9 ms·
How the language you speak changes your view of the world
- wpietri 12y agoWhat surprises me about this article is not that worldviews change, but how quickly these experimenters got it to happen. "When we surprised subjects by switching the language of the distracting numbers halfway through the experiment, the subjects’ focus on goals versus process switched right along with it." I would have expected it was a much slower process. It makes me wonder if we could observe similar effects in multilanguage code bases.
- hkarthik 12y agoI took one semester of French in college after 4 years of Spanish in high school. The most intriguing parts for me were around numbers and counting. For example, the number 80 is "quatre-vingts", which literally means 4 x 20. I thought maybe this gave French youth an edge with arithmetic, and this slight edge might translate to strong mathematics foundations later in life. I have heard there is a strong emphasis on mathematics in their school curriculums, so maybe there is some correlation there.
- TillE 12y agoFrench numbers are really weird and inconsistent. Swiss French is a little more sensible, so you have for example "septante" for 70 rather than "soixante-dix" (60 + 10).
- Hobotron1 12y ago23 auf Deutsch is dreiundzwanzig or "three and twenty-many" Fun stuff.
- Jayd2014 12y agoFun fact: Its the same in Arabic. Numbers are read from right to left.
- cletus 12y agoEnglish is really consistent here. 4321 is four thousand three hundred and twenty one. Probably the biggest inconsistency in English are the numbers 11 to 19. Many European languages are not. Often with numbers between 11 and 99 are a weird special case. German puts the single digit first. As another poster mentioned 23 is "dreiundzwanzig" (literally "3 and 20"). French is worse where 97 is "quatre-vingts dix-sept" (literally "4 20s 10 7"). These are just the last remnants of a pre-decimal ("vigesimal" specifically) counting system. I don't really see how weird rule exclusions on certain numbers would give anyone an advantage in math, particularly because even though the word means "4 20s" when you learn it, it's just a word and it may well just lead to questions like "why isn't 40 2 20s?" There is a cognitive cost with exclusions. I remember reading a study once about how verbs became regular in English. There was a mathematical relationship between how often the word was used and how quickly it became regular. The less used, the quicker it happened. This is why "to be" is irregular (as its the most common verb) whereas most other verbs (with <100 exclusions) follow a simple pattern. It's probably the same with numbers. The numbers less than 100 are used far more often so their irregularity is preserved far longer than the less common numbers above 100.
- lordnacho 12y agoBut what is causing the irregularity? Is there any benefit to conjugating "to be" differently to everything else?
- cynicalkane 12y agoIt's thought to be a combination of colloquialisms + the Indo-European ablaut system, wherein vowels would change depending on conjugation. Consider how many English irregular verbs follow a pattern. Sing, sang, sung. Ring, rang, rung. These are ablaut conjugations.
- Dewie3 12y ago> I thought maybe this gave French youth an edge with arithmetic, and this slight edge might translate to strong mathematics foundations later in life. As opposed to regularly "doing the arithmetic" 8 x 10?
- lisper 12y agoIf you really want to expand your linguistic horizons, study sign language. Sign language is fundamentally different than spoken or written languages. It doesn't just substitute gestures for phonemes or written tokens. Its grammar (and it does have one) is three-dimensional. It also opens you up to the fascinating world of deaf culture, since teaching sign is one of the most popular ways for deaf people to earn extra money.
- spiritplumber 12y agoOne interesting thing as of late is that there are some deaf people who are against ear implants because, as it solves deafness, it weakens deaf culture. http://www.dailykos.com/story/2013/11/17/1256259/-The-Cochlear-Implant-Controversy http://www.dailykos.com/story/2013/11/17/1256259/-The-Cochle...
- jallmann 12y agoThat article isn't really balanced, and is really one person's (rather uninformed) opinion. The cochlear implant debate is a bit more nuanced than that, and it is centered around children. One argument is that, often, the child may not be given a choice whether to be implanted. There are long-term considerations: the CI destroys any residual hearing and the capability for hearing aids to work so you can't "roll back" after the surgery, you can't do MRIs ever again, you are supposed to avoid high pressure/high impact activities (scuba diving, tackle football, etc) -- although many deaf people with CIs that disregard this advice. It's also a big commitment that requires years of auditory training to master, especially if you received the implant after the language development phase of childhood -- maybe 5 or 6 years of age. It does seem the CI's effectiveness is inversely proportional to age of implantation, especially if you are going from zero hearing (with hearing aids) to a CI overnight. The younger you are, your brain has a chance to develop into the CI as it would with normal ears, and those kids are often functionally hearing. Which is totally fine with me, by the way. Source: Deaf, use sign language, have a CI, although I don't wear it anymore. Me and my friends with CIs are no less a part of deaf culture because of it.
