9 ms·
Woman becomes obese after fecal transplant from overweight donor
- e40 12y agoIt has been posited before that bacteria or viruses might play a role in obesity. This is an interesting development, for sure.
- sarciszewski 12y agohttps://xkcd.com/605/ https://xkcd.com/605/ Please be careful not to read too much into one data point.
- delecti 12y agoAlternatively, the alt text from: http://xkcd.com/552/ http://xkcd.com/552/ > Correlation doesn't imply causation, but it does waggle its eyebrows suggestively and gesture furtively while mouthing 'look over there'. There seems to be enough evidence that it's not unreasonable to believe your weight is strongly influenced by your gut bacteria.
- sarciszewski 12y agoI wasn't talking about the relationship between the two, I was talking about "it happened to her, therefore it must be true".
- gambiting 12y ago>>Her weight gain continued despite a medically supervised liquid protein diet and exercise regimen. How is this possible? If they were supplying her with a certain amount of calories per day, she absolutely HAD to lose weight. Unless she was snacking, in which case the whole mystery is solved.
- jdminhbg 12y ago> If they were supplying her with a certain amount of calories per day, she absolute HAD to lose weight. It's weird how people talk about calories in/calories out as if they have a way to measure the second half of the equation.
- brohee 12y agoActually there are ways. A pretty efficient one is being hooked up to a machine measuring the amount of carbon dioxide you are generating, this is not practical outside of a lab tho. But more practically, monitoring heart rate is a decent proxy, after calibrating...
- task_queue 12y agoNot burning as many calories through exercise over time as previously thought? Altered metabolism that allowed her to pull more nutrients from her food or store them easier?
- Symmetry 12y agoThe number of calories that go into your mouth can be very different from the number of calories absorbed by your body. To give a simple example you'll absorb way more calories by eating a piece of bread with olive oil than if you eat the two pieces of food a couple of hours apart. And someone with intestinal parasites will receive notably less nutrition from their food than someone without. It would would actually be very surprising if intestinal flora didn't effect the ratio of calories consumed to calories absorbed.
- elmin 12y agoCan you cite your source on this please?
- panzagl 12y agoI wonder what the reaction will be if it turns out obesity isn't just about 'fatty has no self-control'
- api 12y agoIt would be the death of yet another piece of Calvinist moralist BS -- along the same lines as "the poor are just lazy," etc.
- chez17 12y ago>To treat ongoing CDI-related diarrhea problems, the woman received a fecal transplant from her overweight but healthy daughter, via colonoscopy. One possible situation is that she was eating poorly but didn't gain weight due to diarrhea and when she had healthy stool she gained the weight. Also, 'fatty has no-self control' is a way to stifle opposition to your opinion. Ther is no need for that. The laws of physics apply to all people. Burn more calories than you take in, you lose weight. Clearly there will be factors that determine how many calories you burn (perhaps someone burns them much slower than the average person), but as far as I've read magic isn't real yet. The laws of the universe still apply to everyone. I've yet to see anyone eat well and exercise and not maintain a healthy weight. Ever. Not once.
- CaveTech 12y agoAnd it's important to note that while she wasn't considered obese previously, her BMI was 26, which is considered overweight.
- morganvachon 12y agoBack when I was going through cancer, my weight dropped to around 130 pounds on a 6'4", large build frame. Obviously, I looked like Death himself and I was seriously underweight. However, even when I got back up to my normal 210 pounds and I still looked a bit too skinny, the chart showed me as being "overweight" at a BMI of 26. So I'd take that "overweight" indicator with a grain of salt. If this woman is on the tall side or has broad shoulders and hips, that BMI of 26 could mean she appears athletic or even skinny, and she can certainly be healthy with that misleading number.
- hipcactus 12y agoDr. R. Kelly
- jimrandomh 12y agoSo, a bit of background on fecal transplants. The idea is that you take the gut bacteria from a healthy donor, and put it in an unhealthy person's gut. This will make the recipient's metabolism/digestion more like the donor's. This has been found to work for weight loss; you give a normal-weight donor's microbiome to an overweight person, and they lose weight a significant fraction of the time. So, when I read: > the woman received a fecal transplant from her overweight but healthy daughter, via colonoscopy I cringed. There are three things wrong with that. First: you don't need to use a relative, because fecal transplants don't have risk of rejection. Second, you wouldn't use a donor who's overweight. And third, it's normally done with a swallowed capsule, not with a colonoscopy, which adds risk and unpleasantness for no reason. (Edit: The primary source says "With the occurrence of weight gain after FMT in this case, it is now our policy to use nonobese donors for FMT. The untoward consequences of using nonideal FMT donors are important, because patients may prefer to use a family member rather than an unrelated or unknown stool donor due to the perception that these sources are safer.")
- frandroid 12y ago> Second, you wouldn't use a donor who's overweight. Why did that make you cringe in particular?
- jimrandomh 12y agoBecause they're used as a treatment for obesity, based on a model of "they'll become more like the donor".
- UnoriginalGuy 12y ago> Second, you wouldn't use a donor who's overweight. Why? These transplants are so new and cutting edge that we don't know if taking from an obese person will be a bad or good thing, anecdotes like this might help us form an educated opinion, but it is too early to say for sure. You certainly cannot say for sure if that was a mistake because few know that really...
- 12y ago
- Balgair 12y agoFecal transplants.... what a world we live in.... That said, the study of gut flora is just starting. Here's a summary of <Nature Article I read a while ago but can't seem to find> : When raising sterile mice (no bacterial whatsoever) they tend to do pretty badly. Low body mass, overactive immune system, etc. Taking these mice and then doing fecal transplants (method is for sure 'icky') from obese PEOPLE and thing PEOPLE (totally strange), the mice tend to be obese or thin. Now, they then just cage sterile mice NEAR transplanted mice, and see the same thing, the flora just waft over and find a home. Then they cage sterile mice near thin and obese mice at the same time. The sterile mice get obese, rarely thin, and NOT in-between, it's all or nothing. Flora, this one article I once read states, come in flavors (real icky ones) that like to be in certain relations to each other. Why the mice tended to get obese is strange, and needs more funding. Real cool stuff, I guess, but then you get to be known as the 'rat poop eating' labs. So there is a detriment to the research.
- eof 12y agoIn high school we did an experiment where we caught different types of food on fire, and using them as fuel burning under a beaker, measured the temperature change of the water in the beaker. Later I learned that cow-dung was used for fuel in some of the poorer places on earth. I always assumed there must be some calories left in stool; and that this seeming-dogma about 'calories in calories out' was completely ignoring what could be a huge amount of calories getting shat out (or not).
- jnevill 12y agoShe didn't gain weight because of the calories in the fecal transplant. She gained weight, it's suspected, because of the new gut flora from the overweight donor. Different flora may mean a different metabolism.
- sparkman55 12y agoThere is an excellent New Yorker article on fecal transplants and gut flora. The article spends considerable time talking about the donors, and the rigorous screening process to make sure the donated bacteria are good ones. Obviously, that procedure wasn't followed in this particular incident. Worth a read! http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/12/01/excrement-experiment http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/12/01/excrement-exper...