9 ms·
Yelp Is Exploring a Sale
- zwtaylor 12y agoSometime in the last year I started to find myself exclusively using the reviews and filtering within Google Maps to search for restaurants, bars and other businesses. I can't say I've really touched Yelp at all in months. It definitely seems like Google has devoted a lot of effort to improving these features as I remember a time when their review sections were a veritable ghost town. I won't be surprised if Google ends up buying them.
- primitivesuave 12y agoYelp is the worst company. I'm not saying that just because of the small business owner bullying that I was subjected to, or the frivolous one-star review that they refused to remove, or the horrible customer service I was subjected to when I paid for their premium advertising plan. I say that because Yelp provides a platform for businesses to work against each other. Unscrupulous business owners that see a local competitor on Yelp will write bad reviews to lower their Yelp rating and write fake positive reviews for themselves. The ideal replacement for Yelp in my mind would be a service that allows customers to state positive and negative aspects of their experience, and a Foursquare-like search that lets you easily see on a map which businesses are operating in your area. Business owners should be able to address the negative aspects, and consumers should be able to vote up/down positive and negative aspects of business to combat frivolous statements.
- roadnottaken 12y agoHow would your suggested replacement prevent unscrupulous business owners from writing fake reviews?
- AwesomeGriffin 12y agoPerhaps some way that Yelp independently verifies the identity of the reviewer (maybe some two-factor authentication such as an SMS message), but keeps the reviewer's identity anonymous from the public to prevent harassment of honest reviewers. This identity would also include some additional checks such as business affiliation and location, so for example a restaurant owner in a given zipcode can't post reviews on other restaurants within a certain radius of their business premises. Not sure how scalable or workable all this would be though.
- roadnottaken 12y agoYeah, what's to stop somebody from just lying about their business affiliations?
- kbar13 12y agoi'm not sure that having to provide PII to make a review is a good idea. Maybe if yelp is able to provide a kind of "reviewer's score" based on the reviewer's online activity then people will be more likely to trust reviews for being genuine.
- incongruity 12y agoThe key here is developing good points of convergent measures - not all of which would have to be valid for any one review to be weighted (think a Bayesian scoring approach?) - Age of account - Account engagement (patterns matter too) - Check-ins via a mobile device at the business - Check-ins at other near-by businesses (patterns matter too) - Partner with a Credit Card company to offer Yelp-reward bucks to encourage reviews, track usage and validate reviews (and reviewers) [Use this to feed into the engagement score, above] - Partner with OpenTable (they do this) & prompt reviews after attendance (they do this) – weight these reviews more heavily. [Use this to feed into the engagement score, above] - Let me actually identify myself to Yelp or to the world (or to just business owners, ONLY if I want to [Use this to feed into the engagement score, above] - Reviews of similar businesses (e.g.: I like thai food) -- patterns matter here. Do I rate all competitors poorly, etc? Did I post all reviews in one day, etc? - Do my reviews vary significantly in a systematic way from others in a category? (This shouldn't be enough on its own, but variance might mean something) - Do I post photos of the place? (Factor into engagement score, above -- but if it's only for one business, it might be a flag) etc., etc. Really – a statistical model shouldn't be that hard to do -- maybe processor intensive, but hard? It doesn't feel hard, given all the data they're sitting on...
- derwiki 12y agoI'm pretty sure the review filter (that everyone loves to hate) works this way.
- pbreit 12y agoMy guess is the problem is solvable with a little ingenuity.
- derwiki 12y agoSee also: Yelp's review filter.
- primitivesuave 12y agoBecause the quality of a business would be more accurately represented by its positive and negative factors, which users could vote up/down based on their relevance to their decision to use or not use that particular business.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bkjelden 12y agoThe problem with yelp is that I don't trust other reviewers. Too many bad reviews are docking a business for things I don't care about, or the reviewer went in with drastically different expectations than I have, or they are simply trying to extort the business. A buyer like facebook could have some interesting abilities to fix this problem. Filtering to only reviews from people I know would drastically reduce the noise. Additionally, I theoretically know a few things about the reviewer - what their tastes are, what their level of expertise is, etc. That added context seems like it would add a lot of value to the review. In a sense, it becomes more of a recommendation than a review, which is what I really wanted in the first place.
- lbotos 12y agoI've always wanted a "friend circle" yelp where It showed you recommendations from friends of friends/people you know so you could temper the rating with what you know about the person reviewing.
- munificent 12y agoI believe Google+ actually does this.
- lazerwalker 12y agoFoursquare does this. Explicitly shows you your 4sq/Swarm friends' relationships to the place (have they been there? saved it to a list? said they 'like it' or 'dislike it'?), and then in the list of tips/reviews surfaces the stuff your friends have left before others. When searching, you can even filter for "only show me places my friends have been".
- alwaysdoit 12y agoI always wish I could filter out vegetarians, and I'm sure they feel the same way about me. I'll go to a vegetarian restaurant, but only if non-vegetarians say it's good.
