19 ms·
The birth of Microsoft's new web rendering engine
- ocfx 12y agoI think they forgot the part where they explained why they did it that doesn't use doublespeak.
- FreakyT 12y agoI'm glad to see that Microsoft is finally ripping out all the weird legacy modes -- IE11 essentially ships with 6 different rendering engines! [1] * IE5 (quirks mode) * IE7 (compatibility view) * IE8, IE9, and IE10 (available from the x-ua-compatible meta tag) * IE11's actual rendering engine As an aside, the hilariously long user-agent string is perhaps the best evidence that string-based browser detection is something that web devs should avoid at all costs. It manages to include "Safari", "Chrome", "AppleWebKit", "KHTML", "Mozilla", and "Gecko". [1] https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dn321432.aspx https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dn321432.aspx
- leeoniya 12y agoif you're not detecting on the client (via javascript), then you have to rely on headers. well, maybe via IE conditional comments + cookie setting on transparent pixel request
- stephenr 12y agothe point is you should be doing feature tests, not browser tests.
- leeoniya 12y agothere's no such thing as a feature test on the server side.
- stephenr 12y agoThe things that are different are almost exlusively related to client side tech- html, css and js.
- exprE 12y agoIn an ideal world, perhaps. Sadly, in the real world, a browser seemingly supporting a feature doesn't mean it gets it right, and not all features can be detected by testing.
- spain 12y ago>As an aside, the hilariously long user-agent string is perhaps the best evidence that string-based browser detection is something that web devs should avoid at all costs. It manages to include "Safari", "Chrome", "AppleWebKit", "KHTML", "Mozilla", and "Gecko". Further reading: http://webaim.org/blog/user-agent-string-history/ http://webaim.org/blog/user-agent-string-history/
- hughes 12y agoFor the lazy, the new UA string is: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; WOW64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/39.0.2171.71 Safari/537.36 Edge/12.0 Glad I don't deal in server-side analytics!
- bzbarsky 12y agoIt's basically the Chrome 39 UA string with "Edge/12.0" added to the end so people who really care can tell it's not really Chrome....
- eyeareque 12y agoI'm sure the reasoning behind those modes is because they had big (paying) customers who needed them there to help their "never ever getting an update" mission critical system webpages continue to work properly.
- Someone1234 12y agoI feel like the "A new Web rendering engine is born" section covers quite honestly why they have chosen to fork IE. It seems, to me, to be pretty frank and doesn't contain much "doublespeak." PS - This was originally a reply to a comment which got removed.
- michaelpinto 12y agoThe amount of that article which was focused on legacy was very depressing. When it started to go about how it would break some Little League site that was IE specific that got me very unexcited. Microsoft today needs to learn the lesson of Apple in the very late 90s and just say "no".
- untog 12y agoThey can't. All of the success MS has is based on enterprise - Apple are lucky in not having that restriction. At this point, if MS decided to say F everyone it would come back to bite them very hard. I have a lot of respect to these IE devs for not just quitting and doing something easier, to be honest.
- jonathansampson 12y agoThank you untog; we're doing our best :)
- michaelpinto 12y agoActually it seems strange now, but back in the 90s Apple (and NeXT too) were very focused on the enterprise. They were just "lucky" to have done badly at it. In fact they actually even made servers: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Network_Server http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Network_Server
- scholia 12y agoApple didn't have a huge market to lose. Or to sustain through several decades of compatibility. Also, Microsoft makes the vast bulk of its income (90-95%) from partners. It can't just decide to change everything, it has to move thousands of partners along.
- nakedrobot2 12y agoIs there anything wrong with the ones that already exist, which developers already cater to? What are they accomplishing here, exactly?
- freehunter 12y agoIs there anything wrong with IE? That's the question you're asking?
- thebouv 12y agoAccomplishing? Competition. As devs we don't necessarily want a single browser to be dominant even though we might jokingly pray for such a thing during testing phases. We just want them to be standards compliant, right? Don't get me wrong: there is a certain freeing joy when you work on a project where you know the target browser is the only one you need to think about (like say if you build kiosk apps or apps on a strict intranet). But at the same time, if one player is too dominant or we only have a single voice about "this is what a browser should be" we get the crap we have lately with Apple's voice being too strong on what is or is not accepted into the HTML standard; or when IE had the 90%+ share it used to have.
