3 ms·
If it's really 60% and it works over the general universe of shares, you've built a money machine.
by lordnacho 12y ago
If it's really 60% and it works over the general universe of shares, you've built a money machine.
- omegaham 12y agoRemember that the general direction of the market right now is upward. This means that these day-trading algorithms need to beat the typical rate of return for, say, a diversified index fund. Many of them don't.
- lordnacho 12y agoWell I'm assuming the guy has thought about that, and his dataset is long enough to be meaningful. He didn't say how much the return varied, which you need for the comparison with the index to make sense.
- kasey_junk 12y agoNope because it doesn't account for risk.
- lordnacho 12y agoThe fact that it works over the universe accounts for the risk. If you have a 60% chance of being right, doing it over a few thousand stocks will make your daily return extremely steady, thanks to the law of large numbers. Of course there are correlations and such things to think about, but it's all controllable with that kind of edge.
- kasey_junk 12y agoNo it still doesn't. Because you have to allocate resources to the positional bet and one side of that bet has virtually limitless risk attached to it and the other has limited upside.
- lordnacho 12y agoWhat side has limitless risk? He didn't say what he was up to.
- kasey_junk 12y agoAll trades have 2 sides. Getting in and getting out. If your predictions include "I have a high degree of confidence that this instrument is about to go down" the way you enter that trade is by shorting it. Shorting has no true floor to the amount of money you can lose. This isn't true of going long, as an instrument can only go to zero. There is a natural imbalance between the max risk associated with shorting vs going long (and there are lots of other risks associated with trading, this is very simplistic) that means that no one who has done this sort of thing before uses a predictive ability without risk as a serious basis for a trade. In fact, predictive ability is not that special. There are trivial algorithms that can predict movements with high levels of accuracy (much higher than 60% for instance), but don't perform well on a risk adjusted basis in modelling or in reality.