11 ms·
What If Students Could Fire Their Professors?
- ColinWright 12y agoHere's the take-away quotation for me: The better the professors were, as measured by their students' grades in later classes, the lower their ratings from students. "If you make your students do well in their academic career, you get worse evaluations from your students," Pellizzari said. Students, by and large, don't enjoy learning from a taskmaster, even if it does them some good.
- Siecje 12y agoI don't think that applies at the college/university level. Evaluations are at the end of the course and you will know if you have learned a lot. The problem is profs just reading the textbook or parts of the textbook in a powerpoint, without challenging students.
- bvrlt 12y agoEven at the college/university level I have seen students complaining about professors that were fairly good, sometimes just because the grading was a bit tough.
- Siecje 12y agoWould that be a majority though?
- tr352 12y agoWell those might be legitimate complaints. Professor is fine but his grading is too tough.
- emodendroket 12y ago"Too tough" means "I didn't get the grade I wanted." Grade inflation is a real problem.
- rpcope1 12y agoAgreed. When I was teaching before I started out as a developer, it was unheard of to fail anyone in an entry level Physics class (granted this was an Ivy League school); over many semesters I recall thinking that we had passed several students that had no business advancing "because medschool needs high GPAs" or because we didn't want to ruin some kid's future in engineering (when they may not have been successful anyways). But yeah many (most?) of the kids care about a high grade before learning anything, and expect nothing less than an A, even if they don't deserve it.
- pliny 12y agoemodendroket: 'Too tough', as I've heard it, almost always means 'failing average' or 'failing median', but we can only trade anecdotes around that.
- emodendroket 12y agoBut grade inflation is a real and documented phenomenon that would seem to be related.
- sklogic 12y agoBy the end of the course they'd only know they've got an exam to pass and they'll hate it. Students should not have any say in anything related to their courses, professors, marking, workload and such.
- Siecje 12y agoNo say at all? Not even trigger a review? Profs that consistently get poor reviews are getting them for a reason.
- ColinWright 12y agoPossibly that reason is that the students are being made to work hard to get their grades, and not simply being given good grades for no work.
- sklogic 12y agoBack in my days in the university we (all the students) hated mostly the toughest professors. Now, many years later, the only stuff that I still remember well, to a degree that I can go and pass an exam, despite not using much of it in my work, is from the courses of those most hated professors. And now students are much worse, they're expecting a "value for money", they want to be entertained. They do not like being pushed hard. Just look at all those disgusting stories: http://sheffield.tab.co.uk/2015/01/29/devastated-economists-start-petition-outrageous-exam/ http://sheffield.tab.co.uk/2015/01/29/devastated-economists-... (what kind of cretins can find such an exam "too complicated"?) http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-31814659 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-31814659 (another bunch of morons enjoying a right to have their say) This crap must be stopped. Once and for all.
- jimmaswell 12y agoAre you saying all those students just weren't paying attention in class or something? It seems suspect if that many of them spoke out about it
- 12y ago
- dagw 12y agoBased on my experience at University great teachers who push and challenge students are generally disliked by the large group of students that don't particularly want to be pushed or challenged.
- ohfunkyeah 12y agoBut why wouldn't they want to be pushed and challenged? The only thing universities offer is the chance to learn more and be pushed or challenged. AFAIK they could not possibly be there for any other reason than to learn deeply. I think it would be interesting to know if professors who push and challenge within a non-dgree open online course would face the similar wrath? I'd bet not.
- chrisbennet 12y ago"The only thing universities offer is the chance to learn more and be pushed or challenged." Um, have you been to a university? ;-) When you think about it, the professors aren't (necessarily) there to teach either. They are there primarily for the opportunity to do research though that may be changing as many professors are part time minimum wage contractors.
- ohfunkyeah 12y agoYeah, exactly my point. That statement is laughable to anyone who as been to a University. I'm not even sure if being pushed and/or challenged to become better educated is even a primary focus of Universities.
- dubya 12y agoThe quote is about a pair of university courses. Students, and probably just people in general, are really bad at knowing what they have learned.
- ColinWright 12y agoI see a common theme in this and your other comment[0]. In my experience, however, evaluations from students have next-to-nothing to do with how much the students have or have not learned, and that is the point of the linked study[1]. Quoting: > Controlled, randomized experiments find that > SET ratings are negatively associated with > direct measures of effectiveness. SET seem > to be influenced by the gender, ethnicity, > and attractiveness of the instructor. The other link[2] says: > We find that teacher quality matters substantially > and that our measure of effectiveness is negatively > correlated with the students’ evaluations of professors. Both these formal studies are at odds with what you seem to be saying. ======== [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9445924 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9445924 [1] http://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~stark/Preprints/evaluations14.pdf http://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~stark/Preprints/evaluations14.... [2] http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0272775714000417 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0272775714...
- tjl 12y agoI've only known a few profs who just read the text or parts of the text in powerpoint. Of the profs I was a TA for, only one used powerpoint and he made his own slides separate from the text. It definitely applies. One of the best profs in my department often got poor evaluations in some of the first year courses she taught (which were required for everyone). But, she consistently gets excellent ratings for her 3rd year, 4th year, and grad courses (which were targeted for her specialty). She's known for being tough, but students can learn a lot in her courses and they actually do well. First years seem to think that they can get away with more because she's a short woman. She's had students try and suggest how to change her exams after midterms because they've taught swimming lessons. She once had a comment on RateMyProfessor.ca, "I'd say she worships Satan, but I think Satan worships her." It was eventually dropped after several years, but she wrote it in calligraphy and put it up in her office. We all thought that was very funny.
