7 ms·
This is sad, and not entirely unexpected. Look for a large number of websites to go under just like Gigaom. Oddly enough, the reason these folks are failing is
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
This is sad, and not entirely unexpected. Look for a large number of websites to go under just like Gigaom.
Oddly enough, the reason these folks are failing is that Google's CPC (the money they get for an advertising "click") has gone down Year over Year for the last 13 quarters. What that means is that if your web site depended on advertising from Google (and most do), and your traffic remained constant, you have seen a 33% drop in gross revenue over that same period. Google doesn't call out their click fraud numbers, but they do improve their ability to detect it over time, which means your "quality" click through rate has been going down as well, for a double whammy. So unless you can improve volume, you die. In their Q4 report[1] they make this note:
Network paid clicks, which include clicks related to ads served on non-Google properties participating in our AdSense for Search, AdSense for Content, and AdMob businesses, decreased approximately 11% over the fourth quarter of 2013 and decreased approximately 7% over the third quarter of 2014.
A third less advertising revenue on a 11% fewer clicks over all? Serious pain.
As of the fourth quarter, Google also mentions it is paying nearly a billion dollars a quarter ($968M) to get search traffic. If you're a GigaOm and your traffic is already generating less revenue and fewer clicks are getting through, you can't really add insult to injury by paying people to send you traffic.
[1] http://investor.google.com/earnings/2014/Q4_google_earnings.html http://investor.google.com/earnings/2014/Q4_google_earnings....
- petercooper 12y agoI've seen YouTubers complaining about this too. One I follow (who has over 2m subscribers) says his views are up strongly in the past year (as in over 50% more) but his income has fallen by a third.
- neurotech1 12y agoOn a popular space webcast, TMRO, the host mentioned their YouTube revenue was a "rounding error" compared to their revenue through Patreon (https://www.patreon.com/tmro https://www.patreon.com/tmro). They get $1000+ per episode.
- tomjen3 12y agoWhen did YouTube start using these really annoying video ads? Because it seem at that point that my non-technical aquentiences started to install adblockers. And it seems that youtube users use Patreon now.
- petersouth 12y agoMy adsense money went from $1000/yr to $100/yr and now I'll be lucky if I break $25. Nothing changed with my users. My only guess is that everyone is using adblock.
- tomrod 12y agoDo you see adblock as a bad thing?
- petersouth 12y agoI use it, but it wasn't until my money went away that I thought much about it. I definitely have less incentive to keep it going. I'd need to go through the hassle of getting more dedicated advertisers or sponsors now. So in that respect it's bad for websites in general.
- muyuu 12y agoAt least you're honest about not giving a flying one until it was your bottom line that tanked.
- gitah 12y agoYou're right about ad block. Ad block grew an insane amount (300%) in the past two years: http://i.imgur.com/XIf0JRW.png http://i.imgur.com/XIf0JRW.png
- Scoundreller 12y agoThe graph shows it currently as being at 5%. I really doubt any browser will start installing it by default, so I think adblock will be limited to: a) Really technical people (HNers) b) Friends of HNers that are bothered enough by the real web experience while on their friend's systems that they go ahead and install adblockers. I don't see adblockers covering more than 10% of web users, and they're likely the least valuable 10% of web users (they may earn a lot, but they don't have burning holes in their pockets either).
- brownbat 12y agoSo here's a pesky theory that pops into my mind every time I hear a story like this. I really hope everyone will say it's crazy, though, because the consequences are pretty dire. Advertising is good at selling some products, but advertisers are spectacular at selling advertising. So we've had almost a century-long bubble in bullshit. The best way you outsell other advertisers, masters of bullshit themselves, all spinning how effective their ad is, is by selling metrics alongside your advertising. Metrics are the anti-bullshit. Well, almost... You want something that looks like "actual sales caused." You want to tell a guy, "pay me $10 per ad, and I will generate 10 sales, each giving you $2 profit you wouldn't have otherwise made. We'll split the winnings." You want to claim metrics for sales caused, but you don't really want those exact numbers, you kind of want something that looks hard that you can spin. Something loosely correlated with "actual sales caused" where your art of bullshitting can get slightly better returns than the exact numbers would get. Play to your strengths, right? So magazines come along with subscription numbers, and that's great sauce. Then television comes along with the Nielsen family and, ok, actually Nielsen starts way back with radio in the 1920s, but same idea. Radio/television advertising reaches the most people and every company starts to pay a premium. Advertisers have the whole industry sliced, diced, catalogued and formulated. Superbowl is the premium end, free weeklies are the bottom of the barrel. Everybody has a place, but everyone's using the same game to guess at eyeballs, to guess at actual sales caused. Suddenly, though, there's this new game on the internet. Not a lot of eyeballs at first, so it starts in free weekly category. Suddenly though, Google (and maybe some other companies) can tell you how many ads are actually getting action rather than just eyeballs. It's a metric like we've never seen before, it's the killer metric. Sure, you could get this from surveys, or test markets, but this is like measuring everyone who sees the ad. It's pretty cool. But remember, metrics this accurate are dangerous, it shows when advertising doesn't work too. And a lot of advertising is spin, a lot of it isn't all that great, because advertisers are better at selling ads than they are at selling your product. I hope someone tells me this is all nonsense, though, because if it's true, then Internet advertising is both absorbing the advertising industry then destroying it. That'd be sad. I mean, sure, it's showing us which of our emperors are already naked. But it might mean the constant death of random content sites like this.