- cwyers 12y agoWell, let's flip the question around -- why are there three major open-source rendering engines in the world right now already? Why did Google fork Blink from WebKit? The answer seems to be, major browser vendors have a hard time cooperating at the engine level. Apple and Google had different opinions over WebKit, which eventually led to it being forked. Microsoft has no real reason to think that it could partner with Apple or Google any more successfully than they partnered with each other in developing a rendering engine.
- tmzt 12y agoPartly due to the different sandboxing implementation, Chrome had their own already and Apple was pursuing something called WebCore2 IIRC.
- leeoniya 12y ago"Fixing patterns instead of sites" I don't understand this statement
- Igglyboo 12y agoThey aren't targeting specific sites that are broken they are targeting more general patterns that seem to cause problems.
- leeoniya 12y agoI understand the language. I don't understand what they mean by "patterns". Common edge cases where js/css/html is broken in specific ways? If you write html/css in a relatively compliant way, things will not be so broken that a browser vendor needs to account for them in a "long tail". If your js is broken, well tough luck. Are they just talking about how to implicitly handle commonly malformed HTML, as all browsers do?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- CJefferson 12y agoIf people in the past have written bad js which worked in IE, Microsoft aren't now going to break that code. They don't consider saying "tough luck" to businesses with code which works for them today acceptable.
- leeoniya 12y agomy problem is they're selling this as a "clean break" with no baggage. but then in the same breath explain how they've found a way to still accommodate that baggage and calling it a "long tail". IE is still gonna live next door (to be used for enterprise/compat) probably for a while. I don't understand what they are saying about solving incompatibility issues of IE-specific code in Spartan - which is presumably NOT IE.
- higherpurpose 12y agoThe main thing I would want from a Microsoft browser is actually keeping up to date with the latest in security protocols and crypto algorithms. IE has always been several years behind everyone else in this area, which just meant developers had to keep their websites less secure just to be able to serve IE users as well. That needs to end. I don't necessarily want Microsoft to be a leader in this area (not sure I'd trust Microsoft with any new security protocols anyway), but at the very least it should be a fast-follower. Looking forward to Microsoft adopting ChaCha20-Poly1305 or at least helping to speed up the standardization at IETF and then adopt that standard if their excuse right now is that they can't adopt "non-finalized standards".
- AlyssaRowan 12y agoThe agl draft is actually an out-of-date, expired first draft, but it did the job to get it kickstarted! https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-agl-tls-chacha20poly1305/ https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-agl-tls-chacha20poly1... AEAD_CHACHA20_POLY1305 is however about to be an RFC (via CFRG) - https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-irtf-cfrg-chacha20-poly1305/?include_text=1 https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-irtf-cfrg-chacha20-po... - , and the proper TLS WG draft will essentially just link to that: https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-mavrogiannopoulos-chacha-tls/?include_text=1 https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-mavrogiannopoulos-cha...
- lawnchair_larry 12y agoBased on the team pics, it looks like they got rid of individual offices over there. That's too bad.
- jajaBinks 12y agoI'm a developer with Azure. Most of the developers still have individual offices (a few folks are also 'doubled up' in individual offices because of space constraints). Only some teams have moved to an open-space office layout.
- hirsin 12y agoNope, just the IE PMs - the IE devs on the floor above still have offices :)
- pdknsk 12y agoIt doesn't matter unless they make it open-source or at the very least cross-platform. I'm not downloading a 4GB VM from http://modern.ie http://modern.ie to try it.
- thebouv 12y agoHonestly, with as much OSS as they've been putting out there recently, I wouldn't be surprised to see this browser go that route too. Maybe.
- mishoo 12y agoThey can't. They said in a court of law that IE can't be separated from Windows.
