9 ms·
Is There Enough Meat for Everyone?
- platz 12y agoNo
- Rockslide 12y agotl;dr: no (at least not at the moment): > Returning to the question at hand — how can we make enough meat without destroying the planet? — one solution would be to ask the biggest carnivores Americans and others) to cut back, by as much as half. [...] > But there are reasons to be optimistic. For one thing, the world’s appetite for meat may eventually level off. [...] I also believe that innovation will improve our ability to produce meat. Cheaper energy and better crop varieties will drive up agricultural productivity, especially in Africa, so we won’t have to choose as often between feeding animals and feeding people.
- msandford 12y agoJoel Salatin is one of the first people that comes to mind after reading the article. He might not rub you the right way (as he's an evangelical Christian, etc) but he sure does seem to have some interesting ideas about raising cattle in a natural way that's also highly productive. His way of farming seems to be about 4x as land efficient as his neighbors (if you believe him, I tend to) which is a big deal. It also seems to be relatively low input (not buying lots of feed) and low capital; he uses mostly cheap electric fence. If I sound like a fanboy it's because I'm leaning that way. It really feels like he's "hacking" farming and I have a big appreciation for that. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mjzvtM-Wo4c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mjzvtM-Wo4c
- m_coder 12y agoHe isn't done 'hacking' either. He brings younger people to teach them what he knows and to learn from them and their ideas.
- have_humility 12y agoA BBC Horizons documentary with subtitle "How to Feed the Planet" (popsci--I'm aware) was posted to reddit a few months ago. The conclusion, IIRC, suggested that even the best hacks in beef farming don't hold a candle when compared to approaches that lean more heavily towards transitioning away from beef to other types of meat, especially chicken.
- msandford 12y agoCattle have a FCR of between 5 and 20 or so. Chickens more like 2ish. If beef is bad because it takes 20 units of food to make one unit of beef and you have a way to make 4x the units of food per acre, then your effective FCR (relative to traditional methods) drops from 20 (at the worst) to 5. If it was at 5 then your effective FCR could be as low as 1.25 If it was more in the middle at say 10ish then the effective FCR could be at 2.5 which is pretty respectable. This is made better because you're also getting eggs from the sanitizing chickens and meat from the broiling chickens that are all making multiple passes over the same land at different times. This is of course predicated on grass fed beef with the farmer taking a substantial interest in raising as much grass as possible (sanitizing chickens and paddock system). It's not a lot of work, but it does take more effort than just throwing grain at cows in a feedlot.
- have_humility 12y agoI don't know what a sanitizing chicken is, and apparently neither does Google. I assume from context it means chickens bred to lay eggs?
- msandford 12y agoIn this case it's chickens which get carted around a few days behind the cows. Cows eat grass. Cows poop on field. Flies lay eggs in poop. Eggs hatch into maggots, which eat poop. Chickens dig through poop looking for maggots. This spreads the poop out and gives the chickens an excellent source of protein. Cow poop is actually a good fertilizer for grass, but it's too concentrated normally. The chickens spread it out to a more reasonable concentration and produce eggs in the process.
- Inception 12y agoI am also a big fan of Salatin, though I'm not convinced his method is the answer to our problem. Not because I don't think it works, but rather because his approach doesn't currently fit into our food system. He has stated that he has no intention of scaling up and only sells to consumers in his region. This means that we would need thousands more operations like his to meet our current demand and I just don't see that happening. There aren't enough incentives for farmers to make the switch and I feel confident saying that Salatin's approach requires a lot more work than most of our farmers are used to these days. Not to mention we live in a society that demands fast, cheap, convenient food. It's easier to walk down the street to Whole Foods than it is to find a local farm in your area, figure out what's in season, and then figure out how to obtain it. Whole Foods isn't even cheap by most people's standards and buying directly from a local farm is going to be even more expensive. Don't get me wrong, I would love to see the food system return to local communities! I just don't think society is willing to change...yet. On the other hand, gardens seem like they would be much easier to integrate into society today. We can obtain far more calories per acre growing food than we can raising it and most people have the capacity and space to grow something, e.g., window sills, rooftops, backyards, empty lots, etc. This still doesn't really get around the problem though because it doesn't address the demand for meat. I have and will continue to advocate in favor of reducing demand. This seems like the most logical choice given our current situation. EDIT: Just wanted to add: Support local farms!!
