9 ms·
Internet of Crappy Things
- sgentle 12y agoI wonder if this might be the push that functional programming + formal verification needs to hit the mainstream. Compare Erlang, for example, which must have seemed needlessly complex and theoretical outside of modern super-horizontal-scale computing. I understand that NASA, the #1 in "if this code breaks we all lose our jobs" driven development, are big into formal methods. I think applying that same rigor to smart microwaves wouldn't be such a bad thing.
- pjmlp 12y agoWhat I see is Ada picking up steam after being people getting fed up with C like exploits every day. http://www.his-2014.co.uk/programme.html http://www.his-2014.co.uk/programme.html Or C being so limited, that it just looks like Ada with C syntax. http://www.misra-c.com/Activities/MISRAC/tabid/160/Default.aspx http://www.misra-c.com/Activities/MISRAC/tabid/160/Default.a...
- amm 12y agoThe formal verification subject is tricky. For a lot of software (especially in the web startup world) it is often not possible to hire someone trained in formal methods to perform extensive checks/proofs on software which undergoes rapid change as the company pivots every couple of months. Functional programming alone doesn't give you any guarantees about safer or more correct software than any object oriented language unless you ruthlessly exploit its type-system. Even if you do, the specs have to exist upfront and they have to be correct and stable. One can make the case that isolating side effects and capsuling them in a controlled structure is "the right thing" to do, but that alone does not give you any formal verification of your program. From personal experience I can only say that whenever I brought up formal verification because of security/correctness concerns, I was immediately shut down by business, because it's simply too expensive for software that doesn't control life-critical systems.
- nmrm2 12y agoI think with security (and esp. privacy), the problem is more coming up with the specs in the first place. If you can do that in a reliable way, designing appropriate static analyses is probably doable.
- tsotha 12y agoI'd rather not have everything I own connected to the internet. My appliances do everything I want them to do already. It's not just about hacking, either. It would be pretty easy to chart someone's routine if you knew every time he used something electronic.
- Sir_Substance 12y agoNot only would I prefer not to have everything connected to the internet, I believe it's imperative. In my first IT class at high school, my teacher told me something which has stuck with me as a golden rule of computer security: If you want to make a computer 100% secure, you should unplug all the cables, drop it in a vat of cement and then drop the entire block into the Mariana trench. He's right, but that's some next level security. However, a more usable tenant of security is that devices should be smart enough to do their job, and no smarter. Connecting your fire alarms to the internet will, at some point, result in someone setting all your alarms off at 2am just to fuck with you. The flip side is that if you're at home, you'll hear the alarm before you hear your phone, and if you're not at home then as long as it calls the fire brigade ASAP what different does it make if you get an alert on your phone? Why bother connecting it to the internet at all?
- digi_owl 12y agoThat assumes a two way connection, adn/or a persistent connection. Various existing fire alarms etc will only open a connection to the service provider when needed. This usually because it has a legacy from the POTS days. That is perhaps the biggest issue with IOT, assuming a always present and bidirectional connection.
- sliverstorm 12y agoConnecting your fire alarms to the internet will, at some point, result in someone setting all your alarms off at 2am just to fuck with you. Or, perhaps more sinisterly, someone remotely disabling all your alarms before committing arson.
- confiscate 12y ago"Connecting your fire alarms to the internet will, at some point, result in someone setting all your alarms off at 2am just to fuck with you." I disagree. The "at some point" argument can be applied to anything. Having a smartphone connected to the internet will, at some point, result in someone hacking into your phone and calling 911 using your phone number, tens times a day. At some point, it's going to happen to someone. By your argument, we should ban smartphones because they are not 100% secure. Phones should just be phones, and web browsers should be separate devices. Phones should not be internet accessible because then they can be hacked into.
