6 ms·
I've got the most downvoted Emacs question. It was actually even more downvoted at one point. http://stackoverflow.com/questions/11706028/creating-a-elisp-func
by melling 12y ago
I've got the most downvoted Emacs question. It was actually even more downvoted at one point.
http://stackoverflow.com/questions/11706028/creating-a-elisp-function-to-convert-url-to-html-link http://stackoverflow.com/questions/11706028/creating-a-elisp...
It was a pretty good question but I got into a debate with a moderator. That was my last question and I did a rage quit.
As you can see it was a simple well-defined question, and it produced two good answers.
- wwweston 12y agoIs there any kind of Stack facility for complaining about the quality of moderation? Because the moderation here is so clearly wrong that I'm not sure the people who made that call should have posting privileges on the site, let alone moderation.
- lambda 12y agoActually, that's exactly the kind of question that StackOverflow wants to discourage; people just using it as requests for someone else to write their code for them.
- wwweston 12y agoFirst: even if it's true that SO wants to discourage people from asking questions where they're starting from scratch and haven't written any code themselves yet... it's still a terrible moderation, because the explanation doesn't communicate anything close to expressing that. It says the question is unclear. That's flatly false. Second: is this really the kind of question SO doesn't want? Their privilege, if so, but in addition to being well-defined it's clearly content that more than a handful of people were interested in (at least 15 upvotes on the most popular answer, multiply it by the ratio of non-user visitors to user visitors). It's a programming question, it has a programming answer, and it certainly has instructional value as an elisp recipe beyond whatever intent the author had. And as for whether it's lazy -- that's basically the charge here, right? -- I'm not sure I see a functional difference between someone asking a question like this and someone who has written a larger pile of code and is missing a narrow piece of knowledge to complete it. There's possibly arguably a contextual/rhetorical difference where in the latter situation we see the context which led to the question being asked and in the former we don't... but honestly, nobody who's fundamentally asking other people to just do their work for them is asking about text->html transformations in elisp, it's pretty easy to read between the lines and see that. To underscore the point, let's just compare it to some other questions: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/5410757/delete-a-line-containing-a-specific-string-using-sed http://stackoverflow.com/questions/5410757/delete-a-line-con... http://stackoverflow.com/questions/59895/can-a-bash-script-tell-what-directory-its-stored-in http://stackoverflow.com/questions/59895/can-a-bash-script-t... http://stackoverflow.com/questions/8168320/can-vim-highlight-matching-html-tags-like-notepad http://stackoverflow.com/questions/8168320/can-vim-highlight... It's pretty easy to see what most of these much more popular questions have in common with the one we're talking about here -- as part of whatever these askers are doing, they know there's a capability embedded in a tool that's part of the environment. They just don't know how to bring it out. You could, of course, just tell them to go RTFM for awk, until they get something simple like deleting a line from a file when it matches a string you know, but then again, you could also tell people to go more carefully read the relevant documentation for most programming problems, and if you accept the question and the answer you've got relevant content people are looking for on the site and a recipe people can start learning more from.
- lambda 12y agoThe moderation works based on votes one one of a few pre-canned reasons from several different users. If enough users vote to close, the pre-canned response that the most voted for is what is listed. That means that it doesn't always exactly match the reason that the question was really closed, but it means that it's possible to give an approximate rationale for the close that was performed by several people, not a single person. I have answered a lot of questions on StackOverflow. One of the worst type of questions is the "please, write this code for me" question. There are frequently lazy or incompetent programmers who just ask for code to do their job, along with students who are asking people to help them cheat on their homework. So many people on SO are very quick to downvote and close any such questions. Now, there's a grey area. Asking how to do one specific task which is a small component of a larger program is different enough than asking someone to deliver a completed program to you that it's tolerated. Asking something like "how do I use this one facility in a language" is different than asking "please write this tool for me." There's also just the fickleness of the crowd. Any site which is based on voting, like StackOverflow, Reddit, HN, and so on, can have some questions upvoted and some downvoted due to sheer bad luck, different sets of people looking at different sets of questions, and so on. Trying to expect that a large group will act in a coherent manner, when only a small subset of that group ever even sees any given question (and with strong bias, as different people follow different tags), is just going to set you up for disappointment. > nobody who's fundamentally asking other people to just do their work for them is asking about text->html transformations in elisp, it's pretty easy to read between the lines and see that. Actually, take a look at melling's later comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9126537 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9126537 > Elisp isn't the most widely used language so coming up to speed could be time consuming. Yep, sounds like he was just asking someone else to do a job for him, he wasn't interested in learning elisp.
- melling 12y agoWrong. You don't have to guess if it was for my job, I'm here! I don't know anyone who gets paid to write elisp. I'd just used AWK or Perl if it were for my job. It's a 1 liner. perl -ane '...'
- 12y ago
- ayrx 12y agoYou are clearly not a frequent user of Stack Exchange because you do not know about the meta sites which are available to discuss moderation decisions. And if you are not a frequent user who are you to say that "the moderation here is so clearly wrong that I'm not sure the people who made that call should have posting privileges on the site, let alone moderation"?
- melling 12y agoThat would be incorrect. I've asked hundreds of questions on SO. My complaint on Meta just got massively downvoted.