- msandford 12y agoThe way I read it is that he's not trying to become a mega-corp. I suspect that he knows that's the fastest way to ruin what he's doing; getting big would mean that the company grows faster than the culture and new folks might be tempted to cut corners, etc. I also think he's more interested in seeing thousands of independent farmers have some control over their own destiny rather than getting caught up in the commercial debt cycle that a lot of them tend to. You wouldn't need all the farmers in the US to convert to his methods, since he's far more productive per acre you could have 1/4 of the acreage (and presumably 1/4 of the farmers) that are used in conventional farming and still produce the same output. Given that he uses very little in the way of inputs and sells higher priced outputs (free range chickens, grass fed beef, etc) it's entirely likely that he's far more profitable than traditional farms. That kind of competitive advantage might make it possible for start-up farms to grow and slowly buy out retiring farmers so that no tremendous upheaval is necessary for new ideas to become the norm.
- dbg31415 12y agoThis was good, thanks for posting.
- jasonisalive 12y agoAs usual, Gates gets the true problem completely wrong. The real issue here are the numerous and significant unpriced economic externalities associated with animal flesh production, whose impact is rendered enormous by the scale of this industry. Animal rearing produces a major portion of global greenhouse gases, rivers of faeces, pollutes waterways and overtaxes water resources, not because of a lack of capacity to technologically innovate cleaner solutions, but because collective interests in these resources are not being properly acknowledged and protected through the negotiation and enforcement of pricing. This is a classic economic problem. Bill Gates does the issue no favours with his starry-eyed techno-optimism or his attempts depict food supply as a selfless global communal endeavour. No, food supply is a market of profit-seeking individuals using their resources to generate goods considered valuable enough to trade by other individuals. There is simply an overproduction of these goods because they are being sold without their externalised costs being factored in. Food producers can make their products too cheaply, so too many are made. Tackle the pricing problem and technological development to minimise environmental impacts will naturally emerge. Absent this step, efforts to develop and promulgate technological improvements will never get far.
- codeulike 12y agoThese satellite pictures of the waste lagoons from feedlots that went round last year are pretty scary http://www.wired.co.uk/magazine/archive/2014/05/start/meat-machine/viewgallery/334019 http://www.wired.co.uk/magazine/archive/2014/05/start/meat-m...
- bryanlarsen 12y agoThis is of course not unique to animal farming. Where I grew up animal farming is much more environmentally friendly than grain farming. It uses green water and native prairie, without chemical use or plowing. (Plowing is generally much more environmentally destructive than chemical use). In Saskatchewan, higher pricing of externalities would increase animal production, not lower it.
- sleepyhead 12y ago> Where I grew up Well that is the problem here. Farming has changed. Particularly so in America. A handful slaughterhouses, heavy corn use, chemically power washed eggs, all within a framework that is made for economical returns and not animal welfare or taste. And it is not a US-only problem. Denmark for example is facing huge issues with pig farming and here in Norway we are seeing problems with use of antibiotics in chickens.
- sehugg 12y agoThe article briefly touches on this, but substituting more efficient (< 2 to 1 conversion ratio) meats like chicken and farmed fish seems like a good idea. The high price of beef right now certainly has changed my shopping habits, and I can't say I really miss it -- nor do other Americans according to some sources[1]. p.s. take chicken drumsticks, pat dry, salt and pepper, iron skillet for 1 hour at 450 :) [1] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/01/02/chicken-vs-beef_n_4525366.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/01/02/chicken-vs-beef_n_4...
