30 ms·
Croatia just canceled the debts of its poorest citizens
- rfrey 12y agoThe article says the government "convinced" banks and other companies to cancel the debts, but the lenders will not be compensated. It's left as an exercise to imagine how the lenders were convinced. I can see the benefits of getting a large number of people out of what must be a terrible situation - the numbers suggest most of the people affected probably didn't have enough income to even service their debt. But I wonder how this will affect the ability of non-elites to borrow in the future. Although we all like to hate our financial institutions, they really have been an incredible force against class structures over the last 100 years or so, allowing the middle class to own property, start businesses, etc, by gradually extending credit to more and more people. (I recognize it's not been perfect <coughsubprime>.) Reverting to a situation where only the rich and connected can get loans would be a negative consequence. I hope the government of Croatia can counter that.
- raverbashing 12y ago" allowing the middle class to own property, start businesses, etc," Well, there's this crazy concept called "saving money" where you don't borrow from a bank but rather put some money aside every month to be able to afford something expensive I wonder what would happen to property prices if lending was severely restricted, maybe then the value would actually be affordable and not a lifelong debt that becomes unserviceable in the first hiccup
- jljljl 12y agoThe benefits of saving vs. borrowing really depends on the situation, and it's possible that borrowing is actually more beneficial. Let's say I want to save money to buy a house, and I want to pay in cash (i.e., no mortgage). I estimate it will take me about 20 years to afford the house, so I start putting away money from my pay check. However, since I don't have a mortgage and thus no house to live in, I also have to pay rent somewhere. This means I am paying 1/20 the cost of a house + the cost of rent in my city. Additionally, since I won't be buying a house for 20 years, there's a risk that the value of housing could change drastically in that time period, meaning the amount I've saved might not amount to enough to cover the price of housing when I'm finally ready to buy. Obviously the risk of this happening varies by how I invest my savings, and the particularities of the housing market I live in. So the benefit to saving vs. borrowing comes down to something like: (Cost of Housing in 20Years) + (Cost of Rent for 20 Years) - (Gains from Investments) vs. (Cost of Housing Today) + (Interest on Mortgage for 20 years) Obviously there's a lot of other things to take into account, but it's not as simple as Savings Good Debt Bad.
- anon4 12y agoWell to be fair, borrowing with interest works really well only in the presence of endless growth.
- gizmo686 12y agoNot necessarily. Borrowing with interest also works in the presence of endless inflation; it does not necessarily need real growth.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoBut does it work with near-zero inflation or deflation?
- raverbashing 12y agoI agree with your calculation, of course you don't need to save for 20yrs, just save for a good down payment Too bad a lot of people go buy a house on the wrong side of that equation However, owning vs. renting has an interesting hidden cost: you can move "anytime you want" with rent. Renting usually tracks the market affordability/cost more closely, while your mortgage doesn't change while the price go up or down, BUT if the price goes down this might be a problem.
- Sandman 12y agoWell, there's this crazy concept called "saving money" where you don't borrow from a bank but rather put some money aside every month to be able to afford something expensive Yeah. Unfortunately this only works if you have enough money after you pay the bills etc. to put aside.
- falcolas 12y agoPlus, saving up the 10-50 thousand dollars (say, to start a restaurant in the US) required to start a business would take a significant chunk of someone's working lifetime. To use a more concrete example, you can't make money weaving cloth when you can't afford a loom.
- wtbob 12y agoI think your numbers are off by an order of magnitude, which makes it even harder to do for someone with few resources.
- rch 12y agoNot really - I know someone in the town where I went to school who opened a coffee shop using a combination of cash and credit cards at that level. She now owns the building the shop is in and a home in Hawaii. Not VC riches or anything, but not bad either.
- rhino369 12y agoA coffee shop isn't a restaurant.
- zo1 12y agoWell, a restaurant isn't the only business venture an individual can get into. Just the other day I saw meme-photo (can't vouch for the validity/truthfulness) about a woman that made money at the beach by attaching balloons filled with margharita mix over her breasts. And charging party-goers (probably mostly male) for the chance to drink out of them. Ridiculous and asinine example, but I bet she started off with no more than a hundred dollars in capital. Which means that entrepreneurship, and ingenuity are what's most important. Capital will follow.
- kryptiskt 12y agoDoing five years of work to get the money you need to capitalize on an opportunity is often not an option.
- paulojreis 12y ago> Well, there's this crazy concept called "saving money" where you don't borrow from a bank but rather put some money aside every month to be able to afford something expensive I think the point here is opportunity. You might be able to afford it in X years and pay no interest, which of course is better, but you may also have to act "now". This is where credit is adequate and needed.
- HarryHirsch 12y agoAlso: time. Imagine a fellow (me, as a student) who hasn't got a washing machine and does his laundry every other week at the coin launderette, which takes several hours, including the time spent on public transport. They could save up the several hundred bucks for a washing machine and buy one in a year (student, limited budget, or just simply poor), or buy one on credit now. As soon as the thing is installed you have two more afternoons each month to get more productive work done. What would you choose?
- skylan_q 12y agosaving money because we're all keynesians now, saving is now evil.
