12 ms·
Calling the Oregon Lottery's Bluff After Poker Machine Dealt a Strange Hand
- PeterWhittaker 12y agotl;dr: Oregon poker machines advise players to make moves that favour the house, and couple those with an autoplay feature that accepts house recommendations - recommendations that are inherently unfair to the player. At least, this is what the lawsuit alleges....
- ghostbrainalpha 12y agoYou don't have to qualify that with "At least, this is what the lawsuit alleges". The lottery is not disputing they make recommendations that are not optimal for the player. The question is are they obligated to give the best advice?
- Navarr 12y agoI think no. Video games traditionally give tips - these are designed to help out players who aren't sure what to do. They are not designed to be the best possible move. If the game autoplayed the best possible moves, what would be the point of learning poker? Where would skill come into the mix? This lawsuit seems frivolous to me. I would never expect a game to give me the most optimal hint - only a hint for how to get closer to winning.
- stillsut 12y agoThe guy's in software but then he acts dumbstruck that the machine wouldn't tell him the optimal move? Wouldn't you be happy if there was at least some player skill involved which would contribute over time help you lose less.
- URSpider94 12y agoThat's not usually the social contract in gambling. The house usually goes out of its way to make sure you know the technically correct play (i.e. the one that 9 out of 10 experienced players would make). These are meant to be games of chance, not games of skill. At least at the level that you would never draw to an inside straight, if given the option not to -- that's just dumb. As others have mentioned, there are times you might turn in a winning hand in hopes of drawing a royal flush, since so much of the return is in the jackpot -- that's less clear-cut, and I wouldn't expect a video poker machine to make the jackpot-seeking recommendation, since it's not how you would play in a 5-card draw table game.
- Rangi42 12y agoThe way to give helpful tips, as opposed to best possible moves, is to be more vague, not to recommend a specific less-than-optimal move. Imprecise help like "hold onto your high cards" or "don't gamble on drawing one particular rank" could work, but if the Auto-Hold feature is advertised as a faster way to hold onto an optimal set of cards, then that's what it should be.
- pbreit 12y agoVideo games <> gambling machines.
- lambda 12y agoThey are obligated to display the odds on each machine, so people have at least a fair chance of evaluating their changes (even if they odds are always in the house's favor). In this case, the odds they posted didn't take into account the poor suggestions given by the autoplay feature. So the question is, does the fact that the player has a choice that would allow them to improve their odds to what was posted mean that they met their obligation in posting the odds, or does an autoplay feature that most users choose, because it speeds up the game and requires less thought, determine the odds that they are statutorily required to post. The rules (http://arcweb.sos.state.or.us/pages/rules/oars_100/oar_177/177_200.html http://arcweb.sos.state.or.us/pages/rules/oars_100/oar_177/1...) state: "A close approximation of the odds of winning some prize for each game must be displayed on a Video LotterySM game terminal screen or a help screen. Each game also must display the amount wagered and the amount awarded for each possible winning occurrence based on the number of credits wagered on a game play." So this will likely depend on whether this is determined to be a close enough approximation, and whether autoplay suggesting a sub-optimal play that reduces your odds is considered to be a problem, if you do have a choice that would let you avoid that.
- Strilanc 12y agoI recently attended a talk by the team that approximately solved the two player head's-up limit hold'em variant of poker. Their strategy is close enough to optimal that a perfectly exploiting opponent would take millions of played hands to expect to extract 1 big blind's worth of value. The Oregon lottery should be held to a qualitatively similar standard. They should state how many cents an optimal player would expect to lose, per hand, by following the default advice instead of playing optimally. Also, there should be regulations about how high that opportunity cost can be. ... not that I think the machines are a good idea in the first place.
- elarkin 12y ago> The question is are they obligated to give the best advice? I didn't get this from the article. I understood the issue to be: 1. It is undisputed that the lottery is required to display odds (return $$s per $$s spent). 2. It is undisputed that the lottery displays the theoretical maximum return given optimal play 3. The lottery supports a feature that does not play optimally 4. The issue: Should the lottery be required to display the rate of return given the use of auto-play?
- A_COMPUTER 12y agoI feel like government-run ventures are obligated to not try to intentionally mislead me. If this is incompatible with gambling machines, then the entire venture seems unethical. Well, I won't beat around the bush, I already think government running gambling machines is incredibly unethical for a number of reasons, so the fact that they also have intentionally shitty defaults and misleading instructions is just more proof to me.
- bobbykjack 12y agoAre government run lotteries also unethical? What about government run investment schemes?
