10 ms·
An Ex-Teacher Made a Video Game That Skewers the No Child Left Behind Act
- dba7dba 12y agoAs a parent and married to a wife who's a teacher in a public elementary school in a large school district, I can say all this talk of improving school, train teachers, etc is missing the mark. More of the responsibility rests with the parents, not with the school or teachers or administrators. Sure teachers/school matter, but not as much as the parents from my observation.
- prawn 12y agoShould tackle improving both. And it's obviously not US-specific by any stretch. If we can make it easier, cheaper and more enjoyable to teach and encourage children, it will happen more often. Same goes with food - if the bad stuff is cheaper and quicker, people will tend to eat it. Makes me wonder - has anyone built courseware for 5-15 year olds that dynamically adjusts problem topics based on the interests of the student? e.g., maths problems featuring soccer players (angles, speeds, curves, etc) or maths problems featuring rockets or whatever a kid might fancy.
- DiabloD3 12y agoI agree here. My time in high school (which largely was just a prison, for both kids in and out of special education) was full of people I met that their parents thought kids were just fire and forget. Some of them were smart kids, but they had no proper upbringing. They didn't know what to do, how to act, how to be, and the school sure as hell didn't teach them that. The school filled their head with interesting but useless facts, such as George Washington was our first President. Sure, we should know that, but that won't help us navigate the increasingly complex world that we keep building around ourselves. To put it bluntly, these kids, some of them I called my friends, had no spiritual health (or whatever you want to call it). They didn't know how to force their minds to focus, they didn't know how to prioritize their goals, they didn't know how to make goals in the first place. They did what they were told. Some of them have moved out of state and went to college (again, because they were told to, our school pounded it into our heads that we need to do well on tests to get into college, as if college was the end goal, or even a meaningful step on the journey of life), and are most likely now in debt in over their heads. Some of them probably lost their jobs, some of them probably lost their homes, some of them probably had kids and now work at shitty jobs just to keep food on the table. The ones that didn't move out of state? I know that some of them are in prison or jail somewhere (thanks, grapevine). I know some of them do drugs (some of them did drugs in high school just to deal with how shit their lives were, I doubt they quit when they got out of school; nothing hard though, virtually all of them were potheads). Teachers matter, but your first and most important teachers are your parents. You learn how to be and act through them, and if you don't learn what you're supposed to from them, you're just going to turn into a rather angry human that doesn't really make it in life. What I'm afraid is, my entire generation isn't going to make it in life, and that is terrifying. I'm 31 now, and if I knew what I knew then, I would have probably kicked a few teachers in the nuts for what they put their students through.
- stevekemp 12y ago> Some of them were smart kids, but they had no proper upbringing Which is one of the conclusions of series four of The Wire ..
- dba7dba 12y ago"They didn't know what to do, how to act, how to be" Kids have to be taught how to be normal human beings first, BEFORE school can teach anything. And that education to be a human starts at home, with parents.
- kethinov 12y agoThe blame game is unhealthy. As long as our public discourse is about blaming parents, blaming teachers, or blaming anybody, we won't strike at the root of the problem, which is poverty. Kids living in poverty simply won't do well in school in statistically significant numbers. If we solve that, then we'll solve our achievement gap.
- tom-lord 12y agoHow do you fix education? By fixing the poverty. How do you fix poverty? By fixing the education. Oh wait, hang on...
- kethinov 12y agoHow do you fix poverty? By having a safety net not full of holes like swiss cheese.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoYou don't fix a vicious cycle by addressing only one aspect. So yes, we have to fix both. Then it will become a mutually reinforcing cycle like it used to be.
- tomjen3 12y agoReading through here I see a lot of assertions and very little evidence. Could you back up your claim?
- kethinov 12y agoThis program did an excellent deep dive and the panelists have written books on the subject if you're looking for more depth: http://thedianerehmshow.org/shows/2015-02-18/rethinking_standardized_testing http://thedianerehmshow.org/shows/2015-02-18/rethinking_stan...
- spacemanmatt 12y agoSeconded. I'm amazed that people are still so willfully blind that they need to see the proof. My take is, if you can't perform your own validation here, your eyes are not open. Poverty is written all over America but we keep misreading it.
- A_COMPUTER 12y agoAs lousy as No Child Left Behind is, it annoys me how many people have completely forgotten that it was a reaction to terrible schools that couldn't be fixed, not the invention of them. Everyone just conveniently blames everything on those stupid tests now.
