7 ms·
How a half-million dollar Kickstarter project can crash and burn
- ripter 12y agoIt would be awesome if they open sourced the hardware. Then hackers could build their own Triggertrap Ada to interface with their mobile app.
- coupdejarnac 12y agoWell, they are using the audio jack for i/o. Convert audio signal to a logic level voltage, then use that voltage to activate a solid state relay. Camera remotes are normal open momentary switches, and the relay would serve as the switch. The app is pretty much a timer that outputs beeps. Why not make that too?
- ripter 12y agoFrom what I read, it sounded like they already built the thing, they just don't have the means to bring it to production. Selling kits wouldn't require them to bring it to production, while at the same time letting people experiment and use their app. I don't want to re-create their product, but it would be nice for people who still want the product and are willing to do a little work.
- voltagex_ 12y agoAren't the high costs of injection molding well known?
- asuffield 12y agoYes, and it seems clear from the article that this was understood going into the project. They got screwed when their production volume dropped from 50,000+ (viable for injection moulding) to 2,000 (not viable for anything), after it became clear that the product they had designed was not sellable in the market.
- teraflop 12y agoThe whole point of Kickstarter is supposedly to let people fund projects that require a minimum investment to be feasible, without their money going to waste if that minimum isn't met. If they knew their business model was only viable with 50,000 orders at $99 each, they should have set their target at $5million. Anything else is dishonest and deceptive.
- msandford 12y agoI can't understand how these idiots didn't think to use ProtoMold so that their tooling costs would be reasonable. http://www.protolabs.com/protomold http://www.protolabs.com/protomold $10k buys you a LOT of tooling there and they'll do the maintenance on it if it starts to wear. Yeah you pay more per part, but who cares if it's a $0.20 or a $0.30 part when you're talking about going from $1 to $0.10 of overhead per part. This whole thing reeks of massive, gross incompetence.
- djloche 12y agoAs a backer of projects, I'd rather have them slowly make 3D printed / hand-made editions for their backers, than get a % of my money back. But I understand why they don't want to spend any more energy on hardware.
- no_wave 12y agoMain question - what led this company to think they could even get close to a $99 price? Did someone give them a misleading estimate early on, or did they just come up with that number out of thin air?
- anigbrowl 12y agoDesire; they asked themselves how much they wanted to pay as photography consumers, asked other people if they'd buy into a device at $99, and convinced themselves that it should be easily doable at that price, most likely by deconstructing the marginal (per unit) costs without considering the large fixed costs that allow you to manufacture anything in volume. In fairness this seems to be a normal blind spot in many peoples' thinking. When I've discussed film piracy and market economics with people on HN, many people focus on the duplication cost of printing and packaging a blu-ray disc or suchlike in order to argue that films are extremely overpriced, or assume that there is a conspiracy among distributors to obstruct availability of films in order to extort money from consumers. It takes lengthy explanation to clue people into the numerous hidden costs of distribution (eg language-specific marketing materials, soundtrack-dubbing and so on), and that the considerable up-front costs of film production are typically financed by pre-sales agreements, and that most films do not have hyper-lucrative tie-ins like action figures, theme park rides, and worldwide audience anticipation that pretty much guarantees everyone will make a profit. People tend to focus on the objective and then tell themselves a fairy story about how they're going to get there. I'm not immune. Now when I'm planning a project I try to come up with my best estimates on everything but then I go through and multiply lots of them x 2 because of the things that I don't know I don't know.
- jkestner 12y agoI think you're largely right in that optimism led to a bunch of unforced errors. Evidence: They thought that they'd get 20% conversion on preorders (probably because it made their numbers line up), when those interested had their expectations set at ~$99 and instead got $350. But specifically about not rolling in the fixed costs, it's much larger than that. Their BOM alone blew up 3x. Even if you planned poorly up to that point, what you then do is cut. You find the biggest cost drivers and get them down. Find a cheaper way to make a less-polished case. Ship with 40 hours of battery life instead of spending developer-months getting to 400. Anyway, I really appreciate that he posted this post-mortem. There are too few of these for others to learn from. I hate when someone who obviously loves Kickstarter (and has successfully used it before) is called a scam artist. It may be all the same to a backer, but he's only guilty of mismanagement.
