10 ms·
Six-Legged Giant Finds Secret Hideaway, Hides for 80 Years (2012)
- bpodgursky 12y agoWhat I don't fully understand is, usually when scientists try to preserve rare species, there is a critical mass under which there isn't enough genetic diversity to preserve the species (I've seen ~30 quoted for some rare mammals). But in this case, just two individuals were able to start a viable population. Why are these insects different? I can only think of a couple reasons... - since these insects have a r-selection curve, it's ok if 90% of the offspring are genetic defects, you can always produce another 1,000 eggs - the insects had maintained such a small population for so long that any critical defects had been bred out But I'd be interested to hear from a real biologist. Edit: oops, meant r-selection, not k-selection
- uiri 12y agoThe article touches on this a little bit, I think. Eve's eggs were harvested, incubated (though it turns out only the first 30 were fertile) and became the foundation of the zoo's new population of walking sticks. I am not a real biologist, but I suspect it is some combination of the factors you suggest and that their genome may be simple enough that most defects make the eggs nonviable.
- ufo 12y agoInsects also have complex genomes. The egg fertility most likely has to do with other issues (differences between the natural habitat and captivity, maybe there is a natural tendency for not all eggs to be fertile, etc)
- jschwartzi 12y agoI wonder if the infertile eggs are a sort of decoy? Those eggs look like they might be large enough to make an attractive meal for a bird.
- ufo 12y agoNature is complicated. Not everything needs to have an adaptionist explanation.
- delecti 12y agoI'm not a biologist, but that probably hits the nail on the head, though judging by your comment I think you meant k-selection, and it's actually r-selection that pertains to the "spray and pray" approach to offspring. [1] There's also likely some luck involved that the initial two on that island happened to be viable colony starters. [1] http://www.bio.miami.edu/tom/courses/bil160/bil160goods/16_rKselection.html http://www.bio.miami.edu/tom/courses/bil160/bil160goods/16_r...
- philcrump 12y agoFrom the subtley linked 'Husbandry Manual': http://www.aszk.org.au/docs/lhisi.pdf http://www.aszk.org.au/docs/lhisi.pdf Section 3.2 (p8) The population at Melbourne Zoo, being descended from a single pair, appeared to experience increasing symptoms of inbreeding over two generations until four adult males were introduced, descended from a second pair held at Insektus in Sydney, and their genes began to have an influence. After new males were introduced, no further abnormalities were observed...
- PhasmaFelis 12y agoThat was still pretty interesting, I think. The Melbourne Zoo population ballooned after the four new males arrived: " the population at Melbourne Zoo, which hovered around 20 individuals at any time during the first three years of captive management, rose to 600 within 12 months of the males’ genes taking effect." Even though the four males were all descended from a single (different) pair. That means they got a stable breeding population out of only two breeding pairs! I really wouldn't have thought introducing a single extra pair of ancestors would have fixed everything so dramatically.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoI don't know; a 100% increase in whatever you've got is generally thought of as significant.
- mapt 12y agoIANARB, but- Minimum viable genetic diversity is not a particularly well-established or even objectively knowable metric. I think the relevant number is often vastly overstated, or at least stated without mentioning the strong and arbitrary assumptions that need to be made in determining it. Wikipedia says: "The cheetah has unusually low genetic variability. This is accompanied by a very low sperm count, motility, and deformed flagella.[14] Skin grafts between unrelated cheetahs illustrate the former point, in that there is no rejection of the donor skin. It is thought that the species went through a prolonged period of inbreeding following a genetic bottleneck during the last ice age. This suggests that genetic monomorphism did not prevent the cheetah from flourishing across two continents for thousands of years.[15]" Now - cheetahs are objectively less fit than they would have been without these population bottlenecks, but they're fit enough that they have not been outcompeted. They are probably highly vulnerable to contagion, though - maybe it's only a matter of time before something figures out how to wipe them out... but maybe not. Science isn't gonna be able to predict that one for you. Anything we can figure out how to breed in captivity, in a controlled environment without predators and with an abundant food supply, has very low pressure on it - these bugs could all have the insect equivalent of mental retardation and missing limbs and at least some of them could probably make it to successfully reproduce.
