20 ms·
Boston Dynamics' New Robot – Spot
- tmikaeld 12y agoMan, look how stable this new model is. Could almost place a coffeecup on top and it wouldn't spill.
- bastih 12y agoDoes anyone else feel creeped out by these robots? Put a flamethrower on and some intelligence into Spot, and have the intelligence decide that humans are bad.
- m-app 12y agoIt's just a walking robot. Drones have been here for a lot longer and already carry deadly weapons. Following your logic, you should've been scared and running for years already.
- derefr 12y agoIndeed; further, if we actually wanted something that could climb into your house and shoot you remotely without expending human life—we could have just stuck a turret to a cellphone to a police dog. Robots are scary only because they allow for ubiquitous drone warfare—millions of drones just clogging the streets, or maybe small enough to hide in the shadows like stray pets. For targeted drone warfare, though, we've already had the technology for a long, long time.
- jpindar 12y agoPolice departments already use robots with cameras and guns. But because they're small and have tank treads rather than legs no one seems worried about them.
- blechx 12y agoTo be fair, if you ask people in Yemen, 'scared and running' is probably exactly to the point. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/feb/10/drones-dream-yemeni-teenager-mohammed-tuaiman-death-cia-strike http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/feb/10/drones-dream-ye...
- onion2k 12y agoNo less scary than a human with a flamethrower deciding which humans are bad. At least with the robot there's the potential for the excuse that it's gone wrong rather than wanting to kill people for whatever reason.
- Shivetya 12y agowhich is more frightening. Oh, the robot did it. Great, like that is going to make it all okay. Fuck, drones have already allowed those in charge to excuse themselves from bad choices, now who are we going to blame? The programmer or the robot? I guess whomever ever has the least protection under the law, the robot certainly won't care
- askmike 12y ago> Fuck, drones have already allowed those in charge to excuse themselves from bad choices This has been happening since thousands of years before drones came along. Humans are used since the beginning of time..
- 1stop 12y agoWe don't have any military autonomous drones... there is pilot pulling the trigger... so I don't understand your point.
- hmottestad 12y agoDefinitively creepy. I was thinking about the two legged robots in start wars, walker something or other.
- akavel 12y agoHalfway through the movie, when suddenly there are two of them, now this was creepy to me... like if the first one suddenly cloned effortlessly... and now both are happily hopping along, never tired, we're just harmless, funny guys, you know, your best friends!... <shudder>
- prawn 12y agoClimbing the hill with their eye crazily spinning around!
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoLess scary than an automated or remote-controlled drone shooting a missile from a few kilometers away TBH. Easier to kill, too. Probably a lot cheaper to produce, too. And more effective.
- jp_sc 12y agoIt remind me at these enemies from Half Life 2 ep2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mT-tV7zOEPU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mT-tV7zOEPU
- jobigoud 12y agoIs this a rotating camera for navigation ? Is there more in depth info on this particular piece of the robot ?
- monk_e_boy 12y agoLooks like the same lidar they use on google cars
- platinum1 12y agoLooks similar to what's on top of Google's self-driving cars. I didn't really imagine that much integration between Boston Dynamics and the rest of Google, but perhaps this is a sign that the two groups have joined (or are at least working together).
- dangrossman 12y agoI don't think the use of LiDAR indicates any connection to the car group. You can pick up a Neato robot vacuum at Wal-Mart for $100 with a spinning LiDAR on top, and that's been on store shelves since before Google acquired their first self-driving car team. It's just the go-to sensor for mapping your surroundings in near-realtime.
- culturestate 12y agoIt looks like a Velodyne HDL-32 [1] LiDAR unit. Broadly speaking, it pulses a bunch of lasers (32 in this case) really fast and measures the response time of each beam; think hyper-focused radar. The resulting point cloud can be used to build a high res map of its surroundings essentially in realtime. 1. http://velodynelidar.com/lidar/hdlproducts/hdl32e.aspx http://velodynelidar.com/lidar/hdlproducts/hdl32e.aspx
- mturmon 12y agoI forget the cost of that unit, but it's north of $10K, maybe $20K.
- WillNotDownvote 12y ago
- lispm 12y agoInteresting to see where they will be deployed first. Afghanistan or some inner city conflict in the US?
