10 ms·
EFF’s Game Plan for Ending Global Mass Surveillance
- AndrewGaspar 12y agoRemember you can donate to the EFF at: https://supporters.eff.org/donate https://supporters.eff.org/donate
- lalos 12y agoAlso EFF is available on http://smile.amazon.com http://smile.amazon.com and almost every purchase you make they will receive like 0.5% as long as you make it through the smile subdomain.
- malnourish 12y agoIs there an extension (for either FF or Chromium) that automatically converts `amazon.com` -> `smile.amazon.com`?
- lalos 12y agoI don't use them but I've seen them before https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/smile-always/jgpmhnmjbhgkhpbgelalfpplebgfjmbf?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/smile-always/jgpmh... https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/amazonsmile-1button-for-c/hdgenjhkjihnmigcommchefpajjhdmba?hl=en-US https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/amazonsmile-1butto...
- malnourish 12y agoAh! Thank you.
- p01926 12y agoI'd like to suggest another tool for fighting mass surveillance: mass chaffing. Most of the time our internet connections are idle. And when they aren't, we very rarely use all our bandwidth. What if, instead, we each used a small amount of our resources to crawl the web. We could easily generate 1,000 to 10,000 chaff requests for every genuine one — completely drowning out any signals from our browsing behaviour. This is particularly nice because it highlights the stupidity of trying to find a few needles by searching every haystack in the world. Let's all make hay.
- Strom 12y agoThis is a bit naive. Your ISP peering bandwidth isn't the complete sum of all its customer promised bandwidth. You have access to bursts of high bandwidth precisely because most of the time our internet connections are idle. Yes, this "burst" can actually be sustained 24/7 by some number of people, but not at a mass scale.
- rosser 12y agoAt first thought, chaffing seems like a pretty good idea, but isn't it vulnerable to analysis? By which I mean, if the spooks can demonstrate (based on tracking identifiable markers in your cookies or some other means) that you're at your office, shouldn't they be able to effectively ignore any traffic from your home internet connection? Maybe if we were all running Tor exit nodes or something, but naïve chaffing sounds pretty ... well, naïve.
- p01926 12y agoObviously this "chaff bot" will need to copy your user agent string and tracking cookies. It'd also need to behave exactly like a web browser in every way that can be detected. But is chaffing itself a good idea?
- chippy 12y agomixing the chaff from other users (somehow) would be even better. I seem to recall an early experiment that did this.
- Omniusaspirer 12y agoTrackmenot does this on some level, I'm using it currently to clutter up my search data. Doesn't matter much if it's just me, but if enough people use it then it's at least fighting back in some small way.
- anonbanker 12y agoReplying as breadcrumbs so I can reference this post later. Going to implement this on my VPN.
- honeybooboo123 12y agoCan the EFF be that blind, or are they spewing propaganda? They seem to think that the NSA is not spying on Americans - just because they say so, of course - even though that's a completely ridiculous notion. Which one is a bigger threat to the US rulers: other countries (whose militaries are puny compared to America's), or the 330 million people whose acceptance their rule depends on? They talk about legal "protections" for the American people, even though the surveillance is clearly unconstitutional, which means even the supposedly most sacrosanct law of the land has not prevented it. Why would any other laws? There's other stuff too, but I can't be bothered. Not many people will see this anyway.
- jimktrains2 12y agoAs software developers, we can help by building easier-to-use frontends. For instance, GPG is a great program, but the front end is lacking a bit the last time I used it. We can also build systems designed from the beginning to think about users privacy and data security.
- api 12y agoLast I checked there isn't even a good UI to perform simple file encryption on most OSes. It's awful. There are huge holes in the market. I would pay for that.
- sarciszewski 12y agoTalk to @adamcaudill on Twitter -- he's working on an encrypting camera app (photos are decrypted offline) and would probably love to collaborate on, e.g. frontends for gnupg or reop.
- jbob2000 12y agoThat's because simple file encryption is really hard, and when it works well, you don't even notice that it's working. Encryption is completely invisible to common people. It's not like locking your money in a safe, where you can feel the heaviness of the door and hear the clank of the lock.