- Sir_Substance 12y agoThe methodology is flawed. If a lecturer really is terrible, then more people will fail that course and not go on to do the advanced course, artificially raising the average for the advanced course because only the best students are able to pass the prerequisite DESPITE the terrible lecturer.
- strathmeyer 12y agoYeah, or even... good students are better at identifying bad professors. Some of my professors were leaders in their field but couldn't teach a class worth anything. I can see why the smart students would get good grades in those classes. Why wouldn't the rest of us be able to tell that they were a bad professor??
- cantankerous 12y agoTrue in theory, but not true in practice. Terrible lecturers find ways to rationalize the poor grades of their students (i.e. externalize the blame) and curve grades to get kids to pass the class. Especially bad lecturers will give the bulk of students high grades to preclude complaints. For their part, poor students could care less about what they learn, instead focusing on passing or getting a good letter grade. In poor programs, subsequent more advanced courses in a sequence are subjected to downward pressure when it comes to teaching more rigorous or advanced topics because the students suck so badly (because of the lack of rigor in early courses). A cluster of poor students can be surprisingly good at stymieing course progress. Many professors have to perform research and would rather placate the students with good grades instead of wasting their research time, which is vital to maintaining their careers (Teaching is secondary at research universities no matter what administration tells you) . The can gets kicked down the road, and mediocrity matriculates.
- yodsanklai 12y agoI'm not sure it is that simple. I believe most university students can tell the difference between a good and a bad professor and are honest enough to fill up evaluation forms in good faith. They are able to assess the involvement of their professors, the quality of the projects and the course material. On the other hand, they aren't qualified to discuss the relevance of the topic for instance. I think this type of evaluation has a role to play in order to improve teaching, but shouldn't be given too much importance for evaluating professors.
- sklogic 12y agoMost university students are too young to be able to tell the difference. And they're spoiled by all that "consumer rights" crap. Education is a peculiar thing, the more it hurts, the better the results. But people do not like when it hurts, especially the young and unexperienced ones.
- _delirium 12y agoI would be more willing to believe that with some time passing. In my own case, how I judged my professors with 3-5 years of hindsight is different from how I judged them right at the end of the course, when I filled out the evaluations. The biggest factor in my own case is that in retrospect I have more respect for the difficult courses, and less respect for the easy courses, then I did at the time they actually took place. I think this is mostly because at the time I judged courses by whether they felt fair/unfair, and the easiest way for a professor to avoid students feeling they were judged unfairly is to just judge everyone in a broadly positive way. If you give some people Cs, inevitably some of them will feel they deserved higher (and sometimes they will even be right, since there is an error rate). While if you give everyone an A/B there's less cause for complaint, because many fewer students perceive getting a grade higher than they deserve as unfair. A secondary factor is that when judging in retrospect I put a little less weight on personality and style than I did at the time. Professors with a "entertaining/engaging" style generally seemed good to me at the time, but in retrospect some of them were a bit shallow in the actual material (some were good, though). As an adult occasionally looking for online lectures, I now tend to specifically avoid the more "TED-style" lecturers, even though they are initially appealing, and find I get more out of a more straightforward, sober style. Some of the really easy and "fun" courses in particular feel like a missed opportunity to me: we had a good time every week in class, I got an A, and I rated the course positively, but I've had to go back and self-study from a book because I had not actually learned much the first time around. If you asked me for the rating 5 years later, I would've revised it downwards!
- FollowSteph3 12y agoThat's the crux, the worst and best teachers will be evaluated almost the same. You need some kind of additional flag to identify this, and unfortunately the next class isn't always possible. Another idea would be a follow up survey 5+ years after the student fraudsters. This is possible as most professors teach for longer than 5+ years.
- atirip 12y agoThis. When i look back at my school times - all those who i, let's say, hated back then are those who i now remember most fondly and who actually teached me something.
- danieltillett 12y agoThis is exactly my experience from when I was a professor. I drove my students to the maximum level I could and still keep my evaluation score just above the minimum (3.5/5). At the time they hated it, but later on they loved to tell me how much they learnt in my classes - their memory of all the work faded and they were left with the true feeling of accomplishment.
- regehr 12y agoHere's a different study with similar findings: http://www.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/scarrell/profqual2.pdf http://www.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/scarrell/profqual2.pdf "... our results show that student evaluations reward professors who increase achievement in the contemporaneous course being taught, not those who increase deep learning."
- ohfunkyeah 12y agoIt's easy to take this and the quote above and leap to the assessment that students like professors that give good grades. But why is this? I think it comes from a fundamental disconnect between what a lot of students really want and what universities are complicit in pretending to offer. A lot of students want the degree so they can get a job in field XYZ. Universities are more than happy to take that desire to get a job and conflate it with a desire to get a higher-level education. They are the gate-keepers to getting a job in many different fields but in many ways act as if they have almost zero responsibility for that responsibility. Just imagine if universities decided to no longer offer degrees and only offered the opportunity for deep understanding and learning. Get rid of grades too, just offer P/F for readiness for the next level of teaching. Do you think student evaluations would still have this bias?
- nilkn 12y agoI don't doubt that this is true in general and is sufficient to destroy any attempt to have students control professor selection, but I'm hesitant to take too much away from this. The best professor in my school's math department was also the most beloved; he was routinely showered with praise by students, and his students were also very successful in later classes. And his classes were not at all easy. I guess we can rank teachers in three tiers: (1) The lowest tier, consisting of teachers both loved and despised who either way fail to prepare students for future classes. (2) Abhorred teachers who do succeed in preparing students for future coursework. (3) The highest tier, consisting of beloved teachers who do succeed in preparing students for future coursework. It's very hard to get into the third tier, because it requires remarkable finesse to make students feel good about having to work extremely hard and possibly still not getting a good grade.