- swombat 12y agoI hate to be running to the government for this, but... the FCC has regulations that require some level of testing for devices that are going to use certain parts of the spectrum. Some parts have been declared "free zones" and I believe that's where the wifi systems tend to operate. Perhaps we need the FCC to step in there and mandate some basic security certification for connected devices. At the very least the certifications should check that: * The device always uses some form of encrypted communications if at all possible based on what it's communicating with * If the device implements some form of remote control, that remote control includes both sufficiently secure authentication and authorisation mechanisms to ensure that at least it will take some effort to break into * The device does not leak personal data to unauthorised or unauthenticated requesters, and provides a clear list of what data will be willingly communicated to whom (software should do that too...) And so on... The certification process could/should be implemented by high-reputation security companies like Kasperski or Matasano... Until/unless some barrier to entry is erected, I think it's inevitable that everything that can be connected will be, and that this will mostly be insecure. In the meantime, I guess the solution is to only buy potentially connected devices from premium technology companies (e.g. Apple, Microsoft, Google, Tesla, Nest, etc) - but then, of course, those companies don't sell everything (e.g. no microwaves, car washes, etc) so that would limit the range of things you can safely purchase, for now... On that note, given how corrupt and broken the US system is, perhaps this needs to start in Europe, where there is already a general mindset of consumer and personal data protection...
- icebraining 12y agoFrankly, that sounds like a good way to kill open source IoT projects (which can't afford to hire Matasano) while helping TLAs by centralizing the information on just a few companies. I'd much rather have strong penalties to companies selling unreasonably insecure devices, with reimbursements to clients and rewards to the reporters of security flaws.
- swombat 12y agoThat could work as well... Perhaps a better method than the certification approach. My point is just: we probably need the government to help somehow.
- ansible 12y agoWe're currently working on a consumer device that could well be classified in the IoT category. We're pushing hard to put in multiple good layers of security, even though the hackable potential of the device is low. The amount of personal or otherwise exploitable information is also low. But that is no excuse to leak anything, or to allow the device to be taken over by attackers. The path isn't easy... the library support on many of these embedded platforms is poor. But it must be done.
- jdhouse4 12y agoThere are two things that can break IoT, security and fracturing. But security is a necessary condition for IoT to succeed. I know Apple has surprised many of the companies that want to work with HomeKit with its security requirements. I heard from one company that, for example, was upset that locks cannot be remotely activated. The last thing anyone needs is their house getting hacked and robbed as well.
- jkestner 12y agoIronically, fracturing has superficially improved security for the moment. Devices with the largest user base get a disproportionate amount of the attacks.
- draven 12y agoRemotely activated locks? What's the use case for this? Call your girlfriend when you're locked outside your house and ask her to open the door with her cellphone? There seems to be a high risk for little benefit, or perhaps I don't have a lot of imagination.
- ianhedoesit 12y agoI would imagine it was more of the opposite scenario. Rather than calling your girlfriend when you forget to lock your house, you might want to just lock it remotely.
- jkestner 12y agoThat goes back to what someone else questioned: Should we not address the problem more directly with devices that take action themselves? All we've done here is move the interface off the physical object. Not much in the way of actual smarts. Requiring an owner to take action on a smartphone is a transitional phase.
- higherpurpose 12y agoIoT devices should not be connected directly to the Internet. I don't want my "smart" lightbulbs to be turned on or off through the Internet. I also don't want them to become yet another way for the NSA to spy on us. All things that are connected to the Internet can be hacked, let alone things that come with poor security and from manufacturers that never intend to update them either. In fact, the plaftform makers for IoT (or governments if you will) should require manufacturers to update the security vulnerabilities for 80 percent of users until the end of life. For example, if 80 percent of customers keep the smart lightbulb for 5 years, then that's how long they should be updated. So far Google and ARM's Thread protocol for mesh networking between IoT devices looks interesting and seems focused on security. The devices connect only through a "gateway" through the Internet (which can be your smartphone). That feels like the right approach to me. http://threadgroup.org/Technology.aspx http://threadgroup.org/Technology.aspx
- digi_owl 12y agoEven if something is not directly connected to, or reachable from, the net they can still be a issue. Consider something like a network printer. Convenient as heck, but if your PC gets compromised only for a shot while the attacker may have left a little surprise in the printer firmware. End result is that even after you fully scrubbed the PC the attacker returns because the printer is acting as a proxy. More and more it feels like a no win situation, unless you physically unplug the router between each time you need to do something online.