- GordonS 12y agoNot sure where you are, but it's the same story in the UK. I rarely eat beef or lamb nowadays just because it's so expensive, and instead eat more chicken, pork and local game.
- pjc50 12y agoIn the UK it's really noticeable how beef has shot up in price, chicken is starting to climb a price/quality tradeoff (cheap mystery chicken is everywhere, nice standalone chicken breast quite pricey), and pork is still cheap. Lamb I'm less interested in but is all imported from NZ anyway. Venison is becoming a thing. Ostrich didn't, to the disappointment of a number of early investors.
- have_humility 12y agoTry going with whole chicken and separating the pieces yourself. You can even throw it into a slow cooker completely frozen if you're lazy. The downside is the time it takes to do the separation, but I've found that in aggregate it's actually a marked convenience, even compared to buying already separated chicken breasts. 1 whole chicken = 8 meals for me, and prepping it only takes about half an hour. Last year I essentially switched to chicken as my only meat source for meals eaten at home, mostly by default. I sort of ditched that around Christmas after becoming bored of it, but I've found that after doing 1 hour of prep time (half an hour for chicken, half an hour for packing salads) twice a week with the whole chicken approach, it's hard to go back spending 1-2 hours a day in the kitchen, 5-7 days a week--which is a routine I managed for years up until then.
- sremani 12y agoThe way the US society discourages vegetarianism (even for people who a traditionally vegetarian) is mind boggling. When you ask for a vegetarian option, one would be lucky if he does not get stared like a space alien, esp. in the country.
- jasonisalive 12y agoTry veganism, it's life on Hard Mode.
- nate_meurer 12y agoOh, it's not that bad :) I would call it "very deliberate mode".
- jasonisalive 12y agoTried travelling in a third-world country where you don't speak the language?
- fweespeech 12y agoMy gf is a vegetarian and she has never had that problem...? We do live in a big city tho.
- fennecfoxen 12y agoEh. Blame the FDR administration: the US's institutionalized focus on standardization, commoditization, and industrialized processing above all other facets of agriculture (like nutrition and taste) has left us with a glut of bland vegetables that no one really wants to eat.
- ElijahLynn 12y agoThis is starting to change but yeah, it is saddening how many people think you need meat to survive and grow. Bill Gates left his intelligence behind on this one. All protein on this planet was created by plants via photosynthesis.
- GordonS 12y agoAnother issue is what parts of the animal we eat or don't eat. At least here in the UK, many wouldn't touch liver, heart, kidneys etc with a barge pole, despite never having even tried them. While offal has gained ground in restaurants in recent years, it's still absent from most homes. Offal makes up a decent chunk[1] of cattle and pigs, and fresh, well cooked offal is a delicious thing. There should be more effort by the meat industry to persuade people to try it. [1] http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/147867/ldpm20901.pdf http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/147867/ldpm20901.pdf
- gadders 12y agoA lot of UK farmers are now shipping offal (or the "5th quarter") to other locations such as China and the Middle East. So a lot does get eaten, even if not locally. Source for this is Farming Today podcast on Radio 4.
- Nursie 12y ago>> At least here in the UK, many wouldn't touch liver, heart, kidneys etc with a barge pole, despite never having even tried them. Really? I thought we were pretty good about liver (on its own or in pate) kidneys (steak and kidney pie). Plus black pudding and haggis kinda need offal. Compared to the USA where people universally seem to think black pudding is made of blood and disgusting* . I guess with the exception of cajun Boudin Noir... I thought we were pretty good. (*they're wrong, it's made of blood and delicious!)
- MrDosu 12y agoA personal experience I have made in trying to live off the land a few times autonomously is that it is quite sustainable when you are hunting animals. When you rely solely on plants you need to roam HUGE swatches of land in comparison and extract almost all of the plants you find.