- desdiv 12y agoDidn't Google announce that they won't be taking any more DARPA contracts in the future? People were reading into that and suggesting that they were moving away from all military hardware all together. That's what I was told anyways: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8825795 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8825795 EDIT: Better sources: http://www.businessinsider.com/google-and-darpa-robotics-challenge-2014-3 http://www.businessinsider.com/google-and-darpa-robotics-cha... http://www.popsci.com/blog-network/zero-moment/google-rumored-be-pulling-its-team-darpa-robotics-challenge http://www.popsci.com/blog-network/zero-moment/google-rumore...
- asdkl234890 12y agoDidn't Google announce that they won't be taking any more DARPA contracts in the future? Yes, but they will also finish the current contracts.
- lispm 12y agoDoes that mean Google will not SELL those robots to the army? DARPA only FUNDED THE R&D for most robots from them. DARPA is a funcding organization for military research projects: Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency. The real customers then will be military, police, homeland security and agencies active in special operations (CIA, ...). From their homepage: > Organizations worldwide, from DARPA, the US Army, Navy and Marine Corps to Sony Corporation turn to Boston Dynamics for advice and for help creating the most advanced robots on Earth. So US Army, Navy and the Marine Corps are already giving money to Google for military robotics projects.
- onewaystreet 12y agoMilitary use isn't as big a market as you think it is. iRobot is the largest supplier of robots to the US military but military sales only account for 10% of its revenue.
- akurilin 12y agoCan't have a real dog, but I'll sure go for one of these.
- moreati 12y agoThat's a lot quieter. Is this the first BD quadruped to run without a engine? Anyone care to guess how long the (I assume) batteries last?
- msane 12y agoThis was the first thing I noticed as well. I believe it still runs on diesel. It seems like they wanted to solve all the other issues before moving on to making things quieter and smaller. If you look at the latest ATLAS iteration it is also quieter.
- Kronopath 12y agoFrom the description: Spot is a four-legged robot designed for indoor and outdoor operation. It is electrically powered and hydraulically actuated.
- yellowapple 12y agoBD's first, possibly, but I know there are some folks at MIT who are/were working on an electric quadruped as well.
- Shivetya 12y agoHit it with a car. Can it get up if knocked over? Fall down a stairs and get up? Can it walk on three legs? Just how resilient is it? I am impressed what it can do in the video but I would love to see how it recovers from other than very tame issues
- onion2k 12y agoRegardless of how bad it is, it's probably a lot more resilient than a human in those situations.
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoKick a human like that and he'll be like "OH MY GAWD WHY DID YOU KICK ME YOU NERD!". Robot be like "eh I'll get up and keep going"
- sjtrny 12y ago> Can it get up if knocked over? Yes https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=R7ezXBEBE6U#t=68 https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=R7.... > Just how resilient is it? Watch it on ice https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=cNZPRsrwumQ#t=35 https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=cN... I assumed the HN crowd had already seen all these videos.
- lez 12y agoa bow knot around one leg is enough to paralyze it, I suppose
- anjc 12y ago> I would love to see how it recovers from other than very tame issues You do know that these things don't pop out of the universe via magic right? Do you understand the engineering issues involved here to be judging the tameness of the tests? Why would they hit their expensive creation with a car?
- repsilat 12y agoHah, read the beginning of this article: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/05/05/AR2007050501009.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/05... It starts by talking about a minefield clearing robot, but the whole article's really good.