- jorgecastillo 12y ago>More and more it feels like a no win situation It feels like this because most people are just not willing enough to spend the time, effort and money to be secure. The only thing you (as an average consumer) can't be secure against even if you tried really really hard (why bother) is a well funded government organization (from any country). Security threats for everywhere else are more or less manageable if you really want.
- wz1000 12y agoOr you can require the gateway to be formally verified, running something like this[0] Of course, then you have to construct a spec which is foolproof. [0]- http://www.ok-labs.com/_assets/image_library/NICTA-Technical-paper-Formal-Verification.pdf http://www.ok-labs.com/_assets/image_library/NICTA-Technical...
- _cudgel 12y agoI continue to fail to see how connecting appliances or small electronics to a network adds actual value. Simply throwing technology at a thing doesn't automatically make it better. Yet, here we are, rushing headlong into the "IoT". We ought to recognize this for what it is: pursuit of profit from uninformed purchasers.
- eveningcoffee 12y agoI think that connecting devices directly to the Internet is great nonsense and great danger to our privacy and security. Still it would make sense to have an possibility to connect them to local network.
- TheLoneWolfling 12y agolocal network = internet
- eveningcoffee 12y agoNo, it is rather: Internet = Second party controlled server, Local network = Your own controlled server.
- TheLoneWolfling 12y agoYour local network is airgapped, then? Because otherwise it's still internet-connected. If nothing else, the first person connecting to it with a cell phone is enough.
- eveningcoffee 12y agoYes, sure, but there is big difference between leaking your private data out of your home and break in.
- digi_owl 12y agoI can see some limited benefits, like applying inventory tracking tech to refrigerators. But for the most part you need to be there to refill the device etc.
- amirmc 12y agoThe push is that all devices will end up connected as commodity manufacturers continue to search for 'value-add' services (even if that value is dubious). In a few years, I wouldn't be surprised if 'smart TVs' were the only ones available. Security also becomes an afterthought as companies rush to get products in the market. This is mainly because the components used to build software rarely take account of security/privacy themselves so it has to be considered by the developers -- who are rarely trained to handle it. One approach to this is to build new tools and components that incorporate security & privacy by design. Discarding elements that are not required for a particular use case is also beneficial as there's less a hacker can do if they do manage to get in. These approaches are captured in ideas behind unikernels, such as MirageOS [1], which themselves can be part of a larger stack [2]. I work on both of these and we even put together a contest (Bitcoin Piñata) to incentive a search for weak spots (and a bit of fun) [3]. I honestly think that only new software stacks or government regulations can fix these issues. Given mass-surveillance, I don't hold out much hope for the latter. [1] http://mirage.io http://mirage.io [2] http://amirchaudhry.com/brewing-miso-to-serve-nymote/ http://amirchaudhry.com/brewing-miso-to-serve-nymote/ [3] http://amirchaudhry.com/bitcoin-pinata/ http://amirchaudhry.com/bitcoin-pinata/ and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9027743 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9027743
- pjc50 12y agoI'm evangelising the term "value-subtracted" for things which make money for the vendor at the expense of the user. Lenovo is just the latest, biggest example of this.
- jknightco 12y ago- "In a few years, I wouldn't be surprised if 'smart TVs' were the only ones available. " To your point: when I purchased a new TV last year, the only available "non-Smart" models were of generally inferior quality to the Smart models, from picture quality to physical design. I ended up purchasing one simply because it was the best TV at its price point—I had no interest in the "Smart" features.
- Torgo 12y ago
- whytry 12y agoNow just put this $100 arm band on so we can let your health insurer know how much to charge you.
- chiph 12y agoSure, the device you create for IoT is secure today. But in 3 years it may no longer be.
- alltakendamned 12y agoJudging by history, it _will_ no longer be.