- a3n 12y ago> Well, there's this crazy concept called "saving money" where you don't borrow from a bank but rather put some money aside every month to be able to afford something expensive. Capital idea. I think we should outlaw all lending, to individuals and to corporations. If poor people are expected to save, then it should be even easier for those of much better circumstance and financial ability. Imagine. No more mortgages.
- SixSigma 12y agoIf you didn't borrow from a bank then banks would charge for you to store your money, making your purchases more expensive
- jdmichal 12y ago> Well, there's this crazy concept called "saving money" where you don't borrow from a bank but rather put some money aside every month to be able to afford something expensive That's great, except that everyone is born short housing. You're not trying to afford something expensive, you are trying to cover your short position. And you're either going to do it by buying or renting. And since renting is just throwing the money at someone else, it can make a lot of sense to get into a mortgage instead. (This is why rent vs buy calculators exist.) > I wonder what would happen to property prices if lending was severely restricted, maybe then the value would actually be affordable and not a lifelong debt that becomes unserviceable in the first hiccup Agree on this point. It's a lot like universities and student loans. They have the numbers; they know the average student can afford $x / semester. They also know the average student can take out $y / semester in loans. So what are they going to charge? $(x + y)! Increasing the accessibility of student loans just gives the universities a reason to increase the prices. They don't care how much debt students walk out with; they already got theirs.
- alextgordon 12y ago> But I wonder how this will affect the ability of non-elites to borrow in the future. Although we all like to hate our financial institutions, they really have been an incredible force against class structures over the last 100 years or so, allowing the middle class to own property, start businesses, etc, by gradually extending credit to more and more people. (I recognize it's not been perfect <coughsubprime>.) Reverting to a situation where only the rich and connected can get loans would be a negative consequence. I hope the government of Croatia can counter that. I have the opposite reading of history. Mortgages have been a force of social stagnation in the developed world[1]. What mortgages have done is create lots of middle class property owners. These people have a strong interest in keeping property prices high. Politicians are only too happy to oblige them. Thus society has bifurcated into the "have houses" and the "have nots". The middle classes throw their weight around to prevent new houses being built, as every new house decreases the price of the houses around it. Unlike the developing world, the developed world is perfectly capable of building a house for every man, woman and child. If it did, poverty would all but disappear; it's hard to be poor when you have your own house. But the financial institutions have tied enough of the population into mortgages and home ownership that developed world poverty cannot be eradicated without a serious amount of middle class hurt. [1] (I can only speak for the UK but I guess Croatia, like all countries, will end up in this situation eventually)
- reinhardt 12y ago> Unlike the developing world, the developed world is perfectly capable of building a house for every man, woman and child. If it did, poverty would all but disappear; it's hard to be poor when you have your own house. If only that was true. The top countries by home ownership are Romania, Lithuania and Hungary, while UK and US are in the 33st/34th position and Germany/Switzerland 10 positions below: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_home_ownership_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_home_owner...
- riffraff 12y agonotice that ex-warsaw-pact countries all have high home ownership due to having expropriated property and having had large "social building" projects (which also lead to some horrible places though).
- scotty79 12y agoForget the 1% of most likely noncollectable debt and get 60 thousands customers instead? That seems like no-brainer. I don't think banks needed much convincing. Poor people will repay their debt in trick fees for the banks in no time or just become indebted again.
- vidarh 12y ago> the numbers suggest most of the people affected probably didn't have enough income to even service their debt. Consider the analogue of the UK, where the banks have a duty to consider the ability of a persons ability to service a debt before letting them take out the loan. Failure to do so will let the person who have taken out the loan get the debt stricken off, as the bank will have broken the law... In that light this doesn't seem terribly shocking to me.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y agoI'm not aware of any situation where a debt has been struck out because of this law. Debts are usually struck out because of errors in contracts, statutory procedures, and other paperwork. But courts usually seem to assume that a simple credit check counts as due diligence, and it's the borrower's responsibility to repay debt even if it's offered on an unrealistic basis - e.g. a credit card with a limit equal to a year's income, and an exploding interest rate of 50% or more if a borrower misses a payment or two. Which is not unrealistic, btw. I know of one credit card company offering rates up to 99.9% compound to individuals with poor credit ratings. Obviously they know most borrowers will default - and that seems to be the basis of their business model.
- vidarh 12y agoHere is an example where Lloyds TSB offered to strike off a 100k debt after it became clear they had likely broken the banking code (the banking code is voluntary, but it does not go much further than legal requirements), and it is by no means the only time UK banks have written off loans because they were wrongly given out to people who could not afford them: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/4528567.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/4528567.stm
- ctdonath 12y agoThe article says the government "convinced" banks and other companies to cancel the debts, but the lenders will not be compensated. It's left as an exercise to imagine how the lenders were convinced. I have to wonder the same about the US banking system about 8 years ago: the aforementioned subprime problem apparently led to top bankers literally being brought into a room and told in no uncertain terms they would agree to the planned solution to the problem; what was actually said remains unknown and rather...intriguing.