- 001sky 12y ago
- beedogs 12y agoWhat this tells me is that if you're running a website that uses Google advertising as your primary source of revenue, you should probably sell up now and get out while the getting is good. Ad-based sites simply cannot survive anymore.
- filmgirlcw 12y agoGoogle AdSense stopped being a viable source of ad income for even large-traffic publishers more than 6 years ago. To be clear: as-based sites can absolutely survive, but you need a sales team and good as-ops. The best CPMs are going to come from sales people getting deals done, not algorithms and text ads. That market died in 2008.
- adventured 12y agoThat's obviously false. Whether you can survive on ads is strictly based on your cost of operations. The Internet is overflowing with ad-based sites, and will continue to be. Some will die, the radical majority will not. Five years from now there will be more ad supported sites than there are today. The alternative to Google is to run your own advertising. This is especially true for sites with the scale of Gigaom.
- Scoundreller 12y agoWell, you'd have to try to provide something that Google can't, like "native advertising". But any respectable organization would not run native. Google is simply too good at matching viewers to advertising that is valuable to them (and therefore the publisher). Running your own advertising is hard to be successful with, unless you can convince your advertiser to really overpay.
- filmgirlcw 12y ago>Google is simply too good at matching viewers to advertising that is valuable to them (and therefore the publisher). This is so wrong, I don't even know where to start. Google is very good at managing ad inventory and putting ads from said inventory in front of people. What they aren't good at (or even care about being good at) is getting the right inventory mix for the right site. That requires focused sales teams. I'm not going to go down the native advertising rabbit hole because I don't have time ro have the conversation it needs to have, but I will say that whatever you think it is, it's both better and worse than that. And everyone who is successful in publishing does it to some extent, maybe just by a different name. And it's not new. It's been happening since the beginning of mass media. I can understand not liking advertorials or content that is unclear, but there are not plenty of people making native advertising that doesn't interfere with editorial missions. >Running your own advertising is hard to be successful with, unless you can convince your advertiser to really overpay. Again, this is not true. For a small publisher, running your ads is probably not worth the tech or sales investment. If you're the scale of a GigaOm, you need to take control of your ad game yourself. You can supplement sith ad networks, but the real money comes from doing it yourself. And with good ad ops, you can also provide a way better experience for the ad buyer. Again, we're not talking about small one person publishers. We're talking t about sites that do millions of uniques and have full staff. If you're doing that and not maintaininf tour own sales staff, you're leaving money on the table, incompetent, or you have a product no one wants. Or all three.
- jusben1369 12y agoI assume that's driven by the consumption of content switching to mobile from desktop?
- ZoF 12y agoWhat makes you assume that? Just curious.
- prawn 12y agoI wonder if the transition of readers to mobile can make life hard for content companies monetised through ads? In a typical content site on a large screen, you have loads of opportunities to incorporate advertising. On a mobile screen, you have far less space.
- detaro 12y agoIt would also be interesting how the adblock ratios are for both. My full machines have adblock running for most pages, on mobile I don't.
- Scoundreller 12y agoOn the plus side, it is far more difficult to install an ad-blocker on a mobile device. Most adblockers are not on the computers of the HN-type, but rather installed by HN-type people on their friends computers. (ie: I've probably installed them on 5-10 systems). However, I probably wouldn't bother installing it on friend's phones/tablets, since I use mine, not their's. On the negative side, mobile ads should pay less, since I'm less likely to whip out my credit card and buy something big/profitable on it. At least that is me anyway.
