7 ms·
We need to think of a better way to convince parents to vaccinate their children than hitting them with sarcasm. While these are fun to read from our smug pro-
by joezydeco 12y ago
We need to think of a better way to convince parents to vaccinate their children than hitting them with sarcasm. While these are fun to read from our smug pro-vax point of view, they provide no effect on everyone else.
We need to show parents what life was like before the polio vaccine. Before measles/mumps. Hell, before smallpox. Part of the problem is that younger parents don't believe that these diseases were all too real and way too common before the treatments. There aren't many polio survivors around anymore, and the only place you'll ever see measles is on Brady Bunch reruns.
- tdees40 12y agoI get all this, but I really think the only way to sort this out will be to heavily stigmatize it. It needs to be shameful not to vaccinate your child. I think satire plays into that.
- api 12y agoA post of mine from another thread on this general topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8985668 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8985668
- jgallag8 12y agoI would prefer to live in a world where, as much as possible, rationality guides decisions instead of emotivist social pressure.
- Qwertious 12y agoI would like the former too, but I'll accept the latter if the former isn't feasible.
- blt 12y agoKeep waiting.
- john_b 12y agoUnfortunately you don't, and you never will. You'll have to get used to the fact that "emotivist social pressure" is usually a more effective way to change peoples minds than reason. If people can't be convinced by reason that their dangerous and unreasonable behavior is in fact dangerous and unreasonable, then little is left besides social pressures.
- jgallag8 12y agoEven if something is effective at promoting a good cause, it isn't necessarily an unqualified good, even if one takes a utilitarian view of things. I don't disagree with the use of social pressure in general. Many people have mentioned the idea of refusing to allow children without vaccinations to attend public schools, which might be reasonable, and might be effective. That is social pressure, and I am not in principle opposed to it. However, I am opposed to the idea of stigmatizing anyone who disagrees with one's point of view, even if they are wrong, and even if it will promote a good cause. The problem with public shaming is that it works equally well for both good and bad arguments. A lot of sarcasm just implies that the object has already been established as absurd, the writer doesn't actually have to do anything to establish the fact. Since he doesn't have to make any argument that the object is absurd, it works just as well against any object at all. It can be very distorting, and emotionally twisting, and can be easily used to hide the truth in any discussion. This is what I mean by 'emotivism', the idea that rationality is useless, and therefore the best way to establish one's moral beliefs is by use of assertion and emotional manipulation. Even if it is effective, and even if it can never be fully avoided, I don't feel comfortable using it, because as soon as it becomes an acceptable weapon in any sort of public debate, any hope of rationality is destroyed. And ultimately, that is more important even than the very serious issue of vaccinations. For what it's worth, I don't think the blog post in question falls squarely into this description. He was making an argument by analogy rather than using sarcasm to imply that an argument already exists. This was just by way of response to the sentiment that social shaming is a tool that ought to be used.
- LLWM 12y agoThat sounds dreadful.
- vetinari 12y agoI don't think you can stigmatize such a large group. Trying to do so will polarize the society, not stigmatize few members of it. Not exactly a result you want.
- bentcorner 12y agoPlain old shame should work. Think of the littering campaigns and "earth day" movements in the 80's/90's. This is the sort of thing that needs to be won over on facebook, The View, and supermarket headlines.
- onion2k 12y agoThat's easy: Put the parents in prison for child endangerment.
- KevinEldon 12y agoYes, let's have a government jail people and take responsibility for their children because some government beuracrat decided a certains vaccine was required. The Tuskegee expirement is one example of why the government shouldn't be trusted to do what is in the best interests of its citizens.
- ceejayoz 12y agoIf you have to reach back to Tuskegee to discredit government health standards like vaccination, hand washing, seat belts, etc., you're probably stretching a bit.
- WorldWideWayne 12y agoDo you have to reach back at all to see that the government usually doesn't have it's citizens' best interests at heart?
