11 ms·
Curt Schilling Fights Back Against Daughter’s Twitter Trolls
- junto 12y agoPeople who get caught doing this need to be prosecuted, and if convicted, labeled as sexual criminals and placed on a register. Employers should be able to see the kinds of people they are employing or about to employ. As a father myself, this kind of behaviour makes me sick and I cannot understand people who feel they need to defend these kinds of sick comments.
- senorprogrammer 12y agoToo many people seem to misunderstand that 'freedom of speech' does not mean 'freedom from repercussions'. Pretty glad to read jobs had been lost as a result of this.
- DownvoteMeToWin 12y agoToo many people seem to think they are the moral authority on what reprocussions are appropriate.
- xorcist 12y agoNot at all. Should you not be free to hire and fire your employees depending on who you want to represent your company? Or are you advocating some sort of affirmative action for asshats?
- mikegioia 12y agoYou're totally right. If I managed a team of employees and I saw this in the news the next day, there's no way I would keep that person employed. On an unrelated note, I think you win the best username award :P
- DownvoteMeToWin 12y agoYou made pixels, therefore, you lose your job. Stalin called. He wants his regime back.
- benihana 12y agoToo many people seem to justify their lynch ochlocratic actions on the internet by saying "freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from repercussions."
- chris_wot 12y agoToo many people seem to justify their disgusting and mysogynistic comments by saying "I have a right to free speech".
- sanoli 12y agoThere's a difference between "freedom from legal repercussions", and "if you tweet this people all over will think you're a scumbag and maybe even a creep, and in the real world this has repercussions that don't have to involve the justice system".
- japhyr 12y agoAlso, I believe a person's freedom of speech ends when speech creates a real threat to another person's safety. These kinds of tweets definitely create a threat to the recipient's safety.
- pulmo 12y agoIn that case the boundaries of freedom are not defined by the constitution any more, but by private parties. Therefore any constitutional stipulation of 'freedom of speech' is practically worthless. Freedom can not only be measured by the existence of a constitutional construct.
- jschwartzi 12y agoWhen it's between two private parties, you're damn right that the boundaries of freedom are defined by those two parties. Freedom of Speech only applies to the government and to government use of force. I'm sure the guys who penned the constitution would agree that it wasn't about giving you the freedom to act like a jackass without repercussions.
- crazypyro 12y agoBehavior is obviously not right, but is it really harming someone else's rights? I'm having a hard time jumping from sexual innuendos to sexual predators... I think it would be a massive mistake to try to make into a crime. Although many of these tweets clearly cross the line of tastelessness, how many sexual jokes/innuendos are less obvious and more controversial about whether they are tasteless? We don't need to criminalize this. Nobody's rights are being violated, in my opinion. We shouldn't be using the criminal system unless there is a clear threat of violence, not just some internet trolls trying to get a reaction out of a celebrity....
- japhyr 12y agoThese are not innuendos, these are threats.
- crazypyro 12y agoOh give me a break... the most offensive/threatening one that was posted by Kurt on his blog was: "Teach me your knuckleball technique so I can fist your daughter" You really think this is a creditable threat of violence and not someone trying to make a very, very, very poor taste joke? There are very few tweets I would even consider threats, most were just scumbags trying to get some twitter fame by making terrible baseball sexual innuendos. There are other ones like "Kurt bleeds more from his sock than gaby does when shes on her period" that in no way could even be construed as a threat, but I feel they are getting lumped into the same category, simply because they are distasteful.
- phpnode 12y agoThis is the same kind of deluded apologism that the gamer gate crowd uses and it is dangerous. How can anyone judge the credibility of a threat made by a stranger on the internet? A threat is a threat.
- foogoespop 12y agoI haven't read through the tweets but what crazypyro posted aren't threats, they would be considered bullying though. Didn't the gamergate lady have actual threats on her life? I know her information was doxxed and people actually put her house in their threats.
