13 ms·
Automating Tinder with Eigenfaces
- phreeza 12y agoIt would be hilarious if two people match up both using this bot.
- swah 12y agoHis soulmate is probably on reddit.
- ttty 12y agoI think that what you like is average.. therefore you will like the average.. as expected. If everyone will use a bot like this then only the beautiful girls will receive likes. Pointless. If only you will use the bot then you will have a certain advantage over others. This remembers me a guy that was a mathematician and found his wife with math. Was on another dating site. I never used tinder.
- Quiark 12y agoSince Tinder already shows you almost nothing else but photos, we are already in the situation you describe. OTOH, there's always a gradient, not everyone can have the prettiest girls.
- withdavidli 12y agoProbably the only bot that would appeal to women with its preference setting. It's mostly guys using the bots and filtering after the matches. Love reading the Tinder app reviews: "this thing is broken, been using it for a week and no matches. I ain't that ugly." <- this is almost verbatim. I'm always fancinated by how men and women differ in their usage of a dating app, might as well have two separate UIs. Observing women use Tinder they swipe right around 1 out of 50-100. Just insane differences when compared to guys. I always thought Tinder could monetize by having auto swipe and an undo option.
- s_kilk 12y agoThey've actually introduced a paid-for undo button last week. So not that far off.
- withdavidli 12y agohaha, took them a while. I just deleted mine last week. Of course I make a comment regarding it XD!
- marvin 12y agoThis phenomenon is endemic to dating culture in general. It's strange that the large majority of young Western women who have ridiculously fickle preferences, don't have the insight to realize the consequences of their behavior (or even notice the behavior in the first place). It makes the experience bad for 90% of the participants. Not a bad thought to have separate interfaces by gender, maybe there is something in this idea that could be explored. Although at that point you're sort of codifying shitty gender stereotypes, which might be a transgression that's even worse.
- anjc 12y ago> This phenomenon is endemic to dating culture in general. It's strange that the large majority of young Western women who have ridiculously fickle preferences, don't have the insight to realize the consequences of their behavior (or even notice the behavior in the first place). It makes the experience bad for 90% of the participants. There are no words. Let me see if I understand you correctly. The consequence of women, who are too stupid to know better, having dating preferences, is that your Tinder experience isn't optimal. Is that what you're saying?
- Udo 12y agoThe standard perception is that women are scarce and men are dime-a-dozen. I strongly suspect this might be true even in the gay dating scene (maybe someone qualified might weigh in on this hunch). Like in many social conventions, this scheme kind-of works as long as you subscribe to it. Men are supposed to be undiscerning, women are supposed to reject people like it's a bodily function. As long as you fall within that schema and pursue your partners in a way that confirms their social expectations, you're fine. If you don't like that game, however, it's difficult. Thankfully the internet exists, so it should be possible to date like-minded people who don't subscribe to this convention. Then again, I'm a European, so YMMV.
- nemothekid 12y agoI feel the human race has made a rather amusing step forward to rule-by-algorithm. 30 years ago this would be dystopian, today its a byproduct of a mish-mash of open source libraries.
- 3beard 12y agoI wish I could work myself up into some kind of indignation, but what I really believe is this: if you willingly submit yourself to the cesspits of human banality (i.e. Facebook, Tinder and all the likes), you pretty much deserve all the crap that will be unloaded on you.
- noonespecial 12y agoSo there's the dystopia. The humans become the nearly identical constantly replaceable consumable that the algorithms steer across a dozen generations, mating them and connecting them together to father the algorithms' own silicon ends whatever those happen to turn out to be. I hope they don't like paperclips.
- jarman 12y ago>identical constantly replaceable consumable that the algorithms steer across a dozen generations, mating them and connecting them together to father the algorithms' own silicon ends Surprisingly precise description of life (up to sillicon / carbon substitution)
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoOh please. There was never a Divine Plan for your life, and there's never going to be a mash-up sub-intelligent algorithm that overrides your own direction over your own life. It takes other intelligent agents to do that, ie: people. Crappy classification or regression algorithms being misapplied as cheap, stupid business ideas... are basically nothing like super-intelligent paper-clip maximizers.