- pacofvf 12y agoBut this is another Browser: > This new rendering engine was designed with Project Spartan in mind, but will also be available in Internet Explorer on Windows 10 for enterprises and other customers who require legacy extensibility support.
- mishoo 12y agoThis is a good point. While I have my doubts that it will be an entirely new browser, by simply renaming it they might be able to offer a version for non-Windows OS-es without making earlier statements seem ridiculous. And they should.
- Denvercoder9 12y agoSpartan isn't IE.
- Touche 12y agoI know this is this is the narrative they are trying to promote but I remove code from my projects all the time but don't feel it makes it a different project.
- EdSharkey 12y agoYES! 1-2-3-4, I declare a browser war! Finally. This is the Microsoft I've been waiting for! No more rolling over and no defeatist talk of adopting WebKit or whatever. Microsoft is going to use its muscle and position to make a truly competitive browser. We need more competition, and we need the default browser in Windows to be just as good as Chrome and Firefox. Microsoft, I hope you pull every -ms- vendor flaggin', ring-0 kernel hookin', micro-optimizatin', site-specific D3D driver tweakin' trick in the book as you reach for parity. This is going to be so fun to watch.
- melling 12y agoWe have a already have lot of competition. In fact, it's never been better: Chrome, Firefox, WebKit, Chromium, Opera. You can even get the source code for Firefox and Chrome and contribute. I'm glad Microsoft is making a better go at it, but honestly, Microsoft could have built a more compliant browser any time they wanted too. https://html5test.com/results/desktop.html https://html5test.com/results/desktop.html
- infogulch 12y ago> Microsoft could have built a more compliant browser any time they wanted too. That time is now, can we not be excited for it? Have you heard the parable of the prodigal son?
- Mithaldu 12y agoChrome and friends aren't webkit anymore, but only by way of forking. Otherwise Chrome, Chromium and Opera 15+ are the same engine. The family tree kind of looks like this: -- Internet Explorer -- Firefox -- Safari \ -- Chrome, Chromium, Opera 15+ -- Opera 12 (abandoned) I'm a little unclear on how differentiated Webkit and Blink are in practice, but sadly we have only 3.5 major engines competing at this point.
- Touche 12y ago-- Konqueror \ -- Safari \ -- Chrome, Chromium, Opera 15+ If you want to go further Firefox's lineage is interesting but it's parent browsers are all dead.
- andhof-mt 12y agoBrowser war? Sure. But regardless of the improvements MS makes, they still have years worth of a bad reputation they have built up to get over. It will take leaps and bounds for them to ever build up the respect that Mozilla and Google have for building web technology.
- thebouv 12y agoFor Devs to use their browser, sure. But if it is pre-installed on my mom's Windows machine, she'll be using it. They still have that as a huge advantage. So kudos to them for at least trying to correct mistakes legitimately this time.
- heleph 12y agoTheir problem is more that it's not installed on Mum's phone or tablet. :)
- thebouv 12y agoThat's true. I so wanted to like the Windows Phone. I bought a Lumia 1520 and it was a beautiful piece of tech. And I like the default interface of the home screen (Metro works on a phone, not on desktop imho). But .. then I tried to use the store to get apps and it was a desert. Or the things I could find, worked poorly.
- wluu 12y agoThat's the thing, it might well be on "mum's (next) tablet" (probably not phone). There's a raft of really cheap (7/8/10 inch) Windows 8.1 tablets that are price competitive with their Android equivalents. At the moment they are running full Windows with an Intel Atom processor. From what I've read, these will all be capable of being upgraded to Windows 10 when release. Spartan is going to be released for both Windows Phone 10 (or whatever they are calling it) in addition to Windows 10, from what I've read.
- EdSharkey 12y agoIf you think of the Browser-as-Operating-System, then building a legacy-free IE makes a lot of sense. That kind of OS development is right in Microsoft's wheelhouse and they need to do it to stay competitive if they want to continue to be a client-side application host. If this Spartan team does a good job, then they'll brain drain the rest of Microsoft the way XBox did. Building a web browser from the ground-up in 2015 would be a pretty sweet project to work on. I'm nerd-salivating.