- brendanr 12y agoIf you found this article interesting, check out the book Addiction by Design: Machine Gambling in Las Vegas, by Natasha Dow Schüll. It's an incredibly interesting book about building addictive gameplay, the industry that does it, and the people that use it.
- jab2014 12y agoThe practices of the Oregon lottery seem wrong to me. Government should be in the business of helping people and providing uncorrupted resources and facts, not marketing dreams and hope to people while taking their money hand over fist. John Oliver just did a good segment about this too https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PK-netuhHA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PK-netuhHA
- vonklaus 12y agoI dont think the government has ever been in the business of providing uncorrupted resources.
- felixgallo 12y agonext time you drink water or drive on a road, remember this comment.
- automatthew 12y agoWells and driveways.
- mintplant 12y ago"Uncorrupted", not "exclusive".
- shit_parade 12y agoWater usage in the US is incredibly irresponsible, not really priced by usage(farmers get enormous subsidies), and largely done by favoritism and grandfathered laws. The UN has aggressively called out US biofuel production as irresponsible and even disastrous. Fracking continues to poison the water tables and ogallala aquifer is sucked dry. Why don't you actually try reading, or educating yourself instead of knee-jerk defending the government with whatever at hand response you've learned as a child and repeated verbatim. Fucking idiot.
- baddox 12y ago
- fsk 12y agoOPTIMAL strategy for video poker is hard. (assuming standard 9/6 JoB paytable) For example, what do you hold with (1) AH QH TH JD 3H vs (2) AH QH TH 9D 3H On (1), you hold the 4-flush. On (2), you go for the 3 card royal. (Reason: Discarding the jack makes it slightly less likely to draw the straight, tipping the otherwise close decision to favor the 4-flush.) In the article, the machine was advising plays anyone with basic competence would never make.
- fryguy 12y agoOptimal strategy for a given hand isn't that hard to calculate, either. There are 32 choices of how to hold. 5 of them have 46 possible outcomes, 10 have 2070 possible outcomes, and the remaining can be looked up in a table with less than 13.5k entries.
- thret 12y agoThat is the kind of distinction Alenn Kessler would make! I wouldn't expect the 'auto-hold' feature to allow everyone to play mathematically perfectly, but I would expect it to automate routine decisions for speed. Giving advice that halves a players % to win is disgusting.
- pbreit 12y agoI don't think "advising" is the best description of what happens. The players do not have to select which cards to turn in based on the "advice". That is done for them.
- fl0wenol 12y agoOr you know, NEVER PLAY IT EVER, and probably come out ahead. There are games on your phone, even free ones. Play those at a bar, there's no excuse.
- dagw 12y agoOPTIMAL strategy for video poker is hard. Here's a dude who claims to have worked it out: http://wizardofodds.com/games/video-poker/strategy/jacks-or-better/9-6/optimal/ http://wizardofodds.com/games/video-poker/strategy/jacks-or-... While not a trivial strategy to memorize, it should be quick and easy to code.
- swang 12y agoThis is completely unacceptable, but the State will probably get away with it. If the study he found showed the machines paid out _more_ than it should (but still positive to the State) you bet there would be audits of the machine.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pbreit 12y agoThe Oregon commission is clearly in the wrong but I'm not sure determining the losses is very straightforward. I'm guessing the lower payouts mostly result in more time spent at the machines with nearly the same losses.
- jmspring 12y agoI avoid most video machines, but an anecdote from some time I spend in Helsinki in the early 2000s while working for a company there. Gambling, in a sense, appeared to be legal in Finland. In Helsinki there was one Vegas style casino (similar odds, $10 minimum -- memory serving me right); but many bars had 21 tables. The trip in the "bars" was a tie was not a push, but went to the house. Given I was a loner in a country known for it's lack of gregariousness (a stereotype, I had friend's there, but many focused on family and those outside the city didn't come in during the week), playing the odds was an interesting gambit. Giving up the natural odds in a tie is a push for 21 was a hard one to digest. However, I offset some of it by always taking the #1 position. Not ideal overall, but a help. In the end, after 6 months there, tabulating pure gambling stakes, I ended up a net positive by about 15%. On my return to the US, my first trip was with friends to Vegas. My skewed methodology of playing, assume no tie, for 21, permeated my game for the first few hours. It resulted in unhappy players, but saw a slight uptick in my own earnings. I wish I had the time and energy to more fully document this period, but playing games that expect one skew and then coming into another that expects something else, at least for me for awhile was a benefit.
- URSpider94 12y agoThis is really disturbing. For all of the sleaziness of Vegas, any time I've asked a dealer or pit boss about the house advantage in a particular game, or the correct play for a particular hand, they've told me cheerfully and correctly. They sell strategy cards in all of the gift shops -- and you can have them on the table with you while you are playing. There's no need for them to lie -- they already have the advantage, all they need to do is get you to play long enough to let the odds do their thing.
