7 ms·
The problem of fake gold bars (2012)
- cgtyoder 12y agoThis is from 2012.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cgtyoder 12y agoSeriously - downvoted?
- jessaustin 12y agoUpdate: I forgot that gold is actually used, once in a while, to make things like jewels — which means that bars are melted down pretty frequently. If there was [sic] a significant number of salted bars out there, we’d know about it, since you’d notice when one of them got melted down. Which isn’t to say that there are no salted bars at all, but it certainly does seem to imply that there’s [sic] nowhere near 1.3 million of them.
- analog31 12y agoThat is, unless it's the owners of gold reserves who are salting their own bars to inflate their apparent net worth. I wonder if the acoustical properties of a fake bar would be easy to distinguish from solid gold.
- SapphireSun 12y agoJust do what Archimedes suggested. ;)
- analog31 12y agoWhat, run up and down the street naked, yelling Eureka? Actually, I'm agreed that you could measure the density, but somebody could fiddle with the density too by adding just a touch of this or that to bring everything up to the right weight.
- SapphireSun 12y agoYou could always take small core samples and run them through mass spec.
- imaginenore 12y agoYou suggest to drill every gold bar, thus ruining the certification?
- SapphireSun 12y agoRandom sample. I'm not familiar with gold bars, but I imagine that there are procedures for this (like rectifying at a new weight or recasting the sampled bars). A few milligrams of gold shouldn't be a big deal unless we're dealing with gold fever. If you're willing to melt them down though, you probably don't have to deal with mass spec as some property will have to give (melting point, density, etc).
- diroussel 12y agoWhere 'this or that' can only be something more dense than gold, which are not cheap: http://m.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=10+densest+elements http://m.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=10+densest+elements
- analog31 12y agoAha, I didn't look up the densities.
- imaginenore 12y agoYou can't determine if the gold bar is salted by only measuring its density. It's pretty easy to create a mix of gold, tungsten and osmium to have the exact same density as pure gold.
- ridgeguy 12y agoProbably. Acoustic velocities in tungsten are quite a bit higher than in gold. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speeds_of_sound_of_the_elements_(data_page) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speeds_of_sound_of_the_elements... It should be straightforward to make an acoustic time of flight go/no go meter you could place on a gold bar. Piezo excitation transducer/fixed distance/piezo receiver/process signal propagation velocity -> light up red or green light.
- darkmighty 12y agoAccording to those numbers for a ~10cm bar you'd need ~1 microsecond resolution, or more depending on your tolerance of the tungsten mixture (for 1% tungsten-platinum alloy substitution you'll need ~10ns resolution). I'm not sure this is easy to achieve! A best case commercial speaker/microphone will have a ~100khz bandwidth, which gives ~10 microsecond resolution. If you're aiming for high accuracy you also need to account for thermal variations in speed of sound, which would require a some precise thermometers.
- TaylorAlexander 12y agoI suppose don't use a speaker/microphone then. Use a laser reflected at an angle off the bar to an optical transducer and strike the bar. Watch for the initial strike and the reflection. The time domain is nothing for a dedicated CPU such as the 64MHz one I use in my projects. If the only issue is sensing the phenomenon, I'm sure something could be devised.
- TwoBit 12y agoIf I was a bank dealing with standardized gold bars, I'd make a machine that validates a bar at the push of a button. Surely they have that, given that a single 40 Oz bar is worth $800,000.
- packetized 12y ago"If you can weigh the bar accurately, then you can test for purity by essentially dropping it in a bucket of water and seeing how much the water level rises: a gold-covered tungsten bar will displace more water than a pure gold bar. " I'm afraid that either myself or the author doesn't fully understand fluid displacement.
- gatehouse 12y agoGold density is 19.30 g/cm3, Tungsten is 19.25. Given two gold bars, one adulterated with Tungsten, and one not, either the weight will differ or the volume will differ. So, given equal weights (i.e. standard 400oz bars), you can check the displacement to establish purity. If you use a container that is filled up to a spout, and you measure the displaced water by collecting it in a measuring cup, you can just directly calculate density, and then compare it to gold.