- api 12y ago"It's not like locking your money in a safe, where you can feel the heaviness of the door and hear the clank of the lock." I think the perfect is being the enemy of the good here. Personally I would pay for a really good UI for doing that -- just encrypting files so I can stash them safely in cloud storage or transfer really sensitive stuff. I'd love to be able to right-click and encrypt/decrypt with a GPG public key or symmetric passphrase. I have full disk encryption, but that's very coarse-grained. Unlock the machine and it's defeated. My hack right now is to use encrypted OS X .sparseimage files, but that's OS-specific and clunky. I also have these scripts: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/zerotier/ZeroTierOne/master/attic/encrypt https://raw.githubusercontent.com/zerotier/ZeroTierOne/maste... https://raw.githubusercontent.com/zerotier/ZeroTierOne/master/attic/decrypt https://raw.githubusercontent.com/zerotier/ZeroTierOne/maste... They kind of suck but do the job in a platform-independent way. They could be made slightly better by trying to secure-erase the original source file, etc., but they work. The other problem with invisible omnipresent encryption is that it lacks a quality that I call "situational awareness." I like knowing that something has in fact been encrypted. Seeing a file extension change, like gzipping a file, tells me that yes in fact something has happened. A classic example I use of poor situational awareness in security is IPSec encryption setup between two boxes. The only way I know of to verify that the traffic is actually encrypted is to tcpdump the raw interface and look. The (piss-poor) IPSec tools do not really tell you this in a non-confusing straightforward way.
- fidotron 12y agoAll this ignores the contradiction between the privacy invasion business model and privacy needs. As long as you have major tech companies (most obviously Facebook and Google) reliant on being able to read the communication of their users then you're going to by consequence enable an NSA or similar to intercept all the messages. There isn't a legislative answer to this problem, yet there are theoretical technical answers, but these do not fit with the business models in use today. To fix the problem the market dynamics will have to change.
- gojomo 12y agoWhile Facebook & Google get a marginal benefit from being able to read user-to-user communications, I doubt they're "reliant" on that. They have plenty of other explicitly-public, or intentionally-shared, signals to target their ads. For example, for now the only thing Google is absolutely 'reliant' on is seeing the queries you send their search engine.
- rosser 12y ago...or the contents of your emails in ... you know, gmail.
- gojomo 12y agoGoogle is not reliant on Gmail revenues, or Gmail-originated profiling. The only thing Google is reliant upon is search AdWords.
- rosser 12y agoWait, so the standard by which we're deciding whether or not we're cool with unaccountable private entities reading our personal communications for their own (again, unaccountable) ends is whether or not they're "reliant" on it?
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago
- chatmasta 12y agoAs long as you can surveil one person, you can surveil seven billion people. Computers automate processes. As processes digitize, they become automated. The NSA digitized their surveillance process, and automated it. At that point, they could surveil one person via software, so why not scale it? Should we accept mass surveillance, like nuclear weapons, as inevitable? If so, it should follow that we should adopt a "mutually assured destruction" inspired doctrine, whereby multiple countries agree on the limits of surveillance. Perhaps the world would be more comfortable if constantly surveiled, but wholly informed. Who has my data? What have they done with it? Can I see it? Or maybe, everybody should be able to surveil everybody. True openness, and therefore predictable accountability.
- svachalek 12y agoDavid Brin explored this back in 1998: http://www.davidbrin.com/transparentsociety1.html http://www.davidbrin.com/transparentsociety1.html
- pfraze 12y agogood thoughts, i'd like to offer my counters > Should we accept mass surveillance, like nuclear weapons, as inevitable? If so, it should follow that we should adopt a "mutually assured destruction" inspired doctrine, whereby multiple countries agree on the limits of surveillance. it may be, but the MAD analogy doesn't hold up because nuclear weapons have immediate and distinct effects. surveillance is hard to witness and hard to measure. MAD also uses the threat of nuclear use to keep other parties in check, while surveillance uses, what, the guarantee of use? it doesnt match up. > Perhaps the world would be more comfortable if constantly surveiled, but wholly informed. Who has my data? What have they done with it? Can I see it? i don't see that as particularly feasible > Or maybe, everybody should be able to surveil everybody. True openness, and therefore predictable accountability. perhaps we may move toward enlightenment about one another's secrets someday, but i'm personally skeptical of that path as a solution to surveillance. secrets act as a stabilizing force. keeping something unpleasant can keep people in harmony. if the shock of reveal is great enough, it can break down relationships and the institutions they form, and i wouldn't want to risk doing that en masse. uncovering the unpleasant truths make us stronger, but we have to recognize that it's a process, and not all wounds should be opened at once. but that's not wholly relevant anyway, because there wouldnt be a perfect symmetrical reveal of information. it would be a gradual and asymmetric reveal, which means that the holders of the information could use it to their advantage. you'd end up with a class of people who hold the secrets that could manipulate the other classes. it's not a pretty idea for believers in equitable society.
