5 ms·
It is interesting that this is finally seeing light of day. When the 9/11 report came out several people (not conspiracy theorists) had legitimate questions re
by Someone1234 12y ago
It is interesting that this is finally seeing light of day.
When the 9/11 report came out several people (not conspiracy theorists) had legitimate questions regarding why we're bombing Afghanistan when Saudi Arabia had significantly stronger links to the events than Afghanistan did.
For example most of the money, most of the people, and many of the organisations were Saudi based, and while Afghanistan's now famed "training camps" did exist, a vast majority were in Pakistan.
Even Osama bin Laden (who's a Saudi national, by the way) initially denied the attack until after the US "credited" him by name (and then he just went with it). You can find videos of him denying responsibility on YT (and later accepting responsibility).
I'm not seriously suggesting we should have bombed Saudi Arabia, that's bonkers, I am just saying that it seems like Saudi Arabian national's punched the US in the face while Pakistan distracted, and the US then turned around and beat up Afghanistan in "revenge."
The 9/11 is pretty lacking in on crete information. I'd love to hear what historians think of it in retrospect in twenty or more years, when all the dust has settled. It raises more questions than it answers (not in the "false flag!!!" sense, but in the "so who was actually behind this???" sense).
Honestly a much more believable conspiracy theory is that reputed Saudis funded it and the US and Saudi Arabia covered it up to save face while Saudi cleaned house quietly. That's totally believable and in-line with the 9/11 report, leaks, and other information.
- api 12y agoEver since the Iraq war I've been of the opinion that forces within the USA shamelessly used 9/11 to pursue pet agendas that had been "on the table" for years but lacked sufficient support. Afghanistan was related to 9/11 though in all truth it probably wasn't the most important backer. Iraq had nothing to do with it at all -- it was just a foreign policy hobby horse that they use 9/11 to ram through. Meanwhile our relationship to Saudi Arabia has always reminded me of an addict resorting to sexually servicing their dealer to get their fix. SA is every bit as bad as, say, Iran, but we have a "special relationship." (Yes I'm aware that most of our oil does not physically come from SA or the Middle East, but it's the price that matters and SA has more influence over that than any other country.)
- pyre 12y agoFYI: The "Department of Homeland Security" was a proposal (without much support) that pre-existed 9/11.
- api 12y agoSo was most of the Patriot Act and "Total Information Awareness." The biggest thing that disgusts me is how our government responded to 9/11 by essentially telling us to be more afraid-- in other words helping deliver precisely the emotional message that the terrorists intended. I started to picture the planes hitting the towers with a voice-over of President Bush saying "my name is George Bush and I endorse this message." It viscerally disgusts me, and yes it also disgusts me when Obama more or less does the same thing. If a president today said "the only thing we have to fear is fear itself," I'd fall out of my chair. Our politicians care more about their pet projects and hobby horses than they do about the country. We seem to be entering the late stages of imperial decadence in a lot of ways.
- kiba 12y agoObama did actually say that terrorists are not existential threats to the United States. http://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2015/02/01/obama_we_should_stop_overinflating_importance_of_terror_groups_as_if_they_are_an_existential_threat_to_us.html http://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2015/02/01/obama_we_s...
- api 12y agoThat's somewhat better, but wake me up when one of our current political leadership tells us not to fear them at all.
- jrmurad 12y agoWhy would any sane person tell "us" to not fear them at all? I live and work in Manhattan. I'm aware of the non-zero chance that I'll be a victim. I don't "fear" this enough to move away but I'd be a fool to believe it could never happen.
- bane 12y agoHere's a conspiracy theory for you. The Iraq and Afghan wars were as much about regional containment of Iran as any other reason. There just happened to be fussy and irascible local in both places that caused all the ruckus.