- zimbu668 12y agoThe study went until 1972[1], that's not that long ago. Have humans changed that much since then? [1] http://www.cdc.gov/tuskegee/timeline.htm http://www.cdc.gov/tuskegee/timeline.htm
- ceejayoz 12y agoTuskegee caused a dramatic change in how studies are run, with laws on informed consent and ethical requirements. Humans may not have inherently changed, but our procedures to prevent abuses by humans have.
- notacoward 12y agoOK, so sue them into oblivion instead. The downside is that we'd have to wait for innocent to get injured or killed before the law will grant standing, but if enough people do this then maybe the anti-vaxxers will decide that their oh-so-fashionable "principles" aren't worth the risk of losing all they own.
- falcolas 12y agoIf they aren't convinced by science, and they can't be convinced by satire, what is left to convince them with? This isn't limited to anti-vaxxers either. The number of people who believe we haven't visited the moon is growing year over year. There are also people who believe that the Holocaust did not happen, despite having survivors and well documented photographs. As unfortunate as it is, there's little we can do for some folks, other than treat them as we do children who don't understand why sticking their fingers in outlets are bad, and say "Because I said so".
- api 12y ago"The number of people who believe we haven't visited the moon is growing year over year." It took a lot of evidence to convince anyone that Vikings visited America before Columbus. There is at least a small amount of evidence to suggest that crossings and even a trickle of trade pre-dated the Vikings: http://www.faculty.ucr.edu/~legneref/ethnic/mummy.htm http://www.faculty.ucr.edu/~legneref/ethnic/mummy.htm Other circumstantial evidence includes architecture and burial customs among South American native civilizations that could be interpreted as Egypt-influenced. Yet the majority of scientists greet these claims with extreme skepticism. How could the ancients have crossed the Atlantic? With what? Long boats? When a great, almost mythic feat is not repeated for a very long time, people will begin to doubt it. That's not new and it's not because "people are stupid." It's because people lie and exaggerate a lot, and thus people respond to that by being skeptical of grandiose claims. It also doesn't help that governments often lie as a matter of standard policy, a fact that very rationally leads people to be generally skeptical of what they say. If our civilization fell and another rose in thousands of years, I'd expect that many would respond with tremendous incredulity to the idea that the ancients visited the Moon with primitive metal tubes full of fossil fuel and discrete component computers. How absurd. Instead, they would reason, this was obviously some sort of national myth and a part of the American cult of state -- the rocket is an obvious phallic symbol and it being full of oil represented petroleum as the basis of American power, etc. The only way to disabuse people of the moon hoax theory is to go back to the Moon (or further). I happen to think we went to the Moon. I also happen to think it's at least possible that ancients (Egyptians, Phoenicians, etc.) crossed the Atlantic. But I guess I'm a bit of an optimist about what humans can do when they really put their minds to it... with tubes full of fossil fuel, or long boats. :)
- bryanlarsen 12y agoThis link has been going around the news recently, you can spread it around some more. Roald Dahl (author of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory) had a daughter who died of complications from the Measles. He wrote a letter about it: https://roalddahl.com/roald-dahl/timeline/1960s/november-1962 https://roalddahl.com/roald-dahl/timeline/1960s/november-196...
- saosebastiao 12y agoI used to be a mormon, and I served a mission. People that had been exposed to the absurdity of mormonism were difficult to convert, and people that had never heard of mormonism were relatively simple. Satire and sarcasm might not convince an anti-vaxxer that vaccines are good, but they might convince an uninformed person of the ridiculousness that the anti-vaxxer position is. It can stop the conversion.
- involans 12y agoSo you are saying that sarcasm is a vaccine against stupidity?
- ceejayoz 12y agoSo you are saying sarcasm causes autism?
- ptaipale 12y agoBad sarcasm surely causes narcolepsy.
