7 ms·
Cheaper bandwidth or bust: How Google saved YouTube
- adventured 12y agoI still remember the loud howls of mockery when Google paid $1.65 billion for YouTube in 2006. Mark Cuban said: "Only a moron would buy YouTube" (due to the potential legal liability) and "There is a reason they haven't yet gone public, they haven't sold. It's because they are going to be toasted" and "Would Google be crazy to buy Youtube. No doubt about it. Moronic would be an understatement of a lifetime." http://blogmaverick.com/2006/10/07/some-thoughts-on-youtube-and-google/ http://blogmaverick.com/2006/10/07/some-thoughts-on-youtube-... It was almost universally ridiculed as being far too expensive. Analysis was done in every other article about how Google would never be able to pay for the acquisition with YouTube as a business. Eight years later, it's more than clear that YouTube was a steal for Google at $1.65 billion. It's worth 10+ times that today.
- codexon 12y agoI think it was quite reasonable to doubt youtube had a future. The bandwidth costs still must be enormous and back then more so. Only a few companies had the clout to negotiate favorable prices for bandwidth. Even now I am surprised that they are either making so much from ads or pay so little in bandwidth that they can do what Vimeo charges for free.
- hhw 12y agoGoogle has a lot of settlement free peering, so the bandwidth itself is going to be close to free, although the infrastructure to support it would not be. They also don't have to worry about being present in as many peering locations as most networks of comparable capacity, as their services aren't that latency sensitive, which also helps reduce their infrastructure costs.
- NeutronBoy 12y ago> Eight years later, it's more than clear that YouTube was a steal for Google at $1.65 billion. It's worth 10+ times that today. A 10x valuation still puts it at less than WhatsApp. If WhatsApp is worth $19b, then I'd wager that Youtube should be worth significantly more. EDIT: I'll expand with a few dot points - Youtube has an unimaginably huge content library - Youtube has a solid monetization strategy - Barrier to entry is significantly higher than a messaging app - Youtube is even more synonymous with video streaming than WhatsApp is with messaging (anecdotally, my grandparents use Youtube. They don't even have smartphones, let alone WhatsApp).
- freehunter 12y agoThe problem with having a monetization strategy is then people can see how much money you make. If you aren't making any money and not even trying to make money, the cash investors and buyers throw at you is Monopoly money printed on valuations and total active users. Most startups would drop in valuation significantly if they made even one penny.
- narrator 12y ago>Most startups would drop in valuation significantly if they made even one penny. This kind of stuff sounds EXACTLY like what people were saying during the first dot-com bubble. Did you mean that ironically perhaps?
- bandrami 12y agoWith this and the startup generator posted earlier, I am convinced I am re-living 1998, only at the age of 39 rather than 22...
- freehunter 12y agoNot ironic, no. It's just the truth. Do you think WhatsApp or Instagram would be worth billions if they had to make money? With the absolute minuscule amount of profit they might make, their valuation would be worth maybe hundreds of thousands. Not billions. The reason they're valued so highly isn't because of how much money they would make, but how much value they would bring to an already profitable company. Those valuations aren't based on the idea of profits, but on the idea of being bought out by a bigger player. If they started making money on their own, that value would drop massively.
- zmbergman 12y ago"Only a moron would buy YouTube" - Marc Cuban Let's make sure that quote is never forgotten.
- positr0n 12y agowhy?
- RiverTam 12y agoYes money cant buy you a brain of your own. Poor Cuban.
- bitwize 12y agoSays the man who would go on to invest in "I Want to Draw a Cat For You!"
- CatDrawingGuy 12y agoHey, leave me out of this.
- bitwize 12y agoI love your work, but I don't think Cuban was playing the hard-nosed businessman when he invested; rather he saw something in your idea that just might turn a profit. I think it's rather the same with Google and YT. Google saw that video was going to be big on the Web but their Google Video experiment was suboptimal in implementation They saw that YT did it better and saw a future of integrating that technology with Google's other services, and it paid off.
- eco 12y agoI find Mark Cuban's take back then — and now, he still believes YouTube is a loser as recently as 2015 — particularly funny because selling Broadcast.com to Yahoo for $5.7 billion is how he made his billions. YouTube is soaring whereas Yahoo's music and video offerings are almost non-existent. Maybe he was biased by how bad his own acquisition went for Yahoo.