- Tloewald 12y agoI suspect (3) is pretty much impossible, and being — say — 2.5 involves being a gifted entertainer and either having tenure or dumbing down your grading to avoid ticking off students just for giving out fair grades.
- nilkn 12y agoI think (3) is possible, though exceedingly rare, and perhaps Feynman would be an example.
- fragmede 12y ago> The best professor in my school's math department was also the most beloved Out of curiosity, what class traditionally 'belonged' to that teacher? Freshman classes for non-majors (think pre-algebra for art majors) taught in a harsh-but-fair manner is going to score differently than an upper-class or graduate level on manifolds.
- Crito 12y agoIn my case, there were two professors that were widely loved and often cited as the best professors. One was an english professor who had control over the courses about science fiction and fantasy, and often taught a Tolkien course. No real mystery why he was so popular (although he was also a really great personable guy). The other was a math professor that taught the standard assortment of undergrad math classes. I had him for Calc I, Calc III, and Discrete. Most of the math professors in my university that were teaching those classes (particularly the calculus classes) were either hated or unknown. However he had a reputation for being a truly gifted lecturer, and for having incredibly accommodating office hours. His reputation was well earned and deserved.
- evanpw 12y agoA lot of students are there to get a degree, not to learn something. Employers don't know or care how much freshman chemistry you remember (unless you're a chemist), but they do care if you didn't finish your degree because you couldn't pass some requirement. I wonder if the the same relationship is true in fields where there is a licensing exam at the end of your degree (like engineering). Or maybe something like a high-school AP class, where the final exam isn't written by the person teaching. In that case, the teacher would be more obviously on "the same side" as the student.
- ohfunkyeah 12y agoI'd argue that most employers don't really care. They want to use degree, university, and sometimes grades as a first-round filter for screening applicants. Do they actually care if you took the challenging Philosophy course from the good professor, or the easy-A from the Roman History professor? Hell no. So if the primary thing you want is a job, why would you ever take the challenging class? If a professor is significantly and knowingly more challenging than their peers and they don't adequately convey that up front why shouldn't they deserve a bad review. Part of the job is conveying expectations, and in my experience it seems like plenty of professors who will challenge and push know they are like this beforehand but really don't do anything they convey this until after a student is committed.
- nostrebored 12y agoI think that you're right that employers don't care about the specific courses that you took. I think you're wrong to assume that that doesn't mean that those who do take the more challenging courses do get ahead. The best networking I've done was in my challenging courses, where I met smart people who were also interested in learning and bettering themselves. My admittedly skewed and anecdotal evidence is that those people I knew who challenged themselves are now working at better jobs or going to better grad schools than those who decided to coast by. I did not have a single situation where I did not know the difficulty of a course going in. While professors may not adequately let you know, any one of your friends or a number of websites make this information easy to obtain. I feel like I might be alone in this, but I feel like if anything, a professor should warn you if they know that they do not challenge and push. You're in a university course -- it should be challenging. Courses should not be designed for an average student to excel.
- kazinator 12y agoOf course, a lot of the low ratings would also have come from some students who didn't have any grades at all from those later courses, because they didn't make it. Nothing provokes a low rating like failing.
- cgearhart 12y ago>> Society should not punish people who kill people like Locascio. Direct quote from a student eval [1] of the hardest professor I've ever had. There are more like it. The professor blew it up and posted it on his bulletin board. It would irreparably damage higher learning to put the livelihood of teachers like this in the hands of kids who can't even legally drink yet. And -- in keeping with the premise of the article -- I went on to spend the next two years on the Dean's List, in no small part because I had learned so much in Locascio's classes. [1] http://polyratings.com/eval.phtml?profid=382 http://polyratings.com/eval.phtml?profid=382
- penprogg 12y agoThe problem with this is that society does not accept failure. Fail a few times in college and your GPA is irreparably damaged, you have to spend extra time (and money, oh god the money) retaking courses you "should" have passed on the first go. I find myself gaining the most from courses where the professor destroys me. I spend all semester struggling with certain concepts and then at some point towards the end, once I've been exposed to the bigger picture, everything falls together and all the previous material I didn't understand now makes sense. The problem is that I've already been evaluated for the material. If I get a D in a course and retake it and get an A should I still have that D on that record, even though I arguably know the material better than someone who got a B on their first go? While failure is probably the best way to learn, society conditions people to avoid failure like the plague.
- Dotnaught 12y agoEveryone would get an "A"?
- Siecje 12y agoYou can still not learn very much and still get a good grade. Students are attending to learn and will give negative reviews when they are not learning as much as they expected they would learn.
- dagw 12y agoStudents are attending to learn Depends very much on the course. A lot courses are attended by a lot of students who just need the course to fulfill some requirement and want nothing more than to get a pass with as little work as possible.
- emodendroket 12y agoIt's hardly the case that the same thing doesn't apply to students majoring in the subject.
- emodendroket 12y ago> Students are attending to learn and will give negative reviews when they are not learning as much as they expected they would learn. I admire your optimism but I just don't think that's true in even half the cases.