- Padding 12y agoRichard Dawkins paints a similar picture in "The Blind Watchmaker". In some way it's ironic that with all that effort we've spent on AI so far, simple evolution may yet beat us to the punch as far as AGI is concerned. Makes you wonder about how irrelevant humans are in the grand scheme of things.
- ac166 12y agoI can't quite articulate why fully, but to me this article sums up everything that's wrong with programmers and the community in general (of which I consider myself a part). :(
- gurkendoktor 12y agoBecause it is superficial and cheekily disrespectful of traditional social interactions, and typical "pre-bro" programmers take these interactions very seriously, since producing reliability is our duty above all? That's how I feel sometimes.
- agilebyte 12y agoI don't see it as a wrong. Just a lot of programmers have a personality type that sees us planning and optimizing everything, making it into systems and disregarding rules of social interaction to some or greater extent. You need people like this to push the boundaries.
- waspleg 12y agoFrom Jurassic Park: Dr. Ian Malcolm: If I may... Um, I'll tell you the problem with the scientific power that you're using here, it didn't require any discipline to attain it. You read what others had done and you took the next step. You didn't earn the knowledge for yourselves, so you don't take any responsibility for it. You stood on the shoulders of geniuses to accomplish something as fast as you could, and before you even knew what you had, you patented it, and packaged it, and slapped it on a plastic lunchbox, and now [bangs on the table] Dr. Ian Malcolm: you're selling it, you wanna sell it. Well... John Hammond: I don't think you're giving us our due credit. Our scientists have done things which nobody's ever done before... Dr. Ian Malcolm: Yeah, yeah, but your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could that they didn't stop to think if they should.
- hagan_das 12y agoCare to elaborate? I don't see anything wrong with this and can't imagine how it "sums up everything that's wrong with programmers and the community in general". It's a very clever and interesting piece of automation.
- matthewmacleod 12y agoAll were in agreement that it is not creepy, though some felt it was borderline It definitely is creepy, though.
- andrey-p 12y agoI guess creepiness is a bit of a sliding scale. Maybe somehow the bot also managed to get through to a subset of women on Tinder who don't find this creepy?
- sjtrny 12y agoHow? It isn't invading anyone's privacy or personal space. The actions the bot performs are exactly the same as what humans do.
- jarman 12y ago>exactly the same That's why. People take pleasure in expressing base instinctive behavior (and Tinder is mate choosing, refined to laboratory grade purity), but like to pretend it's something more dignified, not something that can be done by basic machine, be it organic or semiconductor.
- matthewmacleod 12y agoIt doesn't have to be an invasive action to be creepy. I'm confident that setting up a bot to pretend to be human and to engage in conversation is pretty creepy, and I don't think that's a particularly outlandish position to take.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gadders 12y agoLooks like someone has tried to make the blog post on High Frequency Dating from Rob Rhinehart (Mr Soylent) a reality: http://robrhinehart.com/?p=1005 http://robrhinehart.com/?p=1005 (worth a read, it's pretty funny)
- djloche 12y agoAutomate the matching, then the conversations, then the meet-up schedule. TinderPro could be a paid service built on top that has you swipe left/right for x pictures and then takes it from there and does all the rest of the legwork. You pay $$ per month and based on your settings, it schedules dates for you (based on openings on your linked calendar app).
- pachydermic 12y agoThen OpenTable an automatic reservation service, Yelp an automatic review service, Amazon Prime adds an automatic gifting service and finally a way to produce children just by sending in some sample DNA. Perfect efficiency!
- robotnoises 12y agoNOTIFICATION FROM TINDERPRO: Congratulations you are now married.
- TheHypnotist 12y agoThis would really take the pressure off asking someone out.
- kehrlann 12y agoI am not too creeped out by the concept of this bot (actually, I find the whole idea amusing). I can understand why people would find it creepy, but I feel that the creepiness comes from Tinder rather than the bot ... It's only possible because of Tinder and the way it makes users interact with each other. Not a Tinder user myself, so I guess I'm biased in this case.
- StavrosK 12y agoI can't understand why people would find it creepy. There's already a filter built into Tinder (show me women/men), why is an extra filter suddenly creepy? If a bot can know what I find unattractive and filter that out, why not?