- shit_parade 12y ago>The entity that’s conducting the most extreme and far-reaching surveillance against most of the world’s communications—the National Security Agency—is bound by United States law. This seems clearly wrong -- when people like clapper can essentially lie under oath to congress and not suffer any legal consequences it is rather dubious to claim the NSA is bound by US law. There are increasingly 'secret' courts, 'secret' laws, 'secret' budgets, 'secret' legal memos, etc etc, why would you begin your game plan with stating something so clearly incorrect. The reason we know much about what is happening is because of whistle blowers, and much of these people are either in hiding, on the run, dead, or being jailed by the US government. The eff is out of touch with reality if they truly believe the NSA is beholden to the law instead of those controlling and using it as they see fit.
- tomrod 12y ago> why would you begin your game plan with stating something so clearly incorrect Because once Congress publicly disavows the NSAs actions, I suspect then working against Congress would result in rogue status.
- debacle 12y agoThe NSA has the browsing history in hand of every congresscritter and hopeful congresscritter, phone records, travel records, IRS statements, etc. It's not unbelievable that they would use this information to buy or bury an elected official.
- jMyles 12y agoIt's tough to believe they wouldn't. And don't.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoGetting caught blackmailing a Congressman would be very, very bad for them. It's far more likely that money from a secret budget ends up in the campaign fund of friendly politicians, or that politicians who do what they want end up with lucrative consulting work after they leave office, much as it is with other industries. But what do you propose to do about it either way? Go join Lawrence Lessig's anti-corruption campaign. In the meantime it's not like positive change is impossible, it's just harder than it ought to be.
- aluhut 12y agoEasy to handle and free encryption software everywhere it's needed would be a huge start.
- ck2 12y agoWe can't even get torture officially condemned and prosecuted, no way in hell the government is going to stop surveillance. EFF against the government is like a kid on a bicycle against a fighter jet. Only the people can end this and unfortunately they are too busy shopping at the mall. Even worse polls show the new generation of teenagers shrug off all privacy concerns, they have been trained not to care anymore.
- fit2rule 12y agoI don't think the solution is going to be technological in nature. It can only be cultural. We absolutely need a Peace movement that can overpower the current stance of the war movement. We absolutely need to make peace. Probably the only thing that will get us out of this situation is the hardest thing - the most impossible thing - for any of us to do: defeat our enemies by becoming friends with them. We have to work harder to defeat intolerance, hatred, bigotry. These things fester, and are contagious - and they are the lynchpin of the argument being used by the powers to enact their heinous rules and laws, which enslave us all. We need a platform of peace that actually really makes peace happen. Some way of getting the rabid ideological Christian crusaders at the same table as the extremist Muslim terrorists. Some way to bring these massive differences - which are utterly arbitrary and without real substance - to the point where the human beings, on the other side of the books and vitriol, see each other and treat each other as any two humans are capable of doing - with peace, with love, and with an honest and sincere desire to see the party across the table survive, flourish, and prosper. We need to encourage people to be intolerant of intolerance. This is the biggest issue. The NSA wouldn't have any fish in the pond, if we were to gain a level of human understanding, compassion, and cooperation, between the warring factions. However, this is a difficult task. Maybe we, the human species, won't ever be up for the task. Unless challenged by something else, from elsewhere ..
- chippy 12y agoWe need peace. We cannot fight evil for peace, just as we cannot fight a war against terror. Peaceful demonstration movements are destroyed by making them fight. Its really easy to do it. Vietnam war for example, or the fight for the right to protest, or the fight against X Y or Z, or Occupy being sucked into fighting for the right to demonstrate in a public place. I am even talking about being proactive and demonstrating against evil and wrongdoing. Even famous campaigners and activists championing for what is good and against political injustices can not lead us to more peace. The only ideology really that I have come across is nonviolence. I also like the alien threat as incentive for global unity idea - it makes sense in terms of human group psychology (The Other). And I suspect that group psychology may actually make my first paragraph utterly false, as any movement, any group, any collection of humans may not be able to be peaceful. (individuals however could be...)