- msutherl 12y agoPraying that nobody mentions the Sapir-Whorf s/Hypothesis/(Hoax|Strawman)
- blowski 12y agoWell given that you _have_ mentioned it, why don't you want anyone else to mention it? It's obviously relevant.
- kazinator 12y agoIf you know several different languages, the advantage is not that your view is enhanced, but rather you are more aware of the false contributions of language to thought; you are more aware that some pattern of thinking is just really some linguistic convention and not real semantics. For instance, you are more likely to spot someone's equivocation: confusing multiple meanings of some term in the same argument. Right away you realize: "Doh, in this other language I know, those two concepts are not even the same word; what he's saying doesn't translate."
- A_COMPUTER 12y agoI was never that good of a Japanese speaker so someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but to me it felt like there was a lot more ambiguity about things in Japanese than in English. And I definitely found when I used it for long periods of time, even my way of perceiving the world around me changed, in a way that seemed closer to how the Japanese I knew perceived it. I never knew if this was a cause or an effect. And I _definitely_ experienced, as you say, knowing that there was no way to translate something to English without losing its Japanese "feeling".
- timewilltell 12y agoI can relate to this by my experience with Romance languages like Spanish and Italian as they employ the subjunctive mode extensively in their semantics and I'd find myself over time this subjunctive mode/mood creeping into my psyche as I master these langs but lucky me this subjectively negative doubt feeling dissipates as long as I switch back to English* or my native language. PS: The English language employs subjunctives as well albeit to way lesser degree. Constructs like "He said he would come around this time" is subjunctive in nature.
- Htsthbjig 12y agoThere are very few differences between German and English, but there are tons of difference between European languages and Asian ones. I studied in Korea, I was specially interested in Hangul, and found Japanese extremely similar to Korean in the cultural side of things. For example, there is a iconic concept in the US of "bad guy", "rebel against the world". It simply does not exist in Korea, or in Japan by the way. You can't talk about "bad guys"to them, because it does not exist in their world. The same happens with different levels of respect and politeness in Japan, it does not match anything the Western world has. Words are like icons or shortcuts for something the culture has. The intimate relationships, the families, the social contracts,violence, the way of working... it is simply another world of thinking.
- berntb 12y agoThe funniest variant I ever heard of this "language influences your thinking" was a PhD student's description of 14th-15th century literate Swedish debate: All the technical words for discussing debates -- like counter arguments and so on -- were fencing terms. Attack/chop, riposte, counter strike. Up until ~ 500 years ago Sweden was quite like a clan society, think modern Afghanistan or Somalia. They didn't have football, computers or literature -- they only had churches and violence. (At least they had stopped the holmgång tradition. :-) ) (I should have asked more, I was mostly surprised written text about debate etc in Sweden at the time wasn't in Latin.)
- westoncb 12y agoHere's the kind of thing to expect from the article: "Research with second language users shows a relationship between linguistic proficiency in such grammatical constructions and the frequency with which speakers mention the goals of events." —where 'mentioning goals of events' means using the grammatical constructions these people are more proficient with. So, people who are more proficient with X use X more... But, they're really trying to push their perspective, saying things like: "The worldview assumed by German speakers is A HOLISTIC ONE – they tend to look at the event as a whole – whereas English speakers tend to zoom in on the event and focus only on the action." The capital letters are mine, referring to their hypertext connecting to this paper: http://www.degruyter.com/view/j/ling.2012.50.issue-4/ling-2012-0026/ling-2012-0026.xml http://www.degruyter.com/view/j/ling.2012.50.issue-4/ling-20... —whose abstract makes it clear how much they're stretching it by saying "the worldview assumed by German speakers is a holistic one," and then following up with a section titled "Switch languages, change perspective" edit: typo
- amirouche 12y agoThey don't say what do bilinguals for the same exercice.
- julianpye 12y agoI was raised bilingual in German and English, growing up in Germany. For me both languages are very different and to this day I prefer English when I want to talk about ideas and areas where I explore while talking and I use German when I need to be precise. I could never pitch in German and really don't like talking about my projects in German, since everything needs to be exact and committed to.
- radicalbyte 12y agoEnglish is my first language, I learnt Dutch (I'm fluent) as an adult. I have the same experience as you: English is extremely context sensitive, it's for "invention" - it's a very natural language. Dutch is more precise; there's less ambiguity. You have to think a little more before you speak (thanks to the differing subject-object-verb order). I've become a better engineer since learning it. We're raising our kids bilingual because the benefits are just so clear; and I figure that if they get English/Dutch for free then German is very cheap so they can learn an east-asian language too..
