3 ms·
Where is the overwhelming evidence that customers want a different method of payment?
by kasey_junk 12y ago
Where is the overwhelming evidence that customers want a different method of payment?
- amelius 12y agoThey will want it when they find out that they are paying a hidden fee that is being passed on by the retailer.
- kissickas 12y agoI would bet that at least 90% of Costco shoppers know about that "hidden" fee - the higher AmEx fee is the reason those cards aren't accepted at a lot of other, especially smaller, businesses. Beyond that, plenty of businesses are cash-only. It's not because they can't afford the machine.
- lambdaelite 12y agoThat fee covers insurance and other benefits on the card, and with the benefits, you can break even (e.g, I get 2.2% cash back, which offsets the increase the retailer adds to cover interchange). Are you suggesting people don't want the benefits? Also, re your OP, Costco sells far more than just groceries.
- amelius 12y agoYes, people typically don't want to buy their products "bundled".
- lambdaelite 12y agoFor cable, yes, but I don't see how "bundling" applies to credit cards. That credit card companies compete on benefits would also seem to argue against your point. AmEx tried doing a piecemeal benefits program on their Zync card, but AFAIK the product uptake was poor and they no longer offer it.
- kasey_junk 12y agoAs opposed to? Any system of exchange has transaction costs. Even cash does, to the point that many businesses prefer credit card transactions (fees and all) to cash ones. Being able to lower the transaction cost is advantageous to the entire ecosystem, but as an individual consumer it needs to offer more than an altruistic benefit. Right now credit cards are pretty great for consumers (assuming they can handle the budget discipline required for their use). Virtually free 30 day credit, consolidated purchasing, and fraud protection will be very hard to replicate with any other transactional system. The insurance angle is a red herring. I've never used it in my life, and the credit card companies offer it because it is essentially free to offer due to the systems they have to put in place for fraud/credit risk.
- jbuzbee 12y agoRegarding the insurance, I tried to use it once when my daughter dropped a new cell-phone in the water. A quick read of the credit-card insurance promo looked promising, but once we called and talked to a very nice customer-service rep for the insurance service, it quickly became clear that there were tons of fine-print that justified the insurance not covering this situation.
- needusername 12y agoYou can (and we do) run a locally issued debit card system with no interchange, a total annual fee to card holder of 20 to 30 bucks and a cost to the merchant that is at least an order of magnitude lower than credit cards.
- kasey_junk 12y agoOf course you can make trade offs on feature/functionality to change what the transaction costs are. Who said you couldn't? The idea was that consumers were unhappy with credit cards. I haven't seen that. And your system sounds like a poor trade off for my use cases. It is several hundreds of dollars more expensive to me explicitly (based on card rebates on a zero fee card) and is not accepted at as many places.
- 12y ago