- romanixromanix 12y agoMost people just don't care or gave up caring. It's too cumbersome to seriously protect privacy. If friends use Whatsapp and they have my address in their phone's address book, Facebook knows it. Same with photos. And as long as NSA has access to all Google and Facebook data, it's efficient for them. Two interesting projects to mitigate this: Terms of Service; Didn't Read: https://tosdr.org/ https://tosdr.org/ Maidsafe (Distributed encrypted Internet) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RdGH40oUVDY#t=71 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RdGH40oUVDY#t=71
- fit2rule 12y agoI've always thought that the problem with the NSA behemoth is not so much that its collecting everything, on everyone, but that its the only one allowed to do anything with it. I don't think the solution is privacy. I think the solution is to make the NSA's databank available to everyone. This is just as impossible a goal, I know, as getting rid of the NSA in the first place - but hear me out. Just imagine what sort of world we would be living in if everything the NSA has been collecting and storing about our modern civilization for the last 15 years was available for anyone and everyone to access. I'd be perfectly okay with harvesting all data, everywhere, on everyone - if everyone had access to it, freely and without secrecy. I think, were this the case, people would be a lot more careful - and more importantly, aware - about the things they do and say online. The only reason this whole thing is so damaging is that its shrouded in total secrecy - I have no idea what sort of 'bad data' is in the database about me, or those around me - were I able to access this data, it wouldn't have as much of a negative effect on me, personally. I could correct it, get it removed, and so on. Teaching encryption is one thing. Teaching the value of open and honest communication is another thing entirely. Somehow, the solution to the problem of having masters and overlords who have immense power over me, is for me to have some of that power myself. If this were true for everyone - and not just an elite class of humans who have decided to rule humanity through secrecy and domination - then I think the problem would be a lot less relevant. I know as an artist, I'd sure love to be able to broadcast my art far and wide; it seems the NSA would be a perfect platform for that. Kind of like what the Internet was originally promised to be/do, before it became the playground of the corporate elite ..
- thawkins 12y agoBut its not just about "open and honest" communication, its about them also tracking behaviour, who gets to judge what is "open and honest" behaviour. Do you want somebody trawling through your search and browsing history?
- fit2rule 12y agoAs long as I know who is doing it, and where, I've got no problem with that - because then I can do something about it, like track the person down and ask them why they're doing it. But of course its not as simple as that - of course there are still nefarious no-good types out there who would use this information to their advantage - and thats exactly the problem we have with the secrecy. If I knew who was tracking me, because their activity is also open and available for scrutiny, it makes it a lot easier to do something effective in the circumstance that I disagree with their doing so; it may also help me find others who are interested in the same things as me. Its a two-edged sword.
- tptacek 12y agoAn organized, carefully executed plan to thwart global surveillance is a good thing. But EFF laid its plan out, and critiques of that plan are fair game. So: our industry has largely Google to thank for: * The development and deployment of TLS forward secrecy, a technology that has very little operational importance to big companies but that is critically important for increasing the cost of NSA surveillance. * The development and adoption of strong, modern elliptic curve cryptography in browsers (the Curve25519 CFRG recommendation has Adam Langley's name on it). * TLS certificate pinning, which Google pioneered in Chrome, which not only drastically reduces browser susceptibility to CA-based attacks on TLS but also transforms the Firefox and Chrome installed base into a worldwide anti-spoofing surveillance system. * EndToEnd, the Chrome Javascript implementation of PGP, the team for which includes Thai Duong, of BEAST, CRIME, and POODLE fame, who Google was smart enough to snap up. * Years and years of the Chrome sandbox and runtime hardening, which has significantly driven up the cost of viable browser clientsides, which are probably the most important software security weapon in NSA's arsenal. * Years and years and years of Chrome browser security work from people like Michel Zalewsky --- see things like "Notes On A Post-XSS World" for a taste of the security ideas that will be banal and commonplace 10 years from now but that people will forget Google funded. * One of the industry's best organized large-scale fuzzing and bughunting operations, shaking out hundreds and hundreds of bugs in things like video and image codecs. I think that first section in this plan could have been written more carefully. I do not see how it could have been written carefully and retain the sense of urgency that the rest of the document has. And that bothers and worries me. Hey: on the other hand, maybe Google is just as happy with it as EFF is. After all, if they're setting a high bar for themselves, all the better if a bunch of other companies are required to clear that same bar. I know a fair bit about the technical work Google is doing, but virtually nothing about EFF's motives for phrasing things they way they do.
