13 ms·
China's Great Cannon
- jonawesomegreen 12y agoI hope that this drives home the need to be using HTTPS everywhere we can be. It would make this kind of wide scale man-in-the-middle attack much harder to pull off and easier for users to detect. If only getting a certificate was an easier (less costly) process.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoWell, they sometimes block HTTPS traffic; e.g. for Wikipedia (even just wikimedia right now).
- jonawesomegreen 12y agoWould they be able to block HTTPS traffic if it effectively meant that they were blocking the internet though? I think people would have a bigger problem with that.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoIf all websites went https, they would try to block everything, definitely.
- leereeves 12y agoWhen considering the effectiveness of HTTPS everywhere, we should assume the Chinese government will have the ability to create valid certificates. This would allow them to perform MITM attacks against anyone who visits Chinese websites, even with HTTPS.
- kpcyrd 12y agoThey need to sign those certs with a CA. If they do this, they create a cryptographic proof that they're abusing their trust and are removed from the trust store quickly.
- leereeves 12y agoIn fact that happened about a week ago: http://arstechnica.com/security/2015/04/google-chrome-will-banish-chinese-certificate-authority-for-breach-of-trust/ http://arstechnica.com/security/2015/04/google-chrome-will-b... But if China chose to, they could simply require all Chinese websites to use government-issue certificates, forcing the world to choose between allowing Chinese MITM monitoring and losing access to China.
- acdha 12y ago> But if China chose to, they could simply require all Chinese websites to use government-issue certificates, forcing the world to choose between allowing Chinese MITM monitoring and losing access to China. The more likely outcome of that gambit would just be that the CA would be restricted to .cn domains, possibly with some sort of install-on-demand warning.
- nitrogen 12y agoThat would not necessarily prevent attacks like the GitHub attack, which used embedded analytics JS from Baidu, IIRC.
- acdha 12y agoActually, it would have stopped this particular variant because Baidu serves the script from baidu.com: http://www.netresec.com/?page=Blog&month=2015-03&post=China%27s-Man-on-the-Side-Attack-on-GitHub http://www.netresec.com/?page=Blog&month=2015-03&post=China%... That said, it would only matter if Baidu was doing something like serving the script only over HTTPS using HSTS which I imagine would incur a non-trivial backlash for them. I'd also be surprised if they couldn't relatively easily move on to another similarly insecure script requested by many people outside of China.
- leereeves 12y ago> The more likely outcome of that gambit would just be that the CA would be restricted to .cn domains, possibly with some sort of install-on-demand warning. A reasonable compromise, but one which wouldn't prevent MITM snooping or alteration of communications with Chinese websites, like this attack. And to allow snooping of outgoing communications, the Chinese could also require that all browsers used in China trust the Chinese government CA without that restriction.
- NelsonMinar 12y agoCoincidentally, Google Chrome and Firefox recently blocked a Chinese root authority from issuing SSL certificates. (AFAIK, the only default Chinese authoirty). The stated reason has nothing to do with censorship attacks, but it is an interesting coincidence. http://arstechnica.com/security/2015/04/google-chrome-will-banish-chinese-certificate-authority-for-breach-of-trust/ http://arstechnica.com/security/2015/04/google-chrome-will-b...
- JoachimS 12y agoRemember to remove Chinese CAs from the Trust Stores in the OS and browser. Unfortunately this is not very easy in some cases. And next update might add them back again. We really need better Trust Store management as a user. We should be allowed to define what CAs _we_ trust.
- Sanddancer 12y agoWhich underscores the need to use additional authentication measures like DANE [1] and key pinning. Making it harder for malicious entities to wriggle their way into connections seems vital here. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNS-based_Authentication_of_Named_Entities http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNS-based_Authentication_of_Nam...
- zimbatm 12y agoJust installed little snitch. Almost every app on my mac is trying to access some resource on the web, most of them over port 80 or a mix-and-match of both 80 and 443. And then the OS itself has a variety of services that does the same. My computer is like a beacon of light that shines it's position and personal information to everybody.
- alphapapa 12y agoMore than that, it drives home the need to disable JavaScript by default. To do otherwise is inviting every web site you visit (and every third-party site they load content from, and everyone who can compromise either) to run arbitrary code on your system. And it drives home the stupidity of sites which demand JavaScript to view even simple content which could just as well be static.
