13 ms·
SpaceX Profitable as Musk Pulls in NASA Contracts, Google Cash
- skadamat 12y agoMakes no sense, SpaceX has been profitable almost every year they've been in business. Musk & Jurvetson are on record multiple times of SpaceX's profitability and how the aerospace industry is uniquely structured that way. Edit: The article doesn't even mention any rep from SpaceX saying they're profitable. This SEEMS like a guesstimate by the writer
- pkaye 12y agoCompanies have multiple definitions of profitability which they use for the desired effect.
- skywhopper 12y agoTrue, this is what the field of accounting theory is all about: how do you best represent the finances of a company? The best way to do so depends heavily on the type of company you're talking about and who wants to know the information, but many companies choose to keep multiple sets of books--one that follows the IRS's rules (this one is required), one that follows the SEC's rules (required if they are a publicly traded corporation), one for non-public investors, and one used internally allows management to make strategic decisions and departments to make plans. The existence of various ways of considering the finances of a corporation don't necessarily mean that any one method is "wrong". But when you get into questions of "is it profitable?" The answer depends a lot on who's asking. In any one month, more money may go out of your checking account than came in, but does that mean you lost money that month? Maybe some of the outgoing money was paying for a year's worth of an expensive service, or was an investment in some other company, or was the purchase of some assets that will allow you to become more productive. In those cases, while your cash flow may be negative, you can keep a set of books that spreads the cost of a year's worth of service over the entire year, even if you pay it all at once on January 1. Or a building you might want to spread the cost out over the duration of any loans you took out to pay for part of it, or if you paid cash, you still may want to spread the expense out over the 15 year expected lifetime of the asset. Obviously the IRS and SEC rules have to be pretty standard across the board, but within any particular industry or business model, a different representation may provide investors or management with a more accurate picture than the IRS or SEC rules would allow. Obviously all of these can be abused, and investors should be skeptical and do due diligence, but even 100% honest businesses may report a loss to the IRS, a profit to investors, and a break-even for the SEC. They aren't necessarily trying to scam anyone.
- hnnewguy 12y ago>In any one month... Pretty much everything you mention in this paragraph is covered by accounting rules a student would learn in year 1. Cash flow isn't profitability. Spending on assets is capitalized, and they depreciate according to rules, not what you "may want" to do. Yes, there is always some leeway to play fast and loose with accounting, and companies are always trying "adjust" earnings to suit to their business model. 4 times out of 5, it's horsecrap. That's why we have GAAP.
- goodcanadian 12y agoSure, but to take depreciation as an example, the rules do not necessarily match reality. Sometimes an asset's practical life is longer than the rules allow, sometimes it is less. These factors do not just depend on the asset, itself, they depend on how the asset is used. If a company goes under, the resale value of the asset may be worth more or less than its carrying value depending on outside economic conditions, technology changes, or what have you. Even the most earnest accountant can get things very wrong.
- skywhopper 12y agoYep, that's the point I was trying to make. Most people, presumably including the parent commentator, have not taken any accounting, and don't think about all the simple, obvious examples I listed.
- smackfu 12y agoThey should have left "profitable" out of the headline since they barely mention it in the article.
- Shivetya 12y agoGood to see an independent company do this. The only way space will be open to world is for it not to be shacked in the hands of governments; nor should it ever get stuck away as a corporate only endeavor. Let countries do the hard science, the exploration part, and step out of the way when someone else can do the mundane, especially when there are savings to be reaped
- Animats 12y agoIf SpaceX can fly out their 2015 manifest, that will be impressive. This is the year the Falcon Heavy is supposed to launch. Their first manned flight has apparently been postponed; it's been "2-3 years" away for 2 years now.[1] I notice they've stopped putting dates on their manifest for future flights.[2][3] SpaceX is doing a great job, but they're behind their own schedule. They're two flights behind on ISS resupply, and launched less in 2014 than they'd planned. They may be having scaling problems with their organization. They have a a product and customers, but can't meet demand. This may get better once they get their own spaceport in Texas finished. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20130802104411/http://www.spacex.com/dragon https://web.archive.org/web/20130802104411/http://www.spacex... [2] https://web.archive.org/web/20141030024140/http://www.spacex.com/missions https://web.archive.org/web/20141030024140/http://www.spacex... [3] httpd://www.spacex.com/missions
- mrfusion 12y agoHow will the spaceport in Texas help?