- arthurcolle 12y agowhat is the RB in your "I am not a..." ?
- jmiwhite 12y ago'Real Biologist', as requested by the parent.
- jonalmeida 12y agoOr possibly 'Research Biologist'.
- Retric 12y agoIt also relates to new mutations. An insect with 1,000 offspring might lose 95% of them and still be viable, but most birds or mammals would quickly go extinct if 95% of their offspring where non viable.
- pvaldes 12y agoAre different in a "parthenogenetic way". They can clone itselves if necessary. Thus, a single isolated female can lead to an unlimited population of females, all of them genetically identical to its mother, grand-mother etc. It seems that the species is not very worried with the idea of living with a low level of genetic combinations (and mutations can still occur increasing slowly the genetic diversity). great post.
- pvaldes 12y agowell, It seems that parthenogenesis is not still confirmed in this species. Is frequent among stick insects in any case.
- rcthompson 12y agoThe main short-term issue with inbreeding is the emergence of recessive traits. If there are few deleterious recessive traits in the genome of a species, then inbreeding will not be a major problem. In the long term, inbreeding is also a problem because it limits genetic diversity, which means anything with an adverse effect on one individual will adversely affect all individuals (the same problem as "monoculture" in software).
- learnstats2 12y agoIt's true that inbreeding of a small population results in deleterious recessive traits becoming more readily apparent. However, this would still normally apply only to a small percentage of offspring. As such, I would not expect inbreeding to affect the viability of an insect species at all. If they can produce a viable first generation, the large majority of that generation can produce a viable second generation. Mammals might have a harder time with inbreeding because they produce few children, and as such any problems are less likely to be resolved through another line.
- 1ris 12y agoLike most other people here I'm not a real biologist either, but incest does not need to be a problem. Almost all dog-races are the result of lots and lots of inbreeding. Ill effects of incest can be avoided with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_purging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_purging . In case there are only very few individuals left that's probably not what one wants to do, though.
- masklinn 12y agoIANAB but > there is a critical mass under which there isn't enough genetic diversity to preserve the species (I've seen ~30 quoted for some rare mammals) The Blue Book ("Viable Populations for Conservation") puts it between 50 and 1000 individuals for 95% probability of survival over 100 years, but it's highly variable between species and ecosystems on both intrinsic (r-strategy which you quoted) and historical grounds: for the second case, the Mauritius Kestrel was brought back from an effective population of 2 mated pairs. But its ecosystem has a carrying capacity of under 1000 individuals and it had already gone through several genetic bottlenecks. The weta are r-strategist anyway, Poor Knights wetas have clutches of 200~300 eggs.
- cfontes 12y agoThis has been here already a couple times... But it's amazing nonetheless.
- lgunsch 12y agoAlberta is rat free, and is kept that way. Its been rat free for over 50 years now. The border is patrolled to keep the rats out, and there is a hefty $5000 fine for keeping rats.
- ahelwer 12y agoQuestionable. Rat populations have been found at the Medicine Hat landfill, first in 2012 and again in 2014[1]. I guess it's a good sign that it makes national news when a population is found, but they're almost certainly present elsewhere. [1] http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/several-rats-spotted-at-medicine-hat-landfill-1.2602916 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/several-rats-spotted-a...
- lgunsch 12y agoYeah, those were big news then. I remember hearing about it. The goal is still definitely to be rat free, and they work hard to tray and keep it that way.
- goodcanadian 12y agoPerhaps, it is better to say "largely rat free." I grew up in eastern Alberta, and I certainly never saw a rat until I moved out of province as an adult.
- aetherson 12y agoI mean, I grew up in California, not even remotely rat free, and I think I've seen... three-ish... rats in my nearly 40 years? Besides pets or lab animals. Rats hide. Doesn't mean there aren't a fairly large number of them around.