- mark_l_watson 12y agoI totally agree. I started using Cloudflare's free service to add HTTPS support to my most important sites. I have some concerns about routing my traffic through another company, but free is free and I really think people need to transition to HTTPS everywhere.
- jgrahamc 12y agoState level injection is not new. Prior to the Tunisian revolution this was happening on HTTP Facebook pages: http://blog.jgc.org/2011/01/code-injected-to-steal-passwords-in.html http://blog.jgc.org/2011/01/code-injected-to-steal-passwords... HTTPS everything.
- acdha 12y agoI think the big difference here is that it's being used to launch attacks outside of the country. For too many years, the assumption was that these large scale attacks either didn't happen or were only limited to people already subject to a particular government. > HTTPS everything … and with HSTS, too
- alphapapa 12y agoAnd disable JavaScript. And complain loudly to any site that requires it when it doesn't really need to. That would eliminate 99.99% of the attack vector for injected payloads.
- jmnicolas 12y agoFor a long time I wondered why China was using censorship against outside information. I thought it was inefficient and probably useless, what they had to fear ? Then I discovered that "color revolutions" were not happening by chance and that it was a CIA "technology" to remove an unwanted leader from a target country. Now I understand why they use censorship. I still think they'd better educate their people (like the Russians seem to do) though. Whatever wall you build there will always be cracks.
- guelo 12y agoAre you sure the Russian education is not propaganda lies?
- jmnicolas 12y agoPropaganda is by definition a lie. I meant they were educating them about "color revolutions" and that it was certainly better than just censoring the ideas that bring color revolutions.
- guelo 12y agoI do not know if the CIA was involved in the color revolutions but why would you trust what the Kremlin says? Do you believe the Kremlin has no interest in propaganda?
- Crito 12y ago> "Propaganda is by definition a lie." Not even close to true. Propaganda can be lies. It can also be half-truths, carefully selected truths, or even full truths (should those truths put the organization issuing the propaganda in a good light). It can also be completely void of assertions (be they lies or truth) and contain nothing but emotional content. Humour is frequently used in modern propaganda. Funny internet videos that make fun of nations or their leaders, without actually making any sort of claim about them. Humour used as propaganda is particularly effective because anybody who argues against it will be told "Relax, it's just a joke. Stop taking it so seriously."
- 12y ago
- sarciszewski 12y agoThe Great Cannon is basically a proprietary WebLOIC, which of course means Web-based Low Orbit Ion Cannon. You may have heard of LOIC; a DDoS tool being used by script kiddies and activists for the past 4 or so years. "Powerful New Weapon"? Pure clickbait. Playing catch-up with Anonymous is neither new nor powerful.
- TorKlingberg 12y agoThe new part is MitM:ing a popular site to use unsuspecting peoples computers in the attack.
- sarciszewski 12y agoWatering hole attacks and MitM aren't really new either. I know people who used hacked sites to drop slowloris.js payloads to coordinate "Anonymous-related" attacks. (Not really Anonymous related; quotes are sarcasm.)
- fweespeech 12y agoYeah, the only new part is the scale it operates on since it can MitM any site in an entire country and use legal means to guarantee its access.
- sarciszewski 12y agoYep. Using legal means to maintain a privileged position to do malicious things to the rest of the Internet is an innovation that few can enact.
- borgia 12y agoIt is and it isn't powerful. I was pretty impressed by how they attacked GitHub (not why) and in doing so they showed the power of the tool. However, the requests it made could have easily been turned back against Chinese business if Github so wanted. It couldn't be done because there was no reasonable who to turn the traffic back against. If non-Chinese companies simply said "If China uses these tools we will redirect the traffic at a number of large Chinese businesses" then a lot of the power in the tool is immediately withdrawn. At least that's my interpretation of it.
- fweespeech 12y agoYeah, if GitHub had used a 301 Moved Permanently to some Chinese website I think it would have been interesting [rather than responding with the alert message]....however that probably would be deemed "attacking" someone.
- Fuxy 12y agoNot really it's technically deflecting the attack back at your opponent just like martial arts. I would more likely call it active defense. :) Note: Journalists whil always go for the sensational that's no reason not to do it.