- VLM 12y agoSomething to think about: My intro to philosophy prof felt the value of his class was the performance art aspect of sitting thru his admittedly pretty well performed Socratic method in class. The administration wouldn't let him skip finals, so he told us to write whatever we felt like writing to him, place whatever grade we felt we earned on the top, and that would be our grade. From memory the other CS students and I ganged up on him and convinced him to talk about brain-in-a-vat in class for a couple days so I wrote on that topic. This could apply outside philosophy. I sat thru some chemistry classes that bordered on performance art working thru endless examples of problems in class. I think I pretty much learned quantitative chemical analysis by osmosis just watching the prof work problems. I still remember endless buffer solutions puzzles over 20 years later. Also ochem lab was self explanatory, its a practical lab class nothing more, from memory there was no lecture component beyond "this is the fire extinguisher, here is the safety shower, here is the eye wash station" etc. This could probably be extended to CS/IT classes, somehow.
- bunderbunder 12y agoI've heard about (but not yet read) studies indicating a similar relationship between patient satisfaction and outcome for medical professionals to the one between student satisfaction and outcome. There's a pretty strong negative correlation between the two. Frankly, I'm not surprised. Back when I was TAing and tutoring, it was pretty clear to me that a great many students just wanted the high mark, and were much less concerned with how they got it. And I've had way too many conversations with people complaining about a doctor refusing to prescribe antibiotics for a viral infection.
- calibraxis 12y agoWhat if students could fire the ADMINISTRATORS? What if students could run the university?
- itsybitsycoder 12y agoHonestly, at the school I went to, I would've preferred to have the power to fire the administration versus the faculty. Most of the faculty are just fine. Some were great, most had their little quirks and a couple really sucked at their jobs, but that's true in most fields. The administration seemed to spend most of their time giving themselves raises and flushing money down toilets.
- fmsf 12y agoThis would not work, often students perceive strict professors has being bad because they give too much work load or are too strict. It also goes against excellent researchers who are contributing a lot to science but are not great teachers. Often these are "forced" to teach by their university because otherwise they don't get grants. I am not in academia, but in retrospective some of my greatest professors where very hard to deal teachers with huge fail rates. Most students hated them.
- debacle 12y agoI've never had a bad STEM professor who was proficient in English. I don't know if I've just been lucky or if this is a common misconception about the role of a teacher versus a professor.
- maw 12y agoI think you were lucky. I definitely had some miserable professors and TAs who were native English speakers. And some professors and TAs with comically bad English but who were good at what they did anyway.
- debacle 12y agoYeah I had plenty of good ESL professors but I also had a few that, try as I might, I could not learn from.
- ohfunkyeah 12y agoResearchers who are forced to teach, and are bad teachers because of this, SHOULD be fired from teaching. If the university doesn't value their research alone enough to justify their employment they probably should also be fired altogether.
- HarryHirsch 12y agoHow will we know that student ire will be directed at the right individuals? What are the right individuals anyhow? At my department in my beloved state school there are three full professors, each with no grants, paid USD 120000 for doing no research and giving one bad lecture per semester. Then there are several lecturers who are paid USD 40000, doing a better job at lecturing, and more lecturing altogether. We also have half a dozen assistant professors, who are struggling to bring in grant money and altogether doing an admirable job. The great majority of the students doesn't know how the sausage is made and should well keep out of personnel decisions. They don't even know what the sausage is!
- emodendroket 12y agoIdiotic and the adoption of it would destroy public universities, but I suspect that's actually the intent (just like the NC stuff about how professors must teach 4 classes a year).
- bfuller 12y agoTerrible idea. I went to a school where students had no problems calling mommy and daddy and the parents had quite the culture of bringing lawyers against the university. The university had a rule of never taking these things to court, so they would always settle. Even when it was stupid things like students violating an attendance policy, failing their class because of it, and then getting off scott free beacuse their parents called a lawyer. Disgusting practice.
- imron 12y ago> "Professors need to understand that their customers are those students," Perhaps professors should work for tips too /s
- rickdale 12y agoWhen I was studying CS in undergrad I took an upper level CS course that was suppose to end with learning assembly and building something with it. The class for whatever reason moved excruciatingly slow and we never got past the second or third project. The following semester my advisor who was also a cs professor pulled me aside and asked me, "what the heck happened in that class?" And after my answer he said he would take care of it. For whatever its worth the professor that was teaching the class was and still is the head of the department. And the other professor I confided in retired the following year and moved to Florida. Probably unrelated, but I can see department politics fixing the issue of poorly taught classes.
- bobochan 12y agoI have had a chance to look at course evaluation data over time and the scary thing about it is how quickly ratings can change from year to year. One year a professor might be considered an absolute rock star with students raving about the course, but a problematic upgrade to a piece of software used in the course can drive students absolutely mad the next year. I'm convinced that there is a group think that occurs very quickly in the term and profs are immediately labeled as either stars or bozos, and it is hard to change that perception once it has formed. Another huge factor in course evaluations is the economic environment and prospects for upcoming graduates. Tight labor markets seem to correlate with higher course evaluations as students value subjects that will hopefully make them more marketable. Conversely, a lot of courses get hammered when the job market is good because students start getting a "just give me the piece of paper so I can get out there" feeling.
- Fomite 12y agoThe thing that strikes me is how small the sample sizes are - most students really can't be bothered to fill out evaluations, and those who do are probably not an unbiased sample. There's often maybe a handful of evaluations per year for anything but massive lecture classes. It's hard to even make meaningful or realistic estimates of the quality of a teacher from that data.
- bobochan 12y agoVery true, but there are certainly ways that schools can up the response rates if they are interested. Some schools authentication systems that store a student's ID on one system when they complete the evaluation and the actual response anonymously on another system. You can then set policy to say, "Your final grades will not be released until you complete the course evaluation." I have also noticed that giving students 10 minutes at the beginning of the last class, with the professor leaving the room, helps the rate.
