8 ms·
BitTorrent-Style Updates Revealed in Windows 10
- kylelibra 12y agoIf only iOS updates worked the same way. edit: over wifi is fine, was more referring to the incredibly slow downloads I experience the moment and iOS update comes out vs a few days later.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoOh god no. Mobile networks ARE NOT designed to handle torrent type traffic. You will destroy RF bandwidth at towers, as well as backhauls. The best iOS update methods are still "push notify update available to client, fetch over wifi when plugged in and screen locked" and if after a significant amount of time the download doesn't occur, only then fallback to a cellular download directly from the CDN, still at night when usage is extremely low.
- gtCameron 12y agoWhy couldn't "fetch over wifi" use torrent type traffic from other wifi based users?
- toomuchtodo 12y agoYou could, but between how inexpensive CDN bandwidth is when purchased in bulk, along with Apple's desire to control a user's experience so its always positive, a torrent swarm doesn't make sense.
- cordite 12y agoIsn't this why frequency bands that equipped citizens cannot legally forward information among a mesh network? Plus, as far as phones uploading to other phones, regardless of package signing and other security, no one would appreciate unsolicited battery life depletion. I remember this discussion coming up with GoTenna [1] here, where they admitted it would be a nice feature to communicate beyond single point to point transceivers like a mesh network but the FCC stipulates these open bands cannot be used like that. [1]: http://www.gotenna.com/ http://www.gotenna.com/
- yusyusyus 12y agono. this is a limitation specific to MURS, from their explaination[0]. MURS band is cooler for them though because of longer lamdba. but the longer lambda = further propagation / power (a general rule anyway). so, FCC would rather not have long propagation (at least that is what it looks like.. don't know when the rules were put into place, the process, etc to say for sure). [0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8054336 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8054336
- smackfu 12y agoPractically speaking, iOS devices don't keep the update around after install.
- superobserver 12y agoWindows 10 is looking like the Windows 8 that should have been. I'm especially interested in the OneGet module of PS 5 and package management that they'll be working on for it. A Linuxified Windows would be pretty interesting. Why exactly do I see "leaked" in front of Windows 10 so often when one can download the tech preview relatively easily?
- wmf 12y agoThere are still leaked builds that are newer than the public Windows 10 builds.
- AdmiralAsshat 12y agoI remember repeating the already-common joke around the time of Windows XP to my middle school Computer Hardware teacher that "Every OTHER Windows release is good." Vista/Windows 7 appeared to cement that, and Windows 8 / Windows 10 just seems like further proof.
- shitlord 12y agoTo me, it seems like a marketing strategy on MS's part. They know people expect good things from even releases and bad things from odd releases. I think they capitalize on that.
- alatkins 12y agoI think you may be attributing to malice what could be better explained by stupidity :-)
- orionblastar 12y agoIt is actually Windows 8/8.1/10 Windows 8.1 is better than plain 8, I run it and it still needs work and I use the Classic Start program to get the Start Menu back, but 8.1 works better than 8. I suspect there will also be a 10.1 to replace 10.
- 12y ago
- cssmoo 12y agoYet a million feedbacks go unanswered... I'm getting the "old Microsoft feeling again" i.e. prescriptive features rather than what the end user wants. Edit: please back your down votes with some kind of discussion.
- O____________O 12y agoI'm getting the "old Microsoft feeling again" Why? What are some specific examples you see? Personally, I think they got slapped so hard by Windows 8 that I expect Windows 10 to be pretty great. They had me at "console window" (though likely I'll still be using ConEmu).
- infogulch 12y ago(I upvoted to offset unsubstantiated downvotes.) I'm curious what your point is. Do you have any examples of things they are ignoring? This change is good for both Microsoft and its' users since it reduces bandwidth used on both ends, and and could be especially useful in multiple-computer households. It probably comes specifically from the Windows Update team, where they are working on that product alone, and as such the fact that they weren't (for example) fixing some user interface glitch in the new start menu is quite unsurprising.
- MBCook 12y ago> i.e. prescriptive features rather than what the end user wants. This isn't a prescriptive feature, it's an implementation detail on how patches are downloaded.
- freehunter 12y agoGo unanswered as of yet. Every week there's some new feature of Windows 10 being talked about. It almost seems like it hasn't been officially released yet, and they're still actively working on it... Hard to criticize a company for not including features in software they haven't put out yet.