- mbrutsch 12y agoSchilling is just being a crybaby, and you are flat insane. Man up, for Christ's sake, and stop being little babies!
- pulmo 12y agoYes lets ruin people's life for a tweet written in 20 seconds of mental derangement. Insane.
- javajosh 12y agoThat's not what happened. If you read the original blog post, you'll see a sustained, violent screed directed at him and his daughter. It wasn't one tweet, it was a series of tweets over a period of many days. Did this ruin anyone's life? Doubtful. Losing your job is not the end of the world. And you know what? These are young kids. My hope is that this is a serious wake-up call for them to take adult responsibility for themselves.
- appleflaxen 12y agoSexual criminals? really? for words on twitter? There is no question that this kind of behavior is repugnant, but should it really be illegal? The tweets I read are abhorrent, but hardly credible threats. To me, the best kind of sanction for this is exactly what's happening: social shaming and exclusion. But it falls quite a bit short of something that requires legal involvement.
- mikegioia 12y agoI totally agree, the right course of action here is just good ol' fashioned public shaming. There's really no reason to bring the judicial system into this as it would be very taxing on that system to prosecute this type of behavior. A good deterrent to making these kind of public comments is the social pressure of others around you knowing that you in fact act/think this horrible way.
- eveningcoffee 12y agoYes, for words on twitter. We should not live in the world where any kind of rape threat is tolerable. Period. This, or threat of murder or serious injury should be not acceptable in any form.
- benihana 12y ago>People who get caught doing this need to be prosecuted, and if convicted, labeled as sexual criminals and placed on a register. Ridiculous. Maybe we should prosecute people who talk about overthrowing the government on twitter with treason - they're threats! And safety is important! These threats on the internet aren't acceptable, but neither is your reaction to them. There is a vast difference between threatening someone and actually doing something, and the way our criminal justice system treats sexual crimes borders on cruel and unusual. You're saying that someone should have the rest of their life ruined because they made a lewd threat on the internet? We've all heard the story of the kid who went streaking on a dare but happened to be near a playground so now he's labeled a sexual predator for the rest of his life. Do you really think that is a good response to this kind of thing? >As a father myself, this kind of behaviour makes me sick and I cannot understand people who feel they need to defend these kinds of sick comments. Punishing someone won't ease the anxiety you feel about the safety of your kids; there will always be something else waiting to ruin their innocence. You probably confuse people saying your reaction to these comments is extreme with people defending the comments. Regardless, you want to label someone a sexual predator so that you can feel better about the fact that you're scared for your kids. That is disgusting and scarier to me than anonymous threats to my family on the internet.
- intortus 12y agoI think you're engaging in the common fallacy of dismissing things that happen on the internet as "not real." It's long past time we, as a society, grew out of such childish thinking.
- gk1 12y agoAs parent pointed out, these things occur in "real life" and are no less extreme. Streaking, being underage and sexting, having consensual relationships with someone slightly younger but under the age of consent, etc.
- je_bailey 12y agoYou read his statement different then I did. He's not saying that people who makes these statements be labelled as sex offenders. He's saying that people who make these statements be brought to task. If a law has been violated, then charged, and if the court determines there is reason to label them as a sex offender, then so be it.
- lukasm 12y agoI'm afraid the result will be the same as file sharing. There was Napster which was killed by labels, then Kazza which was 10x harder to kill, then torrents which are 100x harder to kill. If they manage to kill it something new will be there. The solution is quite simple: if you're not willing to ignore trolls, don't use this kind of social network. You should NOT drag your family into the business, not even if PR person will tell you that it increases your brand equity.
- eloff 12y agoI'm surprised people are defending these guys. Maybe we're just so used to internet trolls, but the medium doesn't change the fact that we have laws against hate speech and threats. This kind of behavior is just not acceptable, it's a stain on the human race. It's these kinds of trolls that make life really difficult for women online. I'm glad they're learning there's consequences.
- pjc50 12y agoYou know, there are kinds of law enforcement response between "ignore it entirely" and "destroy someone's life forever".