- heapcity 12y agoI'm an abrasive type teacher who gets polarized response distributions. Once when I substituted for the most highly rated professor at a local cc in my subject, I received a most memorable compliment: 'Finally, a real teacher.' ... I quit teaching after one too many interventions from administration and parents about crying kids who could not possibly make less than an A.
- jmilloy 12y agoMy undergraduate courses had professor evaluations. Using these evaluations unilaterally to fire professors is ridiculous, considering the varying incentives students have, the various reasons that professors end up teaching the courses they do, the various values that individual professors bring to university other than teaching, the various ways professors can improve given the right resources and support, etc. But there are poor professors who are evaluated poorly by students yet teach year after year with no improvement. So the problem is that the evaluations are not being used properly -- by professors and administrators -- to make the necessary adjustments. Shouldn't we be firing the administrators?
- nautical 12y agoLet me rephrase it a little bit .. What if in Kung-Fu Panda , the panda could fire his master . FIRE is very strong word , it talks about power over another , teaching is more of trusting some one and accepting someone higher .
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- spython 12y agoI am studying media art at the University for Arts and Design Karlsruhe, Germany [1]. It was founded in the nineties, alongside ZKM, the Museum for new media [2]. One of the founding principles of the school was to limit professor tenure to three years, regardless of the performance. The idea behind it was to prevent the school to become a morass of old ideas and stay competitive in a new field. It succeeded to a degree, especially with regard to the sheer number of different artistic positions that get to be represented at a small university. It is not without fault however - the quality of teaching is not constant; after a professor leaves there is oftentimes a semester of emptiness until a new one arrives. And while the students can not fire a professor, they have a vote in the committee that decides which person to hire as the next professor. [1] http://www.hfg-karlsruhe.de/ http://www.hfg-karlsruhe.de/ [2] http://zkm.de/ http://zkm.de/
- jordanpg 12y agoOne vote for the point of view that says I don't really much care how well-rated as teachers research professors are. My tax dollars should be mostly supporting their research. Teaching should be a collateral duty. It is not a valuable use of time for good researchers. If we need superb instructors to teach basic material to undergrads, let them be called something else. Is there really a single person on this forum who didn't do the bulk of their real learning outside the classroom, anyway?
- chrisbennet 12y agoIt's not as prestigious, but a college without a graduate program will have teachers that are there just to teach. You get taught by professors not not teaching assistants.
- jordanpg 12y agoThat's fine and even important, but there are huge swathes of the American population that don't understand the distinction between research professors and folks like teachers, instructors, and lecturers. They get painted with one brush and, in this instance, are used to score political points with grossly ill-informed voters who have somehow decided that they don't like universities.
- vacri 12y agoHow does this not violate the Eighth Amendment: Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted. Automatic loss of job with no recourse can be seen as both an excessive fine and a cruel punishment. In other news, a friend's wife here in Australia was an XO at a Navy training base. He told me that the base brought in a 'soccer card' system where the recruits could card the drill sergeants and make them face disciplinary action. This didn't take long to completely undermine the ability to make the recruits learn anything and waste the CO's time with meaningless disciplinary hearings, and was turfed out in short order.
- FruitForce 12y agoAs a student myself, in my final year of University and I do feel that there definitely needs to be more control/transparency where the tuition fees go. The faculty that I am on is one of the lowest scoring areas of the university according to the National Student Survey. I assume this is due to the lecturers not having the knowledge or experience when compared to the students who are passionate about their field which they are currently studying for a degree in. Most have managed to get the job with little industry experience to share with students and don't have experience with a modern workflow such as using Linux, git, etc. Personally, I would be much more happier if the lecturers have a basic salary but then allow students to give more of a percentage of their tuition fees to the departments that keep up to date with their field.
- gamechangr 12y agoWhat about giving feedback after graduation?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 12y agoWhat if kids could fire their parents?
- jestinjoy1 12y agoStudents rating professors is bad because 1. Professors raise bar sometimes which students find difficult to cope with and result in low feedback 2. Some students try to "hit" professors with low grades since they are not interested in them 3. More work by professors means low grades from students This is what usually happens in India and I am a professor
- ohfunkyeah 12y agoI disagree completely. You are confusing students rating professors with the how good the survey is and how the university may or may not react to the results. In an of itself rating professors is not good or bad. 1. Part of raising the bar should be making sure students understand that you are doing it and are into it. Also by saying "raising the bar" you are implying that they are going above what the rest of the university is doing. Which is an indictment of the university not of the students. 2. Why aren't they interested in them? Could it be because they are not good? 3. So professors should be able to assign any amount of work that they deem fit? If its a 2-credit course with the workload of a 4-credit course then the professor is bad. If its a 4-credit class and other 4-credit classes have significantly less work, then the university is screwing up. If the its a 4-credit course with a lot more work than other 4-credit courses then that should probably be clearly conveyed up front or have some mechanism for conveying that.
- jccalhoun 12y agocomments on student evals can be crazy. I once had a student write "Stop dressing like a hobo." Who even uses the word "hobo?" To be fair I was going through a faze where I was carrying my things around in a bandana tied on a stick... ;-)
- vonnik 12y agoI attended Deep Springs College, where students literally hire and fire the faculty. It works all right on a very small scale, when the students are committed to learning. Not so well when the students don't like the work that learning requires.