- nakedrobot2 12y agoOk, it's time for another (perhaps timely and relevant) debate about whether AI is going to destroy us or if The Robots are going to take over. Let me point to a great, great essay and debate that lays out lots of these arguments, and points out the fundamental mistakes that are being made when people bring up the fear over AI. Here is the most relevant quote, for me: "let's address directly this problem of whether AI is going to destroy civilization and people, and take over the planet and everything. Here I want to suggest a simple thought experiment of my own. There are so many technologies I could use for this, but just for a random one, let's suppose somebody comes up with a way to 3-D print a little assassination drone that can go buzz around and kill somebody. Let's suppose that these are cheap to make. I'm going to give you two scenarios. In one scenario, there's suddenly a bunch of these, and some disaffected teenagers, or terrorists, or whoever start making a bunch of them, and they go out and start killing people randomly. There's so many of them that it's hard to find all of them to shut it down, and there keep on being more and more of them. That's one scenario; it's a pretty ugly scenario. There's another one where there's so-called artificial intelligence, some kind of big data scheme, that's doing exactly the same thing, that is self-directed and taking over 3-D printers, and sending these things off to kill people. The question is, does it make any difference which it is? The truth is that the part that causes the problem is the actuator. It's the interface to physicality. It's the fact that there's this little killer drone thing that's coming around. It's not so much whether it's a bunch of teenagers or terrorists behind it or some AI, or even, for that matter, if there's enough of them, it could just be an utterly random process. The whole AI thing, in a sense, distracts us from what the real problem would be. The AI component would be only ambiguously there and of little importance. This notion of attacking the problem on the level of some sort of autonomy algorithm, instead of on the actuator level is totally misdirected. This is where it becomes a policy issue. The sad fact is that, as a society, we have to do something to not have little killer drones proliferate. And maybe that problem will never take place anyway. What we don't have to worry about is the AI algorithm running them, because that's speculative. There isn't an AI algorithm that's good enough to do that for the time being. An equivalent problem can come about, whether or not the AI algorithm happens. In a sense, it's a massive misdirection. This idea that some lab somewhere is making these autonomous algorithms that can take over the world is a way of avoiding the profoundly uncomfortable political problem, which is that if there's some actuator that can do harm, we have to figure out some way that people don't do harm with it. There are about to be a whole bunch of those. And that'll involve some kind of new societal structure that isn't perfect anarchy. Nobody in the tech world wants to face that, so we lose ourselves in these fantasies of AI. But if you could somehow prevent AI from ever happening, it would have nothing to do with the actual problem that we fear, and that's the sad thing, the difficult thing we have to face." http://edge.org/conversation/the-myth-of-ai#26019 http://edge.org/conversation/the-myth-of-ai#26019
- binarymax 12y agoI know these are dev models and all - but the public would find them much more pleasing if they'd just put a white plastic shell over it.
- imr_ 12y agoI do not think this would be a good idea. Firstly because of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley Secondly because if we will see robots as livin beings (either consciously or subconsciously), we will associate emotions with their existance. I fail to see any benefits that can come from this. Just imagine movements spawning all over the world that will fight for robots freedom and rights to vote.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI'm pretty sure that putting a white plastic shell over those robots will make them less uncanny - by the very virtue of looking like crap. Seriously, all those "androids" that are fashionable now, made of white plastic and with weird faces, look just ugly. I'm unable to connect emotionally to them the way I easily can with Big Dog of Spot.
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoTBF if they can make better choices than humans, I wouldn't be that bothered if they could vote, :p.
- axefrog 12y agoUncanny Valley doesn't apply. It would apply if they put a skin-and-fur-like shell over the body and tried to give it a life-like head, with eyes, nose, mouth and tongue, and it looked almost perfect, but not quite good enough to pass as the real thing; just enough to make it seem off the mark somehow. A white plastic shell hardly comes close; it would just provide a more attractive veneer.
- dEnigma 12y agoAww, I really feel bad for the robot when he gets kicked, more so because this model is so small. And the animal-like stabilization motions don't help either. Great work by Boston Dynamics
- DangerousPie 12y agoOddly enough I can't help but feel a bit sorry for the robot getting kicked back and forth there. I know you want to demonstrate how stable it is, but damn guys, no need to be so cruel!
- alisnic 12y agoit's a robot
- signa11 12y agoyes, and hopefully, 10 years down the line it is not merged with an ai which can take a dim view of it's predecessors being kicked around on some carbon based life form's whims and fancies (after watching it's genesis)
- xxxyy 12y agoExcept it is in the AI's interest to get kicked like that. This way the company that constructs robots can show how reliable they are, and as a result receive more funding. Our robot overlords will show this to their "children" during history classes. Or in other words: there is no reason to expect that AI will have irrational feelings similar to human feelings.
- coldpie 12y agoI dunno, it's not too hard to imagine a scenario where the AI realizes being kicked is counter to its goals and decides to remove the aggressor. Especially when these things are used for combat, as mentioned elsewhere in the thread. Friend/foe indicator malfunctioning? Well, good luck.
- yellowapple 12y agoI think in this context, it would be more equivalent to sparring than anything: a test of one's abilities. A sufficiently-intelligent AI would likely think the same should it watch videos of its predecessors being kicked during testing.
- jfoster 12y agoI vaguely recall that when the BD acquisition was announced there was speculation that Google might use these for package delivery, but not sure whether that came directly from Google or not. What are the simplest applications of these? Has it been made known what direction(s) Google intend to take this in?