- dragonwriter 12y agoThere's a thing here -- with widespread bad debts, its generally not in the interests of lenders to write them off individually (because it means that those likely to default are attracted to those lenders that seem most willing to do that), but when there is a major wave of them, its in the interest of the lenders for them to be addressed en masse so that the system as a whole is dragged down by the burden those debts put on the consumer market.
- onesongonesong 12y agoIf debts are under 35 000 kunas, monthly income is under half of minimum salary ( you know what sucks? Many workers are on minumum salary, yet don't receive salaries for months, whilst company owners drive luxury cars for a salary 3-4x the average one, so those workers are not eligible) and the citizen doesn't own any land or savings. One of the main problems is that about 10% of our citizens have their accounts frozen. They could change laws to help it, but that would hit their budget. It's absurd that you can get sued by the government for tons of money just for not paying a monthly TV subscription payment, that you are subscribed to by having more than 1 radio frequency receiver, no matter be it a radio, phone or a TV. Or even having an screen in your home. This is like focusing on fighting acne, when your patient is dying of cancer. Yes, it will help a lot of families, and that's great, but elections are coming up and this is mostly a political points move, since the "right wing" won the presidential elections, the political "left" is now worried.
- failed_ideas 12y agoIn part, I love this idea. However, as someone who struggles with debt, I've worked to the point of causing serious health issues just to keep my head above water, so if Canada were to do this, I'd be more than ticked. The slacker next to me gets a clean slate, and I get an early grave.
- jacquesm 12y agoThink of the slacker next to you as having an independent relationship with the state and so do you. I never understood why some people would happily drag down someone else, that's jealousy in disguise. Simply see this as a plus for society because that debt drags everybody down, including you. I wouldn't sleep any worse if all the debt for people earning minimum wage or nothing at all were forgiven, that's a much better way to spend money than to enrich a small number of already insanely rich people. Give it another 3 or 4 decades and a few more rounds of automation and who knows, you just might find yourself in the league of the 'slackers', quite a few of them are not slackers by nature but simply grew up in a time when their skills became surplus and their age forced them out of the productive cycle. Very few people consciously choose to be un-employed and this could happen to all of us.
- davidw 12y agoOne thing is a rule where you know what happens, and there's a social safety net in place, and everyone knows how it works, and has voted on it, and so on. One-off actions are kind of another thing, in my book. Anyway: politics. Article flagged. I'll happy talk politics here in Padova with anyone who wants to stop by and have a drink.
- swombat 12y agoThere's a fantastic scene in the Count of Monte Christo where the Count and his guests witness a double-execution. In fact, thanks to the wonders of the Internet, here it is, from http://www.cleavebooks.co.uk/grol/dumas/count035.htm http://www.cleavebooks.co.uk/grol/dumas/count035.htm . Franz, Albert an the Count are witnessing the execution: Behind the executioner came, in the order in which they were to die, first Peppino and then Andrea. Each was accompanied by two priests. Neither had his eyes bandaged. Peppino walked with a firm step, doubtless aware of what awaited him. Andrea was supported by two priests. Each of them, from time to time, kissed the crucifix a confessor held out to them. At this sight alone Franz felt his legs tremble under him. He looked at Albert — he was as white as his shirt, and mechanically cast away his cigar, although he had not half smoked it. [...] "I thought," said Franz to the count, "that you told me there would be but one execution." "I told you true," replied he coldly. "And yet here are two culprits." "Yes; but only one of these two is about to die; the other has many years to live." "If the pardon is to come, there is no time to lose." "And see, here it is," said the count. At the moment when Peppino reached the foot of the mandaïa, a priest arrived in some haste, forced his way through the soldiers, and, advancing to the chief of the brotherhood, gave him a folded paper. The piercing eye of Peppino had noticed all. The chief took the paper, unfolded it, and, raising his hand, "Heaven be praised, and his holiness also," said he in a loud voice; "here is a pardon for one of the prisoners!" "A pardon!" cried the people with one voice — "a pardon!" At this cry Andrea raised his head. "Pardon for whom?" cried he. Peppino remained breathless. "A pardon for Peppino, called Rocca Priori," said the principal friar. And he passed the paper to the officer commanding the carbineers, who read and returned it to him. "For Peppino!" cried Andrea, who seemed roused from the torpor in which he had been plunged. "Why for him and not for me? We ought to die together. I was promised he should die with me. You have no right to put me to death alone. I will not die alone — I will not!" And he broke from the priests struggling and raving like a wild beast, and striving desperately to break the cords that bound his hands. The executioner made a sign, and his two assistants leaped from the scaffold and seized him. "What is going on?" asked Franz of the count; for, as all the talk was in the Roman dialect, he had not perfectly understood it. "Do you not see?" returned the count, "that this human creature who is about to die is furious that his fellow-sufferer does not perish with him? and, were he able, he would rather tear him to pieces with his teeth and nails than let him enjoy the life he himself is about to be deprived of. Oh, man, man — race of crocodiles," cried the count, extending his clinched hands towards the crowd, "how well do I recognize you there, and that at all times you are worthy of yourselves!" Meanwhile Andrea and the two executioners were struggling on the ground, and he kept exclaiming, "He ought to die! — he shall die! — I will not die alone!" "Look, look," cried the count, seizing the young men's hands — "look, for on my soul it is curious. Here is a man who had resigned himself to his fate, who was going to the scaffold to die — like a coward, it is true, but he was about to die without resistance. Do you know what gave him strength? — do