- analog31 12y agoAgreed. I think a reasonable compromise would be to create a unique distinction such as "online harassment" and "online sexual harassment" at misdemeanor and felony levels depending on the severity of the offense.
- junto 12y agoI can't edit my comment above anymore so I'll add my addendum here. I am saddened by the responses I have seen below from HNers. The story relates to sexual threats of violence and rape of a minor. I stated that the offenders should be prosecuted and IF CONVICTED dealt with strictly under the applicable laws. Our society is slipping into a nasty place where people feel that it is quite appropriate and acceptable to threaten and harass others online. I think that it is a practice that needs to be stamped out, regardless of whether the threats are by men against women or vice versa; racial, homophobic or religious. It shouldn't be tolerated by the mainstream, which when you look on twitter, often appears to be the case.
- DownvoteMeToWin 12y agoAs a father, I have warned my daughter about the Ring of Gyges. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_of_Gyges http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_of_Gyges Look, at the end of the day, it's pixels. You can't even prove that posters are humans or robots on Twitter. Taking umbrage over a Turing-suspicious medium reeks of middle class moral panic and, in my opinion, has no business being on HN.
- graeme 12y ago>You can't even prove that posters are humans or robots on Twitter. Did you read the article? Schilling found at least nine real humans. They've been suspended or fired. Some will go to jail. They were real men making sexual threats to his daughter, thinking they were anonymous. They weren't. Lots of women online face threats like Schilling's daughter received. Women in the tech industry face stuff like this. I'd say it's relevant.
- DownvoteMeToWin 12y agoAnd did you read the article with the precise number of "people" doing this? Oh, thats right. No number on that. But let's celebrate the "justice" of 9 people and their mean pixels being stopped forever. Every human being on the internet gets harassed and if you read about the Ring of Gyges before spouting MSNBC memes for HN points, you'd know why. Stop your puritanical crusade. No one will care after 2016.
- lizzard 12y agoI doubt anyone will go to jail from this, or even face charges, but it will be interesting to see that unfold.
- DownvoteMeToWin 12y agoHEEERE COMES THE NARRATIVE DOWNVOTE, ALL ABOARD!!!!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- japhyr 12y agoFor a fuller context, and to get a better sense of why people are taking his actions seriously, take a look at the original post Schilling wrote where he explains how ugly it got: https://38pitches.wordpress.com/2015/03/01/the-world-we-live-in-man-has-it-changed/ https://38pitches.wordpress.com/2015/03/01/the-world-we-live...
- bargl 12y agoThank you for this link. I just found out about the Theta Xi Member who was doing this. I'm a member and I'll be seeking his full removal from the fraternity. It's not much but it is what I can do.
- chris_wot 12y agoGood on you. What your member did was beyond vile. I have a young daughter, and I'm appalled there are people out there who would event think these things!
- mbrutsch 12y agoYes, please, let's start policing thoughts.
- chris_wot 12y agoNobody is policing thoughts. A tweet is not a "thought".
- bargl 12y agoJust as an update, this guy has been permanently suspended from the fraternity, which is basically the equivalent to an expulsion from a school. I'm also happy to report that this action was already being taken before I voiced my concern.
- pmorici 12y agoToo bad he doesn't go into how he managed to track the 9 people down who he called out. Was he able to do it because he is a famous baseball player and has the resources and connections to make it happen or is it something any normal person on the street can do to stand up for themselves?
- lizzard 12y agoThis is someone anyone can do, or at least give it a shot. Have a look at this article on how to investigate identity online. It gives some thought to risk assessment and ethical behavior in responding to situations like this. https://modelviewculture.com/pieces/investigation-online-gathering-information-to-assess-risk https://modelviewculture.com/pieces/investigation-online-gat...
- cpncrunch 12y agoAlso, if they are actually posting something that is criminal, you can report it to the police and they can very easily track the person down.
