7 ms·
Credit card terminals have used same password since 1990s, claim researchers
- PaulHoule 12y agoSpeaking of "chip cards" I notice that my banks are stuffing my wallet with contact smart cards, but I haven't seen a single vendor in the U.S. that accepts those. Subway in my area, for instance, has terminals that accept ony contactless cards, and my local Target has gone so far to stuff up the slots for contact cards.
- kayfox 12y agoThey are not required to have them in place until October. http://blogs.wsj.com/corporate-intelligence/2014/02/06/october-2015-the-end-of-the-swipe-and-sign-credit-card/ http://blogs.wsj.com/corporate-intelligence/2014/02/06/octob...
- kimos 12y agoThe US is very slow to adopt these kind of payment changes. I'd say I make about half of my CC purchases in Canada right now contactless. My understanding is that since there are countless local banks in the US, adoption of technology changes is difficult and slow.
- talkingquickly 12y agoSimilar in the UK, I'd say I make most of my small purchases (e.g. lunches, coffees etc) contactless now.
- hobarrera 12y agoWhat will happen with people who travel from abroad in a few years? Places like Latin America aren't even thinking about changing cards (heck, we're still adopting the old magnetic cards in most stores!). What'll happen when I visit Canada with my card in one or two years? Will those still be accepted?
- notwhereyouare 12y agowalmart and publix near me take them
- evan_ 12y agoI've seen a bunch of terminals that have a place for a chipped card, but they don't work yet- I assume that a firmware update will enable them sometime soon.
- Johnie 12y agoLater this year, there is going to be a concerted public education movement on the chip card. Once that happens, you'll see merchants actively push you towards using the chip vs the magstripe.
- newman314 12y agoEven then, most of the ones I've seen are Chip+Signature and not Chip+PIN...
- sp332 12y ago"The important fact to point out is that even knowing this password, sensitive payment information or PII (personally identifiable information) cannot be captured," Verifone said. "What the password allows someone to do is to configure some settings on the terminal; all executables have to be file signed, and it is not possible to enter malware just by knowing passwords."
- timboslice 12y agoI wonder what is available in the settings interface? For example, is there some gateway address that could be changed to a MITM transparent proxy? They act like this is no big deal, but 9/10 of these machines has the same password!
- sp332 12y agoYeah but if the password is for an account that doesn't have any access, who cares? I guess some kind of privilege escalation would be news, but that's a separate vulnerability.
- Nursie 12y agoPresumably (and I have worked on devices like these, but not for Verifone) there is some sort of encryption going on. I.E. some protocols I've worked with have had all sensitive data protected by ANSI X9.24 Appendix 1 (I think...) derived keys, or keys derived by various other standard means, such that being able to read the data stream is pretty irrelevant.
- gknoy 12y ago> Presumably ... there is some sort of encryption going on. Color me skeptical. I would presume similarly, but I also would have presumed that they did not have the same password, either. A failure of that scope seems like it could be indicative of a systemic disregard for security.
- Nursie 12y ago
- kw71 12y agoIngenico have a set-up password, too. Once you enter it you can change network settings which could be dangerous in the context of a poorly segmented network. Given this I am wondering what kinds of settings are available in the Verifone secret menu. Is there anything like IP address, which could facilitate an MITM if an attacker walked up and changed it?
- Nursie 12y agoIf there are keys that secure the traffic between the terminal and the bank, is an MITM setup going to be of any use?
- kw71 12y agoWhile some card payment terminals talk directly to the bank, there is strong evidence that this is not how all POS work.
- coleca 12y agoYes. In large scale retailers, the payment terminals would either be connected via Ethernet to the private point of sale (POS) network in the store where they could only talk to the POS controllers, or they would be connected via USB or custom serial cables (IBM) to the POS register itself and all communications would run through the software on the POS terminal. This password isn't the encryption key. Usually keys would be injected into the terminal either remotely through the POS terminal, POS controller or by shipping a special card w/a magstripe to the store where the manager or loss prevention person would swipe the card on each terminal that has the new key on it. PCI standards dictate that the retailer rotates the keys on a schedule with a documented procedure. Changing the merchant ID probably would have little effect in most operations because the transactions aren't going directly to the MC/VISA/etc network, but are passing through a dedicated link to the merchant's acquiring bank. I've never tested this, but I would imagine that the acquiring bank would reject transactions that are for merchant IDs that do not belong to the customer that is leasing the connection. This situation actually happens quite often by merchants just mis-keying the merchant ID when setting up new stores.
- Church- 12y agoSaw this an' stars and stones, first thing that popped into my mind. Was Barnaby Jack that rascapllion. I figure he would've had something to say on the matter.
- peapicker 12y agoInterestingly, this last year, many businesses I frequent updated to new Verifone terminals. My credit card doesn't read on only that brand of terminal (works everywhere else i use it), unless I wrap it in a piece of receipt tape or plastic bag before sliding it thru, then it works after a try or two. Not sure why, but I haven't replaced the card yet simply because it is an interesting experiment.
- creshal 12y ago> before sliding it thru The US are still using magnet stripes?
- Nursie 12y agoYup, it's rather quaint at this point!
- mikeash 12y agoYes. We're just now transitioning to chips. My cards are gradually being replaced with chip cards, starting last year. In October of this year, new rules will come into effect that basically require all cards and terminals to use chips, by putting the liability for fraudulent magstrip transactions onto whatever party was responsible for not being able to use a chip. (In other words, merchants will foot the bill for fraud if they don't upgrade their terminals.) We're taking our time, but we're finally moving there. Edit: despite having chip cards, I've yet to be able to use the chip in the US. Many places now have chip-enabled terminals, but often not set up to use the chip part, and after a few failed attempts I just gave up on it.
- mrchucklepants 12y agoThis happened to me at Costco the other day. Chip capable terminal but it didn't do anything. The guy at the register had never seen anyone try to use it before. He didn't even know the new slot was there.
- ams6110 12y agoIn October of this year, new rules will come into effect that basically require all cards and terminals to use chips How does this affect Square and similar peripheral readers for mobile devices? Will users of those now be liable for fraud?
- iamleppert 12y agoI used to work at a retailer and I know the password myself. This is a prime example of hyperbole. The password only allows you to change things like what is printed on the receipt (the banner), merchant ID and other such things. It basically allows you to enter into a menu to set a few settings. It's not as if you can get a dump of card swipes. Just a few researchers spreading fear about what has been known for a long time.
- abluecloud 12y agoSo, you could change the merchant ID and send payments to other accounts?
- JTon 12y agoThat would be an interesting headache. I would hope there are some sort of back end checks in place for this type of modification
- Nursie 12y agoI once heard a story about a store-clerk who, upon finding their POS setup was broken, went down the street and 'borrowed' a configuration file from another store in the area that they happened to know had the same software. Blissful in their ignorance of what was going on they then happily continued accepting transactions for the rest of the day. Oops.
- JTon 12y agoHa. Pretty damn saavy store clerk
- callesgg 12y agoOn the ones i have used it is 147369