8 ms·
Paradoxes That Threaten to Tear Modern Cosmology Apart
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoThat article didn't even mention dark matter and dark energy. Those also "contradict basic physics" in the sense that they need to be conjured into existence to explain our observations.
- rotorblade 12y agoIt does actually. The statement: "What’s more, there is an energy associated with any given volume of the universe. If that volume increases, the inescapable conclusion is that this energy must increase as well. And yet physicists generally think that energy creation is forbidden." is regarding vacuum energy = dark energy = cosmological constant, etc, and continues to discuss it after that. Another thing I find annoying is when they (this article and also others I have seen linked here on HN) paint the picture of that breaking energy conservation is some kind of magic going on -- it is far from it. In General relativity (GR) you can construct conserved quantities from Killing vectors [1]. For example, if you have a time-independent metric (the GR tool for measuring lengths in space-time) you get a time-like Killing vector, which is associated to a certain conserved quantity; Energy. (Another example is when the metric has certain angular independences and you get conservation of angular momentum.) Now in metrics that mimics cosmological evolution (that is, evolution in time), you have to break time-independence, hence your time-like Killing vector is gone and your energy conservation law is gone! This is portrayed as some magic-like thing (at least that is how it sounds to me when I read these popular cosmology articles), but it is simply a consequence of the mathematics of GR. It might break some usual physics intuition, but I would not say that physicists (at least in this field) are surprised by it. So it does not really "contradict basic physics", one just needs to know more about the details to get a good view of it. We do not need to figure out (or "conjure into existence") a way to break conservation of energy (as is the example here), it is already there in GR. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_vector_field#Geodesics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_vector_field#Geodesics The article on wikipedia is quite lacking on this point, but I link it here anyway.
- jpmattia 12y agoNicely put, though I'd point out > It might break some usual physics intuition, It really shouldn't in light of Noether's theorem: The fact that time independence of the action S gives rise to energy conservation in the first place tells us pretty clearly: If your action has time dependence, you don't have conservation of energy.
- eip 12y agoI want to see a picture of the sun in the visible spectrum taken in free space or from the moon.
- anon4 12y agoThat would look pretty much like what you'd see if you photographed the sun from earth on a clear day and replaced all the blue sky with pitch black.
- eip 12y agoSo show me one.
- kryptiskt 12y agoThis is the sun right now: http://sohowww.nascom.nasa.gov/data/realtime/hmi_igr/1024/latest.jpg http://sohowww.nascom.nasa.gov/data/realtime/hmi_igr/1024/la... "The MDI (Michelson Doppler Imager) images shown here are taken in the continuum near the Ni I 6768 Angstrom line. The most prominent features are the sunspots. This is very much how the Sun looks like in the visible range of the spectrum (for example, looking at it using special 'eclipse' glasses: Remember, do not ever look directly at the Sun!). The magnetogram image shows the magnetic field in the solar photosphere, with black and white indicating opposite polarities. " from: http://sohowww.nascom.nasa.gov/data/realtime/realtime-update.html http://sohowww.nascom.nasa.gov/data/realtime/realtime-update...
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI'm trying to use http://seal.nascom.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/gui_seal http://seal.nascom.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/gui_seal to get some of the recent images from that particular instrument, but can't figure it out - no results are returned for my search query: http://i.imgur.com/ANlgBT4.png http://i.imgur.com/ANlgBT4.png Anyone know what I'm doing wrong? Edit: this might be a better resource, and can automatically show you an animated sequence: http://sohodata.nascom.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/data_query http://sohodata.nascom.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/data_query
- Lewton 12y ago> this change may be as much as one centimetre per second per year Anyone have an idea what that's supposed to mean? Edit: Ah, thanks to both of you, it seems obvious now
- edmccard 12y agoThat if something has a velocity of X cm/sec this year, it might have a velocity of (X+1) cm/sec next year.
- rotorblade 12y agoIt has the unit-dimension the same of acceleration (that is [Length]/[Time]^2), so it should be read as: 'Every year, the velocity of the distant quasars (going away relative us) is increased by 1 cm/s.'
- kordless 12y agoCould there be a similar observation of this if time were slowing slightly?
- jdmichal 12y agoI don't see how. Also, what would "time slowing slightly" even mean? That is, what frame of reference is time slowing against? How would we even measure that effect, given that all of our tools which measure time do so my detecting a fixed interval of it passing? Intervals which would also be "slowed".
- kordless 12y agoTo be more specific, if our reference time were slowing slightly, where 'our' is defined as all humans and devices making the measurements.
- wiml 12y agoI think our time would have to be slowing different amounts w.r.t. objects at different distances from us. This would imply a Universe-wide effect on the rate of passage of time which is coincidentally centered on Earth, or at least on our group of galaxies. Universal expansion has the advantage that it doesn't require the Earth to happen to be at a special privileged point in the cosmos.
- cristianpascu 12y agoI believe there are important social aspects of why/how the large public is presented with certainty about what Science says and has discovered while behind the scene things are not that pretty. It seems that we too often forget that all of our beliefs are based on assumptions, some tested some not, some testable and some not. This means that our efforts are always asymptotically growing towards having true knowledge, as in a true justified belief. This should force some sense of humility in us, specially when dealing to others' beliefs. Religious or not.