- warcode 12y agoProbably the automated messaging/conversation. Anything else is just normal Tinder.
- lmm 12y agoJust like IRL: only looking at women or only looking at men isn't creepy. But only looking at people with particular physical characteristics (aside from the small set that are acceptable to judge on) is creepy.
- path411 12y agoI think this is a pretty natural progression of applying machine learning to real life. I find that people will say things like "I prefer people with blue eyes", but what they are really saying is that the people they find attractive often have blue eyes. Humans don't seem to be able to actually determine the characteristics of a person's looks that makes them attractive, and rather resort to pattern recognition bias. So instead a computer is able to determine what you are actually attracted to as it doesn't have the same bias and is able to consciously distinguish more data from a person's face than the extremely basic set a human can.
- th0br0 12y agoAwesome. Thought about doing something similar a while ago but this certainly beats what I had in mind ;)
- allendoerfer 12y agoThat was step one. Now write a social network for your university.
- hippich 12y agoin this case it seems it should be social network for bots. with tinder's users faces as avatars :)
- for_i_in_range 12y agoLooking forward to attending a wedding where the How We Met story is, "Through a Tinder Eigenface k-nearest neighbor machine-learning algorithm."
- S4M 12y ago"And that, kids, is how I met your mother."
- maurits 12y agoWell, it wouldn't be without precedent exactly. "Operation Match" dates back to the sixties. [1][2] [1]: http://blog.modernmechanix.com/boy-girl-computer/ http://blog.modernmechanix.com/boy-girl-computer/ [2]: http://thecomputerboys.com/?p=654 http://thecomputerboys.com/?p=654
- Backlash85 12y agolaughing out loud <-- yes I typed it out
- bendyBus 12y agoWhat can I say? our bots just really hit it off.
- sarasastro 12y agoHow does this take boobs into consideration ?!
- mescam 12y agoThis is a very important question, indeed.
- Padding 12y agoI love how this is a perfectly valid question given the context .. even if the phrasing may be somewhat off. Back to topic, I'd think boobs (and other parts of the body that aren't part of the face) won't have much impact on prefrences. Would you really reject someone because of their cup size, despite their pretty face? Similary, would you accept someone just because of their cup size despite their less-than-pretty face? I mean sure there are people out there for whom this may be a valid concern, but it won't for the vast majority. So the question then really only is where you draw the line - what about asymmetric boobs and other body features?
- D-Coder 12y agoWhy shouldn't cup size be important to many people? "Would you really reject someone because of their face, despite their excellent cup size? Similary, would you accept someone just because of their face despite their less-than-excellent cup size?"
- draugadrotten 12y agoBad boy. The ideology du jour is left-wing feminism and HBTQ. Boob quality is a male desire, and hence is chauvinist and bad. Now, if tinder offered girls the ability to filter guys by wallet thickness and status... that would be different and totally appropriate.
- daemonfire300 12y agoDepends on the angle. I would say if it comes to Tinder all you get is a picture. So the only metric is the body-form-shape-sizes etc. If the size of some body parts can be measured with the submitted images I see nothing wrong here. Wallet thinkness and status are not represented in our data (image), so it would not make sense to include those metrics, since its out of scope.
- ErikBjare 12y ago> Another person thought it was really cool and wanted the full tour. This could easily be mistaken as a metaphor for sex.
- randomsearch 12y agoPrecision and recall stats needed.
- donkeyd 12y agoTinder should start using Eigenfaces to give people an estimate of the chance of finding a match when they sign up. You know, to manage expectations. "With your face and your standards you have a 1% chance to find a match. Please lower your standards or improve your face."
- junto 12y ago"improve your face". See South Korea plastic surgery stats: http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2012/04/daily-chart-13 http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2012/04/daily-c...
- warfangle 12y agoSee also, lawsuit over similar: http://entertainment.ie/wtf/Chinese-man-divorces-and-sues-wife-over-ugly-children-And-wins/227669.htm http://entertainment.ie/wtf/Chinese-man-divorces-and-sues-wi...
- pavel_lishin 12y agoThis is not a real story: http://www.snopes.com/media/notnews/uglybaby.asp http://www.snopes.com/media/notnews/uglybaby.asp
- warfangle 12y agoI stand corrected.