- swamp40 12y ago20% refunds (promised, not yet delivered). And the company's going to stay in business. How embarrassing.
- FigBug 12y agoThat's the beauty of Kickstarter. No downside for those who get the money, very limited upside for those who pledge.
- hgferee 12y agoWhy are you singling out Kickstater? You statement holds true for any form of investment. There seem to be a misconception what Kickstarter is. Their FAQ is clearly explains it is funding. I'm sure if everyone who backs a project would read it, there wouldn't be so many complaints.
- FigBug 12y agoBecause in a standard investment there is a potential for a huge upside, the product is a huge success and and you make a bunch of money. Kickstarter the upside is capped at getting your reward. I've read their FAQ and I won't participate in Kickstarter. I consider it a bad deal. If I see something on Kickstarter I want, I'll wait until it gets retail release and buy it for probably the same amount and have no risk. And if it doesn't get a retail release I'll live without it.
- hgferee 12y agoThat is completely situational. They are what they are. If you ignore the contract/FAQ it is only your fault. You seem to do so, which is great, but slandering is not honest.
- rhino369 12y agoKickstarter is not a form of investment. It is at it's base a donation with some purchase aspects for some the projects. With an investment you get the upside for the risk as well as the downside.
- FigBug 12y agoSeems crazy to do a project like this with an agency doing the software and hardware design. That's going to be crazy expensive. I would think you need the skills in house to make it affordable.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoOr you need the skills in house to make the price predictable.
- sliverstorm 12y agoYeah, my disbelief just kept growing as it became more and more clear that they seem to have completely outsourced the software and hardware. I'm completely astounded, especially given the aggressive price target that was an integral part of their product.
- jkestner 12y agoThis sounds a lot like the Kreyos story — that guy outsourced everything, including the blame. At least this one took responsibility himself. https://medium.com/@stevekreyos/the-rise-and-fall-of-kreyos-new-ac4e2d847964 https://medium.com/@stevekreyos/the-rise-and-fall-of-kreyos-...
- sliverstorm 12y agoThis idea that a product based company can be founded purely on marketing is infuriating. As if every other part of the business (but not marketing) is fungible. It's like the Idea-Guy, come back to haunt us.
- Balgair 12y agoIt seems like the take home lesson to all hackers and hobbyists out there: Hardware is HARD. Fullstop. $500,000 is nothing for even something as 'small' as this.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI don't think that is the correct lesson. The lesson is that if you are building a product and you don't already have all the expertise in house to finish the design, then you cannot predict what it should cost. Building hardware is actually "easier" in some senses than building software because it is so testable. More importantly building to the 'proof of concept' stage, or prototyping, is essential in a hardware design. I expect that building their device for $500K was eminently doable, with an in house hardware engineer, embedded software engineer, and a mechanical/manufacturing engineer or someone who is really talented and can do all three acceptably well. You don't get their fancy injection molded case, you get something much more boxish, and your controls are simpler. Perhaps the better lesson is don't assume anything you cannot do yourself but can describe is either easy to do or simple to do.
- ghaff 12y agoThe thing with hardware is that there's a lot more "works" or "doesn't work" to it. That's a gross oversimplification of course but software has a lot more latitude to be in the sorta works but is also pretty buggy and doesn't really do everything promised camp. I agree that there seems to have been a gap in even knowing what they didn't know. But an informative and honest post.
- Balgair 12y agoI thought the summary at the end was true though, but I still think that the takeaway for hobbyists and hackers is that getting a hardware device to market is HARD (caps intended). Cloning software is trivial, while getting things from China or wherever is not. If you are a hacker with all 3 skills you mentioned, then you probably can say that it is merely 'tough', but then again, you probably already have a great job with stock options, as you are rare in these fields.