- ceejayoz 12y agoIt's remarkable how little Internet trolls do to conceal their identities. I see amazingly bigoted stuff posted under real names on the local newspaper's comment section.
- lambda 12y agoMost of these people, I'm sure, had their real name on the account, or had their account linked to from some page with their real name, so Googling for their handle would easily find it. At that point, as he mentioned, many of these people were college athletes, so their names would also show up on rosters and various campus newspaper accounts of games. While it is possible to harass anonymously if you try, it's pretty likely that many of these people didn't even try; they just didn't think and said the first thing that came to mind that they knew would get a rise out of Curt Schilling.
- cubano 12y agoI think it is sort of sad that Curt took a moment of achievement for his daughter and turned it in to something about him.
- chris_wot 12y agoHe didn't.
- reitanqild 12y agoAnd here folks I guess we have a real case of harassment. I think there is a line to be drawn somewhere between here and pycon (two men talking privately about something that could be understood as offensive). That said I am surprised about two things: * People trying to argue that this should not be punished because everyone would do if they were safe from repercussions. I strongly believe that a big chunk of the audience here would not steal, kill etc without reason even if they were sure not to get caught. * People suggesting this should be in public registers etc. This story is most likely already a real problem for a few of those guys. Side note: They are not alone. I've recently been reading several seemingly normal grown up people signed in with facebook accounts stating how they think a certain country should be nuked. Edit: as tzakrajs points out these incidents are completely different and that was actually what I meant but I fully understand why it could be read as "a line connecting those incidents." My bad.
- tzakrajs 12y agoThe incident at PyCon: Conversation interloper becomes offended on behalf of non-present female children by the contents of a conversation that she was interloping. PyCon staff of course will be sycophantic with upset guests because they hate bad press. The PyCon incident was a moment of incalculable oversensitivity and probably should just be forgotten when considering the spectrum for which you hope to draw a line on.
- reitanqild 12y agoSorry, my bad: the line was supposed to divide between those point, not to join them. Thanks for the comment! I fully agree that these to events are totally different (and that was kind of my point, -to separate between victims of real harassment and professional victims.)
- lambda 12y agoPyCon staff of course will be sycophantic with upset guests because they hate bad press. All the PyCon staff did was talk to the developer in question, mention that the comments had offended someone, and left it there. That's pretty much exactly what I would expect them to do. That was confirmed by the developer in question: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5412553 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5412553 There were plenty of overreactions in that case; Adria Richards for choosing to publicly shame rather than either talk privately with the developers in question or simply bring it to the PyCon organizers' attention, Play Haven for choosing to fire him over such a minor incident rather than simply giving him a warning, SendGrid for choosing to fire Adria rather than try to work with her to try and bring her behavior more into line with acceptable public relations, and a large number of people on the internet for going way beyond the boundaries of civil behavior in harassing people on both sides of the debate. But among all of those over-reactions, from all accounts, the PyCon organizers behaved eminently reasonably.
- javajosh 12y agoThe big message here to victims is that you are not powerless if you are threatened online. To perpetrators, you will be held accountable for your actions. "Violent threats" are not free speech, never have been. Philosophically, I think there's a long overdue conversation to be had about non-physical harm. Our kids know how to treat cuts and bruises, or how to get help with a broken bone. But what about damage that gets caused inside? If you think about it, not only is the old "sticks and stones" mantra false, it's downright misleading. What's the worst pain you've ever experienced? Was it caused by physical pain, or words?
- vezzy-fnord 12y ago"Violent threats" are not free speech, never have been. Thankfully, this is not an absolute fact, as otherwise people (including many activists) would be routinely jailed for obvious rhetorical techniques said in jest: http://law.justia.com/constitution/us/amendment-01/43-threats-of-violence.html http://law.justia.com/constitution/us/amendment-01/43-threat...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nothrabannosir 12y agoA lot of people feel these threats should be taken seriously, and the law should be involved. I don't know what to think of this situation, but I want to ask you a question. Without irony or snark: How do you feel about the threats of violence made by Curt against those people?