you know what consoled him? It was, that another partook of his punishment — that another partook of his anguish — that another was to die before him. Lead two sheep to the butcher's, two oxen to the slaughterhouse, and make one of them understand that his companion will not die; the sheep will bleat for pleasure, the ox will bellow with joy. But man — man, whom God created in his own image — man, upon whom God has laid his first, his sole commandment, to love his neighbor — man, to whom God has given a voice to express his thoughts — what is his first cry when he hears his fellow-man is saved? A blasphemy. Honor to man, this masterpiece of nature, this king of the creation!" And the count burst into a laugh; a terrible laugh, that showed he must have suffered horribly to be able thus to laugh. However, the struggle still continued, and it was dreadful to witness. The people all took part against Andrea, and twenty thousand voices cried, "Put him to death! put him to death!" Franz sprang back, but the count seized his arm, and held him before the window. "What are you doing?" said he. "Do you pity him? If you heard the cry of 'Mad dog!' you would take your gun — you would unhesitatingly shoot the poor beast, who, after all, was only guilty of having been bitten by another dog. And yet you pity a man who, without being bitten by one of his race, has yet murdered his benefactor; and who, now unable to kill any one, because his hands are bound, wishes to see his companion in captivity perish. No, no — look, look!" I think the scene speaks for itself and reuires no further comment.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bmajz 12y agoThis is an interesting concept and a really old one to boot. Planet Money recently did a great podcast covering a similar measure (although it was specifically for mortgages) in Iceland: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2014/12/05/368723679/episode-587-jubilee http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2014/12/05/368723679/episode-... Interestingly, Saudi Arabia also did something similar (alongside many other measures) to boost public support for the new king: http://www.arabnews.com/news/696661 http://www.arabnews.com/news/696661
- rhizome31 12y agoI'm reading Graeber's Debt, the first 5000 years which explains how this practice is as old as debt itself. It already existed in ancient Mesopotamia. I highly recommend this book to anyone interested in the topic. It also shows how debt is deeply linked to slavery, women slavery in particular, through the phenomenon of debt peonage.
- bmajz 12y agoSounds awesome - will have to check it out. Totally random aside: does it talk about the evolution of debtor's prisons after slavery was no longer an option? I always wondered why people thought it made sense to lock someone up with no economic recourse to pay down a debt. There were probably much better options to deal with the potential moral hazard.
- graeme 12y agoFrom wikipedia: Destitute persons unable to pay a court-ordered judgment would be sentenced to these prisons until they had worked off their debt via labor or secured outside funds to pay the balance; the product of their labor went towards both the costs of their incarceration and their accrued debt. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debtors'_prison http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debtors'_prison Labor was one form. I imagine being sent to prison moved families to action to bail out the debtor when possible. Finally, consider all the debts paid to avoid going to debtors prison. I don't know anything about the evolution of the system. Just pointing out that it wasn't an insane way to acheive the goal of debt payment. (Though a totally inhumane way)
- reqres 12y agoWhile i applaud the motivation behind cancelling the debts of Croatia's poorest citizens, the way it was done is likely to hurt them more in the long run. Forcing banks to absorb the losses of this write-off will likely make it harder for the poorest to access credit in the future. Banks are not social institutions - they're pathological profit making entities. They will have no qualms with raising interest rates or denying credit altogether to compensate for the increased risk of doing business with their poorest customers. The poorest section of the population do not borrow money for no reason. Borrowing is often required for emergencies (i.e. medical) or short term liquidity (paying bills on time). Just as importantly, it's vital for people who want to improve their economic situation by starting new businesses. My primary concern is that banks starting to shut/price them out. The least well off will end up resorting to informal lenders (i.e. loan sharks).
- Yetanfou 12y agoWith a bit of luck the least well off will end up seeing the truth in the money game - they can't win, no matter what they do. This actually goes for many (maybe even most?) people, except for the small_number%. The best way to play the game is not to play it at all - avoid loans, avoid debt, avoid a dependency on money whenever possible. Use the money you make to reduce your dependence on future money by acquiring means to increase your independence. For some this will be hard - if you live in a city there is only so much you can do - while for others it is easier. Barring a revolt of some kind (war, revolution, catastrophe, take your pick) or a radical change in the concept of money, more and more wealth will be concentrated in fewer and fewer hands. Increased automation will reduce the number of ways a large part of the population will be able to make even a semblance of a living wage. If there is no system in place to take care of these people - most likely in the form of a base living wage provided by some authority - they'll revolt before they starve. And who are they? Are you one of them? If not now, maybe soon? So... like Tic-Tac-Toe, the outcome of the money game is known before the game starts. They who make the first move, win. You probably did not make the first move, so you won't. Best not to play, then? This does not mean you should avoid money at all cost, it just means you should not follow it. Don't count on making more tomorrow than you do today. Don't base your plans around the money you'll make or that which you accrued. If you have money, use it to reduce your dependency on future money. Buy land if possible. Use money to become energy-independent. Try to become less dependent on automotive transport. Don't get insurances for anything which you can do without. Learn to produce, not consume. Be creative. Entertain yourself instead of being entertained.