- blueatlas 12y agoI agree that not every device needs to be connected, and there are security implications for those devices that could benefit from being connected. IoT will continue in a big way, and just like the early deys of the Internet, security solutions will develop. It would have been nice if Kapersky would have offered something in the way of potential solutions in this post.
- tootie 12y agoI know these aren't all web-based hacks, but I'm guessing the majority of connected devices are using http. Simply switching to https everywhere would remove a huge amount of attack surface for almost no cost.
- 0942v8653 12y agoThis is partly due to the big red warnings you get with self-signed certificates. Yes, it would certainly help, but to the user seeing a crossed-out https is worse than a simple http. And the user's perception matters much more than security does to these people.
- troymc 12y ago@tootie didn't say anything about the certificates being self-signed. Later this year, the new Let's Encrypt CA will make it free and easy to get certificates.[1] Moreover, it's my understanding that the default with HTTP/2 is for connections to be secure. [1] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/11/certificate-authority-encrypt-entire-web https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/11/certificate-authority-...
- jethro_tell 12y agoBut then you'd have to update the certs, which an appliance manufacturer isn't going to do.
- ryandrake 12y agoWhy not? If they're going to go to all the trouble to "Internet enable" a refrigerator, surely they can include yearly certificate changes as part of their maintenance plan.
- jethro_tell 12y agoThey really should, but I can't even get a cert update on my little home router, do you think a fridge maker is going to do that? Probably once it's out the door, they will pull the one programmer that writes the app and put him on then next fridge or the oven. It's very difficult to see an appliance manufacturer going back to update.
- geographomics 12y agoEven worse, the same sort of problems apply to SCADA systems, which are typically controlling much more dangerous or critical equipment than home appliances, e.g. http://www.computerworld.com/article/2475789/cybercrime-hacking/hackers-exploit-scada-holes-to-take-full-control-of-critical-infrastructure.html http://www.computerworld.com/article/2475789/cybercrime-hack...
- jessaustin 12y agoPresumably the "things" are networked via wifi? In that case I just won't enter my wifi creds, and they'll remain off the network. Possibly some devices might be more valuable when networked with each other locally, and the WAP they use just won't get connected upstream. Of course the things will still be vulnerable if they just connect automatically to any visible rogue WAP, in which case maybe one could glue some lead sheets around the antenna. The only government reaction to this phenomenon I would welcome would be a requirement for device vendors to clearly label devices that automatically connect to any visible WAP, or will only function when connected to the public internet. Demanding that devices like this be "secure" is silly. Only devices the firmware of which is regularly, securely updated, which update process is regularly observed by human beings, can even hope to be effectively secure for any period. We probably can expect that from POS devices in corporate use. We probably can't expect that from a refrigerator in some random family kitchen.
- MiguelHudnandez 12y agoSome HP printers, P1102w, have wifi cards, and when not associated with an access point, they will broadcast their own open network. There is no way to disable this except to open it up and remove the wifi card. I think some Roku models will also broadcast a wifi access point for the remote control to connect to.
- jessaustin 12y agoOur new Canon all-in-one will optionally run an AP, but it's off by default. I've seen roku APs before but I guess I just assumed they could be turned off or secured.
- jhou2 12y agoI was hoping to read more about the crappy quality of most "things" in the Internet of Things (The Nest thermostat is an exception to the rule). To cut costs, the sensors involved are usually very simple, "dumb", often built poorly with low quality components and not integrated very well. It's up to the software, which often isn't written that well either, to compensate. Just getting the system to work is difficult enough with the budget, time, and resources available. Never mind securing it. So, welcome to the Internet of Things that don't work half the time and could probably hurt or kill by accident.
- anotherevan 12y agoI'm far more interested in the Intranet of Things than the Internet of Things.
- blueskin_ 12y agoThis is why outbound filtering on firewalls is just as important as inbound, especially as manufacturers cram more spy capabilities into everything.
- task_queue 12y agoI can't wait for my dishwasher to report back to KitchenAid about its usage + the sights and sound it picks up while idle.