- CamperBob2 12y agoIt's possible that's exactly what it is, in a cultural-transmission sense. (Suggest discussing this one, rather than reflexively downmodding. The use of sarcasm and mockery as legitimate rhetorical tools has previously been brought up by people like Sam Harris. I thought it was a pretty interesting point when I first encountered it.)
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI agree. The whole concept of memes that evolve and spread like genetic material is a useful tool (hell, that's where the 'viral' comes from). It's useful to talk about memetic immunity in individuals and groups. If sarcasm helps you defend against harmful memes, then that's exactly what it is - a vaccine.
- 12y ago
- at-fates-hands 12y agoWas talking to a pediatrician friend the other day about this and he said he's completely befuddled by the anti-vaccine crowd. He started telling me things about the measles outbreak I had no idea about. The one fact he said was how contagious measles are. He said someone with the virus can sneeze in a room and the virus will still be active 8-12 hours later. I agree, I think it still comes down to education and getting the facts out parents and what the risks they're taking.
- transfire 12y agoMeasles can only last two hours air borne. Source CDC.
- jstalin 12y agoA local school district kicked a bunch of kids out of school for 20 days recently when someone came down with pertussis. Those kids didn't have their vaccine. Guess what happened. The majority went out and got he vaccine and were back in a day or two. Can you imagine being a kid in that position? They probably unleashed the fury on their parents and demanded the vaccine.
- protomyth 12y agoThis is pretty much the way to handle it. Kids can say some amazing things to change a parents mind. Satire doesn't work worth beans, it just pushes people farther into positions they wouldn't normally hold. People are remarkably stubborn. I sometimes think the direct (less subtle or funny) satire the internet has exposed us to had contributed to the extremes. Some sensitivity to children that cannot for proper, documented medical reasons receive the vaccine needs to be in order. I am not sure how you handle that without subjecting them to the same shame. I would guess isolate them until the outbreak ends making sure the kid knows the doctors and parents are doing what they can given the kid's condition.
- rdtsc 12y agoI slightly disagree. > We need to show parents what life was like before the polio vaccine. Before measles/mumps. The problem is if they already decided to not vaccinate unless you take them back in time, whatever you show them will just be "yeah this is propaganda you are working for 'them'" this is all computer generated. In a way this seemingly calm and rational way to handling this is already a loosing ground. For example see how you (perhaps unconsciously) phrased this: > our smug pro-vax point of view Note the "pro-vax" label. That is the problem. Once you start calling everyone "pro-vax" it validates the crazies as if their point as equally valid. It should instead be "crazies" vs "non-crazies". Nobody discusses whether we should be "pro-rape" or "anti-rape". There is nothing to debate there. Granted, it should be the same way about torture. We lost that ground. We are just discussing how effective or ineffective torture can be in intelligence gathering as opposed assuming anyone who does it is a sick criminal. I think vaccinations should be in the same domain of discourse. So quickly pushing for legislature to restrict opting out based on "personal beliefs" is the right choice.
- nsxwolf 12y agoWhat are you going to do? Tie people down and force-inject them? In America? What's that going to look like? You'll make these people martyrs. You can stop kids from entering public schools without them, sure! But how far do you want to take this?
- rdtsc 12y ago> You can stop kids from entering public schools without them, sure Public schools, universities is a good first step. Well the 0th step if you wish is to not accept their argument during discourse on equal footing. As in "it is a free country and your crazy opinion is just as valid as well established science, now let's discuss". So treating them like crazies is important, they are to be made fun of and marginalized. Which is kind of like what this blog did.
- nsxwolf 12y agoWell, let me know when making fun of them starts working. I think the best we can hope for is that this is a fad, like macrobiotic diets or biodynamic grape farming.