- fweespeech 12y agoDo you honestly believe that is how the average journalist would report it and the general population would perceive it? 'cause I immediately see headlines like: "Github hacks China over censorship!"
- samiam1 12y agoIt would've been interesting if they had made the 301 point back to Baidu.
- Sanddancer 12y agoWhile fun, it almost certainly would have resulted in China moving to the Syn flood stage faster. That being said, I'm always a fan of the classics, and would have probably gone for a redirect to goatse or the like. Given that the script was giving github full control of the page, a bit of shock and awe would have been rather fun.
- wsxcde 12y ago> We remain puzzled as to why the GC’s operator chose to first employ its capabilities in such a publicly visible fashion. This is the most important question here. I think it's fair to assume this must've been a deliberate choice by the Chinese authorities to conduct such a visible attack. The alternative, that they didn't realize what they were getting into, that they thought Github would cave quickly, seems much to simplistic and naive. And whatever else you can say about the Chinese government, you can't accuse them of being naive. If you believe this was deliberate attack, it seems this is a parade demonstrating electronic warfare abilities. The message being sent seems to be, "don't mess with us, we can do everything you can do and possibly more."
- vinceguidry 12y agoIt may not be as big and publicly visible as we think. Big would be targeting a stock exchange. Thinking at the nation-state level, Github is small potatoes. Who is going to know or care outside of the tech sector?
- ddoolin 12y agoAgreed. At only 1.75% of traffic, my guess is that they could pack a much bigger punch if they wanted to.
- moe 12y agoIt's not something they could do very often. Every time they do such they risk having one of their most important commercial sites (Baidu, QQ, TaoBao) null-routed by the rest of the world. That's not exactly a long-term strategy.
- stingraycharles 12y agoHonest question: why would China care if Baidu is null-routed by the rest of the world?
- T-A 12y ago
- ddoolin 12y agoWhy would China only swap scripts for users OUTSIDE China? And why only 1.75% of the time? If they're willing to do this level of `cyber warfare`, why stop at it's own citizenry, or cap it at a number like that?
- grey-area 12y agoPerhaps just an experiment. I doubt this greatfire thing really matters to them, but it'd be a great way to test offensive capability and mitigation strategies without provoking a serious response.
- acdha 12y agoIn this case, the goal was to attack GitHub. If you only use clients in one country, the target would have the option of simply having their edge routers drop traffic from the entire country. Using international clients removes that option and likely makes the attack more successful because it generates more traffic closer to the target.
- toyg 12y ago1) This is the first time they publicly use it, part of the objective was probably to gauge world reaction. Dropping an atomic bomb on a fishing village is different from sending a few gunmen to that same village. 2) the limitation to external users might be a technical requirement (i.e. where traffic can actually be intercepted) or it might be a political choice to allow for deniability in front of internal public opinion.
- EthanHeilman 12y agoIf China is responsible for this, it shows extreme recklessness on their part, a deep disrespect for the rule of law and the customs of the internet. The people in the chain of command responsible for this should be held criminally liable. The lack of sophistication, ineffectiveness, and bluntness of the attack speaks toward a fundamental capability gap between China and the other "cyberpowers".
- xnull6guest 12y agoThere is no rule of law of customs of the internet, however. That's been the big push for the last decade within the US: to develop an international norms framework for the internet. The problem is that many of the activities being performed by China, Russia, France, Germany, the UK, Israel, Canada, the US, etc are being performed by others - it's difficult for us to condemn China without equally condemning the others. (Those wanting to argue a straw man will suggest that the technical details of this attack are somehow above and beyond the pale of what other nations are known to do and make their argument about js injection.) It's true that China is much more crass and less developed in their cyber capability. It isn't that much less effective however.
- rwallace 12y agoAnd that is one of the reasons it would be a good idea for the US and other Western countries to dial down some of their more aggressive actions: those actions set precedence that encourage other countries like China to match the escalation.
- cpncrunch 12y agoThere does seem to be a difference, though. The US monitors communications, adds backdoors to infrastructure to monitor communications, and injects malware into Iranian nuclear reactors that could be used to make weapons. China, on the other hand, deliberately attacks anyone who criticises their government. In the US you are perfectly free to say the government are a bunch of fuckwits who should be kicked out of office, if that is your opinion. I'm not necessarily saying that what the US does is legal or morally acceptable, just that it is more morally acceptable than what China does. It's like the difference between a private investigator illegally breaking into someone's house to gather information, and a gangster going in and shooting everyone.