- bane 12y ago
- byoung2 12y agoAny guesses who would be the most likely buyer? Google, Yahoo, Apple, or Microsoft would be obvious candidates, maybe Facebook. I'd be interested to see Facebook buy them and get all those reviews and reviewers integrated into the graph. It would be amazing to be able to target Facebook ads at people based on how they reviewed specific businesses or categories of businesses.
- aaronbrethorst 12y agoI don't know if "amazing" is the first word that comes to mind when I think about my reviews of businesses being made available to advertisers in this way.
- byoung2 12y agoIt would be amazing for Facebook and people who buy Facebook ads
- JoshGlazebrook 12y agoWhy do I have a feeling Google, Apple, or Microsoft are going to buy them and then proceed to remove Yelp integration from each other's ecosystems...
- cjensen 12y agoI'd love for Google to buy them so I could trust them. Pro-tip: if you have a credibility problem so severe that you need to put up notices saying that your site does not bias reviews, you probably should stop sorting and filtering reviews based on criteria so opaque that it is indistinguishable from bias.
- mawburn 12y ago>I'd love for Google to buy them so I could trust them. I don't, you can still retain some bit of anonymity on Yelp. Google would probably try to force you to use your real name. I don't know what Google's problem with real names are, but it needs to stop. The last time I left a legitimate bad review for a restaurant on Google, I was harassed through both Google and Facebook. I blocked the owner, his wife, and others, but it made me extremely uncomfortable.
- ISL 12y agoSounds like real names have power, then, no? If I know that you, as mawburn, are backing a review with your personal reputation, I'm going to believe it a lot more.
- ssmoot 12y agoThat should be his choice though. (For myself, as an avid Yelp user, I don't care. It's mostly easy to pick up good vs bad reviews IME.) I also don't have a lot of sympathy for "small business owners" wanting to fight bad reviews. I don't need or want your pointless TripAdvisor style feedback. It's antagonistic, and likely to discourage good reviews. The playing field is level. That's all that really matters. So you get a few completely bogus, unfair reviews? So what. You're in the same boat as anyone else. Give me anonymized data. And while some few businesses will suffer, the amount of reviews encouraged will serve a greater good. At least that's my theory.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- incongruity 12y agoYelp seemingly stopped innovating years ago – really, there's very little in the way of new experiences with them to keep the attention going. I say this as a former Yelp Elite user for 5? years, but no longer, though still an active user with ~350 reviews. As a result, they've squandered their early advantage. Ideas off the top of my head: - Imagine all that they could have done to help small businesses gain deep(er) insight and understanding into their existing customers and/or potential markets. - A (pay for use) tool that let prospective business owners size markets and get feedback from real, local "expert" consumers (aka: yelp elite users?) – all for a fee (and maybe a small pay-off to yelp users?) - Revenue sharing to verified, top reviewers or test marketing that allowed reviewers to get something back for all their engagement - Product reviews (really, can Amazon be the only one to own this?) Review anything with a UPC mark. - A Yelp branded credit card – discounts/cash back for reviewed experiences (this allows: 1) Deeper consumer intelligence, 2) Prompting for reviews 3)Truly verified experiences/more reliable reviews - Brokering partnerships between complementary businesses – e.g.: free Lyft rides between the dinner and movie/music/museum venues for consumers for special events, etc.
- dogma1138 12y agoWell instead it went the ol' fashion way of bullying small businesses. TBH at this point I'm not sure what can they sell, their user share might be a worthy investment however anyone which will be interested in acquiring Yelp e.g. Google, Facebook, Amazon etc. already probably owns most of Yelp's user base via other means anyhow. And as far as Google goes Yelp (Ireland) has given them quite a bit of trouble in the EU in the anti-trust case against Google (heck they've spearheaded the "public" campaign against Google). This pretty much leaves Amazon and Facebook to buy them, and I'm not sure any one of those will want to do it. I have a strong feeling that Yahoo will end up buying them which will result in another flop at the end. If not them then maybe one of the emerging Chinese companies like Baidu or the Alibaba Group (I'm actually thinking that it would make quite a bit of sense for Jack Ma to go after them especially they want to expand to the US and EU markets since they own tons of site that provide C2C and B2C services, heck this might be even more likely than a "US" tech company since Ali has a metric ton of money to spend these days) That said I'm not sure if on the tech side Yelp is worth anything at this point, my personal view on that companies is that the main reason if not the only reason why they kinda dwindled and never really exploded is that they didn't find any clever use for their data which means they don't have some amazing IP to sweeten the deal for potential buyers.
- hinkley 12y agoI hear the Mafia is struggling to improve their relevance in a progressively technological world. They would be perfect for each other. The things Yelp could teach the Mob about extortion and protection rackets... Oh, and computers, too. I hear they're also good at that. (can you tell I boycott Yelp? what was your first clue?
- koube 12y agoHonest (and possibly stupid) question: Where do you go for your reviews, and how do you know that they don't do the same thing?