- czottmann 12y agoI didn't read it like threats of violence. It was stating a fact: _"If I were a violent person, I could be at your doorstep in less than 4 hours"_ Then he explained that's not an option for him.
- a3n 12y agoIt struck me that he was doing something similar to what he's complaining about.
- lambda 12y agoAs he said in his blog post (https://38pitches.wordpress.com/2015/03/01/the-world-we-live-in-man-has-it-changed/ https://38pitches.wordpress.com/2015/03/01/the-world-we-live...), he considered the first couple of comments just harmless joking around, and that's what his "threats of violence" were as well. I want to date your daughter, I want to take your daughter to prom, I want to hit on your daughter etc., those? Those are guys being dopes and saying what guys say. This stuff? This is so far off the radar it’s pathetic. It's pretty easy to read his "i have many friends that are in or former special forces....." in the same light; joking around, maybe pushing the boundaries a bit but nothing that's egregious. It's a pretty normal response from a father to someone who's being a bit too forward with his daughter. Graphic descriptions of rape and violence against a minor are a completely different ballpark. Should he not have made the "special forces" comment? Maybe. That's what showed people that they could get under his skin by making comments about his daughter, so some people took that and escalated quickly. But I don't think anyone would read that as any actual threat, and the people who escalated and graphically described raping his daughter are fully responsible for their own actions.
- philoktet 12y agoHis replies sounded like he was defending his family to me.
- task_queue 12y agoHey, remember that saying about ignoring the trolls? Forget it, let's double down until some idiot does something really stupid and we have to move.
- leereeves 12y agoWe've ignored the trolls and they've grown wild in the land of no consequences. As in the physical world, behavior on the Internet must be governed.
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoDrawing parallels between the physical world and the Internet is bound to be murky. To begin with, the physical world doesn't have a single standard of ethical or moral behavior, as it varies subtly or greatly by jurisdiction. The Internet doesn't really have the same territorial boundaries that are presently vital to the functioning of humans in the physical world, either. Of course there has been some legislation on the matter and many have tried to assert jurisdictional power (famously in file sharing cases), but those are all highly volatile concepts. Indeed, each site chooses its own specific rules and guidelines. They're globally accessible, ad-hoc jurisdictions in of themselves, in many ways. Finally, the web application platforms themselves are not entirely blameless. They've created highly gamified, bizarro worlds where people are signaled and conditioned to engage in forced and obnoxious "social" behavior that many would consider totally histrionic and narcissistic if done in the physical world. The need to post every picture, to post every vapid thought in a global public bazaar... most humans simply aren't used to such a thing, and evidently cannot cope with the repercussions of it, either. Governing behavior on the Internet is doomed to end in an ambiguous mess without enacting ID laws that would subvert its purpose.
- cpncrunch 12y agoSome of us believe that you should nip this kind of highly obnoxious behaviour in the bud. Curt himself gives some good reasons for doing so in the article.
- psamathe 12y agoAn interesting side effect of the vicious retaliation against words on the internet (resulting in losing jobs and similar) is that it effectively creates a caste system. On the one hand, you have people like me who can discard their identity and any links to it and say absolutely anything without fear of repercussion. On the other, you have people who are still linked to real-life identities being forced to censor everything they say out of fear. "Freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from repercussions"? Perhaps not, but anonymity sure does, and people who want to say ugly or cruel things will avail themselves of anonymity. In fact, those people would be the most likely to use anonymity, since it's cost is easily outweighed by the risk of those disproportionate retaliations. So, I ask you, does retaliating against stuff like this tell people it isn't OK, or does it tell them that they need to be anonymous? What about when parts of the world conflict on whether a globally-distributed statement is OK?