- mkempe 12y agoThe most obvious application is military.
- melling 12y agoNah, you're just highly open to suggestions from previous discussions. The U.S. economy is almost $17 trillion. Plenty of uses... mining, construction, oil and gas, etc.
- jfoster 12y agoWhat kinds of applications in those industries?
- eitally 12y agoTo go anywhere people can't, or shouldn't.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agopack animal in rough country
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoTBF it seems a highly inefficient way to move packages in its current form. I'd sooner see an automated truck move around that honks when it's in front of its destination. Or just standardized package dropboxes placed in central locations (on the street in neighbourhoods, in front of apartment buildings, etc).
- binarymax 12y agoFor the folks have an emotional reaction to the kick and re-stabilization, I am reminded of the interesting way Anime has intentionally provoked this response as an art form. The other day I was watching a Ghost in the Shell ARISE episode, and the carrier Logicom is a pink death machine with a cute voice. Makes me realize how good certain aspects are of Japanese sci-fi. I commented previously on adding a white shell to the body to make it more appealing. Maybe Boston Dynamics is keeping them like this on purpose? Maybe they are purposefully trying to reduce the anthropomorphic attachment level?
- kbart 12y agoStrange as it may sound, I felt sorry for that robot when it got kicked.
- Simp 12y agoThe fact that we feel sorry for it as it is kicked is a testament to how dog-like it really is. It reacts to falling over like a real dog would.
- sfjailbird 12y agoThe kicking is a playful reference to the reaction people had when they showed the original BigDog demonstration (also with the kick test). Hence the "No robots were harmed in the making of this video" at the end. Perhaps also a clever way to build sympathy for what might otherwise be a somewhat scary machine.
- mdtancsa 12y agoEvery time its kicked, it should respond in a synthetic voice with, "I will remember you"
- dysfunction 12y agoI don't hate you
- o0-0o 12y agoMy Frenchman coworkers say harmed like 'armed' with silent h. Mount a gattling gun on this puppy and see how people respond to it. Have it fire a round every direction change or slip of 5°. This is getting real too quick for me.
- higherpurpose 12y agoThat's incredibly creepy. I felt uneasy throughout the whole video.
- uptownJimmy 12y agoAll of these robot videos make me feel very apprehensive.
- ashark 12y agoI think it's a combination of video games and fake corporate videos from movies. This seems like something that would be playing on a TV in a near-future sci-fi movie. Something out of RoboCop or those cut bits of Terminator 2 with the guy who invented the things. Hell, short-circuit for a more lighthearted take on it. We've been bombarded with these sorts of videos being a precursor to bloodshed since at least the 80s. Maybe the protagonists of a movie are in a research lab that's mysteriously gone silent, everyone seemingly having disappeared without a trace, and they watch this video, trying to figure out what's gone wrong. They flip through a couple more before finding the one where these things start killing everyone. Other 'bots drag off the bodies, and cleaning robots spin across the floor, wiping up the blood. While the characters' eyes are glued to the screen, the viewer sees the "dead" half-disassembled dog-robot on the workbench behind them start to silently shift, then slowly stand up. See: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ApocalypticLog http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ApocalypticLog
- uptownJimmy 12y agoYou might be confusing the chicken for the egg. ;) I think the reason robots are so scary in movies is because they inherently are scary. Sharks are scary in movies because they are inherently scary. I am convinced that robots hold the potential to completely devastate our collective ways of life, due to violence programmed into them, or due to their disruptions of job markets, or perhaps even due to them coming under cotrol of some future AI-type construct. These scenarios are not ludicrous to contemplate, they are, in fact, quite possible, the first two even likely. That's scary stuff, never mind Ally Sheedy's career-destroying performance in Short Circuit...
- consti2k 12y agoRemember the sound of those machines, as it may be the last thing you hear before you get killed by future versions of Robots. <scary/>
- roadnottaken 12y agoHow does it handle in the snow?