- xiaq 12y agoAn irrelevant rant, but the map of China looks really, really ugly without the two southern islands, Hainan and Taiwan. It looks like a rooster without legs. At the very least, include Hainan, over which China's sovereign rights are in no way disputed. And for aesthetics and political honesty, show Taiwan in grey.
- pjc50 12y agoTaiwan is a separate country and has been for many years. Both the assertions of the PRC over Taiwan and ROC over the mainland are ridiculous.
- moe 12y agoI don't like the underlying assumption in all these articles that the Chinese government was behind the attacks, as if we had proof for anything. Apart from the rather blurry technical analysis this particular article claims: In recent public statements, China has deflected questions regarding whether they are behind the attack But when you follow the actual citation[1] it refers to this rather underwhelming exchange, taken place on a chinese press conference: QUESTION: [..] a report says that a US website was under hacker attack, and the source of the attack was from China. How do you respond? ANSWER: [..] it is quite odd that every time a website in the US or any other country is under attack, there will be speculation that Chinese hackers are behind it. I'd like to remind you that China is one of the major victims of cyber attacks. [..] So the chinese press lady gave her standard boilerplate response, to a less than specific inquiry (which she probably hears on every press conference), in between handling questions about illegal fishing in Somali waters and the Arab League Summit's commitment to a joint Arab military force. And this is now "compelling evidence" for China being officially behind the Github attack? [1] http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/xwfw_665399/s2510_665401/2511_665403/t1250354.shtml http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/xwfw_665399/s2510_665401/251...
- rpedroso 12y agoThe leap to blame the Chinese government for this attack reminds me of the leap to attribute the Sony attack to North Korea. It's possible that North Korea was responsible, but the primary evidence the FBI held up was that the malware used was similar to malware used by DPRK in previous attacks. As many researchers pointed out[1], that malware has been widely available outside DPRK for years. Certain 3-letter agencies have claimed to have additional intelligence pointing towards North Korea[2], but don't go into significant detail. "We're the NSA, so just trust us" In both cases, it's possible the attack was carried out by a state actor, but I'm personally unwilling to point a finger without better evidence than what I've seen. [1] http://www.cnn.com/2014/12/27/tech/north-korea-expert-doubts-about-hack/ http://www.cnn.com/2014/12/27/tech/north-korea-expert-doubts... [2] http://recode.net/2015/01/18/how-the-u-s-knew-north-korea-was-behind-the-sony-hack/ http://recode.net/2015/01/18/how-the-u-s-knew-north-korea-wa...
- fown9 12y agoChina has an authoritarian government that produces pollution that threatens the entire world, ignores human rights and free speech, and supports dictators in Russia and Africa. If China gets anymore powerful, the world is doomed. We need to curb commerce with China.
- Lorento 12y agoReplace China with USA and see how it looks.
- wmt 12y agoMuch further from the reality. The US has huge flaws and gaping failures with these matters, but still compared to China it is objectively way less authoritan, and has a much better track record with respecting free speech and human rights.
- leereeves 12y ago> The US...has a much better track record with respecting free speech and human rights. The rights of US citizens, yes, but our track record on human rights and free speech worldwide is not so good.
- maverick2 12y agoBut when China is at par with what US has been, China's record of human rights and free speech worldwide will be much worse than that of US.
- newuser88273 12y ago...and watch China flood the US with dollars (it has a few of those, y'know?), halt all Apple smartphone production and lobby hard and successfully to finally replace the petrodollar? Maybe all-out war is not the fitting answer to what was, realistically, a tempest in a teapot.
- mike-cardwell 12y agoPretty much any country could perform this attack. The interesting thing about this, is that China thinks it can get away with openly attacking foreign companies. And it might even be right about that. Anyone remember what happened when North Korea attacked Sony? Where are the sanctions this time?
- cinskiy 12y agoAFAICR there is still no evidence that North Korea attacked Sony, but everybody seems to think they did.
- xnull6guest 12y agoThere's tons of evidence that NK attacked SONY and the reason they did it was revealed when the Guardians of Peace leaked the Lynton emails.