- prostoalex 12y agoUntil there's a clear path to buy something, CPCs on mobile screens are going to be worth fractions of their Web counterparts. Current e-commerce experience on the mobile is "fiddle with your phone while trying to type up your account information, shipping address and billing data", so conversion rates are understandable abysmal, leaving mobile ad space to people promoting app installs.
- coldpie 12y agoAdvertisement providers that work in mobile really need to get their shit together. Ads that redirect the app store are utterly unacceptable and ludicrously common. Audio ads seem less common, but are just as unacceptable. I browsed without an ad blocker on mobile for a year or two before I got so fed up with the malware bullshit that I switched to Firefox for Android with ABP installed. Advertisers have no one but themselves to blame for the prevalence of ad blocking software.
- Scoundreller 12y ago> Oddly enough, the reason these folks are failing is that Google's CPC (the money they get for an advertising "click") has gone down Year over Year for the last 13 quarters. What that means is that if your web site depended on advertising from Google (and most do), and your traffic remained constant, you have seen a 33% drop in gross revenue over that same period. All it means is a 33% drop per click, not per thousand visitors, or gross revenue over a same period. As Google gets better at matching ads to users, CPC would be expected to go down, since there would be more clicks, and each click would therefore be less valuable, but there would be more clicks overall. As a micro-publisher, the first question that friends ask to satisfy their curiosity is "How much do you get paid per click", and I have to answer that total revenue is all that really matters, not revenue per click. Shouldn't improving fraud detection increase click quality?
- ChuckMcM 12y ago> All it means is a 33% drop per click, not per > thousand visitors, or gross revenue over a same period. Actually it does. Allow me to explain. In a purely statistical way, for any given web page getting 'n' views, and to keep our units consistent we will define pageviews/1000 as its traffic or T. Some fraction of those views will include an ad click. This is the 'Click through rate', and it can be calculated per thousand page view to get a 'CPM' or clicks per thousand. If you are an AdSense advertiser, Google will tell you what the CTR is for each page on your website that has AdSense ads on it. Each click gets some amount of money, this is the 'cost per click' or CPC. The product of those three, is Revenue per thousand or RPM, so RPM = T * CTR * CPC If you multiply CPC by .66 (down by 33%) that multiplication goes right through to RPM. (or revenue). Regardless of how much traffic you are getting. If Google got better at matching ads to users, then your click through rate (CTR) would go up because the ads would be more appropriate to what the viewer was looking for or interested in. It would not affect the cost per click which is what the advertiser is paying Google, you would just get more clicks per thousand. Web site publishers really only have two things to try to optimize, click through rate and total traffic. If you have heard the term 'click bait' it specifically refers to ways that a web site tries to increase its click through rate by making it more likely you will click on a link (or advertisement). This is the number a web site has under its control. It can also buy AdWords to put its content at the top of search results, or pay a company like OutBrain to put a link to its content at the bottom of an article, both of these are called buying traffic because you are paying someone (Google or the site running Outbrain 'ads') if someone clicks on that link and comes to your web site. If the amount of traffic increase * CTR * CPM (your marginal revenue gain) is greater than the amount you spent to get the traffic, then it is a good deal for you. However, for more and more people that number is negative, they just lose money faster because their ad revenue is going down and the amount they keep is further reduced by the cost of the traffic they bought. And to your final question, yes fraud detection does improve click quality but that hasn't been reflected in advertisers willing to pay more to advertise as Google's sinking CPC number shows.
- deepfriedbits 12y agoAbsolutely. I run a rather large (non-tech) site that doubled in traffic from Feb 2015 vs. Feb 2014 and AdSense revenues were actually down about 6% year over year. Uniques and pageviews were way up, click-through rate was near constant, but CPC got clobbered. It's incredibly frustrating and I can only imagine we'll see a great thinning of the herd across verticals very soon.
- nikcub 12y ago> if your web site depended on advertising from Google They are dependent on Google DoubleClick, but not on Google's CPC product. I'd be surprised if AdWords/CPC made up 5% of GigaOm revenue (it would look more like: 50% conference business, 45% display ads, 5% other ads). CPC is used as backfill on display - right now GigaOM have campaigns from Verizon, Tile and Asana running.
- nazgul 12y agoIf you're doing this for a living the last thing you should be doing is relying on Google ads. The publications that make money at this have sales staffs (and much higher CPMs, and no CLC campaigns)