- biehl 12y agoNo - it was a FAKE reaction to school problems. Fake because it was not designed to work - it was designed to require essentially no new funds. Solutions to school problems exist, are known and were not chosen. Raise teacher pay, make teaching a desirable career. Provide good school food, provide homework assistance, provide school buildings with low noise levels, provide working ventilation to lower classroom CO2 levels, make sure buildings are not fungus-infected ... the list goes on and on.
- hotaru29 12y ago> Fake because it was not designed to work - it was designed to require essentially no new funds. Isn't this policy a federal intervention? If school funding is an issue, why not increase it at state or local level? > Known solutions to school problems exist, You fogot to mention getting rid of teacher unions and starting evaluation of teacher performance. The idea of teacher tenure is simply insane!
- biehl 12y ago> Isn't this policy a federal intervention? If school funding is an issue, why not increase it at state or local level? Yes, why not? However, as a federal intervention - it was not designed to work. > You fogot to mention getting rid of teacher unions and starting evaluation of teacher performance. The idea of teacher tenure is simply insane! Evidence contradict your claim. Finland has strong teacher unions. And the measures I mentioned are largely orthogonal to teacher unions.
- sien 12y agoIn reply to biehl. Finland has been falling on the PISA tests and on other rankings does not do that well. http://www.economist.com/news/international/21591195-fall-former-nordic-education-star-latest-pisa-tests-focusing-interest http://www.economist.com/news/international/21591195-fall-fo... The answer is clear from the international results. If you want a high performing school have big classes, high stakes tests and loads of repetition like the high performing Asian schools do. Or you could ponder why with such great schools why developed Asian countries like Korea and Japan don't run rings around the US in, say, software development and if, in the end, average school rankings don't really matter that much.
- kethinov 12y agoMy wife teaches in a high poverty school and it just mystifies us that so much of the public debate about how to deal with the achievement gap focuses on blame. We want to blame people. Teachers, parents, administrators, we're all looking for a scapegoat and there's no consensus which group is to blame. But it's not that simple. There aren't any bad guys for us to nail to the cross. The achievement gap is the result of stark socioeconomic inequality. Kids in poverty are kids not learning. The only way to deal with the achievement gap is for us to be brave enough as a society to deal with that. Failing schools are a symptom of disease of poverty, not the disease itself. I strongly recommend everyone read this article: http://www.salon.com/2013/08/25/i_taught_at_the_worst_school_in_texas/ http://www.salon.com/2013/08/25/i_taught_at_the_worst_school... My wife didn't write it, but it strongly resembles her day to day experience where she teaches.
- cheatsheet 12y ago1. When you are poor, school feels like you are trading pleasing an adult for the slim chance of getting out of poverty. It feels less like you are working in a real system with an honest chance and more like you are playing in someone's half psychotic maze. The adult world seems like a careless game where no one cares about anyone besides themselves once they've made it. 2. Many of those kids in poor schools are smarter than you think, and have a more realistic understanding of the real world than their wealthy counterparts. It's just the side no one likes talking about, because honestly, it's something society in general is ashamed of. We can build all this great stuff but we can't scale equality. Look at the lives the parents have. Who do you think the kid is going to listen to and learn from the most? What someone says, or how reality is?
- true_religion 12y ago> Many of those kids in poor schools are smarter than you think, When you say something like this it comes off as pretty antagonistic, unless you're about to explain out where specifically someone has said or implied anything about a students intelligence.
- 12y ago
- danielzenchang 12y agoI thought the pineapple issue is only in Japan, Korea, China and most of countries in Asia so everyone's comment was quite surprising to me. Schools are built to create more workers to fulfill corporate or society's needs. The technology might make millions of jobs vanish in few decades so more and more schools will start teaching computer science to young kids and some exetreme cases might be, "hey, let's start educating our 3 year old boy/girl to learn coding"... The question would be, what schools provides? Education or Training?
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> The question would be, what schools provides? Education or Training? One of the problems I see is that this got mixed up, both at school and university level. They say they provide education, but what they actually do is provide training.
- kaitai 12y agoThe real difference in the US is the presence of a substantial number of schools that are instead on the school-to-prison-or-army pipeline. The "high-potential" students are encouraged to join the armed forces, while the kids who have caused trouble are piped into our for-profit incarceration system. I don't see that so much in Asia. As for education vs training, that's a great question. A lot of my students want training initially because they are concerned about their economic futures.
- skds1433 12y ago> ... the United States' No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, which further tied schools' funding to standardized testing results, by making students your biggest problem. > by making students your biggest problem > students your biggest problem > school