- newuser88273 12y agoTo play devil's advocate: If you had the choice between identifying all domestic users of GFW circumvention tools, rounding them up, and shooting them, or attacking some of the foreign devil peddlers of such tools, which is the more humanitarian and mild measure? Edit: I'll try to make this a little clearer. Consider that many of the most free and civilized countries you know will identify, round up and harshly punish consumers of child pornography. Imagine a China (or another state of your choice) that sets its mind to providing the deprived and opressed western masses with as much child pornography as they can download. Is the West's only admissible choice to dutifully round up and punish its own citizens? Is it clearer now?
- joncp 12y agoSo you're comparing access to child pornography with access to news?
- newuser88273 12y agoYou were supposed to compare --- not the forbidden things AS SUCH, but (a) the abstract fact that they're illegal, composed with (b) SANE ways your OWN country can react to the fact of a NON-FRIENDLY FOREIGN power engages in ENABLING, ENCOURAGING and ENTICING your own citizens to breach same law. To give yet another example: At some point in time, exporting an 128 bit symmetrical block cypher from the US may have been grounds for punishing you, the perp. Let's counterfactually assume that China was successfully propagandizing tens of thousands of US citizens about both the ridicoulousness and the anti-freedomness of this law. Assume that thusly propagandized US citizens resisted and breached the law. Again: Would you prefer that the US, assumed to be quite aware of the Chinese efforts, would have identified, rounded up and harshly punished US citizens having exported "munitions" in the form of 128 bit symmetrical block cyphers after having been successfully turned against perfectly patriotic (even if misguided) US policy by non-friendly Chinese propaganda, while completely not doing ANYTHING to stop that propaganda, even though PROVEN to put US CITIZENS IN JAIL??
- eyeareque 12y agoIs it too late for http2 to require encryption by default?
- amaranth 12y agoAccording to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTTP/2#Encryption http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTTP/2#Encryption and the browser support section this is already the case, at least for server<->browser communication. If unencrypted HTTP/2 gets any use at all it will only be for server<->server communication (RPC and such).
- ddlatham 12y agoI mentioned this as a reply in the other thread on this topic, but just to make sure it is clear to those who may not have read or reasoned about the full report: The reason it is powerful is not this particular attack. It's a demonstration that they are willing and able to inject malicious responses to any request going to a Chinese resource (web site, analytics service, ads, etc.). Imagine if instead of returning some DoS javascript they deliver a payload to silently exploit a vulnerability in your browser/OS (and they are surely capable of finding or purchasing those) to do whatever they want with it: - Add it to a botnet - Steal your personal data - Infiltrate your corporate network - Wipe your system (punishment for those accessing or producing GFW circumvention software) Are you confident your browser never makes HTTP requests to Chinese servers? Are there tools we can install to prevent it? [EDIT: It looks like two separate HN stories got merged, and the comments along with them. Didn't know that could happen, but this comment now appears twice here at different places.]
- pdkl95 12y ago> Imagine if instead of returning some DoS javascript they deliver a payload to silently exploit a vulnerability It would be foolish to imagine that this is still theoretical. Tools this powerful are tempting to use. Unfortunately, the first publicly known use of a tool or method is often assumed to be the use in general. Not only are you correct in that the GFW will be used for much smaller attacks that will probably go unnoticed, it almost certainly already has.
- classicsnoot 12y agoPeople talk of boycotting china's products, but has there ever been a real discussion about refusing to sell products in China? With the growing desire for western/external goods, cutting off the Chinese people's access to our[sic] trinkets and stuff might put real pressure on the State to back off on censorship and HRVs to forestall any popular movement...
- maverick2 12y agoExactly, if we can root people to become vegan, oragnic and not by fur etc. Why not have campaigns to not support products made by countries with oppressive governments.