- fnord123 12y ago>Dutch is more precise; there's less ambiguity. Really? I would suggest that Dutch is plenty of ambiguity as you can omit a lot. e.g. "Ik moet naar de tandarts [gaan/rijden/fietsen/lopen/bellen/kijken/wijzen/zoeken]" ("I must [?] to the dentist").
- EdwardDiego 12y agoIf Dutch is anything like German, gaan means "go" and rijden/fietsen are along the lines "go by vehicle". In German at least, you tend to use "go by vehicle" where English would just use "go". That is the preciseness English doesn't have. Interesting that the "I must <x> to the Bla" construct exists in Dutch, English has it, but it's antiquated.
- octatoan 12y ago"We must away / We must away / We must away ere break of day / . . ."
- lordnacho 12y agoIsn't this called the Sapir-Worf hypothesis? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity I'm not sure I can feel it personally. I suppose as with many polyglots, I tend to speak different languages in specific contexts. So it's hard to compare, which I guess is why these researchers are setting up specific situations to do this. For instance, I only really know science/business words/ideas in English. I couldn't do a degree in my first language. And it's awkward to talk business in English with my family.
- westoncb 12y agoThis is one of a long line of people arguing for or against what's essentially Sapir-Worf—people have been strongly divided on it for a long time. I'm surprised to see that something like this article is getting attention, though. I figured that at this late date you'd have to say something much more compelling/nuanced to be considered as adding to the subject.
- learnstats2 12y agoWhere I've seen this discussed, most people seem to agree with you - that they don't personally feel any difference. However, I personally feel a huge difference in how I perceive the world - in the three-ish languages I know, but I also feel some differences in regional variations of British English. It's for this reason I feel fascinated by language and saddened that people seem to be converging on English as a lingua franca.
- Jedd 12y agoThis was my first thought, and I was surprised they didn't mention it - perhaps simply because it's allegedly a controversial subject. Regards the controversy - as with many others unburdened by formal training in the area, much of Sapir-Worf 'makes sense to me'. One area that I don't see discussed so much is variations of fluency within a language, and how that shapes the way a person can internally model, and obviously describe and influence to others, both physical objects as well as more nebulous constructs. Again, anecdotally, I've seen a strong correlation between skills with former and latter, though obviously it's not a simple, one-way, causal relationship. I vaguely recall an HN story last year, about a school in NY (US), emphasising rigously expanding the students' vocabulary & language skills based on this premise. Might have been the University Prep in Brooklyn, but what I can find of that one now seem to emphasis maths & physics above English.
- Htsthbjig 12y agoI see this a lot in China. The monolingual people in China that only speak different versions of Chinese have serious difficulty with abstract ideas and concepts because of their language. Chinese is so outdated and obsolete in so many ways. It has not evolved, yes you could understand today a 4.000 year old writing but at what cost? It is a socking experience, because as a European I take evolution in languages for granted. In some ways, Europeans took the Steve Jobs approach of using new tech, outdating the old, even in language, like Carmack saying f&ck you if you wanted to play his games with only a CPU, and then forcing you to buy newer and newer GPUs. It is hard to read without training things written even 200-400 years ago, but we have powers that Chinese don't have, like using tones for emotions(we used tones for the language 4.000 years ago), flexibility, abstractions. But you can only see those if you speak multiple languages.
- Jimmy 12y ago>Chinese is so outdated and obsolete in so many ways. This is really interesting. Could you expand on this? Do you find it to be something with the vocabulary, the grammar? What about the writing system? I've always wondered how the Chinese language writes loan words (Japanese handles this by having a system of phonetic spelling that's used alongside traditional Chinese characters). And before anyone thinks it's absurd that one language could be better at expressing abstract ideas than others, imagine the limit case: a language with only one word. Pretty useless, right? Obviously no natural language is that limited, but that doesn't mean that a range of variation can't exist. It's an empirical matter whether it does.
- SilasX 12y agoThat hypothetical language wouldn't be more abstract so much as vague and context-dependent which isn't the same thing. When a language better handles abstraction, that means it's better at expressing common elements across a variety of domains without having to refer to particulars. For example, being able to talk about a relation between some X and Y without having to keep inflecting based on whether X means animals or houses. One abstraction-helping construction in English is being able to go from "that thing is red" to the concept of redness. I don't know if English is better or worse at this than other languages except that I remember anecdotes about it being harder to express sentences with unusual referents in Japanese eg "am I wearing the jacket?" vs "are you wearing the jacket.