- Rapzid 12y agoYou're conflating beliefs with hypotheses.
- cristianpascu 12y agoYes, because they are beliefs. We believe c is everywhere what it's measure to be here, but do we know that? If we don't know that for sure it's knowledge. Any sentence that we take as knowledge is a subspecies of a larger group called beliefs.
- Retric 12y agoIf you’re completely honest you can’t guarantee with 100% accuracy what you name is. You’re not 100% positive how old you are. But, when someone asks your name or age 99.99+% accuracy is accepted as good enough. In many ways Science is 'unusually' honest which creates a lot of confusion. Ask everyone on the planet's name and age and you’re likely to find people that make mistakes. But, drop a mere 6 billion marbles and there likely all going to fall.
- onnoonno 12y agoThe problem then is that even the estimation of your accuracy ('99.99+%') becomes baseless if only looked at closely enough.
- aikah 12y agoScience isn't about "beliefs".Science is about facts.Science isn't afraid of the unknown or to be challenged. Religion says one will rot in hell(whatever it is) if one challenges religion. There is no knowledge in religion, as religion doesn't explain anything that can be experimented by man kind.It's just failed philosophy, and it's pretty arrogant. But you're right,both religion and science are man made,they just have 2 opposite purposes.
- antognini 12y ago> What’s more, there is an energy associated with any given volume of the universe. If that volume increases, the inescapable conclusion is that this energy must increase as well. And yet physicists generally think that energy creation is forbidden. It's important to remember that energy conservation is not an axiom of basic physics. It is a consequence of Noether's theorem and temporal symmetry in the laws of physics. In the framework of GR, this means that any static metric will have some conserved quantity that corresponds to energy (though, in general, it will not be the same as the Newtonian energy). But if the metric is not static (as in the case of an expanding universe), there is no need for energy to be conserved.
- rotorblade 12y agoIndeed. I commented on this earlier: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8996190 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8996190
- jessriedel 12y agoRight, this is all well understood. Instead of saying that, we're told: "And yet ask them about it and they shuffle their feet and stare at the ground. Clearly, any theorist who can solve this paradox will have a bright future in cosmology." So the author is either badly informed or willfully deceitful.
- api 12y agoTangential side question: Must energy conservation be local? Would it be "legal" for -- say -- energy to be spent/dissipated (entropy increase) at one location leading to an apparent over-unity effect ("free" entropy decrease) somewhere else? I'm not talking about energy transmission through wires or EM radiation... I mean something apparently disconnected yet coupled. I ask because I've encountered such ideas in sci-fi before and couldn't think of a reason why they're forbidden -- though I have no idea how you would do such a thing.
- nitid_name 12y agoIf it's coupled, wouldn't it cross the boundary of the system, and then be included in normal entropy calculations as a flow across the boundary?
- coldcode 12y agoI've always thought that what we don't know is larger than what we do know, except that we can't measure what we don't know. The universe is continuously surprising. Each discovery winds up trumping the supposed status quo. Being a cosmologist must be a lot like being a javascript programmer, every day what you thought you knew is now obsolete.
- rotorblade 12y ago> we can't measure what we don't know. This is interestingly put, and I would not completely agree with it. Let med give two examples: 1. Before Quantum mechanics we could measure the Photoelectric effect (that is, light that is energetic enough can shoot off electrons from metal plates). This is a Quantum phenomena, and we could measure it before the theory was discovered. 2. Before General relativity we could measure the precision of the elliptical orbit of Mercury. This could not be explained by Newtonian gravity, and is a relativistic effect. But could be measured before the theory was discovered. And before these; Electric eels can shock you, and Magnetic rocks still attract each other, even before Maxwell, Ampere, or Coulomb were even born. The problem now a days (for fundamental theoretical physics) is that we are mostly put in the categories: * There is no data we can't explain with theory. * Theory that is consistent with current data and only predicts new features at much higher energies than we can design experiments for. There are some exceptions to these, but I will exclude these for now, since they are a bit technical. Example of the first one: There is no data directly implying a quantum nature of gravity [1]. Example of the second one: Supersymmetry might not be visible at LHC because LHC is too weak. That second category is why people jump on new results directly, like the BICEP or the super-luminal neutrinos, and the hep-th/ section of arxiv.org is flooded with papers trying to explain it. However, for both these cases, the measurements turned out be be wrong. > every day what you thought you knew is now obsolete. This is what many people say, but I would not agree (in fundamental physics). For example: * One can say Newtonian mechanics is wrong because we have Special relativity now. But one should say: There is a regime (high velocities) in which Newtonian mechanics breaks down. This regime is determined by the speed of light, c. Newtonian mechanics is still correct for velocities much smaller than c. * One can say that Quantum mechanics makes Newtonian mechanics wrong. But one should say: There is a regime where Newtonian mechanics breaks down and Quantum mechanics governs, which is determined by the Planck constant. and so on. It is not "obsolete", or have not turned out to be wrong. One only needs to append new aspects in various regimes. [1] See e.g. http://backreaction.blogspot.fr/2013/11/big-data-meets-eye.html http://backreaction.blogspot.fr/2013/11/big-data-meets-eye.h... > Those of us working on the phenomenology of quantum gravity would be happy if we had data at all [...]
- jchomali 12y agoI totally agree with you.