- Alupis 12y agoThe tl;dr; game plan: 1. Pressure technology companies to harden their systems against NSA surveillance 2. Create a global movement that encourages user-side encryption 3. Encourage the creation of secure communication tools that are easier to use 4. Reform Executive Order 12333 5. Develop guiding legal principles around surveillance and privacy with the help of scholars and legal experts worldwide 6. Cultivate partners worldwide who can champion surveillance reform on the local level, and offer them support and promotion 7. Stop NSA overreach through impact litigation and new U.S. laws 8. Bring transparency to surveillance laws and practices ~~ Addendum: Laws & Presidential Orders We Need to Change * Section 215 of the Patriot Act, Known as the "Business Records" Section * Section 702 of the FISA Amendments Act * Executive Order 12333 * The Funding Hack ~~~ Related cases: Smith v. Obama [1] Jewel v. NSA [2] First Unitarian Church of Los Angeles v. NSA [3] [1] https://www.eff.org/cases/smith-v-obama https://www.eff.org/cases/smith-v-obama [2] https://www.eff.org/cases/jewel https://www.eff.org/cases/jewel [3] https://www.eff.org/cases/first-unitarian-church-los-angeles-v-nsa https://www.eff.org/cases/first-unitarian-church-los-angeles...
- tacojuan 12y ago>2. Create a global movement that encourages user-side encryption I can't even get my close friends/family to install something as simple as textsecure. :(
- ploxiln 12y agoIndeed. When CTOs and CEOs can't help but defer security fixes before anything else, since features matter now and security matters sometime later, how could the "common person" ever choose real security? They might be scared into paying someone money to make the problem go away, like personal firewall and anti-virus (which as we know makes real applications break more than they block malware from working), or they'll do something therapeutic but useless, like some people used to run defrag every day. I'm not sure exactly what will happen in the future, and besides ever bigger and more disruptive hacks, I'm sure we'll carry on somehow with sillier and sillier measures, adding layers to the ones that already don't really make sense if you think too hard. People always manage somehow.
- lazyjones 12y agoI support the EFF, but this will not help our biggest (technical) problem: we no longer own our devices and need to make uncomfortable choices to get them back - i.e. to stop using proprietary operating systems and (black-box) hardware. RMS was never as unreasonable as he seemed, he only thought things through completely and arrived at the right conclusions.
- CyberDildonics 12y agoIs an always encrypted IP standard part of this? I would think at this point public-private encrypted IP would be something that would be a huge selling point for companies. People will buy new hardware if they know it would make it more difficult for their communications to be collected.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- eblanshey 12y agoThere's no better time to get behind projects that aim to decentralize the web, which covers many of the bullet points in the EFF's list all in one go. The primary project IMO to keep an eye on is MaidSafe[0], and I'm actually quite surprised how little attention it gets from the community here. Whereas most service/companies/developers aim to build privacy/encryption into their own apps, the goal of the SAFE network is to create an internet backbone on which all apps are automatically secure, making it much easier to build secure apps for the average coder. I wrote an easy to read overview, both high level and technical, of how it works if anybody is interested: http://blanshey.com/introduction-to-maidsafe-what-it-is-how-it-works-and-how-it-compares-to-bitcoin/ http://blanshey.com/introduction-to-maidsafe-what-it-is-how-... [0] http://maidsafe.net http://maidsafe.net
- ingler 12y ago> "U.S. law and the Constitution protect American citizens and legal residents from warrantless surveillance. That means we have a very strong legal case to challenge mass surveillance conducted domestically or that sweeps in Americans’ communications." ----- The EFF is living in fantasy land. The NSA has never considered itself bound to law because it's not a creature of statutory law but came into existence by decree. > "no existing statutes control, limit, or define the signals intelligence activities of the NSA.” > Roy Banner, counsel for the NSA, 1976 [0] [0] https://www.fas.org/irp/agency/army/mipb/2012_04-owen.pdf https://www.fas.org/irp/agency/army/mipb/2012_04-owen.pdf
- gnopgnip 12y agoThis quote is out of context. The NSA deals with foreign intelligence. Generally speaking, only US citizens are protected under US law.