- hackuser 12y agoA similar method of helping the impoverished, one which has strong support among at least some economists (and maybe more widely), is cash transfers directly to the people who need it. That is, don't fund a service for those in need, fund the people directly and they can buy what they need. GiveDirectly is a leading implementation of this idea: https://www.givedirectly.org/ https://www.givedirectly.org/ It was founded by economists, and their blog has a lot of interesting discussion and analysis of the idea: http://blog.givewell.org/category/givedirectly/ http://blog.givewell.org/category/givedirectly/ One way to approach this idea: Why not do it this way?
- themartorana 12y agoI argue, albeit inexpertly, that TARP money given directly to homeowners to make payments on their toxic mortgages would have been of infinitely better societal good than handing b(tr?)illions to banks without any oversight at all. But you are morally bankrupt for taking out a mortgage difficult for you to pay. The bank, however, doesn't have such moral failings for they are not people. Wait...
- maxerickson 12y agoSaying TARP had no oversight is a bit much. The money mostly got paid back, it wasn't a festival of stealing from the government: http://projects.propublica.org/bailout/ http://projects.propublica.org/bailout/ The best way to look at TARP is as a preservation of the status quo. Whether that was the right thing or not, given how many people have investment assets that are exposed to banking and insurance, the benefits were a lot wider than just to the banking system. Also there were mortgage relief programs that come out of the bailout: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_Affordable_Modification_Program http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_Affordable_Modification_Pr... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_Affordable_Refinance_Program http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_Affordable_Refinance_Progr... They didn't just make mortgage payments though.
- themartorana 12y agoWell, yes, except for where not entirely or at all. [0] [0] http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2011/11/28/142854391/report-fed-committed-7-77-trillion-to-rescue-banks http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2011/11/28/142854391/rep...
- nsxwolf 12y agoYou know there's at least one poor Croatian that paid off his debts and feels like a real sucker now. Kind of like how the last Americans to pay for their own community college tuition will feel.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoRelated sidebar: one of the observations Jefferson made while in France at the beginning of the French Revolution was that institutional debt prevented needed changes from ever taking place. That is, the country was so intertwined in various entities owing various other entities that there was no solution that was acceptable to a plurality. One of the ideas I've toyed with over the past few years is a "debt sunset clause" for all debts, both public, private, institutional, and governmental. Whenever you lend money, you have, say, 30 years to get it all back. Or it's gone. The clock starts when you write the check. From a market standpoint, the additional risk would just be written into the interest rate. But from a systemic standpoint, major gains could be achieved. That way you wouldn't have to have "debt holidays", "debt forgiveness" and so on. It would just take care of itself. (And if you wanted, you could have different time frames for different types of debt, but then you're heading down the over-complicating route again)
- jliptzin 12y agoIsn't that what declaring bankruptcy is for? Does Croatia have bankruptcy laws?
- thesimon 12y agoThere is no law for personal bankruptcy yet. There was one proposal, but it hasn't been approved yet.
- ptaipale 12y agoThere are in fact several European countries where personal bankruptcy is not possible, or where only a "Chapter 11" (re-arrangement of debt, not cleaning table altogether) is possible.
- jkot 12y agoIs not this called bankruptcy?
- juliangregorian 12y ago> Among economists, the scheme is regarded as unprecedented and exceptional. Couldn't be further from the truth. In times past it was commonplace to cancel debts periodically. Moses and Hammurabi are just two examples off the top of my head.
- igravious 12y agoYes. I am not an economist but it troubles me that economists would be unawares (or claim to be unawares) about this aspect of the history of debt. As usual Wikipedia (the wise, the all-knowing) has a page[1] about it. Mass debt relief and forgiveness is unexceptional in history and certainly has precedent. Even as recently as the turn of the century (only a decade-and-a-half ago!) there was an international movement[2] calling for the cancellation of a great deal of so-called third world debt as many countries spend more on debt reparations (just paying off the interest) than on building up the infrastructure of their countries or spending on health or education. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt_relief http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt_relief [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jubilee_2000 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jubilee_2000
- SapphireSun 12y agoIt kind of reminds me of how in some MMO games, they periodically reset the world to keep the game balanced. It usually means there's a defect in the world design, but it's a valid strategy for keeping the game going.
- meric 12y agoCoincidentally 2001, 2008 and 2015 are Debt relief "Shmita" years according to Abrahamic tradition. The Bible instruction is to provide debt relief to creditors every seven years. Putting my non-religious hat on, I wonder if this crept into the bible from ancient society's observations that human credit cycles last seven years.
- igravious 12y agoI thought it mentioned every 50 ((7*7)+1) years in the bible? Very interesting about this coinciding with a notion of a short human credit cycle in actuality. Wasn't there an economics article on here recently that claimed that there are natural short and long human credit cycles?