- smacktoward 12y agoOr maybe he thought that he had suckered Yahoo every bit as much as he was thinking YouTube had suckered Google.
- wnevets 12y agoI didn't think it was a good idea either. I though google would get bogged down by DMCA request and having to pay the big name content makers. I also though once it became only "legal" content everyone would just move on to the next video sharing site.
- comrade1 12y agoIf I remember correctly, it was a way for the investors to cash out on their Google value indirectly. The same VCs (Sequoia I think) that funded Google had funded Youtube. It's been a long time so I may be remembering incorrectly. OK, I just looked up the deal and it was done in stock and not cash. Sequoia invested $9M and received $516M as part of the deal. I did see an article saying Sequoia planned to sell their Youtube acquired Google shares in 2007 (before the lock-out period for employees expires) but I'm not sure if the sale went through. http://www.nytimes.com/2006/10/10/technology/10payday.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2006/10/10/technology/10payday.html?_...
- nullc 12y agoSeems a bit whitewashed by not making any mention of all the youtube internal emails turned up in viacom's discovery with youtube staff participating in, aiding the infringement (including, e.g. removing report functionality), and saying the infringement was integral to the success of their business; But it mentioned viacom's not-completely-clean hands. (Though there was nothing unlawful about viacom uploading their own stuff to youtube...)
- AceJohnny2 12y ago> (Though there was nothing unlawful about viacom uploading their own stuff to youtube...) I dunno, sounds kinda like entrapment or framing to me...
- ab 12y agoPretty interesting stuff. I do wonder how much internal collaboration there is on topics like HTML5 video & WebM. The benefits of owning end-to-end both browser and server for driving media codec development seem enormous. It makes Google's decision to launch Chrome in 2008 much more of an obvious call.
- dba7dba 12y agoI had a coworker who used to work for a direct competitor of Youtube. He left that competitor (as they were struggling) as Youtube was taking off. His older company had been founded by a Hollywood exec/veteran, meaning he made sure to keep out copyrighted material. The way he put it, he said Youtube got big Because Youtube initially allowed copyrighted material. This led Youtube gaining more videos -> more traffic -> more videos -> repeat.
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoAlmost every day I watch something on Youtube that breaks copyright law and think that society is better off as a result, so I think this is a positive outcome. I wouldn't sacrifice all the old adverts, rare blues music etc. just so that big corps can have a better bargaining position over their copyrights.
- throwawaykf05 12y agoThis sort of thinking only encourages more breaking of copyright law, the vast majority of which is of content that is neither rare nor in danger of being lost. I don't think society is better off for that, as it simply exacerbates this specific freerider problem. "Big corps" (and small creators) are investing their resources into providing content that you like? What are you giving back in return?
- blackoil 12y agoPossibly, the content is system recognizes actual owner and add revenue share is going to him/her and not there uploader
- doctorshady 12y agoDefined saved; the site is still losing money.
- anonbanker 12y agoThe fact that Google buoyed Youtube's sinking boat by plugging the leaks with money does not mean that Youtube shouldn't have collapsed under it's own weight and been allowed to die. Maybe then, we would've gotten a free, open, p2p alternative out of the ashes. Now we have DMCA takedowns, region-locked videos, and unskippable commercials. The sooner someone disrupts youtube, the better the world will be.
- rockdoe 12y agoLet's not forget YouTube can also arbitrarily decide what video sizes competing browsers are allowed to receive, or what DRM system they should have implemented. Good luck shipping something that doesn't work with YouTube. I'd say their position of power is greater than Netflix.
- blackoil 12y agoKilling youtube is not solution for that, you can wish Facebook etc will create genuine competition.
- pjc50 12y agoDMCA takedowns and region locks are a legal/social problem, not a technological one. Look at what happened to PopcornTime. You can still self-host your own videos, but then it's hard to monetize them to pay for the bandwidth. Remember that this is a "two sided market": you have to bring viewers and video producers to it. And the commercials are blocked successfully by AdBlock.
- rockdoe 12y agoDMCA takedowns and region locks are a legal/social problem, not a technological one. That seems like oversimplifying matters. The way Google automatically identifies infringing content is very much a technological issue, as well as the vast problems that it causes when it's wrong.
- throwawaykf05 12y ago