- borgia 12y ago>Why not have campaigns to not support products made by countries with oppressive governments. Nobody cares. It's over there, it's not something we need to worry about. It's not like the working conditions of those making our clothes, those making our smartphones, those pulling the materials for our electronics from the earth, etc. aren't unknown. They're very well known. We know damn well that there's children sewing together our shoes. We know that the people making our smart technology products are so miserable that their offices have anti-suicide nets in place around the building and throughout the stairwells. We know this stuff and we don't care. We want our products and we want them as cheap as possible. The shareholders in these companies want the company to perform as best as they can to maximize returns, that means acting nefariously in many cases and we all know that. People do not are and they will not care. If you gave people the choice, to be made anonymously and that nobody would ever know their choice, between paying multiple times what they pay for their technology or abolishing child labour and horrible working conditions they would choose the cheaper option. Or maybe not, maybe they would choose abolishing these things in an effort to delude themselves and make themselves feel better, but when it comes time to purchase a product they will still go for the cheaper one manufactured in horrible conditions. People simply do not care so long as it is not them feeling the affects. That's the same damned reason nothing is being done about the NSA revelations, or the corporate corruption of the US government, or the torture allegations about the CIA and the list goes on.
- bkmrkr 12y agoIs citizenlab down for anyone else?
- vondur 12y agoI wonder how hard it would be to take down the Great Firewall? I'd imagine that may cause some consternation within the ruling party.
- ck2 12y agoThey did this because they have nothing to lose and can show off their technical prowess. What exactly is the world going to do - sanction them and stop buying nearly everything from their factories? I fear the US is going to seriously regret building up China with all our economic business instead of building up all of Central and South America.
- hacktavist 12y agoCrazy my friend Bill worked on this he's the one mention in the article
- jacquesm 12y agoIf this was meant as a demonstration of power it failed miserably. A nation state attacking a single corporation, and not even a very large one at that and all they managed to achieve was being blackholed in various spots and seeing their attack being consumed. Minor nuisance at best, and very much losing face, both in terms of goodwill and in terms of power. If this was officially sanctioned heads will likely roll.
- AaronFriel 12y agoOn the contrary, it sounds like this was just an initial test. It crippled GitHub for days, called into question the reliability of the service, and took a team of people to trace down the attack. And if this paper's allegations are accurate, China's government did this while only targeting less than 2% of the people who pulled down only a very small subset of scripts that will only exist on a small subset of pages. Imagine what would have happened if the Great Cannon were to inject this script into the <head> of every page?
- jacquesm 12y agoWhat will happen is simple: China will find itself in an internet black-hole.
- AaronFriel 12y agoThe problem is that from GitHub's perspective, or that of GitHub's ISP, this would do little to avert the attack. That's because the "attackers" in this case appear to be users outside of China's great firewall who have accessed a service inside of China. Consequently, it is primarily Chinese-speaking users worldwide and web services that provide Chinese language services (and would be likely to use Baidu's or another Chinese service's scripts) that end up looking like the attackers. In this case, it appears most of the requests came from Taiwan, Hong Kong, and the US. China could of course filter this further. With only 1.75% of requests being turned into DDOS attacks, they could throttle this up to ~100% and filter the IPs they target to, say, only US IP addresses. Now the attackers appear to be regular US citizens. What will you do then? Black-hole the US? Beg consumer ISPs to black-hole China?
- cooleng 12y agoIs there an addon/extension for firefox/chrome that can block all the website from China?
- lovemenot 12y agoA bit far-fetched perhaps, but could it be that this attack on Github's front-end was a mere feint for a separate attack on their back-end? If there's a repo hosted there that someone in China wanted to modify, perhaps they would use DOS as cover for a surreptitious maneuver which might otherwise get noticed. This is likely just showing my ignorance of Git, but could an attacker having sufficient compute resources to arrange a Git hash collision and having back-end access to Github, modify sources without it being noticed by the repo owner?
- JoachimS 12y agoThis is actually a very good and interesting question. It would be good if Github started to at least show signed commits and on a per repo level block non-signed commits. And Git should migrate to something better than SHA1.
- rayalez 12y agoAnother weird thing about the whole situation, besides the reasons for the attack and reasons for it failing, there's a question - why github? Seems like a weird choice for a target. Github is neutral, and githib is unambiguously good. Aren't there better targets attacking which would have at least a semi-plausible excuse? I mean attacking github is like screaming "I'm evil". Besides if you want to "demonstrate your power", github is the worst choice for that purpose. They are likely to successfully fend off the attack, yet at the same time even if China would succeed it wouldn't have much to be proud of either(country vs a small company). It's a lose-lose....
- cpncrunch 12y agoThe reason they attacked github is because github was hosting greatfire and cn-nytimes.