14 ms·
Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving on Copyright Extension
- junto 12y agoCan someone explain to me what the carrot and/or stick is, in getting these countries to sign this agreement?
- venomsnake 12y agoWell ... those kind of agreements are used often as vehicles to bypass national sovereignty. Lets say that official X wants to make law Y, that has a slim chance of passing trough the national legislative body or public. But if it signs an agreement that have these provisions, than the country has to change its laws to fulfill the treaty. Due to reasons US Congress can vote only binary on approving the agreement. Take it as is or throw it all away. In other places it is similar. So there are internal politics to consider.
- Goronmon 12y agoThe carrot is that companies pay the politicians. The stick is that the companies stop paying the politicians.
- pmontra 12y agoYou're correct about the carrot but the stick is that companies will pay another politician, who'll get funds to be elected instead of the one who refused to be bribed.
- toyg 12y agoThese agreements are supposed to reduce barriers in both directions, so there is an interest for businesses on both sides to reduce friction and allow greater access to foreign markets. Unfortunately, this laudable process has been more and more hijacked by special interest groups, to the point where international treaties are used as backdoors to impose legislation that would otherwise be very unpopular at home. An MP voting in, say, New Zealand to extend copyright terms, would get a lot of stick; but now he can say "hey, there is some good with the bad, less barriers are good for the economy blablabla" and vote for the whole bundle with significant political cover; he can then collect his copyright-lobby cheque AND keep his seat, win-win. In a way, this is natural; this sort of dealmaking was commonplace at local and national level at most times in history, and it took a lot of effort to make it fairly transparent through the democratic process; now it gets done at a global level, where there isn't a democratic process yet -- we don't vote for a "world parliament" where this sort of issues could be thrashed out in public, we rely on ambassadors and special envoys with wide negotiating powers and no accountability, which naturally results in corruption.
- jpollock 12y agoActually, for New Zealand, there are huge benefits in terms of market access for their primary industries (milk and meat). Add to that the indirect benefits that the movie industry brings to the tourism industry (yep, they measured it), and you have an agreement that is beneficial to the top two industries. New Zealand wants to sell Americans milk and lamb. Then they're going to want to come over and teach Americans how to grow your _own_ milk and lamb.
- clord 12y agoI imagine the multinationals get to play both sides of the negotiation — they can lobby it to both governments. Hence it's probably mostly all carrot ("Sign and you'll get lower barriers to your own products"). I can imagine there may be some stick too: Sign this or you'll lose access to Disney and pharmaceuticals.
- k-mcgrady 12y ago>> "If the copyright holder is an individual, the minimum copyright term would extend to the lifetime of the creator plus 70 years after her death." I'm quite a big supporter of copyright but that's absolutely ridiculous. I think the lifetime of the creator is very reasonable. I can even understand throwing in a decade after that so that the family of a creator who dies young/suddenly are supported for a while. 70 years is 3 or 4 generations of family.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI don't like it, but that's already the status quo in the US and Europe (which the US extended its terms to match, ie the Europeans did it first). The whole copyright system is in drastic need of reform, but you can hardly blame stakeholders for wanting to maintain the regime they currently have. It's worth bearing in mind that all the TPP negotiating countries are already signatories to the Berne convention and are therefore obliged to respect each others' copyrights: http://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/ShowResults.jsp?treaty_id=15 http://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/ShowResults.jsp?treaty_id=15
- m_eiman 12y agoso that the family of a creator who dies young/suddenly are supported for a while To provide this case, make it "the maximum of [life of author, 10 years]". IMHO 25 years regardless of author lifetime would be more than enough.
- jstalin 12y agoThe original US Copyright law extended protection for 14 years with the availability of renewal for another 14. I think that's reasonable and allows the expiration of copyright after 14 years if the owner doesn't take the time to renew.
- unreal37 12y agoI agree it should expire and require active effort (and some $ amount) to renew. That way, Mickey Mouse can still be under copyright but most other artistic works will be available for public use.
- thechao 12y agoWhat about a contract like this: the copyright holder declares the value of the copyright (on the quarter; on the year; but the declared value may only increase); we then tax them on that value---say 1%. The flip side is that the copyright may be purchased 'into the public domain' by simply paying the full amount of the copyright to the owner of the copyright. (The owner has no right of refusal; however, they may increase the value of the copyright by paying the difference in taxes.) For patents, have the tax be $300 for each year of the age of the patent. Surely, a patent is worth $300 in its first year; and, any patent that is still 'interesting' after 10 years is worth at least $3000? Multinational patents/copyrights are payed to the originating country, so that there's no multiple payment issue.
- valar_m 12y agoThis is a bad idea. You want to impose a tax on people when they create something? Penalizing people for innovation is the exact opposite of what copyright protection is intended to do. If I create something, and a corporation with deep pockets wants to take it from me, they can just keep upping their bid until the tax for me to keep it would bankrupt me, forcing me to give it up? No thanks.
- bediger4000 12y agoI don't know - it seems to make sense to me. The copyright holder is paying a tax so that the state protects the monopoly that's granted with copyright. Seems fair to me. Otherwise, we've got the current situation where some corporations get a huge benefit by getting free monopoly-enforcement from the state.