- kxo 12y agoExcept that in the case of live poker, they're getting theirs via the rake. I assume you're talking about blackjack: unless there is a CSM at the table or an absurd 6:5 blackjack payout (you shouldn't be there in either event, period) you can absolutely play to your advantage.
- raverbashing 12y agoWell, the basic strategy for Blackjack is still slightly in favour of the house But yeah, you might track cards (good luck doing that with 10 decks though)
- jacobkg 12y agoMost blackjack card counting strategies are no more difficult with a higher number of decks. Instead of counting actual 'cards', one instead keeps a running total of points based on the cards that come out. In fact a higher number of decks can improve one's advantage when counting because when the count turns in your favor it can happen with more of the deck left to come (so a longer period of advantageous play) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Card_counting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Card_counting
- CPLX 12y agoThis is incorrect, the larger the number of decks, as a general rule, the smaller the advantage of card counting becomes.
- spuz 12y agoThe conclusion that a lower payout means more money for the lottery and less for the players is wrong. If a player receives a lower payout than expected either through bad luck or cheating on the part of the video machine they are more likely to stop playing. There is an online gambling company here in the UK who strive to maintain a 95% payout across all their games because it is deemed the most profitable long term strategy. The chances are that a higher payout for video poker will result in higher earnings for the lottery company which means there is a possibility that the auto hold behaviour is as a result of lazy programming rather than deliberate maliciousness.
- lovemenot 12y agoDo the machines' operator in the UK need to be competitive? How about in Oregon? I am sure question 1 is Yes. Just from reading the article, I guess only the State Lottery can run machines in Oregon.
- joosters 12y agoCitation needed! There's plenty of evidence that gaming machines in the UK are set to far lower than a 95% payout, namely that each machine displays this percentage on it, and they are almost always below 95% The people installing these machines aren't fools, they know that lowering the payouts increases their profits.
- spuz 12y agoI would guess there is a difference between the effect of various payout percentages in online games vs physical machine games. I would assume online players tend to have more time to spend playing on average which gives them more time to hit their spending limit. I would love to give a source for the 95% figure but I only have that info second-hand from an ex-employee. Regardless of whether or not you believe that statement, you should see that the logic that lower payout ratio equals a lower payout amount simply doesn't hold. Imagine if the payout turned out to be 50% rather than 90%. Would you expect the company make more or less money? Even if players believe they were simply unlucky, that will still be enough for some of them to stop playing. The optimal payout in terms of revenue for the company is something that can only be determined by real world experiments and there is no evidence in the article about this case that the lottery company determined that an advertised payout of 90% and an actual payout of 87% by experimental analysis. Hence my tendency to believe this was not an act of deliberate deception.
- hristov 12y agoReally bad article. Goes to great lengths to glamorize that Curzi person, yet does not provide some of the most crucial information on the subject. For example - does oregon law require that the machines have certain winning percentage? And secondly did the state of oregon make a representation to gamblers that this machine had certain winning percentage? And finding documents marked "confidential" that say the machine has a certain winning percentage means nothing. You cannot say that a confidential document that was unknown to gamblers before Cruzi obtained it from a public records request mislead anyone. If people do not know about a document there is no way it can mislead them. Since the article is quiet on the two questions listed above it seems very likely that their answer is "no". In that case that Cruzi person, as glamorous as the article makes him, probably has no case. If the machine is not required by law or by previous advertisement to give out a certain percentage, I do not see how the fact that the advice it gives results in a lesser percentage than other possible advice is at all relevant.
- gnud 12y agoI agree that the article wasn't very clear on this. It does, however, say that Oregon law requires the lottery to tell players the win chance. The state lottery knew that the win chance they told players (0.9), was actually higher than the win chance when using 'auto-hold' (~0.85). That doesn't mean that Curzi will win, of course.
- harywilke 12y agoFrom the article: 'The lottery’s rules require “a close approximation of the odds of winning some prize for each game” and say those odds “must be displayed on a Video Lottery game terminal screen.”' Curzi discovered that the odds displayed were not correct and the commission knew about it.
- hristov 12y agoThat is also very puzzling. It gives the above quote but it does not say whether these odds were actually displayed on the screen of this particular game, and it does not say which odds were displayed (the ones with using autohold or the ones without).
- ck2 12y agoI'm waiting for "quick pick" lotto draws to be reviled as not actually random but the machine picks numbers least likely to win because they recently won.