- juliangregorian 12y agoApocryphal: http://www.snopes.com/media/notnews/uglybaby.asp http://www.snopes.com/media/notnews/uglybaby.asp
- warfangle 12y agoI stand corrected.
- iopq 12y agoCan someone also make a bot that goes on dates with women to filter them? With your face and conversational data, of course, or they'd think it's weird.
- anantzoid 12y agoIt's surprising to see that the Messaging bot actually worked out pretty well (according to the author) given the fact that StanfordNLP's sentiment analysis really sucks sometime. Probably because the initial chat messages are very similar and generic.
- saiya-jin 12y agoHow many of you folks have found a long lasting, good quality date via Tinder? Serious question, no pun intended. For me, albeit using it for only cca 6 months, it was useless. Same for people around me. Yes, I got tons of likes, many conversations, a few dates that could be more if wanted, but women available via this were mostly... uninteresting. I am a bit picky (I am quite sporty type, and silicone beauties whose idea of perfect sunday is basically doing nothing while showered in luxury repulse me). Never been looking for one night stands or similar, that's for poor folks with daddy (and other) issues. Those kind of "relationships" tend to take more from person than give, and after some time, meeting such a person is rather sad story (or, more blatantly who wants to seriously date slutty used opposite sex). Well, once you've got things to offer to women that they want, you can, and will be picky. I kept telling myself, it's just another way of meeting people, like all others. But for me, tinder crowd ain't doing the "game" seriously enough. Maybe location didn't help (Geneva, on border with France, and to be polite general French mentality towards relationships ain't compatible with mine). So I found amazing girl via other ways (climbing), dropped whole tinder app into oblivion. Nice idea, and kudos to this guy for really getting max out of concept, but not for me. And seeing success rate around me, just going to a stupid bar, dressing nicely and just be a man women want gives you way more reward for any effort. But it cannot be done from couch, can it :)
- mpthrapp 12y agoI met my current girlfriend on Tinder. We've been together a year as of the end of this month. I had tried OkCupid as well and had no luck, though I'm not sure that was the fault of the site.
- saiya-jin 12y agoall the good luck to you & your relationship ;)
- JeremyMorgan 12y agoI'm pretty sure Tinder and OkCupid and the like have just slightly different results statistically as any other form of dating. Because of the efficiency and availability there is a chance of more misses and people not taking it as seriously, but overall I think it would be foolish to say real relationships cannot be developed by these sites. Best of luck to you both.
- solve 12y agoYou should try shuffling around this pipeline a bit. Instead of: See face -> Score face -> Yes them only if score is good Try: See face -> Yes to all -> Score the faces of people who Yes you back Also would be really interesting to create multiple Tinder profiles with different pictures, and see the beauty score distributions of people who Yes'ed each different picture. That would be a very nice, automatable dating A/B testing experiment.
- omaranto 12y agoAll were in agreement that it is not creepy, though some felt it was borderline. I wonder how much of the feeling that this was not creepy came from the fact that he wrote the code himself. To me these two sounds pretty different: "I came up with an algorithm that attempts to choose people and starts conversations the same way I would." "I'm using an app I found that chooses people and starts conversations for me." Come to think of it, neither sounds exactly creepy to me. The first sounds awkward but the second just sounds lazy... My point is that there is a difference between writing the code yourself and just using it.
- draugadrotten 12y agoAll were in agreement that it is not creepy, though some felt it was borderline. If I was sitting face to face with a creepy guy I would also not challenge him that his actions are creepy. I would just do anything to calm him down, then leave at first opportunity.
- omaranto 12y agoThat's a good point.
- jareds 12y agoIf I were single I would be using this. I'm totally blind so Tinder has never been useful to me. I don't know how well it would work but I could see having my friends help me train it by describing pictures to me. I was never a big fan of the like absolutely everyone option, I felt like it would be hard to start a conversation. "Why did you like me?" "The algorithm I use to make up for the fact that I can't see your picture decided I should like you." would at least be a unique way to start a conversation.