- hyperbovine 12y ago> Finally. This is the Microsoft I've been waiting for! ... Microsoft is going to use its muscle and position to make a truly competitive browser. Oh-ho man, what I wouldn't give to teleport this comment back to 1997 or so...
- 72deluxe 12y agoHaha very true. It reminds me of the time Apple announced that Internet Explorer was going to be the browser for classic Mac OS, with Bill Gates calling in, to shouts of NO!!! NO!!!!! NO!!!! It makes me chuckle. It always boggles the mind that the web is mostly just rendering of documents and flinging backwards and forwards of requests, yet the passion it invokes with browser wars and web developers. A browser is essentially a HTML Help File viewer yet you get followings and wars! It doesn't make sense. Even less sense is made when they reinvent all application features in a web browser to make web pages behave like desktop applications. Kind of useful, but an incessant broken/fix/reimplement cycle
- q2 12y ago>>> This is an ambitious goal given that the Web consists of over 44 billion Web sites This is not the number of "web sites" but number of "web pages" [1]. [1] http://www.worldwidewebsize.com/ http://www.worldwidewebsize.com/
- hrremmer 12y agoHahaha. Microsoft and Internet are fundamentally incompatible. All you need to do is go to their homepage to see they don't get the Internet. Never have, never will.
- bobbles 12y agoHey at least they removed the hopeless full-page-blocking "would you like to fill in a survey" that was on their HOMEPAGE.. its a start
- jongalloway2 12y agoSome interesting information to the contrary: http://rainypixels.com/words/the-story-of-the-new-microsoft-com/ http://rainypixels.com/words/the-story-of-the-new-microsoft-... http://paravelinc.com/work/microsoft.php http://paravelinc.com/work/microsoft.php
- ulfw 12y agoToo bad there won't be a OS X Version.
- kibwen 12y ago> the new engine began as a fork of MSHTML.dll but has > since diverged very quickly Curiously, this means that Spartan will still be able to trace its lineage back to 1992's NCSA Mosiac (in contrast to Mozilla's Servo, which is a greenfield project). I expect that it will be fascinating to compare the two projects as each matures.
- ethomson 12y agoTo be pedantic: even if there is code from MSHTML.dll in Spartan, there's no code from NCSA Mosaic in MSHTML.dll. Internet Explorer originally licensed Spyglass Mosaic, which licensed the name (and the code) from NCSA, but did not actually use any of the code. Though I suspect that there's not actually any Spyglass Mosaic code left in IE these days. (Edited, I said that there's no MSHTML.dll code in Spartan. That I do believe exists.) (Source: http://ericsink.com/Browser_Wars.html http://ericsink.com/Browser_Wars.html)
- 0x0 12y agoInternet Explorer 1.0's "About" box claims it is "Based on NCSA Mosaic": http://utilu.com/IECollection/img/iecollection_ie100_win40nt.png http://utilu.com/IECollection/img/iecollection_ie100_win40nt... (Curiously, Internet Explorer 1.0 showed a version number of "4.40" in the about box.)
- jonathansampson 12y agoIE is (originally) based on NCSA Mosaic code, by way of Spyglass. Spyglass had nearly 70 or so vendors using the same code if I'm not mistaken. The original source code of IE 1 can be seen (an Easter egg) in the video on our blog post (at about 40 seconds): http://blogs.msdn.com/b/ie/archive/2015/02/26/a-break-from-the-past-the-birth-of-microsoft-s-new-web-rendering-engine.aspx http://blogs.msdn.com/b/ie/archive/2015/02/26/a-break-from-t....
- wluu 12y agoThat's a really cool easter egg :)
- joeblau 12y agoDoes anyone have metrics on how much of the traffic on the internet is HTTP/S vs everything else?
- WalterBright 12y agoI hope those 9,000 sites include github. IE hangs when confronted with a github display of a PR that has more than 1000 lines of diff's.
- jonathansampson 12y agoDo you have one that we can use to check future builds of IE against?
