18 ms·
If a Caller Says, 'I Am with the IRS,' He's Not
- corysama 12y agoI was contacted by one of these scams recently. A quick Google for key terms in the message (the "officer"'s name and the phone number) showed it to be a scam that particularly enjoyed exploiting immigrants because they are very likely to pay quickly to keep everything quiet. How they have been able to operate such a scam for years without getting arrested is beyond me.
- enraged_camel 12y ago>>How they have been able to operate such a scam for years without getting arrested is beyond me. Yep, I'm flabbergasted. Impersonating a federal officer is a felony, and on top of that, the IRS takes its shit seriously and hates getting screwed with.
- esmi 12y agoI doubt they're in the US. voip and one compromised something with an ethernet connection and a modem.
- MichaelGG 12y agoIt's that, plus it's not being investigated very seriously. I ran a VoIP company, and supposed federal investigators wouldn't even go through the hassle of getting s legal order for customer information. It's the same for robodialling. The FCC or anyone could put a major crimp if they wanted to, but no one really digs into complaints very much.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rosser 12y ago> What if you get called by someone who is with the IRS? FTFA, 3rd ¶: "If you are surprised to be hearing from us, you are not hearing from us," Koskinen said. "Our way of contacting you is by letter."
- cldellow 12y agoExcept the article is wrong. In 2010, I received a call from the IRS. Agent 0199475 wanted me to go to http://pay1040.com http://pay1040.com and pay my taxes. Unsolicited call? Check. Asking me to use a 3rd party website? Check. Was curt with me when I asked how I could trust that he was with the IRS? Check. In this case it was all legitimate. I looked up the IRS phone number on irs.gov, called back, and got a hold of the same guy. I was a foreigner, which I think is why I was treated differently. Maybe domestic payers never receive phone calls, but I certainly did.
- hayksaakian 12y agoI use the same strategy when I get an "authoritative" phone call: 1) what is your official website? 2) where is your phone number listed on that website? 3) what is your name? then i go to the official website (irs.gov or whatever in this case) get the official number, and ask for the person by name. If it's the same person, then congrats it's all legit.
- hkmurakami 12y agoYea this is also important when someone allegedly calls from your bank.
- xenadu02 12y agoYup; got a call from NCIS once (not the show, the real thing). The agent was more than happy to tell me what office she worked for and her name. I then looked up the number on navy.gov independently and got transferred back to her. Fun fact: it was over a guy who was stealing equipment from the Navy and selling it online. Turns out they didn't want the equipment back (since it couldn't be re-deployed for security reasons). They just wanted me to testify against him. I believe he ended up pleading out once confronted so I never ended up testifying.
- fsk 12y agoMy parents got one of these calls and it really made them panic. They're getting older now. They should put more enforcement effort into catching these people. You record everyone's phone calls and you still can't catch people pretending to be IRS agents?
- freditup 12y agoI had an uncle actually get scammed and send money because of a call like these. He's a pretty intelligent guy, I was really surprised he got fooled by it. But goes to show how effective these scams are. There never seemed to be much interest from anyone in helping him recover his money / tracking down who did it. I also wish there was more action to stop this kind of thing, although maybe there's a lot more action than we think in the background.
- ccvannorman 12y agobe careful what you wish for -- allowing use of nsa recorded phone conversations for non-terrorist crimes means they set a precedent for using those recordings against any citizen for any infraction, no matter how minor. there is a good reason we DON'T accept the use of warrantlessly obtained phone recordings in bulk (at least not yet).
- flippant 12y agoI don't think he's advocating for warrant-less wiretapping.
- fsk 12y agoThat information can be collected without an illegal search warrant. The phone companies are required to keep call records for at least several years. I tell the IRS investigator that I got such a call, and now they request the records from the phone company.
- learnstats2 12y agoIf my personal data must be collected, I should be able to use it for my personal benefit.
- thesimon 12y agoRelevant: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZSIO2z3qrwA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZSIO2z3qrwA Not surprising that they don't have any bad feelings about it.
- LoSboccacc 12y agoone of those link on that page should totally go to a page stating 'I just told you to not fall for scam links and first thing you did was to click on a random link on a random internet page! next time, know better not to!"
- Potando 12y agoWhat's wrong with clicking on an unknown link? It can only hurt you by taking advantage of an unpatched security bug in your software. But if you have that, you might be vulnerable doing all sorts of other things on the internet. And you probably do have that and are vulnerable doing all sorts of other things. It's just not very likely to hurt you in either case.
