8 ms·
Anyone who has critical opinion of current system should first study enough to pass "Turing test for mainstream monetary economics and monetary policy" (test wh
by nabla9 12y ago
Anyone who has critical opinion of current system should first study enough to pass "Turing test for mainstream monetary economics and monetary policy" (test where you try to fake others that you are economist who understands prevailing monetary theory and defends the policy). For example, to know how economists think about general equilibrium theory of credit.
There is huge knowledge cap between economists and policy makers and journalists and population.
Who here in HN thinks they could pass the test If I were to administer one? For example questions related to macro- and microeconomic determinants of the demand for money,
Baumol–Tobin transactions demand for money, portfolio selection, demand function stability, quantity theory, general equilibrium framework for money, yield curve, interest parity, AA–DD paradigm, etc.
I feel that at least I know enough economics to know that I don't have simple technical solution (bitcoin, gold, what have you).
- pjc50 12y agoIsn't some of this in "economists differ" territory (Krugman and IS/LM, MMT, etc)?
- nabla9 12y agoYes, but you should expect that economists who differ understand the rationale behind different approaches. At least everyone should have understanding of classical form of monetarism before they start to depart from it.
- irixusr 12y agoThat's like saying 'anyone who's opposed to eugenics should pass the "Turing test for mainstream eugenics and racial hygiene" otherwise they're ill-informed'. Which is largely the argument used against opponents at the time (the opponents were ignorant "medieval obscurantists", if religious speaking from "superstition") My objections to modern economics are as follows: - utility is an ordinal quantity, not a cardinal one. I can tell you I prefer my soon-to-be-born daughter's first kiss to my sister's cheerful hello, but not by how much (how much "what"? What are the units?). - the utility function, so widely used, is an unknown function. However mathematics are performed after choosing an arbitrary functional form that has the features desired But most importantly: - It assumes utility exists and humans behave accordingly. These are fundamental objections to the field. I can talk to an economist about yield curves flipping, but that jumps over the foundational objections: they are projecting complex human behavior onto fairly outdated mathematics. And then making a mess of it.
- nabla9 12y ago>utility is an ordinal quantity, not a cardinal one. Rational choice theory assumes only complete partial ordering, transitivity and that irrelevant alternatives are independent. If preferences have continuous representation, utility function can be continuous, otherwise they are not (but can sometimes be modeled as continuous), >It assumes utility exists and humans behave accordingly. I think you are implicitly adding too much meaning into economic definitions of preference and utility. Economic definition of utility and preference assume very little. As long as people are forced to make decisions where they select one option over other you can infer underlying utilities.
- darkmighty 12y agoIsn't "complete partial order" the order of the ordinals? Or maybe you need the hyperreals to get the full picture (i.e. to be able to associate a number with each choice for any set of choices)? I don't know much about this stuff. But I agree utility is a model and it's conditions are quite clearly stated [1], and one may always infer an utility from the given choices as long as they obey those quite brand conditions (and I wouldn't call a choice consistent if they don't obey those -- for instance if you prefer A over B, B over C, and C over A). [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_choice_theory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_choice_theory
- marcosdumay 12y ago> Rational choice theory assumes only complete partial ordering, transitivity and that irrelevant alternatives are independent. Just that? Does it have any feature that wasn't widely disproven on real people?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- copsarebastards 12y agoYeah, it's sure terrible to want people to be informed on a subject before forming an opinion on it. /sarcasm Your post boils down to: "The models are outdated, so let's throw out the entire field." The thing is, the outdated models are predictive enough to be more useful than your complete lack of a proposed alternative. And even if you did propose a better model, you'd still have to understand the outdated models in order to prove that they are worse than the model you're proposing.
- DamnYuppie 12y agoPass an economics test? How many economist could pass a simple common sense test on finances? From what I have seen they simply construct models with lose to no ties to reality. It seems to me they act much like the clergy in days gone by; privileged, empowered, completely based on faith, and questioning them is heresy!
- TheCowboy 12y agoAs finance relates to economics, many academic economists would pass it just fine. The anti-intellectualism of attacking models has become really disconcerting. Should we start dismissing coders for using abstractions, that solve real problems, with no ties to the reality of the machines running the code? If you make a statement about how X will result in Y, you have some model upon which your idea is based. That can be critiqued and studied to see if X does in fact result in Y. Everyone uses models in their thinking without realizing it.
