39 ms·
> Apple is a vile antitrust monstrosity. These jerks needed to be slammed with a lawsuit long before this one single example of their flamboyant and abundant an
by AlexandrB 12y ago
> Apple is a vile antitrust monstrosity. These jerks needed to be slammed with a lawsuit long before this one single example of their flamboyant and abundant anti-competitive behavior.
While Apple are being increasingly huge dicks with their ecosystem I think you'd be hard-pressed with an antitrust case because Apple does not have a monopoly (or even a majority marketshare) on mobile devices.
- zamalek 12y ago> I think you'd be hard-pressed with an antitrust case because Apple does not have a monopoly on mobile devices. > [Merriam-Webster] of, relating to, or being legislation against or opposition to trusts or combinations; specifically: consisting of laws to protect trade and commerce from unlawful restraints and monopolies or unfair business practices. It doesn't only apply to monopolies but it is a very good tool for dealing with them.
- captainmuon 12y agoThey have a monopoly for the iOS platform, at least. And in some jurisdictions you don't need a monopoly to be guilty of anticompetitive behavior.
- AlexandrB 12y agoDo you have the same stance on Twitter? Twitter has a monopoly on the Twitter platform and may choose not to provide API keys for apps that it doesn't want to exist. Is this abusing a monopoly? If not, why not?
- Dylan16807 12y agoTwitter has definitely performed anticompetitively in the past like that. Legal or not, it's abusing their position.
- Alupis 12y agoIf Twitter was killing an App or Device made by a 3rd party simply because Twitter was entering that market and wished to monopolize the user-share, then yes I'd consider that anti-competitive. (yes, Twitter does just that, and yes, it's anti-competitive in my book). Simply not being able to mention "Android" or "Android Wear" or now "Pebble Watch" is ridiculous. If I chose to buy an Android Wear or Pebble Watch, it's because I felt it was a better match for me... I still would have bought an iPhone (since I'm looking for iPhone Apps).
- mikeryan 12y agoIf Twitter was killing an App or Device made by a 3rd party simply because Twitter was entering that market and wished to monopolize the user-share, then yes I'd consider that anti-competitive. This is exactly what they've done.
- Alupis 12y ago> This is exactly what they've done. I realize that. If you look at the parent, they were making the argument that it's not the same.
- mikeryan 12y agoIf Twitter was killing an App or Device made by a 3rd party simply because Twitter was entering that market and wished to monopolize the user-share, then yes I'd consider that anti-competitive. This is exactly what they've done.
- mason240 12y ago>If Twitter was killing an App or Device made by a 3rd party simply because Twitter was entering that market and wished to monopolize the user-share, then yes I'd consider that anti-competitive. Don't they have long history of doing exactly that?
- pjc50 12y agoTwitter's stance of shutting down apps that get too many subscribers definitely looks bad to me - although it's a little different in that no money changes hands. http://www.pcworld.com/article/2104603/metrotwit-vanishes-as-twitter-restrictions-claim-another-victim.html http://www.pcworld.com/article/2104603/metrotwit-vanishes-as...
- burnte 12y agoI'll agree they're not a monopoly, but they're being highly anti-competetive, to a point that a legal remedy might actually be successful should the FTC or DOJ push it.