- a2kadet 12y ago> To me, Kickstarter backers aren’t just customers. They’re our friends. They are mavens. They represent our most passionate, most ardent and most enthusiastic customers. > Yes, that’s it. I failed. We failed. It feels horrible, and it’s the end of Ada. But not the end of Triggertrap. Uh... if I was your "friend" I would be livid that you weren't going bankrupt to sell off every asset you had to pay me back in full. *Edit - My post was more about the use of the term friendship to absolve the author of guilt. Seems to have been effective This seems like shady business ethics to me.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dsugarman 12y agoIf I was his friend, I'd buy him a drink and tell him that we all fuck up and things will get better.
- pavlov 12y agoIn the friend scenario, you gave your friend a hundred bucks so he could try to build his dream widget. Would you really demand that your friend be declared bankrupt over a 100 dollar debt? (I'm not sure I agree that Kickstarter backers are that kind of "friends" to companies who took their money, but that seems to be the argument...)
- welly 12y agoSome "friend" you are then.
- Frondo 12y agoI am glad that my friends feel differently (and that I feel differently about my friends and their success/failure).
- aikah 12y ago> To me, Kickstarter backers aren’t just customers. No , the people you took money from aren't even your customers, because you didn't give them the service they paid for. So don't even insult them saying they aren't just customers, they aren't even customers to you. If there were, you would have delivered what you promised. They are just easy money with no strings attached.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoWow, that sounded so painful, and painfully obvious to anyone who has designed and built hardware. I think lesson 5 should be lesson 0 and re-written: They wrote: As soon as the Kickstarter money hit our account, we should have hired an experienced hardware product manager. And it should be: Before contemplating a Kickstarter campaign, we should have hired an experienced hardware product manager and had them price out what such a product would cost to bring to market at various volumes. Kickstarters work when they are the "D" side of R&D and fail when they start with the "R" side and try to get to "D".
- hkmurakami 12y ago>Kickstarters work when they are the "D" side of R&D and fail when they start with the "R" side and try to get to "D". I feel like we can extend this from Kickstarters to certain types of larger companies, where their expertise is in the D phase and their R efforts are largely fruitless (though granted, this is a bit of an exaggeration on my part). In a way, it takes discipline to stick to the D phase and let others do the seemingly sexy R work.
- bsder 12y agoYeah, yet another example of "Gee, hardware is actually hard." These guys should be crucified. $100 retail means $30 BOM. This is easily a $30 BOM project provided you supply the labor. Yeah, you're going to be working your own 3D printer. Pouring your own silicone rubber for molds. Soldering your own chips. etc. However, you got $500,000. That's enough to fund two people (one hardware and one software) an entire year and still have $250K left for development. They didn't learn crap.
- jkestner 12y ago> provided you supply the labor That's the #1 lesson. You can't consult away all the challenges, especially not the core of your product. As he found out, no one else is going to give a crap like you will, and if you don't have expertise in that area yourself, you're going to pick the wrong people. I'm still trying to figure out how the BOM got so high without alarms going off.
- kikki 12y agoIt's actually quite amazing how it feels that the author doesn't really mind that he's failed, and sees it as a learning curve. It almost reads like he's proud that he's blown half a mill, just read the title. This is real people's money. Whether or not it was more expensive than you originally planned, whether or not you feel really bad about it, you should not be allowed to just have another go at it. It makes an absolute joke of the entire concept of crowdfunding. For a Kickstarter that budgeted 50k, received 300k, and was still nowhere near production, that's just really poor management and people like that shouldn't be in the business of making promises and taking other peoples' money.
- socalnate1 12y ago"you should not be allowed to just have another go at it." Yes you should. Since when did we get the idea that failing at something (even spectacularly) should preclude you from trying again? Nearly everyone who reads HN has benefited enormously from the mindset that allows entrepreneurs to keep trying.
- kikki 12y agoThe entrepreneurs you're talking about lose a lot more when they fail in the real world. Networking contacts, trust, even become bankrupt. This company literally just moves on to the next product like it's nothing with no repercussions. Failing at something is fine, being naive and irresponsible with other people's money - without repercussion - is not.
- jamesrcole 12y ago> This company literally just moves on to the next product like it's nothing with no repercussions. You just flatly assert that. Is it actually true? I don't know, but surely they've at least got their reputation, with backers and others, from this failed product. > Failing at something is fine, being naive and irresponsible with other people's money - without repercussion - is not. You're failing to acknowledge that kickstarter backers know -- or should know -- the risk. It's their choice to back a particular project.