- krschultz 12y agoIt takes a lot of effort to convince people of things. For many things, it is worth spending the time to understand why people believe what they believe, and crafting arguments to try and sway them. For the anti-vax crowd, it's simply not. We don't spend a bunch of time trying to figure out how to convince people it's not a good idea to fire off an AK-47 in their backyard when they have neighbors. A large majority of us decided rationally that such behavior causes way too much risk to the rest of us, and made it illegal. The anti-vaccination crowd are on equally shaky ground. I'm not saying we should mandate the flu shot or a brand new vaccine, but for something as contagious as measles with a 60+ year track record of safety and efficacy, I don't have time or patience to reason with the last 3% of people that don't want to vaccinate their kids. I've had some serious health problems in my life that were just luck of the draw in genetics. I'm now short one organ, and I'm incredibly thankful that I live in 2015 and I can live a healthy and happy life due to modern medicine. Still, I'm at risk for a lot of diseases because I'm weaker than I would otherwise be. It pisses me off that healthy people don't realize that their actions can kill other people. If my kid was the one with leukemia and his healthy classmates were not getting their vaccines because their parents are idiots, I would be spending all of my time fighting to keep those kids out of schools, doctors offices, public places, etc.
- sergiosgc 12y agoThere are situations where you should convince people, there are situations where you must mandate a decision. Whenever personal freedom produces large negative externalities, the law must mandate behaviours. These mandated behaviours should be such that freedom is restricted by the minimum needed amount. As an unrelated example: smoking is not prohibited; Smoking in closed public spaces is. For vaccination, I believe the sweet spot of mandated behaviour is to mandate vaccination of children participating in large public groups. Children that go to public schools must get vaccines. Children playing team sports must be vaccinated. Parents then maintain the freedom of not vaccinating their kids, but must abide by the rules that prevent those kids from being a menace to the rest of the population. Note that this is only needed because vaccines rely on "herd protection". If vaccination coverage drops, vaccine efficacy drops precipitously. The effect is very pronounced. 90% coverage is much less effective than 99% coverage. Not vaccinating a child poses a risk for the child, but also poses a risk to all other children he/she is in regular contact with. P.S. A lot of other discussions may arise: Government prohibitions tend to be slippery slopes; Children should be somewhat protected from their own parents; Should groups be allowed to skip vaccination altogether?. These are secondary issues, irrelevant to the main decision that is: Mandate vaccination for children that are members of larger groups, so that the group maintains disease protection.
- JonFish85 12y agoI think one problem would be how much can we legally restrict from society someone who isn't vaccinated? Can work places restrict this (especially ones like hospitals and the like)? What about government jobs? What about health insurance companies? Life insurance companies? Public transportation? Flying? What about the government-subsidized/provided health care? Can they mandate vaccines? They're free to roam about our society as they please (within reason).
- sergiosgc 12y agoHere, it helps that the problem is more acute in children groups. It is acceptable for schools to require proof of vaccination on admission. It is also acceptable for sports clubs to do so on admission. Mixed adult/children environments are not as problematic, because adults resist better to these diseases and so the infection rate gets a lot lower. A lot of text to say that this is a Pareto rule scenario. Cover the 20% of places where kids spend 80% of their social time and you get most of the needed protection.
- mynegation 12y agoNormally, I would be the first to mention that sarcasm is the lowest form of wit. But in that case I'll say: I will hit with whatever works. Be it sarcasm, legislation, or graphic photos of people with vaccine-preventable diseases.
- calbear81 12y agoWhat about asking the kids that were recently exposed to do a public service campaign and visit the homes and families of other anti-vaxxers so that they can see the effects of MMR "in the flesh"?
- pmontra 12y agoI'm less than 50 and I remember how life was (Italy here). When I was little some children had polio and couldn't walk properly, I didn't know why at the time. Luckily they were the last ones and luckily I was vaccinated. However I had both measles and mumps, not a big deal but maybe only because I was little or because of proper treatment. I think every child at school had them sooner or later and all of them came back to school. We were the last ones not to be vaccinated against those diseases. As an adult I got vaccinated against hepatitis, cholera, yellow fever, typhus, tetanus etc (I travel around the world on vacations). No consequences. Vaccination for me is an obvious choice. I can think that measles is easily survivable but I won't expose a child of mine to polio. Get all the vaccinations they offer you, it's a good investment. However, if you don't live a problem you don't really appreciate it. Example: talking with people born in the mid 80s, it was impossible to convince them that there was a real concern about nuclear war at the time they were born (remember Reagan, Brezhnev, Andropov, the Star Wars shield?) Obviously nobody was going to fire missiles, they say. Go read the newspapers, watch the movies, etc I say. No way.