- darklajid 12y agoYou're asking down-voters to explain their reasoning. But you didn't provide yours? Three (two, really) lines. The first one is .. vague/useless/devoid of content. The second is a general stab at Microsoft for falling back into old habits of 'knowing it better' (nevermind that this is something I regularly read about Apple or the Gnome project guys..), without any details. The third line is only added as an edit after people expressed that your comment lacks content, and is asking down-voters for explanations. Again: You didn't explain your point. I can summarize that post as sigh M$ suxxorz and while that might be even more useless/use offensive language for hyperbole, it contains all the facts and pieces of information that you listed in your post. So what is the real problem? Maybe you have a great point. What isn't answered? What features do you think are useless? What features do you think/know/believe are wanted by users?
- rplnt 12y agoWhy are these reports always from "leaked" versions? MS publishes new builds like biweekly through MSDN. Is it only "clikbait"? Because I'm sure the writers didn't find how updates (or anything) work, rather someone who has legit access to those builds.
- asyncwords 12y ago> MS publishes new builds like biweekly through MSDN. While this is supposed to be true, there hasn't been a new public build in 50-something days. Most of the new information is coming from leaked internal builds.
- Alupis 12y ago"leaked"...? ... as-in posted by some Microsoft Employee under direction of Microsoft Management in a "we don't want to write-up a change doc or support info, nor answer questions about this build, and/or test the waters for a possibly controversial feature without officially claiming the build." "Leaked", in the same sense as anonymous Government Officials "leak" important news to the press to test waters before the administration officially backs an issue, or big manufacturers "leak" pictures of new products to the press to create buzz before they do an unveiling... one would think the world was made of holes. Why do we call all these things "leaks" when they so-definitely are not. They are "clickbait", plain and simple.
- joshuapants 12y agoWithout evidence to suggest that is the case, it's probably best not to make wild claims.
- rplnt 12y agoThey have proper release notes of course. Maybe talking about a feature violates some NDA, I'm not sure, but they are not leaked in the sense that the build itself leaked from Microsoft.
- rplnt 12y agoYou mean public previews, which are meant for end users and press, but the development builds are being released much more often. Latest is less than a week old.
- higherpurpose 12y agoWill those torrents be encrypted too? If they are actual torrents, hopefully that means ISPs like Comcast won't throttle torrents anymore - or maybe they'll just get Microsoft to pay extra for the privilege.
- arthurfm 12y ago> In 2013, Microsoft bought Pando Networks, a company developing BitTorrent-like P2P software that included dedicated servers and smart bandwidth throttling. This would feel like a natural fit for Windows patch distribution. [1] [1] http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/03/windows-10-to-support-peer-to-peer-downloading-of-apps-and-updates/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/03/window...
- jewel 12y agoThe interesting thing about the screenshot is that it says "Local PCs", as in PCs on the LAN. This would be incredible and I wish everyone would do the same thing. Especially Steam. Imagine what a problem it is when you want to play a ten player game of TF2 at the office and nobody has it installed. Getting updates from local PCs is something much easier to program than the general case of P2P traffic over the Internet. A simple UDP broadcast packet can find other peers, and wifi or the LAN will work great for transfer. A long time ago we had to put an HTTP proxy in for debian updates so that when we updated all of our virtual machines it wouldn't saturate the T1.
- sliverstorm 12y agoImagine what a problem it is when you want to play a ten player game of TF2 at the office and nobody has it installed. This is where you create a network drive and share it with everyone's Steam client as a Steam Library. (Catch: you can't use iSCSI unless you use a cluster FS, and circa 2012 using a Samba share required some text file editing)
- ossreality 12y agoA bunch of concurrent random access into game content files can't be a good idea. Unless that share is on a RAID or something maybe.
- orionblastar 12y agoI agree, it is like when Microsoft made KMS activation servers for companies that had volume licenses and no Internet connection to Microsoft to activate systems. Only now it can download Windows 10 updates and then have each machine on the LAN connect to it to download updates. Every time I reformat a Windows machine, I have to go through the downloading updates process to get it back to speed. It would be easier if I had all of the updates on a local machine I could connect to and download them. Steam too, every reformat means the games have to be downloaded again unless you can back them up to a USB drive or something.
- 12y ago
- voltagex_ 12y agoThis is going to cost me - uploads are counted as well as downloads on most plans in Australia.
- freehunter 12y agoDid you read past the first sentence? The second one says "in the settings is the option". The screenshot shows a toggle switch. It won't cost you a dime.
- voltagex_ 12y agoSorry, what I should have said was "I'd like to use this, but it'd cost me". I'd hope Microsoft is also offering to let ISPs cache updates for faster/cheaper delivery.
- bsder 12y agoBasically, this is an admission that Windows Update on a low-bandwidth connection chokes your bandwidth to a crawl.
- tem5050 12y agoI'm quite excited for this! I have a monthly data-cap at my residence and updates will often reach in to the several hundred megabytes range (sometimes even reaching 1GB!) This would allow me to download the updates once and then spread them out, saving me a bunch of data for other things! Good on you, Microsoft.