- popee 12y agoHi, croat here. Just one detail, this year there will be elections in Croatia and current gov didn't do anything useful for our economy, so this is kind of popular measure. Don't get me wrong, it's always nice to help, but situation is little bit complicated, taxes are very high and in some way this is not fair to people that are paying everything. Also, there are huge number of people living and exploiting social measures, so ... In this context it's impossible to help those who really need help. You know what is the saddest part? Opposition party (conservatives that ruled from 2007-2011) is convicted for criminality and they are atm most popular, so for common and independent people there is no light at the end of the tunnel. If someone can solve this chaos he/she will be candidate for Nobel's price. P.S. Sorry on bad english
- bsaul 12y agoYour comment made me realize a more appropriate title would be : "Current croatian government cancels poor citizen's debts one year before election". But that would probably cast a VERY different light on the event. The original intent was probably to give the (positive i guess) impression that the greek trend of not paying debts is spreading.
- riffraff 12y ago> the greek trend of not paying debts is spreading. I don't think that trend exists (yet) but _canceling_ debt (creditor) and not paying debt (debtor) are quite different.
- bsaul 12y agoI don't know the details but i suppose the debts weren't owned by the state (nobody borrows from a state) but rather by credits corporations or banks.
- riffraff 12y agoyes, but that doesn't change the fact that the croatian government would have persuaded/forced the banks to cancel the debt, it's not the people with a loan who decided not to pay.
- zb 12y agoA similar act occurred as part of what may now be regarded as the foundation of Western democracy: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seisachtheia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seisachtheia was a regular feature of the ancient world: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jubilee_(Biblical) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jubilee_(Biblical) and occurs on a smaller scale in our own society on a daily basis: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bankruptcy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bankruptcy So if we ask a so-called expert on the subject, what will he say? Among economists, the scheme is regarded as unprecedented and exceptional. "I can't think of anything comparable," Dean Baker, co-director of the Washington-based Center for Economic and Policy Research, told The Washington Post. Of course he's against it anyway.
- oldpond 12y agoThis is great news, and I hope the world follows suit. Debt amnesty is indeed a time honored solution to the current crisis. When a person goes into debt they sell their future wages. When a government goes into debt they sell future tax revenue. Now all the future wages and tax revenue that can be sold are in the hands of the banks. (Sure, governments could keeps selling future tax revenue from future citizens who haven't been born yet, but let's pretend they don't.) So the banks are in a bad spot; no more debt to buy. If they stop lending, the money system dries up and everyone loses their jobs (happening now). If they try to raise the interest rates (effectively zero now) nobody will be able to afford the payments on their debt and everyone goes broke. So, the whole system needs a big reset. Hence the need for debt amnesty. What we do after debt amnesty is critical. Do we just start the same old cycle over again? Or do we take this opportunity to make a fundamental change. The government is the only body that can legally create money, but they don't. They create the money in the banks and then borrow it back at interest essentially giving the banks control of the currency. We need to take back control of our currencies and declare general debt amnesty for all governments and citizens at all levels. Business can carry on as usual; they get to keep their debt. Governments should never be in debt again. With governments out of debt the economy starts moving again. In Canada, the largest employer in the country is the Government of Canada, and in each province the largest employer is the respective provincial government. Not hard to see the benefits of a government able to spend enough money to fix the roads, schools, parks, and all the other shared services we use. Of course the banks won't like this idea. However, if the government creates enough money ONE TIME to cover the debts that are being erased then the banks are made whole. Basically, the banks get one chance, just like everyone else, to sort themselves out and figure out how they plan to operate post-amnesty. But they won't rule the world anymore.
- kaonashi 12y ago> When a government goes into debt they sell future tax revenue This depends entirely on which government. It's true in the case of California or Greece, but not Australia or the U.S., for example.
- yottah 12y agoCroatia doesn't even have bankruptcy laws yet which is awful, and the political class is so bad and incompetent that I don't see Croatia experiencing any growth in the next 20 years. If you're a young and intelligent person in Croatia, you should move to some place where you wont be oppressed.
- Shivetya 12y agomy understanding is that Croatia doesn't have bankruptcy laws similar to some Western countries so once you cannot pay simple debts, like bills for utilities, your bank accounts can get frozen by the state? As for it being unprecedented, nah, many near failed states will do about anything to prop up the popularity of the ruling class.
- velcro 12y agoNote that the amounts in the article are not factually correct. Its really not $138. Its actually: A.) max. 2500kn (croatian kuna) or $367 USD for singles B.) max. 1250kn or $183 per household member (so for families of 4 it would be $183 x 4) This is obviously for the poorest of the society that have had their accounts blocked for debt longer than 360 days. Most working people in Croatia would not be able to meet that criteria - minimal state-imposed gross salary for 2015 is 3030kn ($445 USD). People also tend to mix net and gross amounts (everything salary-related in Croatia is usually presented as a gros amount - while in the US/EU its usually net). Not an insignificant difference because Croatia has some of the highest taxes in the world. Source: https://servisi.fina.hr/otpis-duga-javna-objava/info https://servisi.fina.hr/otpis-duga-javna-objava/info
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- guard-of-terra 12y ago"If lenders think this can happen again they will charge very high interest rates to low-income borrowers" If lenders got their money back from government, they will be much more eager to lend.
- nandemo 12y agoLenders won't get their money back. > The government will not refund the companies for their losses.