- ibebrett 12y agoIts just as arbitrary as "why do you like me?" "we happened to be in the same bar, which is randomness+a bit of factors based on our personalities" just because a computer is not causing you to randomly meetup at say a party, bar, concert doesn't mean its more or less based on randomness + a few factors based on your personality, location, age, etc (more or less what dating sites use)
- eyeareque 12y agoWhat photo would you seed the algorithm with? As in, do you have a preference for facial features? a Tinder for the blind population would be pretty awesome. If everyone was forced to take a 3d photograph (MS kinect scan maybe?), the algorithm would work even better.
- UUMMUU 12y agoI do like seeing Scala being used more.
- cinquemb 12y agoPretty cool. I really like that people are exploring ways to come in contact with one another. I wonder if someone would add a meta data filter that if a twitter /Instagram /vine handle is found, grab the max tweets, vines, posts (filtering out reposts/tweets perhaps) and see how they cluster compared to past selections/interactions.
- ha292 12y agoA person is not a face. Dating sites of all shades "sell" us a person at various levels of depth and according to our interests. Our interests can be deep, or can be shallow. Tinder is "selling" shallow+fun (Appearances, nearness, sexual adventure). Shallow + fun sells. Look at a magazine. Eigenfaces takes the idea a step forward. Automate shallow+fun+selection. Remember the vaporized alcohol craze ?
- driverdan 12y agoWhat's your point? Everyone knows Tinder is primarily for hookups and is shallow.
- pkfrank 12y ago>Another person thought it was really cool and wanted the full tour. Innuendo?
- EGreg 12y agoOf course humans are way more advanced at this. We can look at more than faces. We can look at a person turned slightly to the side, and size up their body, face, hair, read their expression, and what they're trying to say, in a fraction of a second. Let's see how eigenface figures that out. Until then, swiping right for everyone may be a better strategy for straight guys.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tibbon 12y agoThe predefined message trees were kinda terrible, "I can't wait to introduce you to my mom"?!?!? Aside from that, its pretty neat. Edit: kinda wish it ran data analysis on multiple threads/cores. Edit2: It seems to be taking up 61 threads right now in fact... so its doing that quite well.
- TheHypnotist 12y agoAt least tell you are a fan of moms??
- kirk21 12y agoAnyone that can create a noob proof walkthrough to get this thing running? Thanks.
- touristtam 12y agoit is actually in the readme: install sbt, run the commands. That's assuming you have cloned the repo on your local machine and are running the commands from within the local repo.
- goblin89 12y agoI imagine paid services offering this functionality are about to come up and rise and make news with their profits. Perhaps Tinder will have its own built-in. The potential is certainly there. Automatic messaging would be especially neat. Bots can take the time-wasting initial conversations all to themselves, after exchanging with each other more or less predefined templates they’d employ a crude ML-enhanced algorithm to estimate whether their respective human masters would like to take it from there or let it slip. Less awkwardness, less uncertainty, more efficiency.
- jeffreyrogers 12y agoThe problem is that no matter how clever you make your algorithms in the end dating is about people. And if the person isn't interesting then nothing else matters. There are other things worth optimizing in ones life besides technical sophistication. Interpersonal skills are a big one.
- kirk21 12y agoCould do some A/B testing on your own pics + description to see what works best.
- kpierce 12y agoYeah I was wondering if someone had built this feature. Put 15 or so pictures with descriptions. Use some spintax to optimize. Same with messages.
- JeremyMorgan 12y agoSo how does it handle the plethora of ladies who post pics of themselves with another guy? Or other girls?
- cheald 12y agoFTA: "Only pictures with single, identifiable faces are used (to filter out false positives)."
- brosky117 12y agoReminds me of anaface.com (where they tell you how attractive you are based off of symmetry). I'm married so this is just plain entertainment for me but I think there are some genuine use cases for this on the Tinder side of things. Think about it. If Tinder knew your preferences and was able to analyze the faces of all the users nearest to you, it could make your feed so much more relevant. In the end, Tinder's success is directly proportional to the number of dates it sets up. Basically, the more "attractive" people you encounter in your feed, the more frequently users will engage with and return to the app. I'm biting off an idea that is too big for me to chew but I imagine huge potential here.