- ffwacom 12y agoCriminal negligence
- javajosh 12y agoConsider that a "major camera manufacturer" cost this enterprise many thousands of dollars by sending a letter.
- anigbrowl 12y agoAn expense the enterprise could have avoided entirely with a little bit of effort and common sense in advance. Here's the top results for 'trademarks for dummies': http://www.dummies.com/how-to/content/patents-copyrights-trademarks-for-dummies-cheat-sh.html http://www.dummies.com/how-to/content/patents-copyrights-tra... I'm not saying they should have spent $$$ on legal advice before setting pen to paper. Trademarks are A Thing in the world of business and not a particularly hard thing to learn about. If you're going to call your product 'Triggertrap Red' you shouldn't be too surprised when you get a letter from 'Red Camera' objecting to the apparent linkage between your product and theirs. I mean, if you invested some sort of automotive accessory, would you call it the 'Javajosh Lexus'?
- javajosh 12y agoIt's funny that both you and the other commenter assume I'm taking an editorial position on this. I was taken aback by the asymmetry of effort and cost. They hired a "small team of lawyers" to deal with a letter. It wasn't a lawsuit. It was a piece of paper with words on it! Sort of similar to when you launch a big AWS cluster and when you hit "enter" you know you just spent a lot of money.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThe piece of paper with words on it was created by a bunch of highly paid lawyers to get their attention. If it was a typical demand letter, it probably demand not only that they cease and desist from use of the infringing mark, but that they turn over any and all material employing the infringing mark for destruction, as well as a complete accounting of their financial interest in said mark. I imagine Triggertrap's legal bill was about 10% for the time to explain 'they're right, you're wrong, give it up already' and 90% for the drafting of a reply letter and compliance sufficient to get the injured party to call the matter closed. Now, that's a lot to ask for in a letter - usually a Trademark C&D goes along the lines of 'stop or I'll sue' - but in the context of a money-raising campaign, and given the fact that Red Camera company had historically and famously employed the pre-order launch strategy themselves, I think it would have been appropriate to come down on Triggertrap like a ton of bricks. Don't forget that trademark law works on a 'defend it or lose it' basis - if you don't vigorously contest infringement of the mark, then some later infringer can raise a defense of constructive abandonment. Not a lawyer, but I've long been interested in this subfield of law. Monitoring and defending the mark against potential infringers isn't cost-free either.
- stestagg 12y agoFar more lucrative, and easy to screw over customers, become a supplier to the kickstarter projects, rather than start your own KS. Naiive business people who have suddenly received 100,000s in capital are the easiest to con
- sliverstorm 12y agoAh yes, the old "sell shovels" game. You might be on to something.
- fudged71 12y agoRunning a campaign, you'd be amazed at how many messages you'll get from service providers. It has become a hotbed for this. Now it really makes a lot more sense.
- stestagg 12y agoFar more lucrative, and easy to screw over customers, become a supplier to the kickstarter projects, rather than start your own KS. Naiive business people who have suddenly received 100,000s in capital are the easiest to con
- anigbrowl 12y agoNot seeing the screamingly obvious trademark problems with using the name 'Red' before launching the Kickstarter is sort of astonishing to me. That sort of naivete would have been a huge red flag from the outset. These days 99% of trademark collisions can be avoided with a Google search and a little time to get familiar with the basic legal issue involved. I mean, you have to call a product something in order to sell it to more than 3 people, and if it has a name it seems like basic common sense that you'd want to avoid overlapping with similarly named products in the same market sector.
- vkjv 12y agoI saw similar red flags in other places. "Internally we expected that at worst 20% of people who had signed up to the newsletter would pre-order, and at best 50% of people on the list would convert into sales." I work for a brand whose customers are fairly passionate about it and those expectations are insane. A little market research would have shown that the 1.5% that they got was right in line with the standard.