- gbhn 12y agoI don't know anything about this case, but it could be there's a bunch of air trapped inside the bar with the tungsten, assuming the forgers didn't alter the outside dimensions of the bar.
- hippich 12y agobar with tungsten is larger than pure gold bar. so air will not help here.
- joezydeco 12y agoNot if you start with a gold bar, then hollow the core out like a Twinkie and fill it with tungsten and the plug the end. Which I believe is what gbhn was implying.
- Terr_ 12y agoThen the bar is not heavy enough, because you've run out of room to add tungsten on the inside, and adding it on the outside would change the volume or shape of the bar. Tungsten is less dense than gold. Not as much a difference as actual twinkie filling, but either way you're stuck with a similar issue.
- rdtsc 12y agoSay you found your $100M worth of gold is salted. I am guessing you wouldn't advertise it in public too eagerly. You'd probably want to offload it and turn it into some other asset as soon as possible and make it someone else's problem.
- code_duck 12y agoI suppose that depends on your ethics… Though most people's ethics would be tested when it comes to $100 million. Hopefully, anyone discovering fake gold would file a lawsuit or report the fraud to law enforcement.
- TorKlingberg 12y agoSelling a gold bar you know is fake would be very unethical indeed. However I could imagine people would avoid testing gold they already own, as nothing good can come of it.
- damian2000 12y agoOne option is to only buy directly from a government owned mint that pours its own bars. e.g. http://www.perthmint.com.au/investment_bullion_bars_coins_barspage.aspx http://www.perthmint.com.au/investment_bullion_bars_coins_ba...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- code_duck 12y agoThis article would be more useful if it contained any sort of facts about or reasonable estimate of what the frequency of fake gold bars may be. As a glass flameworker, I and my colleagues buy gold, cut it up, stick it on rods of glass, and put it on the flame to deposit gold vapor onto glass. We would notice fake gold right away, but I haven't heard of that happening. (Though, the typical flameworker doesn't buy whole 1kg gold bars!)
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoOr just buy gold coins. Buy some Krugerrands, some Maple Leafs, some Double Eagles, etc. Yes they can also be fake, but what are the odds that you'll buy fakes of all those different coins?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- chebucto 12y agoThis same problem happened to the Ethiopian central bank. One batch, which had been bought from a trader, was discovered to be fake fairly quickly; another batch of faked gold, seized from smugglers, had been in their vaults for years. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/7294665.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/7294665.stm
- Htsthbjig 12y agoWell, banks are not stupid, and it is cheap for them to certify gold bars in quantity. There are certification authorities that do exactly that. Here in Spain you can hire them, and they will melt the gold in front of you and use expensive instrumental to know how much gold a gold bar has. We also have the concept of "notary" that is a person whose job is to certify something by law. They are trustworthy. It is individuals who should be afraid of being tricked. But you have at your disposal cheap microbalances, micro ohm meters(I made myself one for like USD30), 3d scanners(to calculate the volume as using water is tricky because surface tension of water), quartz transducers to measure speed of sound.
- alkimie2 12y agoAh! An area where bitcoin is superior to gold!
- logn 12y agoThe bigger worry should be the paper market. It's speculated that governments buying huge quantities of physical gold will sell non-existent gold on paper to keep the price of gold stable during their purchase.
- chrisbennet 12y agoI'd be more worried that your gold bars weren't actually in your bankers vault anymore. Look what happened when Germany tried to repatriate their gold from the U.S. Federal Reserve.
- brazzy 12y agoThey didn't "try", they are doing it, partially, piecemeal. Which may be because the Fed didn't actually have all that gold available, nicely separate in a vault labelled "Germany", but even if that is true, the case is rather more complex than just "The Fed embezzled the gold that Germany gave them for safekeeping". Because Germany never gave that gold - they never actually had it. It's in fact the German export surpluses from the time before the USA went off the gold standard.
- Stacko 12y agoAcoustic properties provide the solution to detecting fake bars. Specifically, sound velocity measured by ultrasound. Articles that discuss the issue and compare test methods can be found here. http://testyourgold.com/ http://testyourgold.com/
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]