- mindslight 12y agoThe attack occurs because models shift from being descriptive to prescriptive. For example, interest rates. A large part of why they're so low is that technology has enabled tracking everyone and everything, essentially guaranteeing that people cannot skip out on debts. Ever-lowering interest rates is what has caused housing prices to shoot through the roof (most people budget for a house in terms of monthly rent payed to the bank). Mainstream economists take these conditions as unassailable facts, create models based around them, and then advocate for policy that's consistent with the model. But every (worthwhile) model is consistent with the system it was developed for, so what they are essentially doing is simply advocating for the status quo while fortifying and obscuring their inbuilt assumptions. Policy needs to be debated in terms of the bigger picture - does it make sense that saving is so heavily discouraged? does it make sense that there is a dossier built up on every person that determines where they can live and their general station in life? does it make sense that the only way to preserve one's wealth is to play the Wall St casino? does it make sense to make buying a home so easy while essentially erasing the concept of ownership? does it make sense that prices should always be going up when competition wins out by lowering them? If these assumptions start being examined, long term financial instruments are indeed going to act weird in response. But the function of the economy should be to optimize for us, not to optimize us for itself. And yes, we should dismiss coders who attempt to force their abstractions onto us (ie proprietary network protocols)
- omilu 12y ago"You may abuse a tragedy, though you cannot write one. You may scold a carpenter who has made you a bad table, though you cannot make a table. It is not your trade to make tables." -Samuel Johnson
- innguest 12y agoHi Mr. Economist. Lots of fancy terms there. Would you care to provide proof that mainstream economics is a Science? What predictions does it make that are falsifiable? How can we test and reproduce what it says about the world? For instance, before we started QE it was thought to be a good idea. Now they're changing their mind. Were they wrong before? If so, what was it that we learned now about it so we won't make that mistake again? Are we really accumulating knowledge in this "Science" or are we winging it as we go along? Also answer me this. Physics students can make all sorts of computer simulations that simulate some aspect of reality, like the center of a tornado, or fluid dynamics, or galaxy collisions, etc. And physics students barely have any money! Now my question: Bankers, with all their money, have never been able to get a single simulation of a country going. Where is the computer simulation where we mess with interest rates, minimum wage, QE, etc, and see what happens? Where is it? Where's proof of this great "Science"?
- drjesusphd 12y agoIt's starting to be done [1], but by physicists. Among their basic conclusions from their simplified models: - A free market naturally tends toward an exponential distribution of wealth. - When debt is allowed in the model, the rich get richer, even without considering that interest is paid from the poor to the rich. - The U.S. clearly has a two-class structure. [1] http://physics.umd.edu/~yakovenk/econophysics/ http://physics.umd.edu/~yakovenk/econophysics/
- pash 12y agoEconophysics enjoyed a brief vogue in the late 1990s and early 2000s, but the field has mostly dried up. Much of what the econophysicsts "learned" turned out either to restate things economists already knew (this time in physics-speak) or to be results that were very sensitive to modeling assumptions. But mostly the physicists gave up because they discovered that problems in economics are much harder than problems in physics; everything is a heterogeneous n-body problem with endogenously determined rules governing interactions.
- innguest 12y ago
- 3pt14159 12y agoI think most of us here studied econ as a minor in University. The thing is, it doesn't take much knowledge to correct poor policy decisions. Credit default swaps, for example: basic mismatch in incentives. I was screaming at anyone that would listen about the coming crash. It was on the cover of the economist a full two years before the crash. Didn't matter; got fucked anyway. Economics isn't like physics. There are wide disagreements over a host of issues and models and the disagreements impact public policy, which impacts us; the electorate.
- dmd 12y ago> I think most of us here studied econ as a minor in University. Wait, what? I've never met a single person who did. Am I the outlier, or are you?
- return0 12y agoEconomics is not one of the fields that has gained the "trust the experts" badge. Common sense says that you trust the experts when they have proved themselves, and, in economics, they haven't.
- lurkinggrue 12y agoIt looks like from the outside it's a case of experts in screwing over everybody while making it looks like they are not. Or just trying to siphon off value out of the system using applied phlebotinum and handwavium. Perhaps I'm just a cynic.
- zeteo 12y ago> Anyone who has critical opinion of current system should first study [... the] general equilibrium theory of credit [...] macro- and microeconomic determinants of the demand for money, Baumol–Tobin transactions demand for money, portfolio selection, demand function stability, quantity theory, general equilibrium framework for money, yield curve, interest parity, AA–DD paradigm, etc. [... A]t least I know enough economics to know that I don't have simple technical solution That's like saying you can't complain of a headache unless you're a neurosurgeon. Not even when the neurosurgeons have declared they have no solution for your headache. And heaven forbid you try to do something about it before studying graduate-level neurology. (BTW, neurosurgeons have a much better diagnosis and treatment rate than economists.)
- ilaksh 12y agoMoney is a foundational technology for society. The core hasn't changed in thousands of years. It predates high technology and information systems. Traditional money alone is obviously outdated. The situation we have is as if World of Warcraft had only one stat for each character (money) and no way to track what was going on wih the environment aside from user reports. And the server somehow could not regulate anything in the simulation without it being done by a user. Economists have done an amazing job with one number, at least in terms of finding ways to game the system and multiply one's point total while ignoring billions of people. But we need automated and mainstream systems with more than one dimension.