- ivanche 12y ago:) Lotto draws are independent so you have an equal chance of winning with any numbers.
- VLM 12y agoYou'd like to think they're independent and fair, but thats kind of the whole point of the article. To quote the state director in the article “I don’t think we’ve ever represented that the auto-hold gives you the optimal result,” he says. “The idea was that it gives you a good result.” You'll get a perfectly good result if the lotto balls are loaded. Might not be optimal, might not be random, but it'll be a good result, as in not some random negative integer or a float or wrong number of balls.
- ivanche 12y agoI agree with you that lottery might make lotto draws unfair. For example, they see in advance which combination of numbers is NOT played and somehow they cheat and draw exactely that numbers. Lottery can do that for several weeks in a row, thus making the prize pool bigger and bigger and atmosphere between players hotter and hotter. As a side bonus, lottery can use fresh cash (from stakes) for several weeks at 0% interest rate. But, can they really do it? Manipulating lotto balls and drum (mechanical devices really) is much harder than manipulating software behind some video poker game. I don't say it's impossible, but harder.
- ck2 12y agoYou are saying one week the numbers are 12 50 23 08 33 the the next week the odds are the same for the same numbers to be drawn? Because that is very counterintuitive if true.
- ivanche 12y agoI was developing online gambling games for 6 years and I'm totally on Justin Curzi's side here. Oh, and if anyone's interested in how those games are made feel free to AMA.
- chernevik 12y agoMy understanding is that state lotteries were initially justified as means of putting criminal numbers rackets out of business. People were going to play one way or the other, so give them an honest game and stop funding hoodlums. That makes sense. But there is no justification for state lotteries as revenue raising streams, nor for behavior maximizing those revenues. They shouldn't advertise and shouldn't be creating new games to increase their take. These are just taxes on mathematical illiteracy and risk factors for people with gambling problems. Of course, the revenues are more important to the politicians than the general interest, so here we are.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lnanek2 12y agoDon't even understand how this is an article, they flat out have a disclaimer: > Auto-hold strategies vary by game, based on the particular features of a game and do not necessarily result in theoretical payouts On smart phone games auto is often not the best strategy, just the easiest (Summoner's War with 30 million downloads, I'm looking at you). Sounds like the guy was just ignorant and thought auto was something it was specifically declaimed not to be. If it was labeled "Best" I might feel something for him.
- mwexler 12y ago... Or the guy was just like so many average humans and assumed that the machine was doing something more than randomly picking cards to hold. If the machine said it was auto-picking the worst cards, we'd all be mad. If the machine said it was randomly picking the cards, we'd all be surprised: why even do that? Who does it help? Therefore, from an implicatures pov, the only reason for the machine to pick cards (or "suggest" cards) is to recommend a good hand. Since the computer can often pick the best hand, why would we not assume that it's doing so, to give us mere humans "a fighting chance", so to speak? Why should we assume that it's not picking the computably best cards to hold, other than our belief that the machine "cheats"? And that's what the article examines. I don't think it's ignorance on our gambler's part; I think it's the standard "Black Hat UI" issue mentioned on HN so often: We assume that sw does somethign to maximize utility for the user, based on the design or experience, when it's instead doing something to maximize profit for some other entity. Yes, it's a gambling machine; we all understand that it's designed to take our money. But offering a feature as part of the experience that appears to help when it doesn't (or to a lesser degree than would be expected via presentation), would be deemed misleading by any reasonable person, small print and disclaimers aside.
- logfromblammo 12y agoI see a lot of comments here about suboptimal play. These are missing an important point. The machine is not playing poker. The machine is presenting a game that superficially resembles poker, to achieve a slot machine payout rate of 90%. As a slot machine, it is a game of chance, not skill. If the actual payout of a machine advertised as 90% is 85%, that is fraudulently advertised odds, period. So the lottery posts a notice on the machine that user interactivity may reduce the odds of winning. Relying on that information, everyone just hitting the "play" button like a robot--treating this particular type of slot machine like a regular, non-interactive slot machine--should realize the posted odds. They did not. The owner of the machine was aware of this. The Lottery made false statements to its customers, harming them by its deception and profiting in the process. That's fraud. It is true that the Auto-Hold function does not need to recommend the optimal Draw Poker play. IT MUST RECOMMEND THE PLAY THAT ACHIEVES THE ADVERTISED SLOT MACHINE PAYOUT.
- thedufer 12y agoIs anyone else horrified by that demographics chart? The "income" pie chart has a line that splits it almost perfectly in half, yet one side contains 61% and the other 39%. The 24% piece is clearly way over 1/4, and the 25% way under. Are they drawing these by hand?
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoNice catch.