- olavk 12y agoCan you post a link to one of these unfairly downvoted questions? I'm curious.
- melling 12y agoIt was removed from Meta. If there are archives, perhaps my user id can link back? Are the deleted messages purged? My user id from the message: user568866 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:-H105lCRrEYJ:stackoverflow.com/questions/11706028/creating-a-elisp-function-to-convert-url-to-html-link+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:-H105lC...
- collyw 12y agoThat sounds exactly like my experience. Challenge anything on moderators, and you will be down voted to hell. Its like normal site down voting on steroids. "Do not question the mods"
- lambda 12y ago> It was a pretty good question No, this is not a good question for StackOverflow. You simply asked for someone to write code for you, which is not what StackOverflow is intended to be for. It is intended for help on a particular specific problem you are having with your own code.
- debaserab2 12y agoAnd yet there is at least one, if not two very useful answers to his supposed non-question. Thank god for these arbitrary community standards, shielding people from getting useful answers to questions that are deemed as formatted incorrectly.
- melling 12y agoIt was a short well-defined question with given input and a specific output. Elisp isn't the most widely used language so coming up to speed could be time consuming. Someone else even starred it so they must have found it to be useful. If I'd just ask to "Calculate someone's age in C#", that'd be a much better question? http://stackoverflow.com/questions/9/how-do-i-calculate-someones-age-in-c http://stackoverflow.com/questions/9/how-do-i-calculate-some...
- maxerickson 12y agoIt is arguably more specific. It'd be interesting if they would just register something like shitpile.com, set up an instance of Stack Exchange on it, turn off the moderation game, and push closed and deleted questions there instead of disappearing them. That would at least sort of be an experiment on whether all of the decisions they have made about what Stack Exchange sites are 'supposed to be' actually matter or not.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoNow is it? It also asks basically to teach how subtraction works, which is something you should know when leaving primary school.
- fapjacks 12y agoEchoing other sentiments, this is not a good question at all. You haven't shown code that you've tried, you're not asking a specific question about the problem you're having writing such code, and (worst) you're basically asking someone to write the code for you. This is a code request, NOT a question about coding.
- melling 12y ago* How do I loop over an Emacs buffer and process each line? * How do I split a string in Elisp? * How do I construct output to an Emacs buffer? All were answered in a little over a dozen lines of Elisp. Small, well-defined, pieces of code are a great way to learn.
- maaaats 12y agoWhy didn't you ask that question, then? A general concept with many uses is useful for many, and would have stayed.
- bjwbell 12y agoI have to laugh, the question is now deleted due to your linking to it from here I'm assuming .
- reneherse 12y agoGoogle's cache of the now deleted page: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:-H105lCRrEYJ:stackoverflow.com/questions/11706028/creating-a-elisp-function-to-convert-url-to-html-link+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:-H105lC...
- function_seven 12y agoI'm getting a 404 now when I click your link. Was your question deleted after you posted this?
- melling 12y agoYes, that's how they roll on StackOverflow. Hope they fixed the bug so the guy who answered the question didn't lose his points. He was upvoted 13 times.
- function_seven 12y agoWell it's back up now. SO looks like it has a Wikipedia problem[1]. [1] http://www.themarysue.com/wikipedia-losing-editors/ http://www.themarysue.com/wikipedia-losing-editors/
- jacquesm 12y agoApparently. That's a pretty sick move. In other words, you can't talk even about stackoverflow on another forum without stackoverflow moderators trying to take control of the discussion. Whoever did this on SO should have their moderator privileges removed pronto, that's a very bad piece of advertising for SO and hurts its image much more than the rest of this discussion and the original article combined.
- olavk 12y agoI see lots of complaining over SO moderation in this thread and other places, but the actual examples shown always turn out to very sensible moderation. For example your question is clearly not appropriate for SO. You are not asking a specific question, you are just asking people to write code for you. That somebody was nice enough to actually write your code for you, does not mean it was a good question! Now there might actually be an audience for a "write my code" website, where users could post programming tasks or homework exercises, and other developers then might try to solve them for the fun and challenge of it. But SO clearly does not want to be that kind of website.
- melling 12y agoThe answer was 15 lines of very educational code that would have benefited anyone learning elisp.
- olavk 12y agoTo put it bluntly, it would have been much more educational for you if you had actually tried to code it yourself. If you during this had encountered a concrete problem or question which you couldn't solve on your own, you could have posted it on SO.
- melling 12y agoBut it's perfectly acceptable to ask how to split a string in C#? That's not covered many other places? It's a duplicate, yet highly up voted question. http://stackoverflow.com/questions/8928601/how-can-i-split-a-string-with-a-string-delimiter http://stackoverflow.com/questions/8928601/how-can-i-split-a... There's probably 100x more C# information than elisp on the internet.
- maaaats 12y agoIt is highly upvoted because many people have found it useful. Contrary to your question, it's a question with many uses. >That's not covered many other places? (...) >There's probably 100x more C# information than elisp on the internet. So what?
- jlarocco 12y agoThat wasn't a question at all. It was letting people know you wanted them to write code for you. If your "question" starts out, "I'd like to create...", and finishes with the expectation that else somebody will write the code for you, it's a pretty good bet you're going to get down voted.