- XorNot 12y agoMeasles can become measles wncephalitis. It kills you in 12 hours.
- pmontra 12y agoYes (+1), and to be clear: I would vaccinate my children against measles and everything else. My parents would have done it too. Maybe I should have written "I could think that measles is easily survivable..."
- wonderyak 12y agoI (American) was born in 1980 and I clearly remember being told that the Soviets and their Evil Empire were going to kill us all some day. It was a time where calling someone a 'communist' was not just a rhetorical device, but an actual insult. This was a common thread from school, to the news to my family. People were worried about the communists still and the rapidly degenerating situation in the USSR only increased the worry.
- bch 12y ago> We need to think of a better way to convince parents to vaccinate their children than hitting them with sarcasm. False dichotomy -- we need to think of all the ways...
- cshu22 12y agoFirst off I'm pro-vaccination. However this example doesn't really add up for me. I'm not a doctor, but if the rest of us vaccinate our kids, won't they NOT GET SICK? Hence calling it an immunization. So if the rest of us are immunized the only people getting sick are the anti-vaxxers. For this allegory of the Car Brakes and Social Responsibility to truly be a 1-to-1 comparison of social risk with regards to pro/anti immunization he'd have to basically present the premise that everyone else who has car brakes is protected from the less informed anti-brakers.
- alexbecker 12y agoAs many people have pointed out here, the issue is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity. Vaccines are not 100% effective, and some people can't get vaccinated (due to allergies, immunodeficiency, chemotherapy, etc). Infections spread exponentially, with each infected person infecting X other people (I'm oversimplifying here of course). The key is to make infection of a random person sufficiently unlikely that X < 1, so the infection dies out rapidly instead of becoming epidemic.
- andrewaylett 12y agoUnfortunately, it's not that simple. Maybe 95% of the people who get vaccinated are subsequently immune, the rest (and people who have depressed immune systems) are dependent on herd immunity. So the small number who choose not to vaccinate can make life much more dangerous for the few who can't or for whom the vaccination was ineffective. For a good look at the maths, see this blog post: http://www.goodmath.org/blog/2015/02/05/quick-vaccine-math/ http://www.goodmath.org/blog/2015/02/05/quick-vaccine-math/
- rewind 12y agoThe recommended age to vaccinate is 12 months (I've read as early as six months). Until those babies are able to be vaccinated, they're at risk.
- jbigelow76 12y ago>So if the rest of us are immunized the only people getting sick are the anti-vaxxers. You are leaving out the infants that are not yet old enough to immunized as well as those with immunodeficiency that cannot be vaccinated.
- sliverstorm 12y agoThere aren't many polio survivors around anymore I've come to the conclusion that this is really the key change that allowed the anti-vax movement to flourish. Not sure what to do about it though.
- _almosnow 12y ago"We"... as in "we, the good ones"...
- snarfy 12y agoStudies show presenting hard evidence to irrational believers strengthens their beliefs. I'm not sure how you can convince these people. The best thing I've found is to lead by example.