- michaelt 12y agoAs easily as you and I:- Snow: http://youtu.be/W1czBcnX1Ww?t=1m12s http://youtu.be/W1czBcnX1Ww?t=1m12s Ice: http://youtu.be/W1czBcnX1Ww?t=1m24s http://youtu.be/W1czBcnX1Ww?t=1m24s
- blechx 12y agoThe military interests in these machines seem to go in the direction of what you could call drones on the ground. Invading an area on the ground is still necessary to occupy and maintain control. Air-based drones are used more for targeted attacks and assasinations, with documented collateral damage, or killing and terrorizing of civilian populations put less eloquently. With drones on the ground, the situation changes completely, and you can have much more control over areas without putting any soldiers lives at risk. This would make occupations much more cost effective, probably mostly in the PR sense, any government getting lots of their youth killed will sooner or later have a problem at home. Not so much with drones. I find this a very frightening development.
- honeybooboo123 12y agoYes, they're developing tools for war and tyranny. For example, why else would their robots need to be able to move in "rough terrain"? Watching those videos was vaguely sickening. As icing on the cake, the people those robots will be used against are now paying for their development..
- berberous 12y agoThese things trotting along as a pair at 1:24 are super creepy. They look like cops. I can't help think of the Sentinels from X-men.
- hcrisp 12y agoI' more impressed with the agile ability of the technology. But it does remind me of the mechanical hound from Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451. "The mechanical Hound slept but did not sleep, lived but did not live in its gently humming, gently vibrating, softly illuminated kennel back in a dark corner of the fire house. The dim light of one in the morning, the moonlight from the open sky framed through the great window, touched here and there on the brass and copper and the steel of the faintly trembling beast. Light flickered on bits of ruby glass and on sensitive capillary hairs in the nylon-brushed nostrils of the creature that quivered gently, its eight legs spidered under it on rubber padded paws. "Nights when things got dull, which was every night, the men slid down the brass poles, and set the ticking combinations of the olfactory system of the hound and let loose rats in the fire house areaway. Three seconds later the game was done, the rat caught half across the areaway, gripped in gentle paws while a four-inch hollow steel needle plunged down from the proboscis of the hound to inject massive jolts of morphine or procaine."
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThis thing seems to walk like its blind - is that the case? It responds to the ground conditions AFTER taking a step and slipping, instead of by choosing a path carefully.
- metaphorm 12y agoit has optical sensors but they don't point at the ground at its feet, they point ahead at the horizon. similarly, humans don't watch their feet as they walk, they look ahead at the horizon. making real-time adjustments to footing is a necessary part of walking. the sensors on the feet provide the data for these adjustments, but they are touch sensors, not optics.
- j0e1 12y agoRobots might just take the place of becoming man's best friend!
- kenbellows 12y agoBD's 4-legged robots consistently fall just a little inside the uncanny valley[1] for me. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley
- raldi 12y agoActually, my reaction was, "Holy shit, robot quadrapeds have reached the uphill side of the uncanny valley."
- ekianjo 12y agoImpressive, but wouldn't such a robot be easily trapped in nets placed on the ground?
- cconcepts 12y agoI saw big dog in action way back when those videos came out. But for some reason, I find the confidence and obvious dexterity of this thing way creepier. Not to mention the fact that big dog had a noisy ol' two stroke engine so I could hear it coming - this bad boy could sneak up on me if I was sleeping soundly enough...
- Symmetry 12y agoIt seems much less noisy than the Big Dog.
- cygwin98 12y agoWow, amazing! Though it does seem a bit creepy to me, as the stories in old sci-fi novels, where a big corporation X built and operated a robot army taking over the governments and ruling the world, tend to become reality at a increasingly fast pace.
- wahsd 12y agoSo how many of you think you or your children will survive the massacre once AI robots make human work unnecessary for the ruling class to live a life of exploit.
- JabavuAdams 12y agoTeach them how to build the robots and how to hack the robots, now.
- wiineeth 12y agoI feel scared looking at them
- wiineeth 12y agoI feel scared looking at them
- karmacondon 12y agoTwo points of clarification on this technology. Its current intended military application is to carry equipment. Ammunition, spare parts, weapons, food and the like. Many US Army soldiers carry 70-80 lbs of gear into combat. The idea is to lighten that load by having machines carry some of it, in order to save lives and shorten conflicts. Wheeled vehicles don't work on a lot of terrain types, hence robot dogs. Robots don't feel pain or a sense of injustice when you kick them. It's no different than kicking a washing machine or a car tire. It looks like an animal out of necessity, to be able to follow humans while walking over uneven ground. But it's just a device. If it can't take a few kicks how can it be counted on to climb a hill or navigate a jungle? Somewhere out there, a 19 year old kid is about to carry 80 pounds of gear on a 10 mile march in order to be shot at upon reaching his destination. The only thing he cares about is living to see tomorrow's sunrise. Kick the hell out of the damn robots.