- Crito 12y agoIf you've got a rat infestation in your building, it won't take long to figure it out even if you never see them. They have a tendency to cause a lot of damage and leave their shit all over the place.
- fillskills 12y agoIts always great to hear a positive story in conservation
- vex 12y agoThe title of this article is base clickbait...
- vlunkr 12y agoI can't exactly describe how, but it doesn't feel like clickbait. Maybe because it wasn't misleading, obviously it wasn't going to be about real six-legged giant, so I assumed it was an animal or something.
- matt_morgan 12y agoRight. It turned out that it was /actually a good title for the article/.
- jordan0day 12y agoI disagree -- there's no question mark at the end of the title, nor any credulity-challening with "You won't believe what happened next!" I think this is just a well-written headline. Or, to think of it another way: It's only clickbait if the headline is more interesting then the actual article. For this article, that's not the case at all.
- lucb1e 12y agoWhat I find interesting about the paper[1], regarding housing: > "[include] a jar of water. There is no need to cover the top of the jar, as LHISIs generally do not drown themselves as other insects do, except for very small nymphs on very rare occasions." So I guess being stuck on a rock surrounded by water taught them to avoid falling into the water, unlike apparently other (land-based) insects. [1] http://www.aszk.org.au/docs/lhisi.pdf http://www.aszk.org.au/docs/lhisi.pdf
- ars 12y agoThey are also much much larger than most insects, that's helps too. And strong enough to defeat surface tension.
- nathanb 12y agoAre there any updates to this story? How is the de-ratification going? A few searches did not turn up anything that seemed like a useful update.
- ForHackernews 12y agoHere's a slightly more recent article from August 2012: http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/running-ponies/2012/08/22/lord-howe-island-stick-insects-are-going-home/ http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/running-ponies/2012/08/2... It says that they've established a captive population of giant stick insects on Lord Howe, and they were planning to start eradicating rodents this year: "The plan is to eradicate the rats and mice from conservation areas on Lord Howe Island in 2015, and then reintroduce the captive-bred stick insects, and their natural predators – a sub-species of boobook owl. This AU$9 million project has just been approved last month, as announced by Federal Environment Minister Tony Burke and NSW Environment Minister Robyn Parker. According to the government press release, they hope to wipe out more than 130,000 rodents using poison baits, some dropped by air, in allocated conservation areas. Special ‘arks’ will be used to protect native, endangered species until the rodents are gone."
- compto35 12y agoHow do you get rats off an island? My grandmother showed me…
- gamegoblin 12y agoFor anyone who is confused, compto35 is referencing this chilling monologue from the James Bond film "Skyfall" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0dFsAtAlEo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0dFsAtAlEo
- miander 12y agoI'm not sure why, but this brought a tear to my eye. Those insects are beautiful in their own way.
- dEnigma 12y agoSame for me, it's mostly the romantic element of the lone survivors hidden on that unreal island.
- grondilu 12y agoI'm all for preserving endangered species and all, but frankly these insects scare the hell out of me and if I was anywhere close to one of them I may run away, screaming like a little girl. I believe I'm not very exceptional a person thus I suspect they'll have difficulties convincing people to have this species reintroduced on any inhabited island.
- jusben1369 12y ago'screaming like a small child" perhaps is better.
- ars 12y ago> screaming like a small child" perhaps is better. Why is that better? Have you never heard a little girl scream? It's not the same as the sound of a little boy. Let's not let political correctness wash away every difference that makes individuals special.
- dnewms 12y agoSince voices don't change until puberty -- any kid screaming sounds the same. And in the vein of special individuals, there are little girls who love and hate insects, and little boys who love and hate insects. Perhaps a more original phrase or analogy would be better: I would scream like a Dryococelus australis being attacked by rats.
- ars 12y ago> Since voices don't change until puberty -- any kid screaming sounds the same. Apparently you have not met any. They don't sound anything alike, except maybe as newborns. > there are little girls who love and hate insects He just said scream like a little girl, there was no connotation of girls hating or loving insects. Just a sound.