- fit2rule 12y agoI am raising my sons to be multi-lingual (German and English) and it is a wonderful thing indeed to see the mind expansion that occurs on your average code-switch .. especially in very young minds. "Daddy, the erdapfel sind too hot!", and "Das Feur makes me vv-aaaarmm!!" .. ;) Much amusement in such moments. And socially, I think it sets the kids up a bit as well, because they are quite acclimated to the strange looks from strange people when you switch fluidly, between the languages. There is a huge caché, and the boys seem to be becoming aware of how to spend it.
- YAYERKA 12y agoThanks for your comment. It brings up positive nostalgic memories for me. I grew up speaking, reading and writing three different languages, as well as constantly hearing another being yelled through the phone. Not sure about the article; personally it's helped me be able to adapt quickly in lots of foreign places and realize that with a little time and enough "banging your head against a desk" anything can be understood (even Cyrillic alphabets).
- Jayd2014 12y agoSame here. Fluent in 4 languages. For me the best advantage is not learning just the language, but the whole culture. If you can't laugh to comedy standup stars and understand the culture of other people, it really doesn't help much if you are fluent in one language or more. Languages also promote a more liberal worldview and more tolerance for others.
- fit2rule 12y agoI agree with you - the moment you learn another language, you step outside the borders of your own culture, metaphysically, and are able to see things from a different perspective than what is normal. That's the value - and the liability - of language, in my opinion. The world would be a better place if we all spoke more than just our mother-tongues ..
- Soarez 12y agoSteven Pinker has dispelled this notion in his book The Language Instinct. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Language_Instinct https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Language_Instinct
- rustynails 12y agoThat book makes sense, to a degree. Language does not tell us how to think, but it can constrain what we say. I find that our words reflect what we think, particularly when it comes to our prejudices. Common indicators are language that is inclusive or exclusive (we/us/I Cs them/they), notions of gender (eg. Feminism indicates a prejudice toward one gender). I have found that when someone has a biased mindset (particularly an exclusive one) and you point out their mindset through their use of language, most moderate people start to think differently and as such, their language changes. However, I find that emotive people and political correctness break this pattern. This parallels the "faith" gambit - logic never enters the equation.
- sukilot 12y agoThe Language Instinct sets up a straw man and then dispels that.
- SimpleMinds 12y agoA little bit related to article, as I'm not bilingual but just speaking English as another language and this come up after conversation with friend (another not native English speaker). I learned my English mostly thanks to computers and playing games, including classical RPGs. I started to read Malazan Book of the Fallen[0], a very dark and heavy fantasy series. I started in English, then switched to my native language, now to have maximum fun from it (as I like it a lot), I read one book in native and then reread in English. What I've noticed is that reading in my native language makes me feel much more connected to characters, I see the whole relations between persons more vividly and intensively. Then rereading in English, the same characters (which I already know and like!) feels much more distant and abstract. But :) All the fantasy scenes plays much better in my head in English than in my language. For some reasons sentences like "blood dripping from sword", "screams of souls", "massive", "darkness", "spread his wings" etc instantly trigger the feeling of magnificent and out-of-this-world scale of experiences. Even though translation is top-notch, for those parts I prefer the English version. Very interesting experience. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malazan_Book_of_the_Fallen http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malazan_Book_of_the_Fallen
- johnchristopher 12y agoWhat about fantasy in your native language ? How does it feel ? I am of the opinion that translated works are (unintended) betrayals of the original text. And that a `native` author will produce better wording (sigh, sorry about that) than a translator.
- SimpleMinds 12y agoDo you mean originally written in my language? As coming from post soviet block, most of our fantasy is a bit different in a sense that from the beginning it doesn't involve epicness of Tolkien, Malazan, Black Company scale. From the beginning books focus on different things. I would like to read some of them in English to see how's the difference in perception.