- Wohlf 12y agoI don't really get feeling bad about kicking the robot, must just be that it looks so much like an animal. Speaking from military experience I can say being able to kick it out of the way is extremely useful, it may be between me and the closest cover from enemy fire, or it might be about to step on a mine or IED. Looks very promising, hopefully future versions can come with built in light armor. That would be a dream come true for many grunts out there, letting a robot carry your extra supplies and also provide cover from small arms and shrapnel.
- patrickyeon 12y agoI don't have the stories handy, but there are records of military units getting emotionally attached to their bomb disposal robots. For example, some units have held funerals for the robots that are rendered non-operational, and some soldiers have even gone to the extreme of risking their own life to "rescue" "injured" service robots. It shouldn't need to be said, but this is the exact opposite of what the robots should be doing (reducing risk to their operators). Kick the damn things all you want. Normalize it so that nobody does something stupid trying to protect a machine.
- 12y ago
- netcan 12y agoIf you watch this and your imagination doesn't run in the direction of evil robot army.. well, your imaginations doesn't work the same way as mine does. I see a drone fleet of 100 bulky trucks galloping along contested highways towards a city boiling over with the violence of several simultaneous wars. They're protected by speed and dozens of armed UAVs. 96 make it through. Acceptable losses. The first truck to unload its four legged robotic soldiers loses 30 units to the welcome party, a quarter. By the time the tenth one is unloading, they're not losing any. The last robo-dog is unloaded just 18 minutes after the first truck arrives. By that time, there are over 10,000 dogs in squad-packs seeking targets from a database of 7,000 known enemy combatants and seeking control of strategically important sites. there's something uncanny and creepy about how robots move once they've been riddled with armor piercing rounds. A leg stops working or a sensor gets damaged and it's impossible not to imagine that it's an injured animal in excruciating pain. The single minded resolve thug, that's all machine. If you're shooting off legs, you need to shoot off all four before these things will stop. Any chance Boston Dynamics will adopt a don't be evil policy?
- kmfrk 12y agoThey won't stalk you, if you check the opt-out field.
- zachrose 12y agoThough of course it will be an opt-in field that's pre-checked and surrounded by opaque verbiage.
- joubert 12y agoGoogle owns Boston Dynamics
- izak30 12y agoNot that I'm on the dystopian future train, but "Don't be Evil" isn't a Google policy.
- 12y ago
- nl 12y agoThere's an old saying in AI/Robotics research. Q: How do you escape a killer robot? A: Walk up some stairs. Might be time to reevaluate my escape strategy.
- TheLoneWolfling 12y agoPlan B: Q: How do you escape a killer robot? A: Climb a ladder.
- cududa 12y agoLooks like BD thought of that one :) http://www.bostondynamics.com/robot_rise.html http://www.bostondynamics.com/robot_rise.html
- yellowapple 12y agoAnd to make things even worse: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6b4ZZQkcNEo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6b4ZZQkcNEo
- TheLoneWolfling 12y agoThat's for textured surfaces only.
- Florin_Andrei 12y agoUntil the killer robots come in the shape of flying multirotors driven by an AI.
- TheLoneWolfling 12y agoThen just throw floss at them. (Or any other similar thin thread / line - preferably with something tied at the end to make it easier to throw)
- acadien 12y agoIt seems like using these devices for delivery is one possible end goal (besides the obvious military applications). A self driving truck alone cannot deliver packages to your front door. However put one of these robot dogs inside and figure out some way for it to pick up and drop off packages and suddenly you can take on FedEx/UPS/etc. Side note, anyone else really want to ride one of these?
- justinpaulson 12y agoThe goal of a robot should never be to kill a human being. Robots are not human police that are in danger of death, and therefore should never be equipped with lethal rounds. The goal of a robotic soldier or police patrolman would only be to disarm and detain. A robot would not be making judgement decisions about life and death because it is not also trying to protect its own life like a human soldier/policeman. There is no reason a robot could not simply detain a criminal until humans could arrive and arrest the suspect, there is no need for a robot to engage in lethal combat. I think the fears people have about robots swarming war zones and murdering civilians should be quelled by laws which prevent the construction of robots with lethal ammunition and the accountability of those that deploy robots if a robot does in fact kill a human being.