- LoSboccacc 12y agoIt's about preemptively scaring people on how much is easy to have them do this and that action when the communication looks legit And following a link from a scam email has a greater risk of drive by infection, since it is specifically crafted for that and has the user already has convinced being legit: you have to take in account that once the seems legit feeling is active escalating action gradually is likely to succeed. It's about context and psychology. If one of those link from an officially sounding page had a download this to check if you have been scammed a lot of people would have done just that. In the same way you need to preemptively scare them, so that the message of trust no one really comes across vivid
- saurabhtandon 12y agoRecently my friend from work got a similar call which asked him to transfer $5000 immediately or else he will get arrested for improper tax filing/tax evasiongoo within 30 minutes!!! Being new to the US, he was scared and started panicking. But people calmed him down and told him to ignore it. He might have transferred the amount if he had no one to consult that day.
- nlh 12y agoI'm not sure if their policy has changed recently, but at least as of a few years ago, the IRS definitely did call you. I got audited (joy!) and was notified by a relatively-friendly phone call by the auditing agent. Now, she was following up on a letter she'd sent first (to an old, invalid address), to which I hadn't replied, so the "we contact you by mail" thing is also correct. But at least in my case, they most definitely (and legitimately) called.
- xenadu02 12y agoI've been audited once before and they sent letters well prior to calling. For hilarity: I ended up finding more receipts and getting additional money back so the agent ended up doing me a favor.
- kpommerenke 12y agoI got a call that I'd be audited, and the letter only arrived a few days later.
- AznHisoka 12y agoI'm curious - what happens after you get audited?
- derekp7 12y agoIn one case, I got an audit letter, said it was a random audit, and everything checked out. A second time, I got a letter that I made an addition error (in their favor), and ended up getting another couple hundred bucks back. An audit can also result in them asking for a paper trail to back up what you claimed. Keep in mind that many of the common items (interest earned, mortgage interest paid, etc) are all filed with the IRS by third parties, via a 1099 or 1098 form. But for some other items that you can claim deductions on, such as business expenses, you will need to provide them a copy of the receipts if they ask. If you can't back it up, they adjust what you owe, and may apply interest / penalties, which you will have to pay. If not, they can do things like garnish wages, freeze bank accounts, etc. But that will come after a court judgement typically. Keep in mind that some of the items they will go after: If you turn in expenses at work, and they reimburse you for that, the IRS may still require you to retain the receipts to show that it is a valid business expense that you got paid for -- otherwise they can consider that income and tax you on it.
- orokusaki 12y agoIsn't this exactly the same thing the IRS does, criminally extort money from tax payers by pretending to be a legitimate branch of the government?
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI got called once and said "Oh really? What office?" but they realized I wasn't buying it and hung up. These things are pervasive and they are annoying, they are also impossible to prosecute in the "small" so I'm wondering if there is a case to be made for user provided call tracing. Specifically, if you get a call, you can originate from that same phone a request for trace which returns the origin point of that call. These days with call setup being 100% digital the trace information is available immediately (rather than after some fictional period of time with an open line) so why not provide this as a service to phone subscribers? I'd be willing to pay $10 whenever I triggered the service, and the data is out there so its essentially "free money" for the phone company.
- rdl 12y agoI'd be tempted to string them along. If you pay your taxes, these people are basically stealing from you by increasing fraud and decreasing the willingness of others to pay taxes, as well as stealing from other people. I'd be fine with IRS CID spending $100 to catch $1 of criminal predation on taxpayers, here.
- Hello71 12y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malicious_caller_identification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malicious_caller_identificatio...
- ChuckMcM 12y agoWhich is tied to law enforcement involvement and is of no use in this case, they won't follow up. I've tried. But if the phone company would send me that information, I could use it to follow up with an investigation into who these people are, where they live, how they get their money, who is complicit in the money laundering, etc. And then either give that to the press, the Internet, or the police depending on the desired effect.
- gumby 12y agoAmusingly, I once got a call from the actual IRS -- and the caller asked for my SSN before continuing! I declined to provide it, asked for his name, looked up the IRS number in the phone book (this is how long ago it was), and eventually got through to him. He did not seem at all upset or surprised by my wanting to do so. Turns out there was a similarly-named company not that far away from us, whose CFO had the same last name as me. As soon as I called and gave my SSN he said, wait, do you work for "Cygnus" and I said yes, but we figured what had gone wrong out and he said, "sorry, never mind". Total time on the call: less than 60 seconds. Total time to get through to him? About 30 minutes. Still, the commissioner's advice was essentially correct: I was surprised to get the call because it wasn't for me. Was the IRS, but not a call for me. Good thing I called back though!
- nhebb 12y agoI've been getting a lot of the IRS and the "This is Windows calling" calls recently. I usually tell them to fuck off, but once in a while I will string them along. I figure my best revenge is to waste their time so they can't spend it harassing someone else who doesn't know better.