- wiggumz 12y agoI can see it now, it will be like Lord of the Flies... Or perhaps profs will feel obliged to give out A's to keep their jobs.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ponderatul 12y agoLet me give you the other perspective, the one where we ask if the professor is payed by the University to teach. From my understanding they are chosen for their research, their interest lies in research and so the incentives are aligned towards that. That way teaching for a large amount of academic professors is just a side-job, and comes secondary in the pecking order to researching itself. I'm specifically targeting Management/Business courses in the UK. Now you see why student evaluations are used. We can suffer the consequences of this disconnect between incentives and foci of an academic, and that becomes problematic. Most academics need to be kept in check, and connected to the realities of how the students experience their course, in terms of "support available"; "clarity" etc.
- 727374 12y agoDetermining professor tenure via student rating is obviously an extreme idea and likely to fail as outlined by many of the other comments in this thread. But, framing students as customers, is a worthwhile debate to have in the US given the high cost of tuition. Considering the crushing debt student loans can create, students should think of going to college as an investment with risk and return. I wish it were not this way. Let's not pretend that most US universities aren't operating like sophisticated businesses concerned with marketing, generating revenue, and besting competitors. That makes students (along with some other groups) customers. And perhaps if these customers are unhappy, maybe we should blame management (administrators) instead of professors.
- j2kun 12y agoThe market would fix this should the bill become a law. All professors and applicants who care about their jobs will just leave Iowa or never go there in the first place. I wonder who will suffer then?
- KaoruAoiShiho 12y agoWages will increase and the highest quality professors will flock to Iowa to become millionaires. Kinda like how it is in Korea.
- j2kun 12y agoHave you seen professor wages recently? It would be much cheaper to lobby to counter the law than it would be to give wages that would draw professors to a shitty job. If they wanted wages, they'd leave academia anyway.
- sbpayne 12y agoYeah, this is certainly ridiculous. Student ratings often correlate more with grades than they do actual effectiveness of professors. The professors who inflate grades (and thus are really the ones that are diminishing educational value) are the ones who would keep their jobs. I like the place this is coming from (there's zero accountability from students to professors). But such an extreme measure is something I feel would work against the end goal.
- pistle 12y agoWhat if a small, semi-random sample of voters could fire an elected official for any piece of legislation they attach their name to? I see the grades in Iowa elevating and the market-value of a degree from Iowa discounting. You get an A! You get an A! You get an A! You ALL GET AN "A"!!!!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cafard 12y ago'Ted Hilles, the chairman, was a remarkably kind man who was embarrassed by having to do so, but he read the student comments aloud to each of us. "This is the kind of teacher that I came to Yale to study with,", the student you had given a B+ or an A would say. Then there would follow the report of students like Smithers, to whom you cad given a C or a D: "This man is the worst teacher I have ever studied with, he is a disgrace to the Yale faculty and far infirior [sic] to my masters at Andover. A profound cynicism about student comments was born from the experience of hearing these absolutely opposite evaluations one after another and knowing how closely they correlated with the grades you had given." --Alvin Kernan, In Plato's Cave I don't recall there being student evaluations of teachers in my undergraduate days (which were not spent at Yale or anything like it). When I went back to school part time in my 30s, I wrote bad things about only a couple of instructors, both for showing up unprepared (and occasionally not showing up at all).
- balabaster 12y agoThe problem with this approach is that it's hard to evaluate the performance of your teacher until many years later, at a time when you only just came to realize that not only had you learned a lesson, but also the magnitude and how profound that lesson was. I didn't come to appreciate everything my grade school teachers instilled in me until many years into my professional career. If you'd asked me as I was getting ready for my exams how I'd rated them as teachers, those I liked the most would have gotten the highest grades regardless of how much I'd really learned from them. Those I liked the least would have gotten the lowest grades. It wasn't until many years later that those I liked the least during my academic career (if you can call it that) were the ones who actually taught me the most. It would have been a shame for them to be fired on something so subjective as how much I liked them or how dissatisfied I was that they'd just issued me the 4th 'D' grade in a row. It's only now that I genuinely appreciate everything they taught me that I feel honestly worthy of sitting in their classroom again to learn what is they're willing to impart. So I say thanks to those teachers that pushed me, those that held me accountable, those that I disliked during school. It was you that would likely have been fired by these performance evaluations that gave me the most. I just never would have had the foresight to give you the grade you deserved.
- kazinator 12y agoDegrees granted from any university that regards students as customers are automatically worthless junk, because they are essentially purchased goods. When a professor is rated low, at least some of that rating has to do with the professor having a high standard in the awarding of grades and passing of students. If students get good grades then no matter how much the lectures suck, or how unavailable that professor is for help and so on, large numbers of those students will not rate that professor low. Poor grades are the exacerbating factor in a revolt against a professor. If you're a C student, the moment you see a B+ next to your student ID on the course results table, all memories of the prof either vaporize or become rose-colored.
- ohfunkyeah 12y agoDegrees and grades are a big part of the problem because they are treated as currency to get a job. Degrees are like the Microsoft points system. I want a job in field XYZ. Well to get that you have to buy 256 credits. But, but, it looks like the job really only requires 120 credits. Too bad you have to buy 256. Ok, fine... WTF, part of the 120 credits have absolutely no relevance to the thing I want to do. Yeah, well you still need to take them.
- kazinator 12y agoAll university credits are relevant to that job, even those humanities courses and whatever. Credits directly relevant to the job skills are more like vocational training; whereas university is supposed to be about education. Also, one reason some jobs prefer applicants with degrees is because university completion shows that you have some ambition and willingness to work hard toward a goal that is several years away, in the face of deadlines and stress, and possibly financial risk also. They know you've pulled a few all-nighters to get through. In other words, you're gone through a pretty tough four year (or more) project: to produce a degreed version of yourself. That degree shows that you can work, even if you don't have employment experience.