- jimworm 12y agoFamous people leach fame into others by interacting with them. The easiest way to force someone to interact with you is to hit them somewhere vulnerable. Mr Schilling either wasn't aware of his vulnerability or hoped that it wouldn't be exploited. When it did get exploited, he didn't try to hide it, leaving a gaping wound for even more famewhores to leech fame from him. It worked, because I saw their tweets and I'm not even a baseball fan. Compare that with someone sufficiently invulnerable, Obama for instance. Or even Chuck Norris. The other fact is that with a large audience, it'd be silly not to expect that some percentage would be murderers/rapists/other unsavoury types. Getting a dozen offensive tweets out of a million-strong audience is still only 0.000012%, orders of magnitude less than the actual threat of rape.
- leereeves 12y agoWhat would happen to someone who made comments like these about Obama's daughters?
- skj 12y agoI'm pretty sure lots of people do this.
- minikites 12y agoSo that makes it okay?
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoI don't know if it's okay, but it is a fact that celebrities and common folk are held to different public standards. This has been true since the days of village gossiping to the present where countless publications exist for the sole purpose of serving as trash rags and yellow tabloids on the private lives of high-profile public figures, going day by day without significant legal troubles.
- 12y ago
- remarkEon 12y agoFor those debating whether or not these tweets constitute an actual threat there is a related case before the Supreme Court, Elonis v. United States [1]. It was argued back in December but because this will be major precedent I doubt we'll see an opinion until SCOTUS Season in June. The case seems to hinge on "subjective intent to harm" and will be the first major case (that I'm aware of) that will deal with speech like this on social media. Elonis is different (petitioner was convicted for making threats against his ex-wfe) from this thing with Schilling, but the context of the case is the same here - and the justices are quick to acknowledge that conviction standards are pretty strict in defining what constitutes a "true threat" and what a "reasonable person" would construe as a threat. Justice Breyer gets particularly snarky during oral argument. From the ScotusBlog summary: Issue: (1) Whether, consistent with the First Amendment and Virginia v. Black, conviction of threatening another person under 18 U.S.C. § 875(c) requires proof of the defendant's subjective intent to threaten, as required by the Ninth Circuit and the supreme courts of Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Vermont; or whether it is enough to show that a “reasonable person” would regard the statement as threatening, as held by other federal courts of appeals and state courts of last resort; and (2) whether, as a matter of statutory interpretation, conviction of threatening another person under 18 U.S.C. § 875(c) requires proof of the defendant's subjective intent to threaten. [1] http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/elonis-v-united-states/ http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/elonis-v-united-s...
- rileymat 12y agoWhy is it so hard for twitter to implement some optional filter for this stuff? You have a complete history of a users tweets and a record of how long the person has been active, number of followers, textual analysis of the tweets, block/mute status with respect to other people, whether you follow ect. It seems like it should be really easy for twitter to put messages into a spam/harassment folder, never to be seen by the target.
- ZoF 12y agoReally easy? ...Really? Edit: Not only would this alter a core and fundamental aspect of how Twitter currently operates but it would certainly be non-trivial to implement in an unobtrusive manner. Who wants what blocked? Is there a generic 'spam/abuse' filter? Is it on by default? Are those tweets put into a spam/abuse section or entirely unviewable. What happens when someone sends a tweet that is blocked by the filter, are they notified? Try to clearly define what metrics/identifiers you would use to determine a tweet is offensive and should be blocked and then call this implementation trivial.
- Estragon 12y agoFederated twitter blocking where people can choose to outsource the blocking to people they trust would be pretty cool. Kind of like AdBlockPlus lists.
- sanoli 12y agoSomewhat related, a UK boxer tracked down a twitter troll, and it worked. http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1563667-boxer-curtis-woodhouse-tracks-down-twitter-troll-shows-up-at-his-house http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1563667-boxer-curtis-wood... Of course, this is not a practical answer as we'd have everyone driving around everyday trying to locate assholes, but I can't help but feel good about the troll being exposed as a coward. Like in those fight videos where the bully gets it. I hate watching fights, hate watching real-life violence, but the bully getting what he deserves is an exception.