- backlava 12y agoAnd Bridget, et al, with cardholder services.
- WalterBright 12y agoIf the caller ID says "anonymous" or "unknown", I don't answer. I refuse to talk to callers who won't identify themselves. That gets rid of most of them. For the rest, if there are a few seconds of silence after I answer, it's a robocaller and I hang up.
- noobermin 12y agoSomewhat related, but my girlfriend lives in Singapore, and I recently visited there while stopping by my parents' in Palau, which is a Pacific island. The internet infrastructure in Palau is pitiful, so when I tried contacting her by phone while there, and it turned out she blocked the number because it was weird (she said the number was a bunch of 8's. Coming from Palau's whacky telecom corp, it's not surprising). You never know if your loved one is stuck at the side of the road somewhere trying to get to you. I usually answer the phone and figure out who is on the line and I usually can determine who is a scammer and who isn't. Then again, I don't get calls very often, so may be I have more patience with calls. Emails? I am probably much less diligent about determining their authenticity.
- netvarun 12y agoThat's a really interesting story! I've noticed similar strange numbers appearing from those who call from a VoIP service like Skype. One heuristic I use when I see a call from an unrecognizable number is to drop the first call and take the next one (if it comes). Well meaning folks, usually will retry in a short while, while scammers will usually move onto the next target.
- sjg007 12y agoSomeone should start an SSL verification service for official phone calls.
- spacefight 12y agoGreat idea - but with with what verification level? admin@domain.tld email verification?
- choppaface 12y agoThese scammers have been hitting me with a phone call per day for the past 3-4 months. They always use a different phone number, and only twice did they leave voicemail (one was a recording, one was a bunch of guys chatting as if they forgot to turn on the robot). The recording says something like "the IRS is suing you." For the numbers that weren't blocked, I tried checking them using Twilio's Lookup service: https://www.twilio.com/lookup https://www.twilio.com/lookup While the numbers are often in my local area code, the Twilio API shows the "Mobile {Network,Country} Code" is typically in South America or Eastern Europe. How did they get my phone number? I replied to a Craigslist ad a while back that turned out to be a scam :( I wish there was a way to get rid of the calls ...
- cmdrfred 12y agoGoogle voice my friend.
- brightsize 12y agoYep. I have two GV numbers and never give out my real number ever. If someone legit wants to talk to me, they'll leave me a GV voicemail.
- tracker1 12y agoOne suggestion, I set my voicemail on my actual phone to the disconnect tones followed by a very long random message... I use an mvno that doesn't let my set conditional forwarding. Love GV been using it for years.
- cheetos 12y agoHypothetically speaking, how could one go about retaliating against this? If one could identify the source numbers, could one set up a network of counter-robodialers and effectively DDOS them?
- cmdrfred 12y agoIf you want to spend a couple bucks you can use Twilio's api to spam the hell out of them.
- taf2 12y agodon't to that please. 1. you could get it wrong. 2. that is not the intended use for an API like that. 3. it would be better if you spent your time to report or collect information to help law enforcement catch them. It might be fun to use the API to hurt them but you're effectively stooping to their level if you did... and in the process remember you're hurting twilio if you do that.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoI was thinking more like drone strikes. As with fax spam and email spam, these people deserve death. With 7 billion people hanging around the last thing we need is a handful of first-world career criminals.
- Scoundreller 12y agoSay "Oh yes, I will get them, just wait a few moments", then put the phone down and come back some time later. ELIZA or other natural language responder could be effective too.
- phkahler 12y agoI honestly don't understand why caller ID can be spoofed or disabled by the caller. The only things this enables are illegal and/or annoying. In this case, one should be able to report the number to the authorities and they should be able to identify fraudsters very quickly and put some people in jail.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoAllowing hiding caller ID is important for privacy reasons (the privacy of the person being called). Allowing spoofing caller ID is important so internal landlines don't need to be revealed, and instead they can present you with their main number.
- pandaman 12y agoThere are legitimate uses for "spoofed" caller ID (it's not really spoofed, it's whatever the call originator declared to be, you can originate calls without ability to terminate them so a particular call may not have a "real" originating phone number at all). E.g. companies use their 800-number or some kind of central dispatch to ID all their phones. Google Voice has an option to show the original caller ID on forwarded calls or your own Google Voice number, both seem to be more useful than an ID of whatever box Google used to originate the call to you at the moment. Basically the caller ID is as useful as the reply-to in e-mail: if you want to get replies then you make sure you fill it with correct information but it's not authenticating the sender by any means.