- JimboOmega 12y agoKind of. You need attractive users who will interact with you, not just that you get to swipe. Honestly, taking guys swiping out of the equation until women have swiped them would already massively improve the experience for most users. I've run into plenty of guys complaining that in a week and hundreds of swipes, they get none in return; and women complaining that the app must be broken because everyone they swipe right to already liked them back. Of course Tinder is interesting already because it's gotten people to buy into the bare minimum effort side of things - unlike other sites which generally try to find good matches based on personality, shared friends, or anything.
- duderific 12y ago> Honestly, taking guys swiping out of the equation until women have swiped them would already massively improve the experience for most users. My understanding is that the app Coffee Meets Bagel does exactly this.
- JimboOmega 12y agoIn a strange coincidence I downloaded that very app about 3 hours ago. But their site was down or not accepting signups or something, so I left it aside. Anyway, from what I can tell, it's selling point is that it gives you one match a day... as opposed to the endless waves of matches of OkCupid or Tinder. Whether or not that's actually a better experience, I don't know, but I do know a few female friends who like it. So that's enough to get me interested.
- andkon 12y agoSo I've been using this for a few hours now. The automatic messaging is hilarious ("Lisa are you a fan of avocados?") and weirdly effective. Also, it's been showing me that my non-robot tinder game just sucks, and could be improved with the basic principles of flirting: no seriousness ambiguity and non-sequiturs get conversation going being bold and casual about the things you say Basically, every message should communicate that you don't really give many fucks, and are playful.
- magicalhorse 12y agoAvocadoes, and "I can't wait to introduce you to my mom!" are weirdly effective. The Tinder game is strong in this one.
- JDiculous 12y agoWait, so guys are still getting matches on there? Am I the only one who doesn't get matches anymore? A couple years ago I'd get like 5-10 matches/day using the app for like 10-15 mins/day tops. Every time I'd log in, the first 5-10 or so profiles would be from people who swiped right on me. Now I seriously never get matches anymore. I'd estimate that it'd take me 30 minutes of swiping right on every single profile to even get a single match. I live in one of the most population dense areas (Manhattan) and consider myself at least average looking. Anyways I've abandoned Tinder for a competitor. I'm getting matches in the new app at a rate that's more in line with how Tinder used to be for me. My theory is that guys on Tinder just began swiping right on every single profile. I guess it's more efficient that way because then you can just filter the matches afterwards who you know are already interested in you. But the downside is that it makes women more selective. Even then though, it doesn't make sense that I can load up Tinder now, swipe right on the first 100 profiles, and not get a single match (unless they changed the algorithm to not put people who liked you you at the top).
- JimboOmega 12y agoSwiping right constantly is close to my strategy, and most guys, because of the low rate of matches. I've been known to swipe right rather than wait for images to load, definitely.
- Apofis 12y agoWhat's the alternative?
- freyr 12y ago> and consider myself at least average looking There's your problem. Many men on various online forums have compared their response rates when using a photo of an average looking man (or even above average looking man) and when using a photo of a very attractive man. The average man gets almost no matches, and the attractive man gets nearly all matches -- and, apparently, a surprising number of invitations for casual sex. It seems to be a case of the Pareto principle, with 20% of men claiming 80% of the rewards, though the numbers might be closer to 5% and 95%. I'd assume this is a consequence of skewed supply and demand, where most men are happy to match with anyone and therefore swipe right frequently, and women receive many potential matches and can afford to be selective. I suspect this plays out in the dating scene as well (e.g., a small percentage of men sleep with a disproportionately large percentage of women). But the situation seems even more skewed on Tinder, where all emphasis is on physical appearance.
- ikonos_de 12y agoWhat template was used for the interface from the screenshot?
- acannon828 12y agoJust to make sure I'm understanding how this works: 1. Faces are simply averaged for "Yes" and "No" training swipes. 2. Each one of these two "average" faces are mapped to an Eigen space (where the Eigen vectors are computed from the training sets? or were they preprocessed with some other dataset?). 3. For every new face, the bot maps that face to the same Eigen space and makes a Yes/No decision based on whichever model vector it's closest to (either the "Yes" vector or the "No" vector). ...right?
- acannon828 12y agoIf that's the case (I think it is but correct me if I'm wrong) wouldn't it make more sense to compute the Eigen-representation of each training face first, then average those Eigen face representations as opposed to the cropped faces themselves?