- scotty79 12y agoI have trouble understanding this. > the program is expected to cost up to 210 million Croatian kuna ($31 million), > "I am not sure that this is the best way to help low-income people. If lenders think this can happen again they will charge very high interest rates to low-income borrowers," Baker said. Will the money be paid for debtors or not at all? (in case of those lenders that did not agree to forget the debt)
- nandemo 12y agoNo. > The government will not refund the companies for their losses.
- JDiculous 12y agoNow I'm just waiting for them to do this in the USA for student loans
- JamisonM 12y agohttp://www.reuters.com/article/2015/01/15/us-croatia-welfare-idUSKBN0KO13220150115 http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/01/15/us-croatia-welfare... The government program involves major local banks, leading telecom operators, the four biggest Croatian cities and several public utility companies. The government will not pay the debts; the creditors will simply absorb them. Frankly in the absence of consumer bankruptcy laws it is clear why these particular creditors are willing to go along with this scheme, even though it will cost them some revenue, without much of a fight. These were likely amounts small enough, given the parameters of the debt-cancellation rules, that recovery was never a particularly practical option anyway. If the debt on the books of utilities or a bank is not good enough to sell to a third party and is not considered recovery internally then the accountants would be quite happy to simply have these amounts off the books and the corporations and governments probably reap more rewards in positive PR than the debts were worth. The perhaps larger problem that I think is being solved here, besides the debt itself, is the bank account "blocking"[1] that appears to be a provision in current law that the government is not interested in changing. Once someone's bank accounts are blocked I presume that they are forced into the cash economy and that is bad for the government in lost taxes as well as citizens with respect to many things, including good old fashioned "getting ripped off". [1] http://www.croatiaweek.com/over-300000-accounts-blocked-due-to-debt-from-bills/ http://www.croatiaweek.com/over-300000-accounts-blocked-due-...
- bnt 12y agoCroat here: This is BS. They canceled peoples phone & other commodity debt. This is basically rewarding people for being financially irresponsible. I could have easily taken 5 phones on 2 year contracts, decided not to pay and gotten that written off with this law.
- rospaya 12y ago> I could have easily taken 5 phones on 2 year contracts, decided not to pay and gotten that written off with this law. Not really, since the law only covers people who have no savings, no propery and earn a third of the minimum wage. You have to be seriously poor to get your 5 phones for free.
- bmmayer1 12y agoLet's just look at the predictable consequences of this move: 1) Banks and other corporations will never lend money to poor people again. Full stop. If there is a chance that the government will write off that debt (effectively stealing future earnings from banks) for these loans, banks just won't issue them. Say goodbye to educational loans, healthcare loans, car loans. Say goodbye to home loans and mortgages. If you're poor, you just became a ward of the state. And you thought being in debt was bad... 2) If a legitimate institution do want to lend money to poor people, interest rates will skyrocket to compensate for this additional government-cancellation risk. If they skyrocket above usury laws, then legitimate institutions will no longer be in the market and the job of lending at-risk capital will turn to the black market. Look out for loan sharks and indentured servitude, including sex slavery, on the rise in Croatia in the future. 3) The money has to come from somewhere--it isn't free. By canceling $31M in debt, the government is causing $31M in losses to corporations and institutions that were owed that money. That means $31M less in spending, economic growth, job creation, not to mention taxes, which will have to go up to compensate for the loss. These taxes (or inflation) will hit the poorest people while the rich horde more money or offshore it to prevent it being taken away. 4) Lending is the foundation of economic growth, especially for the poor, by allowing borrowers to leverage their limited assets in exchange for future earnings. All things being equal, people will borrow money smartly or stupidly, but the consequences, good or bad, are faced by the people who borrow. If the government cancels debt, it is incentivizing bad borrowing and making it harder for good borrowers to get the capital they need. It's the worst kind of pandering to the voters with long-term destructive consequences to the people of Croatia. In other words, exactly what you'd expect from politicians. Keep up the good work!
- lifeformed 12y agoUnless I'm reading this wrong, isn't this good for banks? The gov't is paying the debts, not just declaring them gone. The banks get everything back.
- gnoway 12y agoNo. The article points out that the lenders will not be reimbursed.
- olefoo 12y agoSomething to consider; high-interest consumer debt is a public health problem. It travels with and exacerbates substance abuse, compulsive gambling and other social pathologies. If we view it this way our current permissive attitude towards payday lenders and such is quite literally insane. The equivalent of allowing gonorrhea infested prostitutes to operate a brothel on Main st. that offers bareback specials.
- craigds 12y agoDoes anyone know if bad debts are tax deductible in Croatia? If so, the government would have just needed to convince the banks that the chance of getting the money back was lower than the tax they'd be repaid by forgiving the debt.
- jqm 12y agoI wonder if this has anything to do with attempts to tamp down Russia's influence in the region. Poor people without a lot to loose are destabilizing force in a society. 31 Million is peanuts to help insure order. Maybe banks and corporations were convinced this way?
- tn13 12y agoSo the people who were responsible enough to pay their debt ended up paying for irresponsible people deep into debt ? Government did not "cancel" the debt, it simply paid it off using someone else's money.