- mtrpcic 12y agoThe spaceport is being built specifically to accommodate SpaceX rockets. The idea is to have the rocket automatically fueled when it gets docked, use robotics to stand things up, and add a bit more automation to the overall process. There are a few articles about it online, but I just found this one from Bloomberg: http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-07-11/elon-musks-futuristic-spaceport-is-coming-to-texas http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-07-11/elon-musks-f... It's not the be-all and end-all of space stations, but it's better than something that was built decades ago for a previous generation of vehicle.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoI don't believe launches from the Cape have enough fuel to boost back to Boca Chica though, do they?
- 12y ago
- yeldarb 12y agoWhen's the IPO?
- wolf550e 12y agoElon Musk said many times that not soon.
- cryptoz 12y agoSpaceX will IPO when their Mars Colonial Transporter is making regular trips between Earth and Mars. Elon thinks that taking the company public before then would result in a potential derailment of Mars colonization plans. Having MCT making regular Earth-Mars trips before going public will ensure that quarterly-return-investors won't try to interfere with sending millions of people to go live on Mars. Citation: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/342566837852200960 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/342566837852200960
- Crito 12y agoFor anyone that isn't aware, this is actually what Elon Musk has stated in interviews in the past.
- tsotha 12y agoI think we can all read that as "not in my lifetime", though I may just be a pessimist.
- cryptoz 12y agoMCT should be flying its first trips in about 15 years (Elon says 10-12, so we add some). So I'd guess IPO in around 15-20 years. The real colonization effort will probably be getting going in 20-25 years. SpaceX will want to send about 80,000 people each year (or each launch window), and that scale is probably 30-40 years away. Most of us will see SpaceX go to Mars. And optimistically, I think many of us will go too.
- tsotha 12y ago
- josephjrobison 12y agoI love how the writer phrased Google's incentive for investing as "Google has a practical goal in linking up with SpaceX. It wants to beam the Internet to hard-to-reach regions of the planet so it can take in more advertising revenue." While... "'Space-based applications, like imaging satellites, can help people more easily access important information, so we’re excited to support SpaceX’s growth,' Google spokesman Aaron Stein said in a statement."
- skadamat 12y agoAgreed, it's a bit silly to assume that all Google cares about is ad revenue. Plus, improving internet accessibility and making more revenue aren't mutually exclusive. Why do self driving cars? Def no ad revenue there.
- cryptoz 12y agoI agree with you completely until > Why do self driving cars? Def no ad revenue there. Sure there is. Many people commute in their cars for 1-2 hours per day, when it is illegal for them to look at ads on their smartphone. If Google makes this legal, it's another 10%ish increase in the waking hours that people may be clicking on their ads. I think that Google's ambitions are a lot higher than this, of course. Self-driving cars will be a lucrative business for them in numerous ways. And increased ad revenue will be one of them.
- minthd 12y agoI don't believe ad revenue in self-driving cars will be meaningful. I don't think google will force people to watch ads after they pay for being driven.Maybe only as a discount ,but most will prefer not to, the same way that today, there aren't any attractive options to watch ads for pay.
- vertex-four 12y agoNot force, but the fact is that people will have more time to do whatever they want while their car drives them somewhere, during which many will be browsing the Internet through choice, and browsing the Internet generally involves looking at ads. Frankly, I'm not entirely sure such a roundabout benefit even comes up in management's eyes compared to the difficulty of getting self-driving cars working and on the roads, but it is one.
- tiffanyh 12y ago>> "SpaceX Profitable as Musk Pulls in NASA Contracts, Google Cash" Re: Google investment of $1B. I'm not an accountant, but when did taking investment money constitute making a business "profitable"?
