c...
- beagle3 12y agoMaybe. But all of those big business are using the opportunity to basically bypass sovereignty in the western world, as well as ram a lot of other harmful legislation. So it's not all about China anymore - and in fact, East Asia is basically independent of the way it will be felt by most people. So practically speaking, it isn't about China and East Asia at all.
- xnull2guest 12y agoTo have a good understanding of why the USG wants the TPP, yes, it's about China. As citizens we feel that inequality of wealth opportunity is the high, urgent priority - and that tools inside the TPP will exacerbate these issues. As the government the existential threat to the US hegemonic uni-power world order - and by extension the political power and much of the economic opportunity and strategic interests of the US - is the high, urgent threat. TPP is a bad deal because it only seeks to solve one of these and may actively harm the other - but I remember Obama saying something to the effect of "find me a better deal."
- ExpiredLink 12y agoThe leak is the European Commission: http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/press/index.cfm?id=1230 http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/press/index.cfm?id=1230
- xnull2guest 12y agoThis is TTIP, not TTP. Can you clarify what you mean?
- sh33mp 12y agoSo could someone clarify this for me? Is is that the TPP negotiations are occurring in secret, or is it that the TPP will be passed without it being available for the public to view (which should be the case for most bills?)? The former seems very reasonable to me (that negotiations happen in secret, and then the final product is presented to the public/congress for a vote), but up to this point I'm still not sure which is the case.
- rayiner 12y agoThe negotiations are being done in secret. The result will be presented as ordinary bills to legislatures. But I'm not sure if there is anything reasonable about non-national security issues being discussed in secret. We're talking about commerce here, not nuclear weapons.
- shmerl 12y agoHere is a good review of how it works: http://economixcomix.com/home/tpp/ http://economixcomix.com/home/tpp/
- cheeseprocedure 12y agoThis is fantastic. Thank you!
- bradbatt 12y agoThat was amazingly good and informative. Cool site and book!
- beastofthefield 12y agoThis is a necessary and enlightened agreement to put a check on China that does not respect international rules, and give non-Chinese Asian allies and US an economic boost. Whoever is leaking this is not doing a service to the world as it only panders to a misguided populist impulse. This agreement is leading us towards a more free and prosperous world.
- xnull2guest 12y ago100% agreed on impulses of all sorts by citizens who don't understand what the TPP is about. But this is because there is no discussion about it on frank terms - the US can't even take a real stance on it and have to work in vaguaries and "and for national security". The closest they came was Obama's SotU. Without a real explanation there no way for citizens to understand, so they panic. And populists do have legitimate grievances.
- jqm 12y agoContaining China (as if this will work:) does no good for me if I'm simply handed over to corporate masters who have control over my government and I have no say. Thus the secrecy I suppose.
- godgod 12y agoWhat does it say about a government that will implement a secret treaty like the TPP against the will of the majority of the people. Our so called elected representatives can barely even see it what's in it.