- joshschreuder 12y agoTry this: https://github.com/golang/go/commit/b986f3e3b54499e63903405c90aa6a0abe93ad7a https://github.com/golang/go/commit/b986f3e3b54499e63903405c... To be fair, it's extraordinarily slow even in Chrome, but IE11 rendering on this page is pretty bad.
- ygra 12y agoImpressive to see the difference between browsers there, though. IE is unusable with ~420 MiB of memory for that tab. Chrome is unusable as long as the page loads; after that only slowed down slightly, with ~540 MiB of memory for that tab. Firefox is snappy, fast and takes only 180 MiB of memory for that tab.
- WalterBright 12y agoHere's one: https://github.com/D-Programming-Language/dmd/pull/4381/files https://github.com/D-Programming-Language/dmd/pull/4381/file... It's not even that big, and it's nearly impossible to scroll it.
- joosters 12y agoWill there be any useful privacy options in this new browser? e.g. will the cookie options be something more than a global allow/disallow all cookies? Will it offer a way to control/block/clear other client-side data, like flash cookies, local storage and so on?
- johnkchow 12y agoThis interoperability-focused approach brought the obvious question of adopting an existing open-source rendering engine such as WebKit. While there were some advantages, upon further investigation it was not the right path forward for two important reasons. First, the Web is built on the principle of multiple independent, yet interoperable implementations of Web standards and we felt it was important to counter movement towards a monoculture on the Web. Second, given the engineering effort required, we found that we could deliver an interoperability focused engine to customers significantly faster if we started from our own engine (especially if unshackled from legacy compatibility concerns), rather than building up a new browser around an open-source engine. We will continue to look at open source and shared source models where it makes sense and look forward to sharing more details in coming posts. This is a powerful paragraph from the article. I'm all for competition, and if they actually produce the next great browser, that'll just mean better browsers overall (and probably even better tooling for us devs). I'm a bit skeptical whether they can pull it off, but at least I have a good feeling that they're out to prove us all wrong.
- amelius 12y agoI just wished we could put on top of our HTML something like: <meta render-engine="webkit" /> or something along those lines.
- munificent 12y agoWe just need to implement an HTML renderer (or two or three) in JS and then ship the renderer with your site.
- amelius 12y agoBingo :) But it makes me wonder how well is asm.js supported by the new IE?
- jonathansampson 12y agohttp://blogs.msdn.com/b/ie/archive/2015/02/18/bringing-asm-js-to-the-chakra-javascript-engine-in-windows-10.aspx http://blogs.msdn.com/b/ie/archive/2015/02/18/bringing-asm-j...
- adrusi 12y agoBut it will still be non-free, and probably won't sync history/bookmarks/open tabs with mobile, except perhaps windows phone. And it only works on windows. I don't see what would entice users to switch from Firefox or chromium or opera (or midori, konqueror, etc) to a new Microsoft browser. Its probably still worth telling users not to use internet explorer, just in case they ever end up buying a Mac or Linux PC, and out of principle to support free software. Its good to see competition, but I theorize that this will hurt Mozilla and benefit Google and Microsoft. The quality of chrome has been stagnating recently due to its large market share, while Firefox has been steadily advancing (because Mozilla's primary agenda is to move the web forward). Users have started a slow migration back to Firefox, which I love. A good internet explorer, paired with effective marketing, could threaten chrome and force google to get their act together, ending the Firefox rennaissance. But realistically I don't see Microsoft marketing this effectively, and internet explorers reputation as a piece of crap will haunt it for years to come.
- tarblog 12y ago>Users have started a slow migration back to Firefox Do you have a source for this? I haven't looked at trends in a while.
- JTon 12y agoProbably just anecdotal based on discussions here at HN [1] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9045305 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9045305
- Veedrac 12y agoIt sounds like your primary concern is that it might be good...
- GhotiFish 12y agoPersonally for me? I am deeply concerned that internet explorer becomes not terrible. People would be stupid enough to then use it. Then microsoft would have more clout. They would immediately use that clout to cause enormous industry problems, push bad standards, fail to comply with open ones, push windows specific extensions, ect ect ect. I am 100% concerned that internet explorer might not suck. If that happened, the internet would be in a much worse place.