- DiffEq 12y agoThe problem here is that not all diseases are the same in terms of risk to health/life or even the ability to infect others. Comparing Smallpox to Polio to the Measles in equal terms is a stretch at best and probably closer to being dishonest. Many people recognize that either wittingly or unwittingly and so getting vaccinated against Measles and Chicken Pox just isn't a high priority. Now to talk about the MMR vaccine: It has had a rough go the last few decades. It was reformulated a couple decades or so ago and the efficacy was massively reduced to around 30% or less if I remember correctly. They went back to the old formulation later but not after a full decade or more of using the new formula that didn't really work. In several of the measles outbreaks of the last decade or so - most, if not all, of those that got the measles had been vaccinated. Of course then everybody blames the anti-vaxers for the outbreaks :(
- sschueller 12y agoI agree with you but I think some of the following needs to happen as well. There is a huge miss trust of government and pharma. Vioxx, AZT, Fen Phen, and Thalidomide to name a few 'miss steps'. - Big pharma should have some responsibility and making sure vaccines are safe. [1] - There should be a clear line between what vaccines are absolutely necessary and which ones aren't. Right now it seems like you need all (maximum profit) - Big pharma should not be permitted to lobby for new vaccines to be mandatory (HPV?). That decision should be made by someone not under a motive to make profit. [1] http://www.fiercevaccines.com/story/supreme-court-drugmakers-cant-be-sued-defective-vaccine/2011-02-23 http://www.fiercevaccines.com/story/supreme-court-drugmakers...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Dove 12y agoWhile these are fun to read from our smug pro-vax point of view, they provide no effect on everyone else. I actually suspect the effect may be negative. The piece seems persuasive if you already agree with its premise: that vaccines are essential for safety, and that their costs and risks are overwhelmed by their benefits. But someone who disagrees with that would find the analogy false, and hence the piece merely obnoxious and misleading. In fact, consider the effect such an article from the other side would have on you. Set in the 1950's, the author writes, "Well, sure I smoke tobacco. They keep coming out with studies that say it's beneficial, and the government sure seems to want me to, and sure I trust those guys..." I'm not sure what your reaction would be to that sort of thing, but mine (which I suspect is common) is, "Ah ha! The fact that they are forced to resort to bad analogies proves they don't have any good arguments!" By way of contrast, study my rhetorical hero, Milton Friedman. Seriously -- agree or disagree with his stance on things -- go watch a clip from a debate with him on Youtube. He radiates a profound respect and agreeableness, constantly smiles, assumes the best of his opponents' characters (even when arguing they are making the world a much worse place for many people!), seems almost apologetic that he is forced to disagree with them, and focuses relentlessly upon the meat of the argument as the source of that unfortunate disagreement. He makes it very easy to change your mind. Very easy to agree with him. By assuming you are a good and smart person and focusing only on evidence, it is safe to say, "Oh, yes, I hadn't thought about that", and remove emotion from the equation. That is the most effective strategy I am aware of for changing people's minds -- and he's good at it.
- notacoward 12y ago"they provide no effect on everyone else" I'm not so sure. In between convincing the anti-vaccine folks that they're wrong (not gonna happen) and mere trolling is a third option: moving the Overton Window. http://www.mackinac.org/OvertonWindow http://www.mackinac.org/OvertonWindow Many people believe that we shouldn't try to be "fair and balanced" when it comes to vaccination. The science is just too solid, and the stakes are just too high. If one is pushing for a mandate, then one tool is to marginalize and trivialize the anti-vaccinationists' POV to such a point that nobody even listens to them. Then there's no resistance. To that end, derision does serve a purpose. Note that I'm not actually condoning these tactics, even though I believe that in this case the goal is a worthy one. I'm just explaining part of what I believe lies beneath these otherwise-just-obnoxious kinds of comments and posts.
- technofiend 12y agoI guess you could stand in front of abortion clinics with pictures of children in iron lungs, wheelchairs or braces with a sign that days "Choose life, choose vaccination" but there's an overlap with people who are both anti abortion and anti vaccination, oddly. I'm not sure you can convince someone using faith-based arguments without potentially challenging their faith.
- philwelch 12y agoWell, anti-vaxxers are about to see how bad it gets with all these measles and whooping cough outbreaks they've caused. Personally, I'm past convincing parents to vaccinate. Let's move straight ahead to involving Child Protective Services and throwing anti-vax parents in prison for criminal negligence.