- ohfunkyeah 12y agoOne can say that all university credits are relevant to any job but only in the most general sense. Certainly you wouldn't advocate 8 years of general education before getting into degree specific education so the amount is at the very least arbitrary. Yeah you are probably right about ambition as a general filter too. But the point remains that universities take advantage of this. They know full-well that plenty of students are there to get a job and they can and do milk this. Issuing degrees is not part of Universities being "about education". Degrees are an arbitrary milestone, that can be received after completing a nearly arbitrary set of classes, that in-turn have taught an arbitrary set of lessons. The fact that Universities have coalesced around issuing degrees of the same type without ensuring their curriculums match further makes the degrees aribitrary.
- jackmaney 12y agoI am SO fucking glad that I'm not in academia anymore.
- x3n0ph3n3 12y agoThe last thing we want is a coalition of creationist students getting their biology professor fired because he dared to teach them about evolution.
- crazy1van 12y ago"And therein lies the paradox. Yes, students are paying, often handsomely, for their degree. But they're not exactly customers, either. They're participants in an experience — one that is meant to be challenging, even grueling." If that's "not exactly" the definition of a customer, I'm not sure what is. The students are customers. The real paradox is if they vote for easier teachers, the product they are buying loses its value.
- ColinWright 12y agoPerhaps the problem is that the customer thinks they're buying one thing, the professors think they're selling something different. There's no clear statement as to what the product actually is. Is the product an education, or a degree?
- chasing 12y agoStudents and professors are not peers. A professor has to be able to force a student to do something they don't want to. "You don't understand this." "You're not doing this right." "You're not working hard enough to learn what you need to learn in the limited amount of time we have, here." Etc. A student might find this unpleasant, embarrassing, or whatever. But that doesn't mean the professor is wrong. Or bad at their job. Student evaluations are valuable, of course, but the idea of using them alone to decide a professor's fate seems incredibly unfair.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoWhy 'unfair'? Because they're being rated by a person that knows them from only a few hours exposure a week, in a stilted environment and based on a narrow context of arcane skills? Sounds like a student's life. Cry me a river, professor.
- chasing 12y agoStudents and professors are not peers.
- kefka 12y agoThe professors should be servants, in the same light a server is to a meal. I pay for it, I get it the way I want.
- chasing 12y agoIt's actually much more complicated than that, and as someone who has been a student and is currently an adjunct professor, I find that attitude to be horrible. The student-teacher relationship is a collaboration. Also, please don't go through life thinking that every single person you might give money to for something is your "servant." Not even the person on the other side of the McDonald's counter.
- kefka 12y ago
- retali8 12y agoIt's really frustrating when I paid $50k/yr at a top 5 univ for CS deg, and some of the CS courses (including a junior year core) were taught by PhD students with incomprehensible English accents. I have no issue with non-english speakers getting their PhDs...they're obviously very intelligent and I respect them greatly...however, they are not suited at all for instruction by lecture... in those courses i learned nothing during class, and learned everything myself later on. i once had a PhD student as lecturer in an advanced track course -- we bumped into him at a bar one saturday...this guy was jumping all over the tables, drunk and wasted out of his damn mind... now i did have some amazing profs but those were all tenured.
- sgustard 12y agoAfter I'm finished firing my professors, do I still get my degree?
- VLM 12y agoThe purpose of higher ed is to outsource the selective pressure from corporate HR depts to university admissions depts. So the corporation can hire the "right people from the right social groups" by using the degree as proxy. Seeing as the admissions dept has already done all the work of filtering applicants to select the right ones, sure, why not. May as well issue the degree at admission time, skip the dog and pony show of 4 years of attendance. It'll have little to no effect on outcomes in non-vocational fields. The vocational fields don't belong at uni/college anyway, they belong at vo-tech schools just like welding or diesel repair.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoSorry. Outside of community colleges, professors are researchers first and teachers second. Let the students fire the TAs. Not like they get paid anyway.
- xijuan 12y agoI just wanted to say few things about my experiences on reading students' ratings on ratemyprofressor.com. First, professors who consistently get good ratings are usually very good lecturers. They are not necessarily easy profs. But they do give great lectures and explain things more thoroughly. On the other hand, professors who get consistently low ratings are usually not good. For example, last term, I took a course with a prof who got 2/5 on ratemyprofessor and her lectures indeed suck although she is a kind person. She doesn't explain the math materials she is teaching; just barely writes down notes on the board. And all the students I have talked to also think she is not a good teacher. The term before I took a course a prof who got 4/5 on ratemyprofessor. She is indeed a great prof and explained everything so clearly. Our class wrote the same exams as the sections but our average was 7 percentage higher overall. Of course, the ratings from that website may not be equivalent to the ratings profs get from their actual teaching evaluation. But from my experience, I think the students do have the ability to distinguish between good profs and bad profs. And students' ratings are not only based on how easy the course is but also based on how interesting the lectures are and how approachable the prof is. Does anyone who has an opposite experience from what I have experienced? That is taking a course who a prof who got high ratings on ratemyprofs but felt the prof was bad.
- ColinWright 12y agoBut everything you say is what everyone believes is "common sense." If all you want are clear lectures well delivered, great, follow the advice on some random rating website. The research, however, says that the student evaluations are negatively correlated with subsequent ability in the subject. In other words, you are repeating the common sense view that is flatly contradicted by careful research. What should I trust: your anecdata, or published research?
- Fomite 12y agoI have definitely had life-changing professors who taught be extremely valuable lessons who were poorly rated on that site. And one of the worst professors I ever had (like if I build a time machine I'm going back to tell myself not to take his class) was highly rated on that site.