- adventured 12y agoThey're not making that claim. Bloomberg is a high quality source for financial / business related news, their writers are extremely unlikely to confuse such a basic financial matter. The "as" in the title isn't meant to be a "because of Google cash," rather it's an elaboration of the present context of SpaceX, noting they're both profitable and have the cash from Google.
- bengali3 12y agoI had to reread as well. The 'as' separates the events. ( but how else can I get hot terms like SpaceX, Google, NASA, Musk and Profitable in a title!) think 'John types on the keyboard at his house as Jeff arrives to work'
- rplnt 12y agoCan we just agree these kind of titles are horrible? Random (I know it's not) capitalization, weird structure. It's just hard to parse.
- sandworm 12y agoI have trouble trusting business statements from companies in the space industry. They play in a world of secrets, classified technologies and continuous background checks. At every launch, over in the corner, sits a uniformed member of the US military and a switch. That switch is to destroy the rocket should it run off course. SpaceX might be profitable today. It might be very profitable tomorrow. But because of the classified nature of the industry that can change in a heartbeat. Fall out of favour with certain government agencies and suddenly that constant stream of background checks slows, deadlines get missed, and profits become loss. There are many fingers on many kill switches. Maybe the company is or will be a great success, but that success comes only with permission. Investors beware: Balance sheets are only half the story. The other half is not open for inspection.
- loceng 12y agoWell, they're offering an economic benefit (cheaper) to those who want it, with the U.S. government (and I imagine primarily military) with interest in seeing this succeed and anything that allows rapid deployment of whatever (slightly terrifying) into space.
- sandworm 12y agoThat is to assume that those customers care about economic benefit. Frankly, if cost were their only concern, the US military would have abandoned ULA and gone with SpaceX long ago. I'm reminded of the first calls (90s->2002, not the later programs) for bids to replace the KC-135. There were only two real contenders, Airbus and Boeing. Airbus's first reaction was essentially: "why even bother."
- greglindahl 12y agoWhen you're launching a $2B satellite, saving $60mm on the launch is not a slam-dunk. The Air Force had a series of launch failures that made them extremely conservative. Sure, I think they ought to be moving faster with SpaceX, but you should give them credit for having some serious concerns.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ctrlrsf 12y agoHow could you not be profitable with NASA contracts and Google cash?
- spiritplumber 12y agoI have to wonder, if Elon Musk is alive on earth today, what's the use of me? He's done pretty much everything I wanted to do in life, only a little less efficiently, and much faster. What's the point?
- aroman 12y agoI often ask myself these same questions.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI too ask myself this sometimes. Here's my shot at answers: - he can't fix the entire world by himself, there are a lot of things you can do to make a difference; - edw519 would probably point out that he's not making the thing he makes by the power of his own hands, he leverages the global economy to achieve his goals; if you do anything that's even remotely useful, you're helping him and everyone else; - somebody needs to buy those Teslas ;). (not that they sound very convincing, I'm not sure if I ever believe them myself)
- bgvopg 12y agoYou are making a logical fallacy of sorts. He wasn't destined for this role, he just happened, by skill and luck, to make it out of the 7 Billion people who didn't. If he was alone he wouldn't succeed.
- rwallace 12y agoComparative advantage. Even if he is strictly better than you at everything you do, there is only one of him, and he can only do one thing at a time.
- Retra 12y agoThis is an unnecessarily depressing way to see things. What you should believe is that your dreams are not meant for you. They are meant for someone much like you who probably doesn't exist yet. Someone who will actually understand what you've done and how you've helped them achieve what you would like to. You will die, and someone else will follow in your footsteps. Make sure that person has what they need to live the life you wanted, because you're probably the only person who really knows what that is worth.
- mempko 12y agoso tax payers are padding Elon's pocket book. If a NASA official made that much, people would complain.
- sixQuarks 12y agoI didn't realize the cost of fuel is only $200-$300k for a space launch. That's ridiculously low considering it costs more than that in fuel to cross the Atlantic ocean in a 100-foot yacht.
- fredo699 12y agoNever before in my life have I seen such a mangled and incomprehensible title.