- timv 12y ago
- jonalmeida 12y ago> Where, they wondered, did that poop come from? The question that drives scientists to do what they do.
- dghughes 12y agoAs well as parents and dog owners.
- jheriko 12y agoi'm in two minds about this. on the one hand, this is evolution in action, the habitat for this animal was decreased by the presence of a successful predator. on the other, rats have no sympathy from me, and we have plenty of them around, so why not wipe them out to allow insects to flourish? somehow killing a bunch of rats to allow a failed species to reclaim its territory seems wrong. so i lean towards letting this insect take its chances in its tiny little habitat. if we were talking about exterminating people to make room for any of the species we have destroyed it would be a no-brainer...
- glesica 12y agoBut it wasn't natural competition, we brought the rats there. I guess you can argue that the actions of humans are just as "natural" as any others. However, I think this is a very foolish way of looking at the situation because we act based on intelligence, not instinct. Competition only "works" when everyone is playing by the same rules. This means that we throw off the equilibrium for the rest of the planet because we play by different rules. In fact, our intelligence is such that I don't even think we're playing the same game any more.
- jheriko 12y agoits not just that we brought the rats there, its that rats are so well adapted to being transported by people that they spread with us and succeed in diverse habitats. keeping that island rat free is going to be a constant battle, because rats are so good at spreading by using our transportation as a vector. like i say, i'm in two minds... i do think its incredibly sad to wipe out a species by introducing another like this. we lose something really special and unique. i just can't give equal weight to the argument because its so flooby dooby and driven by emotion rather than sensiblity. also, i don't think we play by different rules... we classically out compete every other species in almost every habitat. we are the pinnacle of evolution today. the fallout of our actions are nature in action, despite the temptation to treat humans with some special place of privilege in the natural order of things... that being said, our alturism is part of that success, and is ultimately the source for the feeling argument.
- habi 12y agoThere's a very nice animation short on Vimeo about the story: https://vimeo.com/76647062 https://vimeo.com/76647062
- pvaldes 12y agoThe idea is not to change disgusting black rats by disgusting black huge insects, in fact is more complex. If we could wipe rats and restore the unique ecosystem some other species could re-flourish again. Like this fligthless bird, the Lord Howe Island Woodhen, only 15 of those birds remained in 1980 in the world, about 300 birds currently: http://m2.i.pbase.com/o6/21/489821/1/146964222.sYTnvRRL.DSC_9444.jpg http://m2.i.pbase.com/o6/21/489821/1/146964222.sYTnvRRL.DSC_... Or this beautiful endemic stag bettle http://blog-imgs-46-origin.fc2.com/a/r/c/arc6464/20111120214347443.jpg http://blog-imgs-46-origin.fc2.com/a/r/c/arc6464/20111120214... this exclusive snail: http://www.lordhowe-tours.com.au/images/snail_survey.jpg http://www.lordhowe-tours.com.au/images/snail_survey.jpg some birds will benefit also http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/ff/Lord_Howe_Silvereye.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/ff/Lord_Howe... http://www.barraimaging.com.au/Birds-By-Country/BirdsOfAustralia-1/Passerines/Whistlers-and-Allies/Australian-Golden-Whistler/i-dLTbqQX/0/L/Australian%20Golden%20Whistler%20Male%20%28%20Pachycephala%20pectoralis%20%29%20Ssp%20contempta%20Lord%20Howe%20NSW%20May%202011%20AU-AUGW-11-L.jpg http://www.barraimaging.com.au/Birds-By-Country/BirdsOfAustr... http://www.avesphoto.com/website/pictures/TLTGRY-2.jpg http://www.avesphoto.com/website/pictures/TLTGRY-2.jpg and also this big bush cockroach: http://lordhowe-tours.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/Cockroach_small.jpg http://lordhowe-tours.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/Cock... And also other 950 endemic species