- ColinDabritz 12y agoInteresting. I feel that "intellectual property" already penalizes people for innovating. It supports the original creator directly, but it prevents all the other innovators from creating more work in the same direction that is inspired by the first. Perhaps the tax helps balance this value?
- 12y ago
- transfire 12y agoWe need a more nuanced copyright system, that takes into account the on going use of a work. I can completely understand the Disney should still have a copyright on the image of Mickey Mouse. But only b/c it is still relevant to their on-going business. The idea of somehow putting a value on a copyright, so the public could conceivably buy it out once it's value falls into an affordable range, that makes a lot of sense, but how to do that fairly?
- bryanlarsen 12y agoDisney has a trademark on Mickey Mouse, which is more than enough to protect it even if the copyright had expired on the original Steamboat Willy.
- transfire 12y agoThat's a good point. So the image of Mickey is still protected for them. I am trying to imagine if I created a company like Disney and a cartoon like Steamboat Willy. Would I want it to go into the public domain after I died if my company were still going strong? If it were not for the company then sure. Let the public domain have it. But the company would be like an extension of myself. In that case I am not so sure.
- acjohnson55 12y agoI'm sure. If said company is so great, incentivize it to continue to create great things, not just coast on decades-old work.
- valar_m 12y agoDo you not see how this would rig the system in favor of deep pocketed corporations even more? You basically said it yourself: "I can completely understand the Disney should still have a copyright on the image of Mickey Mouse. But only b/c it is still relevant to their on-going business."
- dublinben 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- walterbell 12y agoAre the criminal provisions for archivists and DMCA-for-cafes still present? http://www.forbes.com/sites/emmawoollacott/2014/10/17/latest-tpp-leak-shows-even-harsher-copyright-rules/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/emmawoollacott/2014/10/17/latest... “If the US gets its way, then criminal penalties will apply even against users who were not seeking financial gain from sharing or making available copyrighted works, such as fans and archivists,” write Jeremy Malcolm and Maira Sutton of the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF). “Such a broad definition is ripe for abuse.” ... while the last leaked draft of the TPP, dated November 2013, showed strong international opposition to this criminalization plan, Canada now seems to be the only serious hold-out. This may, suggests James Love of Knowledge Ecology International, be because this new draft gives some countries extra time to implement the agreement – meaning that current governments won’t necessarily have to carry the can for their decisions." The European version of TPP is called TTIP: http://www.computerworlduk.com/blogs/open-enterprise/ttip-updates--the-glyn-moody-blogs-3569438/ http://www.computerworlduk.com/blogs/open-enterprise/ttip-up...
- oliwary 12y agoThis[1] linked chapter in Lawrence Lessigs book "Free Culture" is absolutely fascinating, well worth the read if you have the time. [1] http://www.authorama.com/free-culture-18.html http://www.authorama.com/free-culture-18.html
- abandonliberty 12y agoArticle title is wishful thinking. There's no sign the TPP is failing. If they're arguing about a last chance of salvaging legitimacy for the TPP process, I think that was a long time ago.
- Estragon 12y agoThe EFF is correct that this is a travesty, but the real scandal is the undemocratic way the TPP is being negotiated in the first place.
- snowwrestler 12y agoIt's being negotiated the same way every single international agreement has been negotiated, so that's probably not a scandal.
- Brakenshire 12y agoBut it is much more powerful than the trade deals of the previous generation. Whereas those earlier deals dealt exclusively with trade, new deals also include 'non-tariff barriers', i.e. things which are a mixture of trade and domestic policy, like regulation of food, product safety and the environment. But the mechanism for negotiating the deal remains the same as before. That is manifestly unacceptable.
- snowwrestler 12y agoFrom the U.S. perspective, NAFTA and GATT are more powerful than TPP would be. Both address NTBs and were negotiated this way. On top of that, international security agreements like NATO and the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty were negotiated this way, and those arguably have more serious import for a nation than trade.
- Estragon 12y agoChattel slavery was done much the same way everywhere, but doesn't make it any less of a scandal. I'm not equating this with slavery, just pointing out that your argument is bogus.
- vinceguidry 12y ago> multinational entertainment conglomerates, who have twisted what is notionally a trade negotiation into a special interest money-grab Honest question here, is there really a difference between the two? Is there some doctrine somewhere that specifies exactly what constitutes a trade negotiation and what is considered corruption of said negotiation? I see these kinds of statements thrown around a lot without a lot of justification.
- yuhong 12y agoNot that the TPP is a good thing, but personally I think that the fight to not extend copyright terms beyond the term US have now is more important.
- rwmj 12y agoGood essay somewhat related to this, about being pro-market but anti-business: http://stumblingandmumbling.typepad.com/stumbling_and_mumbling/2015/02/anti-business.html http://stumblingandmumbling.typepad.com/stumbling_and_mumbli...
- malandrew 12y agoTBH, I would imagine that the reason that there is no requirement to renew copyright is because Big Content knows people are lazy and that the more content from the past stays copyrighted by default (even if the author doesn't care to assert that right) means there will be less free content to compete for attention in the future. Not requiring formal registration and renewal is a clear attempt to reduce the commons, not merely protect the copyrights owned by Big Content.
- danbmil99 12y agoSad (libertarian!) panda.