- walterbell 12y agoAmazon reviews have their own vulnerabilities, but Amazon makes money from ecommerce rather than selling ads to the owners of the products being reviewed.
- hsod 12y agoAny suggested reading on Yelp's Mafia-esque extortion? A quick Google turns up a bunch of innuendo and vague allegations but nothing concrete.
- chollida1 12y agoI wrote about this a couple of weeks ago here. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9467649 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9467649 Public social networks are really starting to feel the squeeze from wall street as people are getting tired of giving social companies large multiples on the promise of massive revenues that are only a few quarters away. By the looks of the intra day chart, people are excited about this news. Not really sure who would make a good acquirere however....
- adventured 12y agoIn terms of preserving maximum value for shareholders, Yelp has no choice but to sell itself, and the sooner the better. They're currently able to generate $10-$12 million in net income on $377m in sales. Their growth rate has slowed down drastically. Take their 52 week high (much less their all-time high), which is a roughly $6.4 billion market cap. Their best case scenario, ten years from now, is that they're worth ~$6.4 billion. $200m in net income on that $6.4 billion market cap pegs them at a 32 PE (plausible, if not a bit rich, ten years out). To get there, they probably need - even giving them the benefit of expanded margins with scale - $2 to $3 billion in sales. The only way they're going to exceed those types of numbers, is through using their equity on acquisitions. Here they're sitting on a very rich stock market valuation, in one of the greatest bull markets the US has ever seen, and it's unlikely they're ever going to top their 52 week high. Selling is the obvious move.
- pbreit 12y agoYelp could easily roll out "AdWords" and absolutely kill it. It's insane they've dragged their feet so heavily on this.
- jinushaun 12y agoKill it with SMB money? Business like Yelp have always had a hard time monetizing mom and pop shops, and keep them repeat customers. The real ad money is not Uncle Joes' Falafal Shop down the road.
- pbreit 12y agoI think it is. I had a small retail store and would definitely have advertised against [my retail category] + zip code. A no-brainer from my perspective.
- wehadfun 12y agoAngiesList should buy them
- adrr 12y agoAngiesList's market cap is 350m, don't think they are in a position of buying anyone.
- guelo 12y agoGeez, people really have it in for Yelp on here. I trust Yelp reviews more than I trust some shitty diner's owner complaining about the bad reviews. Overall I've found the ratings to be spot on.
- CyberDildonics 12y agoI hope before the buyer closes the deal they go to the last page to see the bad reviews about the company.
- shanev 12y agoMy very first iPhone app was a Yelp client called Places. It launched on day one of the App Store. I worked closely with Yelp on the app, sending them screenshots, talking about API limits, etc. They never told me that they were also working on their own app. To my surprise the App Store launched with an app from Yelp that looked exactly like my app Places. Soon after they started limiting my API access and changed their terms of service to only allow access to 3 reviews per restaurant. They also injected text into my API responses telling my users to download the official Yelp app. In retrospect I should have known not to build an app entirely on a third party API, but the situation could have been handled more professionally for sure.
- impish19 12y agoThat's a little sad to hear.
- abetaha 12y agoWould be interesting to see who's interested in buying them given most of the negative comments about them here. Perhaps Yahoo can scoop them up like it did with other startups in a similar situation.
- rajacombinator 12y agoGonna chime in with a positive vote for Yelp. I live and die by Yelp reviews - I basically won't patronize a new business unless it checks out on Yelp. If you know how to interpret the reviews, they are incredibly useful.
- jinushaun 12y agoBut I don't have time for that when I'm hungry and swimming in a see of bad 4s and great 3s because Yelp is too stupid to implement recommendations and taste profiles. I'm an elite Yelper with a shit ton of data in Yelp, they should've been able to figure out how to automate this by now.
- egusa 12y agoI know Yelp gets a lot of criticism (and some of it deservedly), but I always respected how they did their best to provide an honest platform for reviews. Compared to other competitor sites (Ex: CitySearch, which basically allowed & many times encouraged businesses to post their own fake reviews on their own companies), I think Yelp is very ahead of the pack.
- toephu2 12y agowho leaked this info?
- jinushaun 12y agoThe Google argument is bullshit because if your site is worth visiting, people will always append "yelp" to the query; just like I routinely append "wiki" and "YouTube".
- igonvalue 12y ago> By 2009, Yelp found itself in talks about a possible takeover by Google for at least $500 million, the Journal reported at the time. An interesting bit of history is that the acquisition offer was scuttled when Yahoo put in a competing bid that Google could not match. Supposedly the management team did not want to work with Yahoo, but the board had a fiduciary duty not to accept an inferior deal, so both offers fell through.[0] In retrospect, it was a good outcome for Yelp; the market cap is now several times higher than either of the acquisition offers. [0] http://techcrunch.com/2010/10/01/the-ugliest-girl-at-the-dance-how-yahoo-destroyed-yelps-google-acquisition/ http://techcrunch.com/2010/10/01/the-ugliest-girl-at-the-dan...