- hmottestad 12y agoSo fun thing to do in these kinds of videos is to look for women. FYI. This video has 1 woman, at the end. She doesn't say anything, she just stands there, and she's only visible for a few seconds. Summing up. Microsoft's new engine, still fighting to gain traction with 50% of the population ;)
- SmokyBourbon 12y agoSo you believe web browsers should be tailored to a specific gender? What would a woman-friendly web browser look like? Does it open a thousand URLs before finally picking which one to render?
- anjc 12y agoRidiculous comment.
- 10098 12y agoWhat the hell does that have to do with anything?!
- 0x0 12y agohttp://xkcd.com/927/ http://xkcd.com/927/
- Ajedi32 12y agoThis isn't a new standard. This is a new rendering engine which implements existing standards.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jonathansampson 12y ago@IEDevChat on twitter is now (and for the next two hours) answering questions regarding Internet Explorer and Project Spartan. Just ask your question(s) with the hashtag #AskIE.
- melling 12y agoWhat keyboard is he using @3:10? It curves down? Looks a little like a wing.
- wluu 12y agoThat's the Microsoft Ergonomic Sculpt keyboard. I've got one, and while it's not a mechanic keyboard. It is quite comfortable, and if you want an ergo keyboard I'd highly recommend it. Here's a review by Marco Arment: http://www.marco.org/2013/08/30/sculpt-ergonomic-keyboard-review http://www.marco.org/2013/08/30/sculpt-ergonomic-keyboard-re...
- amelius 12y agoHere's an idea for an architecture that doesn't suffer from compatibility problems ever: - Every web site refers to the bytecode for its required render engine - This engine is loaded in an intelligent/cached way, and run in a sandboxed environment whenever the website is visited - Since the website picks its own render engine (or provides its own), the developers of the website know for sure that it will render the website correctly - Besides the render engine, also the scripting language could be referenced/provided in the same way. An architecture like this could boost the proliferation of open-source render engines and in-browser languages.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoso, Java, then the problem with bytecode is you lose virtually all the benefits of the web it's also not novel: you can do this today with JS, and your users will hate you because it can't be indexed and you can't select text
- amelius 12y agoThis approach doesn't need to depend on Java. It would preferably use a minimal, non-garbage-collected VM, or something along the lines of NativeClient (or simply asm.js initially). "It can't be indexed" happens to hold for a lot of websites that are basically single-page web-apps and which build their contents from within javascript. Fortunately, Google and others are using AI techniques to index pages. No need for special markup, or special structure. Text-selection can be built into the render-engine of choice. Granted, this is not a guarantee that it will work for all websites, but even today you can turn off text-selection for a website, so you don't have that guarantee now either. Also, AI or OCR could help here. As an added benefit, it would allow one to even select text in an image. Also note that this doesn't work so well in JS, because JS is not a multi-threaded language and it typically suffers from garbage-collection pauses. This is not good enough for UI work, unfortunately. And also not good enough as the target of compilers. But, granted, to get this started, JS (or the asm.js subset) could be used initially (and be replaced later).
- amelius 12y agoI'm just amazed that they had to figure out that the "long tail" matters. It seems so obvious. It is almost like the owner of a hardware store coming to the conclusion that his customers want more than just a swiss army tool.
- doppel 12y agoI really really hope Microsoft adopts the strategy from competing browsers: - Make one version of Spartan and keep it AUTO-UPDATED, instead of shipping a new version every couple of years that is, more or less, completely decoupled from the previous version. - Decouple the browser from the operating system. I don't really care if they make it cross-platform (though it would be nice), but if the browser stops updating unless you upgrade to the next version of Windows you WILL end up with legacy sites again and again that cater to a specific version, and then we can start over and just replace every rant against IE 6-7-8 with Spartan 1-2-3.
- thecatspaw 12y agocross-platform would be awesome. Would make it so much easier to develop for Microsoft's browser while not using Windows.