- primroot 12y agoThere is a linguist (Daniel Everett) who thinks language can make you less prompt to accept a religion https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BNajfMZGnuo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BNajfMZGnuo
- aorth 12y agoOn a related note: learning another writing system can also be enlightening. Last year I learned how to read Cyrillic and it was a valuable experience. Now I'll see tidbits on Russian-language forums that I can kinda make sense of, or jokes about people using faux Cyrillic[0] in band names, t-shirts, etc. :P More practically, it makes you think about coverage of non-Latin characters in fonts! What does a Cyrillic "ya" (я) look like in your font of choice, for example? Also, I'm curious how most peoples' browsers display it here on HN! BTW, Fira Sans[1] and Noto Sans[2] are two open-source fonts with Cyrillic coverage. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faux_Cyrillic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faux_Cyrillic [1] http://www.carrois.com/fira-4-1/ http://www.carrois.com/fira-4-1/ [2] https://www.google.com/fonts/specimen/Noto+Sans https://www.google.com/fonts/specimen/Noto+Sans
- mrcactu5 12y agoisn't this the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis? I remember in linguistics class my professor spent an entire lecture on how it was so controversial. It's a pretty common-sense idea but neither of the two guys who developed it are linguists. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/relativism/supplement2.html http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/relativism/supplement2.htm...
- OvidNaso 12y agoAlong these lines, I've often thought about the cognitive paths that could be explored or changed if I were to learn braille or sign language. Neuroscience has recently studied and given legitimacy to the state of 'Flow' or 'the Zone'[0] which has been long been understood in the physical realm, but is probably the same or similar in states of other creative activities, like speech or writing. I wonder if it may be easier to induce if one knew American (or any dialect) sign-language. Could we more readily produce eloquence or insight with the forced physicality athletes and meditation guru's use? And how much beautiful poetry and prose are we missing produced by the deaf community? 0. Popularized in recent books by the psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi and journalist Steven Kotler.
- westoncb 12y agoFrom my understanding, 'flow' is basically when your mind has set on and is comfortable with some 'procedure' for doing something; at that point, there's no 'meta process' watching the procedure performed, looking for ways to correct it—the procedure just runs on its own (and it runs much more efficiently that way—kinda like representing a procedure in hardware instead of software). If there's much to that, it probably doesn't matter much whether the procedure has immediate physical consequences or receives data from the physical senses.
- thisjepisje 12y ago“Learn a new language and get a new soul” — Czech proverb.
- indralukmana 12y agoI will speak with a point of view from Indonesian with Javanese ethnicity. Most of Indonesian peoples can speak at least 2 languages. Our local or regional language and national language. Me myself can use 4 languages: Javanese (native), Indonesian (native), English (intermediate), Japanese (beginner), Arabic (beginner). For the Javanese language there some tiers of politeness but the usage in society can be generalized to polite Javanese (kromo) that we use when speaking to elders and rough Javanese (ngoko) that we use with our peers. I have read some articles that speak about language effects on mind or point of view. But since I was small I learned more than two languages I cannot really differ them. Something a kin to the expression of "asking a fish what is water". Based on my own feelings and experiences there are some nuances that accompany each language that I have known. I cannot describe them with words yet, but a language would be appropriate on different settings, medias, and intended audiences. There are some language usages that are not appropriate when used in a different settings but sometimes of course there are some usages that would also help exploring the meanings
- tiatia 12y ago"To speak another language is to possess another soul" Charlemagne “We inhabit a language rather than a country. “ Emil Cioran "I speak Spanish to God, Italian to women, French to men and German to my horse." Charlemagne “The limits of my language mean the limits of my world.” Wittgenstein
- AlbertoGP 12y ago"I speak Spanish to God, Italian to women, French to men and German to my horse." Charlemagne I had learnt this line as attributed to Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor (king of both Spain as Carlos I, and of Germany as Karl V). Charlemagne could hardly have spoken those languages as they didn't quite yet exist around the year 800 A.D. when he lived, but spoke Rhenish Franconian, Latin, and some Greek [1]. Charlemagne was the first Holy Roman Emperor which could explain the confusion, but Charles V lived around 1500 A.D, seven centuries later. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlemagne#Language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlemagne#Language I have quoted those words myself for a number of years, but when checking before commenting I found out that he didn't ever say exactly that, but according to reports some 40 years after his death: https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Charles_V,_Holy_Roman_Emperor#Misattributed https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Charles_V,_Holy_Roman_Emperor#... "When Emperor Charles V used to say, as I hear, that the language of the Germans was military; that of the Spaniards pertained to love; that of the Italians was oratorical; that of the French was noble". "Indeed another, who was German, related that the same Charles V sometimes used to say: if it was necessary to talk with God, that he would talk in Spanish, which language suggests itself for the graveness and majesty of the Spaniards; if with friends, in Italian, for the dialect of the Italians was one of familiarity; if to caress someone, in French, for no language is tenderer than theirs; if to threaten someone or to speak harshly to them, in German, for their entire language is threatening, rough and vehement". Thanks for triggering me into correcting my misunderstanding. :-)