3 ms·
So it's really only viable because it gets rent free land from the tax payers. It seems like it's just some magic accounting trick to not count the revenue tha
by chii 12y ago
So it's really only viable because it gets rent free land from the tax payers.
It seems like it's just some magic accounting trick to not count the revenue that the tax payer would have received for the land currently being given tent free.
In other words, public transport is just not a profitable business.
- craigmccaskill 12y agoIt's hard to count the value in having well run, on time and cheap mass public transport system. Maybe the tax payer at some point subsidized this effort, but it doesn't have to keep doing so to get the benefit. The government was unlikely to develop and run these malls themselves, so it seems like they government would've just sold the land and then had to run the MTR itself. Seems like a win-win to me.
- mfjordvald 12y agoThey also have the advantage of a relatively small area to cover with a hugely dense population. The ticket prices are low as well so almost everyone actually uses the MTR. Pretty prime conditions for a profitable public transportation system.
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoYeah, I'm in favor of well run public transport, I think it's a vital part of a well functioning society. I even think that land should be developed around transport lines in a holistic manner (both to make them social hubs and to make the most effective use of real estate and construction disruption. But this is just poor accounting if the land and the right to build on it is just transferred for free. On the other hand, the company is majority owned by the government anyway, so this is probably still the smart thing to do (depends on how that $1 Billion plus a year profit gets fed back into the government funds via their shareholding and whether social benefits are driving their construction plans rather than short term profit).
- davegardner 12y agoAccording to the article the fares cover 175% of the operating costs. So even without the additional income from real estate it's still a profitable business.
- chii 12y agoah, i missed that - i read in the article that the land development and rental was making up the majority of their profitability.
- api 12y agoCars are only viable because they get roads from the tax payers.
- cpursley 12y agoExactly. In the United States, most people don't realize the impact the interstate highway system had on market pricing. It effectively subsidized cheap land and road travel.