- Mahn 12y ago> Make one version of Spartan and keep it AUTO-UPDATED, instead of shipping a new version every couple of years that is, more or less, completely decoupled from the previous version. This is what IE 11 currently does, so I would imagine they will continue doing so with Project Spartan.
- jonathansampson 12y agoWe have actually been updating Internet Explorer for some years now. We don't touch machines that have opted out of updates, but for everybody else we've been moving them forward regularly. Spartan is neat because it's a separate app, built on a different architecture that will not only continue to allow us to update in an evergreen fashion, but it will allow us to do so at a much faster rate.
- hipsterrific 12y agoI like the fact that you guys are sampling more and more of the web rather than sticking to the top 9K sites. This will make fixing issues in one browser less of an issue (hopefully I'm crossing my fingers).
- Gravityloss 12y agoIs it just me or is there some kind of an air of sadness about the video? I like that they have real developers and not pr people talking about the product, and I don't like fake positivity. I guess it's impossible to please people like me, if you're Microsoft.
- somanim 12y agoThis is rubish. Bring back the glory days of Opera. Webkit has turned to trash and Chrome/Firefox along with it.
- cromwellian 12y ago(general reply to some of the negative comments in this thread) When someone is taking the right steps, I think they should be praised. Whatever bad feelings about Microsoft people have, they seem to be a newly revitalized company of late, are implementing cultural changes the way they interact with other ecosystems, and are shipping more open source, and seem to be playing well with others. We should reward good deeds, not punish them.
- taf2 12y agoWhen MS decides to release an open source rendering engine - we can start taking them seriously... until then they're never going to be worth taking seriously.
- mtrpcic 12y agoReleasing a rendering engine is what it takes, but releasing the entire .NET core isn't good enough?
- mattdesl 12y agoFor add-ons and DevTools plugins: it would be cool to have AtomIO style architecture. Easy to install, easy to develop for, easy to publish to npm, and written in pure JavaScript. IMHO it would quickly propel Spartan to the forefront of the developer community and would really help move the web forward.[1] [1] http://mattdesl.svbtle.com/motion-graphics http://mattdesl.svbtle.com/motion-graphics
- Ajedi32 12y agoYou mean like Vivaldi?
- rebootthesystem 12y ago>Our mission to create a Web that “just works” Errr. Sorry MSFT. The web pretty much does work. So long as you don't use IE. Seriously, I haven't touched IE in probably four years. OK, here and there when there's no choice for some reason. I could probably count those instances -over four years-- with two hands. We don't even test on IE any more. It's shit and I have no problem ignoring it. MS needs to understand that standards compliance is important. Don't waste my time and money dealing with your crap just because you were too incompetent or couldn't bother to make your browser standards compliant. And it is slooooooow. This coming from someone who's been with MS since day one. They are going to have to walk on water for me (and I am sure others) to give the new browser more than 30 seconds of a chance. That's how much trust they've lost. Oh, yes, what's up with this business of breaking fonts with a routine OS update. Do any of you folks at MS actually use the operating system you create and maintain? Nobody tested this KB3013455 update? Nobody saw that it is destroying fonts on various systems? And you are going to create a new browser? Sorry. A bit tired of bullshit. Don't tell me. Show me.
- edoloughlin 12y agowe felt it was important to counter movement towards a monoculture on the Web Am I alone in wishing there was an actual monoculture on the web? Where you could spend time making your app/site more functional instead of more compatible?
- touristtam 12y agoNow if they could just force this new web browser onto every single Windows XP and later installation out there, so we could get ride of the horrendous amount of IE version < 11 still in use, I would see this in a positive light. The only way I am using IE at the moment if for corporate website that are engulfed in MSFT technologies.
- scholia 12y agoIf Microsoft tried that, it would probably end up back in court. Microsoft actually has very little power over its large customers, or those customers wouldn't still be using XP, launched in 2001. If Microsoft could wave a magic wand then everybody would be on IE11, but it can't. In fact, it can't even make them patch security holes that were fixed years ago.
- runewell 12y agoAuto-update is the main feature I care about. With auto-update we don't have to worry about legacy browsers holding back the entire industry.