- jaegerpicker 12y agoThat's not completely true though, a large part of police work is also preventing violence against citizens. What would the robot do if it arrived at a domestic violence call and needed to save a women/child from abuse? I could see a massive public outcry if the robot simply watched the crime take place.
- justinpaulson 12y agoIt would disarm and detain the assailant. The same thing a human police office ought to do in that situation. Are you trying to argue that it should just kill the abuser?
- jaegerpicker 12y agoCertainly not in every case but there are a lot of times when disarming is not an option. I don't know if you have had any kind of defence training but I have and disarming an armed opponent is one of the hardest things to train for. More often than any one would like the police really have no choice.
- circuitslave 12y agoThey are very "dog" like. Maybe a new market will be small robotic pets you can upload your old pets mind download into to have "fluffy" with you forever - or until the maintenance contract is up anyway.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago"Hi, my name is Blinky, and I just want to be your friend!" http://vimeo.com/21216091 http://vimeo.com/21216091
- circuitslave 12y agoThanks for the link!
- Fuzzwah 12y agoI watch these things move and wonder why a huge amount of effort is going into working on bipedal robots; ie the DRC: http://www.theroboticschallenge.org/ http://www.theroboticschallenge.org/ Surely an arm (or two) attached to the top of one of these would allow for almost the same level of interactions, while simplifying the whole "moving around" thing.
- 51Cards 12y agoI think it's an ergonomics thing. We have spent a lot of years building a world and tools modeled around the bipedal creatures that created them them. One of these would have a hard time going through a revolving or spring loaded door or sit in a vehicle. If we can eventually create beings that integrate with the existing world seamlessly it's easier than adapting everything else.
- q2 12y agoHow much weight these machines can carry? If they can carry human weight, then we have "robotic horses" if height is more just like horse. I read Google has self-driving cars project. Now it seems we can have self-driving bikes/two-wheelers in future. Also, we see/hear about vehicular/car accidents and in future I won't be surprised to hear/see "robot accidents".
- jpindar 12y agoThe full size military one, known as LS3 (Legged Squad Support System) which is now undergoing field tests can carry several soldier's packs, so it should be able to carry a person. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cr-wBpYpSfE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cr-wBpYpSfE
- raindrop777 12y agoDoes anyone know what mapping software these guys are using (SLAM implementation perhaps?)?
- usaphp 12y agoI don't understand what advantage does this bring over a small tank or something with caterpillar if they were used in a war? Caterpillar seems to be more effective than legs, especially in dirty environments of a war. Can somebody explain that to me?
- usaphp 12y agoAlso a simple mantrap would snap it's leg or at least make it impossible to walk further
- InclinedPlane 12y agoEven with treads a vehicle that size couldn't handle the terrain that thing was going over.
- ovulator 12y agoIt can transverse very tight rugged terrain, like a bombed out building.
- rasz_pl 12y agothis is small tank in a bombed city block https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r9hWEFhIxLg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r9hWEFhIxLg it has fire power, but ultimately gets stuck
- beltex 12y ago"What Are The Civilian Applications?" https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/565181590431485952 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/565181590431485952
- rbobby 12y agoSlap a saddle on it and you have a fun new vehicle.
- on_and_off 12y agoautomated delivery service ?
- rasz_pl 12y agokilling civilians while sporting police badge, duh
- aeturnum 12y agoMan, Boston Dynamics continues to impress. Their work has been fantastic to watch evolve. The endless applications of autonomous robots that can navigate almost any terrain should be obvious. Finding missing people, supply deliveries, searching for poachers, surveying, etc. That said, I feel like I know what the next century's horseman of the apocalypse will look like. :)
- sgt101 12y agoOh noes - the robot army is here! Those submarines with the power to end life as we know it (basically post 19th century life), we've forgotten about them, let's all get worried about the robot army! What I mean is, it's not autonomy that you should worry about, it's actuators. The biggest actuators are nuclear weapons - a trident sub can slap 200 warheads that are 50* bigger than Hiroshima's onto a given continent, and the fires would blot the sun from the sky for two years. There are 7 billion agents with autonomy knocking around, and the type that they are derived from has a bad record about doing dumb evil things! Cool AI would probably be a safer arbiter of our extinction.
- 95win 12y agoCan anyone point to refs that explain Boston Dynamics' approach to robot control and coordination? Seems to be a completely different method than something like Asimov. Any insight appreciated.