- whiddershins 12y agoEconomists called the move "unprecedented." I assume those economists never read any history at all, or they would have known debt forgiveness has been used since ancient Sumeria to help rebalance messed up economies. https://archive.org/details/Debt-The_First_5000_Years https://archive.org/details/Debt-The_First_5000_Years
- shitgoose 12y agoYou don't save money by reloading, you just shoot more.
- nathan_f77 12y agoThis is a beautiful idea. Straight from the Bible, too [1]. But I wonder how many citizens are right on the edge of these limits? That would really suck if you had a monthly income only slightly higher than 1,250 kuna. Also, if you have 40,000 kuna in debt, is the first 35,000 wiped out? Or none at all, because you're over the limit? > They cannot have any other property or savings. What if you have 2,000 kuna in savings, but you're still 37,000 kuna in debt? I think a function might be fairer than hard thresholds. Maybe take monthly income as a parameter, and then wipe out lots of debt for the extremely poor, a bit less for people who are closer to the poverty threshold, and none for anyone who has a reasonable monthly income. Round the output to the nearest 1,000 kuna. Sure, it's more complex, but we have computers now. Also, "The government will not pay the debts; the creditors will simply absorb them." That really sucks for the creditors, even though those debts probably had a low chance of being repaid. But it just feels wrong to force a company to forgive debts. Surely the right way is to use taxpayer money, or take a hit on inflation. I really want to read the actual bill. Does anyone have an English translation? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jubilee_%28biblical%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jubilee_%28biblical%29
- alienasa 12y ago> What if you have 2,000 kuna in savings, but you're still 37,000 kuna in debt? This is directly translatable to being 35,000 kuna in debt. You can't ignore savings when determining ability to pay debt.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cubancigar11 12y agoI just want to add that Indian governments have always canceled debts of farmers (who make up the majority population) in election year. So this kind of measure is neither novel nor unprecedented, as the article in WaPo suggests.
- seesomesense 12y agoIf I was a Croatian lender, I would immediately stop lending to the poor. Alternatively I would find a way to charge them very high interest rates to compensate for the risk of the government doing this again.
- mrow84 12y agoThe idea that lenders will stop lending to poorer people seems very popular, but can someone explain why this situation will remain immune from market effects? Markets are not an exercise in rationality, they are an exercise in making a return on investment, and, investment will occur where people think they can make a return, almost irrespective of the existence of crashes (in this case, government cancelling debts). I really don't see why people won't invest under the belief that they will be smart enough to pull out in time, just as they do in lots of other markets such as housing and shares. It seems to me that this "no lending to the poor" argument is popular more because it fits with a particular set of politics, and is justified only by an appeal to its rationality as an idea, rather than to whether or not it might actually obtain.
- dsirijus 12y agoResponsible countries handle this through a simple legislated idea - personal bankruptcy; this is a political populist move not inspired by any actual reasoning into effects of this on economy. Not that I think effect is of any serious impact, for anyone. This move is exactly of the category that is crippling Croatia. We (yes, a Croat here) are in a bit of a pickle, and let me explain the core of the it... Even excluding astonishing amount of pensioners (many from previous regime) and war-inflicted disabled persons (whose actual condition is matter to be looked upon suspiciously) and other non-working class of people, work-force segments into two distinct categories - directly or indirectly dependant on the goverment as source of income, and the good "old" private sector. The trouble here is that former is riddled with catastrophic inefficiency, corruption and evades competitive market, and the latter carries the burden of former. The issue is - in democratic elections, majority wins, and the former here is the majority. So we keep up with this cancerous tumor of goverment-dependants who won't ever vote for someone who'll put a stop to it (hey, they're not crazy, why would they vote against their immediate interests), and violently cut it out of the system. Maybe, and just maybe (haven't crunched the numbers), within a generation, when few factors align (war-disabled die off, unemployed numbers increase even more), the actual critical mass of value-adding work-force outweighs the tumor, brighter days await us. And even that is under assumption there will be an election choice that'll be catalyst for those changes at that point. I personally don't hold an optimist view. Hell, even our geographical geometric shape looks unstable and unnatural. War ended by higher powers putting a stop to it, not resolution. And as far as EU membership goes - meh, we're again at the age-old role of a border country as a proxy for keeping the region stable and keeping the muslims out. Important role, but hardly grateful. Not to end on a completely sour note - I did notice a sentiment of unity last few years. Particulary noted during holiday sales (or the lack of excessive spending), people seem to coalesce in misery, slowly perceiving that we're in this shit together, unlike during last two decades, where they would aspire beyond means, due to many factors including prominence of war-profiteers. Like my grandma said: "It was never worse here during my lifetime. After WWII at least everyone was poor."
- blackstrype 12y agoThis sounds too ridiculous to manage... The cost simply of controlling who is eligible for debt cancellation adds more burden on taxpayers. I think they'd be better off to calculate a debt cancellation eligible for everyone. Tax rebates for those who wish to donate their debt cancellation to others. In large: let the community decide what to do with their own tax money.
- ksk 12y agoI don't know if this was motivated by religion but this stuff is very Christian in nature :) http://biblehub.com/deuteronomy/15.htm http://biblehub.com/deuteronomy/15.htm