- have_humility 12y agoWhat are the numbers on the chart in the linked page supposed to mean? Average meat consumption per capita per year, organized by country? And the bigger question: how do this kinds of charts keep getting made, and how do articles that otherwise make no hint at their own charts' existence keep being published?
- diego_moita 12y agoIt is a good question. I think it refers to carcass per person. This means that they're counting the weight of non-eaten tissue (bones, skin, intestines, brains, etc). The chart sounds odd to me. I am Brazilian and I know that Argentinians and Uruguayans consume a lot more meat than us, I believe even more than the Americans. When it comes to non-carcass, edible meat only we are at 37 kg per person/year. The Uruguayans are at 60 kg.
- rboyd 12y agoI'm grateful Gates and others are funding meat alternatives. He briefly touched on the ethical issues (by proxy), but we hardly ever do here on HN. I remember in 2011 Zuckerberg resolved to only eat meat that he killed himself. I think more people ought to try that. I know I wouldn't be able to hunt and slaughter my own food, and I respect people that do much more than the status quo of outsourcing animal murder. It's pretty hypocritical of this society to elect ~4 species of animals that we endorse killing. But we think about eating dog or dolphin and rageface.
- beat 12y agoOh, if people get hungry enough, they'll eat dogs and dolphins, all right. At the end of WWII, rats had been exterminated in Berlin. That was all there was to eat.
- gadders 12y agoI invited my 93 year old gran to a barbecue (she's 97 now) and asked her if there is anything she doesn't eat or wouldn't like. Gran: Whale meat Me: Er, OK. I can do that. Gran: We had it during the war on rationing. You didn't know if you were eating meaty fish or fishy meat.
- gadders 12y agoI love meat. My neighbours have cows and sheep and pigs and I own chickens. I've been up close with all those animals and they're pretty cool in their own way. I sometimes thing that if meat could be grown in a lab and animals didn't have to die, I'd be happy with that. But then I realise that arsehole food scientists from somewhere like Kraft would get hold of it and ruin it.
- beat 12y agoA basic vegetarian argument is that meat is inefficient compared to grain, and there just isn't enough resource. But if this were true, then older cultures with far less resources would never have wasted food on raising meat. Clearly, they did. Animals are a way of turning inedible things into edible things. Grass? Well, you could till it all, or just turn sheep and cattle loose on it. Grain hulls? Throw them away, or feed them to the chickens. Spoiled garbage? Pigs will eat it. For as long as we've farmed, animals have increased rather than decreased the food supply.
- pdx 12y agoExactly. I grew up on cattle ranches in Montana and Wyoming. The short growing season, rocky soil, and dry conditions would make any attempt at farming laughable, but the cattle did just fine. Driving them into the high mountains for summer grazing allowed the mountain grass to also be converted to beef. None of that land was appropriate to farming, which means that any beef grown there is extra food for the planet. What always amazes me about capitalism is how it often manages to allocate resources efficiently. Nobody is raising large cattle herds down in farm country. Land that can be farmed is generally farmed, because that provides the best return. Land that can't be farmed, is ranched. This idea that you have to give up farming to have meat doesn't take this into account.
- beat 12y agoThis doesn't mean corn-fed meat isn't wasteful, of course. But it does mean that meat itself isn't the cause of hunger elsewhere.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoIf it is wasteful, I wonder how much is caused by corn subsidies.
- astazangasta 12y agoYes, it does. You just don't realize that we've used up all available pasture land.
- shusain 12y agoLike carbon caps, governments could introduce meat production limits if none of the other solutions pan out.
- gadders 12y agoThere is also this company: http://motherboard.vice.com/blog/silicon-valleys-fake-eggs-are-better-than-the-real-thing http://motherboard.vice.com/blog/silicon-valleys-fake-eggs-a... that is planning to create synthetic eggs (even though eggs are pretty much are the perfect food).