- codefisher 12y agoI would like more accountability from professors somehow. Maybe not from student reviews, but at least someone unknown to the professor randomly attend a few classes to check the quality of them. Right now I have a professor that says things during class that are obviously incorrect, and can be verified as incorrect. Her attitude towards students is also disrespectful. But there is nothing we can do about it, no way to communicate to the university that they should be embarrassed and ashamed to have such a professor.
- rebootthesystem 12y agoCameras in every classroom. You can then annonymosly report problems with time and date for review. I had a Calculus prof who was worthless. She would literally read from the book and copy it verbatim on the blackboard. No questions. If you had a question you had to write it down on a piece of paper and leave it on her desk. If she could get around to it the question might be answered in a day or two. Students had no way to fire this prof or get her reviewed and replaced. We had to endure the torture and learn on our on.
- chasing 12y agoHave you actually tried to communicate with the university? Because I suspect you could find someone in the department willing to hear your complaints. Now, they very well might disagree with you. Or they might not immediately act. But surely you have contact with an academic advisor or know the name of a department head. If you make this sort of contact, though, I'd recommend against saying anything like "[you] should be embarrassed and ashamed to have such a professor." Stick to facts. Also, note that even very accomplished and intelligent people can make mistakes when they speak. I don't know what "obviously incorrect" facts you professor is stating, but I've had good professors bumble words and even ideas. And I know (as a former student) that students love discovering and pointing out those errors. Even if they have no real bearing on the quality of education being delivered.
- Fomite 12y agoHave you tried to do so? I've seen coherent, well-written letters from a large number of students influence the direction a course took (it was redesigned from the ground up for the next year), and both student and peer evaluations of teaching are definitely a factor in tenure decisions - and depending on the position, may be a major factor. But I'd start with laying out concrete things, rather than "embarrassed and ashamed".
- rtconner 12y agoAs someone who had a few professors/teachers who I hated while in their class, and now really appreciate looking back : Never trust a student opinion on a professor.
- tmerr 12y agoI have finite attention. Attention (time and effort) is probably more important to my learning than the quality of my teacher. Without attention you fail. With infinite attention you get a perfect grade. When you take a hard course it consumes a disproportionate amount of attention. Even if the teacher is bad at his/her job a harsh grading scheme will drive you to spend hours in the library. You will learn a lot because you are burning valuable attention; attention other classes can not have. So such a class necessarily good? Of course not. Not if the learning benefit is outweighed by learning opportunity cost. So regarding the finding of the study The better the professors were, as measured by their students' grades in later classes, the lower their ratings from students. I'm not confident that performance in later classes of the same sequence is a fair measure of learning; what matters to me is performance in ALL later classes. How do evaluations correlate then?
- VLM 12y agoI see an article and HN post full of obsolete old people thinking. You can't outsource responsibility for your life to someone else and then complain about it. The prof is not responsible for what a student learns or enjoys any more than the prof is responsible for the students sex life or religious belief. The student is responsible for learning the material. If the prof refuses to answer questions or refuses to eval the students the prof is guilty. If the students are lazy thats too bad for the student, sucks to be them. If the students don't like their prof, who cares, they're just ignorant kids till they learn something useful... Old people thinking is you learn for 4 years then work at the same company doing the same thing for 43 years and retire with the corporate gold watch. Young people thinking is you learn full time for 4 years and then work while learning part time for 45+ years. For 4 years you have profs who you think you can outsource your responsibility for learning to... and your plan for the following 45+ professor-less years, still have to learn with no one to outsource your responsibility for learning to? Good luck with that. There is also the missed effect of warped samples because the population is not constant over time. Lazy students either sink or swim and possibly learn to avoid hard profs in the future. Given that selection pressure its hard to imagine hard profs not resulting in better grades later because the sample is self selecting itself away from hard profs or dropping out. Even if there is no difference in educational attainment between hard and soft profs.
- douche 12y agoIn my experience, the teachers I learned the most from were also the best teachers, i.e. the most engaging. Difficulty was really a separate concern, in a lot of ways. There were very easy courses that I learned a huge amount from, and difficult courses that weren't worth the time I spent on them. To be honest, I only bothered to rate professors because I couldn't see my final grades until I did so. Consequently, only the very excellent and the very terrible really got any kind of response.
- mreiland 12y agoI hate history. HATE HISTORY. In Uni I had to take my final history course and only 1 professor was available. Little did I know at the time... The man was a hardass. a quiz every single class over the previous classes lecture, you can only make up 3 quizzes, after that it's too bad so sad. And yet I LOVED the course. People talk about good orators and I had never known one until I met this guy. I was absolutely enthralled every lecture. He was just amazing to listen to, somehow he made what he was talking about seem exciting, it was crazy. I passed the class with an A and I've never regretted taking that class. I remember it fondly. And I'm the guy that would completely stop going to classes, showing up only for the tests, so that's saying something. I think it's a terrible idea to start grading professors on by their students evaluation. I think student evaluations are good, but personally I think too many professors already cater to their students, the problem would only get worse. And the ones who are there to learn will get left behind.
- vishaldpatel 12y agoHaving been through three colleges, the professors that seemed to be disliked were not the ones that were the most difficult, but the ones that were terrible at explaining the material to the students. For some classes, students stopped going to class and studied on their own.
- komodekork 12y agoA universitys main focus should be on research, education is second. Let the colleges educate the masses. Therefore students shouldn't have a say in if a professor should be on the faculty or not, as long as he is churning out good papers.