- 1123581321 12y agoI think one factor is that people imagine their Kickstarters to be backed by a high percentage of people who visit the page when this probably isn't the case. If Kickstarter provided more lucid 'conversion metrics' to campaign runners, then they would have more realistic expectations of post-campaign sales promotions and this would help them to budget and plan more accurately and soon enough to avoid some problems.
- jayess 12y agoI'm guessing this is the trademark he's referring to: http://tmsearch.uspto.gov/bin/showfield?f=doc&state=4807:9r4gt3.3.2 http://tmsearch.uspto.gov/bin/showfield?f=doc&state=4807:9r4...
- TeMPOraL 12y agoThe search link has expired. Could you please provide the query you used?
- Crito 12y agoHis link works for me right now, but it is these guys: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Digital_Cinema_Camera_Company http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Digital_Cinema_Camera_Compa... http://www.red.com http://www.red.com They really should have seen it coming. Red is pretty well known, even if you aren't in some sort of camera-related industry.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoYup. I wasn't sure if this is what he meant, but if it was this, then indeed, Red is a very known name in camera-related industry. Hell, even I know about this (via HN) and I have absolutely nothing to do with photography.
- teh_klev 12y agoThat link is broken: This search session has expired. Please start a search session again by clicking on the TRADEMARK icon, if you wish to continue.
- jayess 12y agoHere's a better link (I hope). http://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=77668132&caseType=SERIAL_NO&searchType=statusSearch http://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=77668132&caseType=SERIAL_N...
- kevin_thibedeau 12y ago>the electronics agency claimed that the original microprocessor didn’t have enough memory This sounds like an attempt to pass blame. How could their engineers not know from the datasheet if there was enough memory (presumably program flash)? They had a prototype before the KS campaign. They must have had some way to estimate the space requirements for the final design. Flash is cheap. Bumping up to a bigger memory can't possibly be the main cost driver.
- sliverstorm 12y agoMemory == SRAM, not flash. SRAM is not cheap, and if you are not efficient with your SRAM usage you can suddenly find yourself stepping up several entire classes of microprocessor.
- kevin_thibedeau 12y agoEmbedded applications like this don't need lots of RAM. One has to wonder why such a simple application that boils down to a controlled delay was hard to achieve for them. It seems like they were too focused on a sexy LCD interface driven by god knows what over-engineered software crammed into what should have been a simple device. Now I see that the prototype was an Arduino, probably implemented within the safe shell of the Arduino libs rather than working with the baremetal AVR. Clearly they were way over their heads from the start.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- coupdejarnac 12y agoNo kidding, this project could have been accomplished with a cheapo PIC. I've basically already built this project...Hmmm, kickstarter idea. :)
- hurin 12y agoPlease, Please, stop publishing articles in these ridiculous 600 pixel text widths. The other 73% percent of my screen is there for a reason.
- joshuapants 12y agoHave you ever read a newspaper? There's a reason that text is typically contained in columns: readability. Presumably these writers want their content to be read.
- brianwawok 12y agoNewspapers can't be responsive.
- pyb 12y agoThe whole system has become so unhealthy for hardware startups. Kickstarter pushes everyone to overpromise and underdeliver, which is precisely the opposite what any good startup should aim for.
- driverdan 12y agoIf their company isn't folding they need to refund 100% of the money they raised from Kickstarter. There is a clear expectation of Kickstarter being a pre-order system no matter what the fine print says. I bet if the backers sued them they'd get a judgement in their favor.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoThere's a lot to criticize here, but one suggestion I've not seen anyone make is some kind of commitment to backers to make them whole. This is an ongoing enterprise, so there are any number of ways that might happen. One is just to say, "Look, we don't have the money to pay you back now but we are converting your contributions to loans at interest rate $X and will pay you back when we have the cash, which we expect to be $DATE." Or give people a discount on some future product. Free software updates for life. Something. Otherwise this reads as kind of narcissistic: "It's been so painful for us to spend all your money!" They also made any number of mistakes that are so large and well-known as to be nearly inexcusable. They were clearly learning on other people's dime, and that's kind of a problem when the product never materializes. Outsourcing design and development is a terrible mistake for a boutique product. While this was a product management failure, the lack of in-house resources was an even bigger error. For a $500K budget, zero money should be have been spent on design. Let the engineers decide how it looks. You can make it pretty on the second iteration. The first one will be charmingly ugly, and it will exist. Design people can suck down an astonishing amount of cash arguing about fonts, and that kind of thing makes a difference if you're selling to the mass-market, but for a niche/enthusiast/industrial product? No one cares. I once worked on an industrial product where a design company burned a huge amount of money on everything from UI layouts (mostly unusable) to icon design, to fonts. I re-did their UI so it could actually be implemented with the development and hardware resources available, added a few icons they had missed, and replaced their pricey commercial font with a free one. Number of complaints about the UI from the people who had approved the design dollars in the first place? Zero. No one could tell the difference (I'm sure a designer would have gone spare looking at what I produced, but our customers weren't designers... they almost never are.) Good design in a mass-market product can be a huge big deal, but hitting that perfect sweet spot the way Apple does so often is incredibly difficult and expensive. The odds of hitting it are so low for a project with limited resources that you're far better off not trying until you've got a shipping product.
