5 ms·
> We used to make fun of the Soviet Union for its lack of freedom of travel ("papers please"). You only need ID not pre-authorization. You don't have to get Id
by MBCook 12y ago
> We used to make fun of the Soviet Union for its lack of freedom of travel ("papers please").
You only need ID not pre-authorization. You don't have to get Idaho to authorize your vacation and Nebraska to allow you transit.
- eternalban 12y agoA journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step ...
- andrewguenther 12y agoAnd then you slide down the slippery slope?
- eternalban 12y agoHere is how one such journey ended. [1] That handsome devil is the person quoted in GP. [1]: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/6a/ForbiddenCity_MaoZedongPortrait_(pixinn.net).jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/6a/Forbidden...
- dragonwriter 12y ago> You only need ID not pre-authorization. To the extent the federal government requires valid state-issued ID for travel but neither mandates states to issue ID nor prohibits states from rescinding IDs that they have issued, you in effect do need pre-authorization, even if the actual pre-authorization regime is fairly light touch, granted by default for long terms without specific travel plans, and rarely revoked.
- eli 12y agoI've heard of states revoking your ability to drive, but not your ability to have a State ID. What's an example of that? (That said, I agree that if IDs are going to be required for voting, travel, etc then they should be free to acquire.)
- Rapzid 12y agoThe federal government does not require valid state-issued ID.
- smackfu 12y agoAnd the US is actually pretty good about not requiring you to always have Federal ID on you, compared to European countries.
- lettergram 12y agoI find it strange compare the laws of a state to others and say things like, "It's pretty good compared to..." They are different government types, founded on different laws, containing different people, and so on. The United States was founded on the idea of "freedom" so, it seems strange to require anything on you, unless it impedes others freedoms.
- bgilroy26 12y agoIf you found a nation on an idea, the specifics of the idea are going to be hammered out. Both the idea of "freedom" and the idea of impeding others' freedoms have been specified in US legislation and in the case history of the US court system. Without going through and clarifying what freedom and impeding freedom mean in different situations, the US economy could not exist at its present size. Investors can be confident that life will go smoothly based on the US Government. That's what powers the US Treasury, which powers low interest rates, which powers our economy.
- krschultz 12y agoTechnically the US was founded on that ideal, then the Articles of Confederation was seen to be unworkable, so they federalized a bunch of power in the Constitution, which was then amended with the original Bill of Rights because the Constitution without didn't really guarantee freedom. It's important to not hand waive away that evolution, because the US is not run on the most-free system of government that could have been imagined in 1776. We ratcheted that down almost immediately, and to argue otherwise is incorrect.
- Frondo 12y agoI can't see how the US was founded on that idea of "freedom unless it impedes others freedoms," since, at its most basic level, the US government has always restricted people's movements. If you "own" property, I can't freely walk onto that property. Your "ownership" places a severe limitation on my ability to exercise the freedom to move about freely. It seems specious to claim retroactively that the US somehow cares about freedom at all, when some of the most basic were stripped from us at its founding.
- toddmatthews 12y agoalso, "papers please" was a German thing AFAIK
- fit2rule 12y agoIts not much of a German thing any more, precisely because the Germans seem to have an awareness for just how ridiculous things can get, whereas Americans seem instead to just be fine with the ridiculousness..
- mikeash 12y agoRussia has a long history of requiring internal passports to travel, including the USSR but existing both before and after.
- fit2rule 12y agoID is a form of authorization. There are plenty of people who can not get a valid ID in the United States, yet they wish to travel too. So, they walk.
- senorprogrammer 12y agoThat seems like quite a bit 'only'.