- cxseven 12y agoThat's still not a technical reason why the barn door needs to be wide open. Google being able to set the originating phone number should be the exception rather than the norm. Just like money transfers, there could be an obligation for telephony services to provide valid identifying information, enforced through a chain of contracts where a link doesn't get to set originating info unless it also agrees to the contract. There will always be holes, but at least this would provide a mechanism for eliminating them. Also, a "green zone" could start in the US and expand outwards, eventually kicking scammers off of VOIP links situated in the US, forcing their costs up. PS Google has been experimenting with verifying email senders.
- Smoofer 12y agoVaguely OT, but does anyone have good information regarding how to identify or block scam/shady websites? My grandfather tends to fall victim to these types of things - not even always explicit scams like this, but believing hugely inaccurate political websites ( think Obama impeachment conspiracy type BS ), and buying into wonder-products or just the general drivel you see in spammy ads on AOL. I'm probably going to start by cleaning up his computer some and installing Ad-Block, but most of the links to the websites are coming from his emails - any advice from someone that have dealt with similar scenarios?
- minikites 12y agoI use Pollock's HOSTS file: http://someonewhocares.org/hosts/ http://someonewhocares.org/hosts/ It blocks a handful of spam/scam sites but it's mostly for malware, maybe there's another sort of HOSTS file for spammy sites?
- lucaspiller 12y agoAlthough it may seem a bit harsh, maybe it's better to just have a whitelist. My dad started using a computer a few years ago and I've been worried about the same as he gets older. The number of sites he browses is minimal though. It's not as if he needs to go on a massive search to figure out the best practices for X new technology and read a load of blogs.
- jpmattia 12y agoI find it odd that the article did not comment on why the scam works: Many folks have the perception is that the IRS is an unreasonable, strong-arming organization. (Not that I've had any large issues, but I've found the agents there to be fairly reasonable for the small stuff I've dealt with.)
- thrownaway2424 12y agoLOL, people still answer the phone.
- prawn 12y agoThis is flippant and not very HN, but I did upvote it. I get more nuisance and spam calls than I get legitimate calls, and that's with getting on any do-not-call register I can. I pay $40-50/month for the privilege of getting mostly time-wasting phone calls at my office and it's infuriating.
- usman11 12y agohttp://mytricks30.blogspot.com/2015/04/final-four.html http://mytricks30.blogspot.com/2015/04/final-four.html
- usman11 12y agohttp://mytricks30.blogspot.com/2015/04/final-four.html http://mytricks30.blogspot.com/2015/04/final-four.html
- usman11 12y agohttp://mytricks30.blogspot.com/2015/04/final-four.html http://mytricks30.blogspot.com/2015/04/final-four.html
- fma 12y agoI like how the title of the story implies that the scammers are all men, but in the article the person who left the voicemail was actually a "stern woman". Where is the PC police when you need it?
- 300bps 12y agoSince I signed up for the free (to consumers) www.nomorobo.com the scam calls don't bother me anymore. They won an award from the FTC for innovative ways to stop automated phone calls. You use your phone service's simultaneous ring feature to ring your house and Nomorobo at the same time. If the call is from a known scammer / automated dialer it picks up the call and immediately hangs up. So your phone only rings once.
- alok-g 12y ago>> Koskinen said. "Our way of contacting you is by letter." Scammers cannot contact by letter purportedly?!
- fillskills 12y agoOur landline has been called by 1) IRS scammers 2)FBI scammers 3)Some fake govt health organization suing my company for 40K!! Funny story - So finally I told the fake health organization that if they were genuine, they would send my company a letter and paper work. And voila, a few weeks later we get paperwork with misspelled company name from those scammers! I have to give them credit for trying!
- tempestn 12y agoSome of these scams can be extremely elaborate and sophisticated. Does anyone remember this one, where the scammer already knows all your personal info, tells you to call the number on the back of your card, and when you do so you end up still talking to the scammer? http://www.theguardian.com/money/blog/2013/jul/29/courier-scam-lose-money-bank-cards http://www.theguardian.com/money/blog/2013/jul/29/courier-sc...
- Evolved 12y agoMaybe it's just me or maybe I have too much time on my hands but I really enjoy messing with the scammers. This is most entertaining when done with sound bites from movies. Also, the IRS wants their money much much more than they want to send you to jail so they'll work with you and be more than accommodating as long as it means getting paid what their owed.
- 37prime 12y agoMy colleague has been getting these kind of calls at the office. The callers do have heavy Indian accent. It is amusing for us for any of these scammers to call any of our direct extensions.
- sneak 12y agoIt's 2015. Every bank will communicate with me using TLS and email. Why the hell won't the IRS? It's insane, backward thinking.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]