- vitalus 12y agoFor the sake of its customers, Kickstarter needs to be doing a better job of evaluating projects, as it sounds like this project wasn't viable from the outset. This hurts their credibility and makes me wary of funding in the future. In the "Refunds" breakdown on the Kickstarter page, it shows that they're refunding the remaining 20%, while Kickstarter is keeping the 5% fee. Shouldn't Kickstarter be refunding their cut?
- JeremyBanks 12y agoWill Visa be refunding their cut?
- vacri 12y agoKickstarter did their middle-man job in good faith; why should they be liable?
- armored 12y agoDon't listen to some EE expert tell you the product can't be developed for less than a million. These guys are used to working at big shops that routinely throw that kind of money into the garbage. This product could have shipped, if only they had run the numbers first. With a cheaper chip, better project management and using a shop like Proto Labs for tooling they could have made it happen. Resourcefulness, not resources. $99 is pretty aggressive, but it could be done with a slim margin. Run the numbers first, THEN spend the money.
- jkestner 12y agoResourcefulness, agreed! I have made consumer products for less, with resourcefulness, careful planning and sweat. Key is to do a bunch of the work yourself. If you don't have those skills and can't learn them, get cofounders who do. Or use the skills you do have as constraints when developing new product ideas. Don't try to do too many new things at once — you're compounding risk.
- Aeolun 12y agoI just don't understand this. I read this to mean that they only started looking into the cost of production after they finished R&D... No matter how you look at it that's pretty retarded.
- DanBC 12y agoThis 2012 Gizmodo article talks about their previous kickstarter efforts. http://www.gizmodo.co.uk/2012/01/triggertrap-the-story/ http://www.gizmodo.co.uk/2012/01/triggertrap-the-story/
- aikah 12y agoKickstarter is a great social experiment.I wouldn't give a cent to any project. But if people looking for some thrill or some desire to make something happen give money,they are free to do so. Yet I find pathetic people then complaining on kickstarter forums after a scam,what did they expect? there is nothing to expect.Because these consumers are not really protected,and kickstarter itself doesn't give a fuck about them. On the other hand sooner or later, "backers" need to have a legal status.Donators,investors,consumers whatever, it needs to be regulated, like any other industry. Right now it isn't,but it will, mark my words.
- jkestner 12y agoHere's a pie chart of how the money was spent: http://petapixel.com/2015/03/02/triggertrap-has-failed-after-raising-nearly-500k-for-the-ada-modular-camera-trigger/ http://petapixel.com/2015/03/02/triggertrap-has-failed-after...
- bhayden 12y agoStill not very useful. $135,000 on "staff costs" doesn't say much - did one guy just pay himself $100k for the hell of it? $5,000 on travel expenses, did they expense all their gas for commuting and take a business trip to hawaii? $7,000 for "kickstarter campaign" - what are they possibly spending $7k on? This is a separate amount from the fee that KS takes. The lack of transparency is dumb.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- weissadam 12y agoI've said it before and I'll say it again. Kickstarter is basically Skymall 2.0 with added suspense. Will they actually ship it?! Will it actually work?! Will it actually work well?!