- dredmorbius 12y agoSaudi Arabia did not have direct government supporting links to Al Qaeda as Afghanistan did. The relationship between the U.S. and Saudi Arabia is quite strong and close, for all the obvious reasons: the US needs SA's oil, and SA benefit greatly from US military support. The fact that Saudi Arabia is paid in US dollars also gives the country a substantive interest in how well the US and its financial system do. It's a relationship which dates to FDR and King Saud at Great Bitter Lake: http://articles.latimes.com/1990-08-09/news/mn-388_1_king-saud http://articles.latimes.com/1990-08-09/news/mn-388_1_king-sa... This doesn't mean that there aren't elements either within Saudi Arabia or originating from it which don't look kindly on the US. I suspect you could find similar qualities within the US itself. It's also helpful to keep in mind that in his 1998 fatwa against the U.S., one of bin Laden's points was "support of authoritarian regimes in the Middle East such as Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Jordan". That is, bin Laden was aligned against the Saudi government. http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2002/nov/24/theobserver http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2002/nov/24/theobserver And yes, what the Saudi government and the Saudi street felt was somewhat at odds. Anthony Summers and Robbyn Swan cover this in their Vanity Fair article "The Kingdom and the Towers" http://www.vanityfair.com/politics/features/2011/08/9-11-2011-201108 http://www.vanityfair.com/politics/features/2011/08/9-11-201... What did happen in the immediate aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, and I remember this, was that the US contacted the Afghan government, then the Taliban, and effectively requested bin Laden's head. The Taliban refused. The US attacked. http://edition.cnn.com/2001/US/09/20/gen.bush.transcript/ http://edition.cnn.com/2001/US/09/20/gen.bush.transcript/ http://web.archive.org/web/20010922035810/http://www.pbs.org/newshour/updates/september01/taliban_9-21.html http://web.archive.org/web/20010922035810/http://www.pbs.org... Pakistan, while yes, supporting the Taliban in many ways (and still), did lend government support to the US aim of rooting out bin Laden. How sincere that was (particularly given where bin Laden turned up) is open to question. But Muscharraf didn't pull the same move the government of Afghanistan had in refusing the US's requests. So, no, actually, most of what you've claimed here is extremely mushy-headed bogosity. Is it possible that there was significant Saudi financial support for bin Laden? It wouldn't surprise me. Could it have included members of the Saudi royal family? Again, quite possibly. The Saudi royal family is comprised of thousands of members. Around 15,000 according to the BBC. This isn't some small nuclear household. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Saud http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Saud Are the contents of such a report likely to be both contentious and yet more conspiracy fodder? Yeah, probably.
- arjn 12y ago>> I am just saying that it seems like Saudi Arabian national's punched the US in the face while Pakistan distracted, and the US then turned around and beat up Afghanistan in "revenge." Umm, no ... that is not how it happened with Afghanistan. Rather than argue here or be an armchair analyst, all I will do is point to a couple of books by Ahmed Rashid - "Taliban" and "Descent into Chaos" that include a pretty good historical commentary on the US action in Afghanistan.
- Alex3917 12y ago> It raises more questions than it answers (not in the "false flag!!!" sense, but in the "so who was actually behind this???" sense). Out of curiosity, what exactly would you need to believe that it was a false flag attack? Given the facts that: - On the morning of 9/11, the two folks the Bush administration chose to lead the investigation were watching the attacks over breakfast with the guy who ordered 100k to be wired to the lead hijacker to pay for the attacks. - Multiple top FBI officials have said they could have stopped the attacks but were prevented from doing so. - The secretary of transportation said he overheard what he interpreted as Cheney giving the order to shoot down one of the planes. - The Taliban offered to hand over Bin Laden if the U.S. presented evidence that he was involved in the attacks, and the Bush administration declined to do so. - The Bush administration prevented an independent investigation into the attacks for over a year, and when they finally allowed one they gave it almost no money and completely stonewalled it. - Members of the commission said they were lied to by people at every level of government but were prevented from doing anything about it. - Large portions of the report are still classified, and IIRC 2/3rds of the notes and transcripts of the commission are still classified. - The testimony of several whistleblowers was not included in the report, or they were not allowed to testify. Several whistleblowers were given gag orders. - The majority of the trial testimony of the gitmo detainees has been has been classified. And that's where the government didn't prevent them from testifying on certain subjects entirely in the first place. - One of the two main pieces of evidence linking Bin Laden to 9/11 was a video tape of someone confessing under torture, which was later destroyed. The second was a video of a short fat guy the government claimed was Bin Laden confessing to supporting the attacks, even though he looked nothing like Bin Laden, and Obama then refused to release pics of Bin Laden after his death to show the public whether or not his appearance really had actually been radically altered since his younger days. I mean short of jesus himself coming down and saying the government was involved in 9/11, I don't see what better evidence you could get. And those are only the most well verified facts, not including anything that is disputed or conspiracy-theorish, of which there are plenty more claims at varying levels of credibility. I'm not saying it's not possible that there wasn't a conspiracy, and I could see how other reasonable people could disagree, but I really don't see how anyone can look at the evidence and say that the 'conspiracy-theory' stuff is clearly nonsense.
- patronagezero 12y ago> several people (not conspiracy theorists) Nice, you choose to single out a section of people who've been reliably wrong, and excluded them from the people that have historically been correct. Good job, you tool.