- ingler 12y agoLook at the Project SHAMROCK section after the quote at fas.org. US citizens haven't been protected by law for decades vis a vis SIGINT.
- superobserver 12y agoSome might find the game plan partly shared (in addition to the main angle on Snowden revelations) by Kim Dotcom and the Internet Party of New Zealand: http://kim.com http://kim.com
- nickik 12y agoFirst I want to congratulate the EFF in all the great work they do. Thank you guys. Second I want to address a problem that concerns me a lot and that I see again in this discussion. I have a huge problem with equating the facebooks and googles with the NSA. Some people make it seam as if the NSA (and simular) are the lesser or at least equall evil compared to Google, Facebook and co. I think this is madness, how can we compare companys that try to sell us ads with a organisation is sending policy and millitary forces to peoples houses all over the world and puts them in prison or even kill them. In what world are we more afraid of a company that overs us 10% of the laptop you thought about buying compared to the serious danger that the NSA posses to democracy, libery and peace. I am unable to understand this position, I would rather have 100 Googles and 100 Facebooks then 1 NSA and I live in a country thta is in frindly relations with the US, if it were otherwise I would rather have 1000 Googles or Facebooks. I dont want to come accross a defender of big buissness, in a parallel world where there is no NSA and no mass government survallance I would happly join the facebook bashing. I would happly lament the fact that gmail has centralised your email to much. But in this world, those are things that I dont think about a lot, or rather I think about it only in the context of the NSA. Some people argue that its the fault of Google and Facebook that the internet is centralised and this makes the internet easy meat for the NSA, they then go on to argue that Google and Facebook are basiclly just as bad as the NSA because they helped in the process. This kind of argumentation relies on many assumtion that are, at least in my mind, not at all valid. First, you assume that the internet would not be centralised without these companys. This is not at all clear, we see a again and again that centralisation has benefits for many users and for the companys itself. It is simply good buissness to gather data, every startup does it and every big company does it too. Any company that does not do so is very likly not going to be the next Google or Facebook. I love OpenWispherSystem and use there products but they are not going to be the next Google. Second, you assume that centralisation allways makes syping easier and I question this too. Compared to a cyper punk future of peer-to-peer darknet full crypto, onion routing, forward secret (add more crypto buzzwords) this is of course the case but compared to the likly alternative its not that bad. Even for very good technical people like the people in this forum it is hard and very time consuming to run there own mail servers, and use PGP. The likly alternative is people running a non updated box of a old OS with old tools that are bound together by handnitted crypto (if any). We have learned from XP, IE6 and things like that that you simply can not really on common people to keep up to date with features, let alone security. Without getting a hole lot better at OpenSource and peer-to-peer we will not create a digital revolution. I am still up for trying and will help where I can to make that future happen eventually and I hope you will do so to. But in the mean time we have Google and Facebook. While I do not expect much from the morality (I do expect a little) I hope they are at least smart enougth to protect there own data from the government and the competition. Facebook is using fantastic crypto in Whatsapp, Google has started to use better encryption internally and is fighing on many other fronts. These technical changes will hurt the NSA, this is afterall a fight on economics (cost/benefit of mass survaillance) and 600 million encrypted chat users will cost the NSA, even if they can get at the data by hacking every single smartphone on the planet. The worst things Google or Facebook could do to me would be unpleasent, the worst thing that the NSA could do is hard to even imagen. The NSA and secret services like it are amung the biggest danger to our freedoms and it does not matter on what side of the politcal spectrum you are, guns are at risk as much as healthcare. tl;dr: So lets first worry about evil goverment that have SWAT teams and drones and then worry about to much ads.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zmmmmm 12y agoOne of the most important things that could be done is for browser vendors to change their approach to self signed certificates. At the moment it looks like a disaster when you visit a site with a self signed certificate, and certainly no reputable business would do it. However given what we know about how compromised certificate authorities are likely to be, I actually now consider a self-signed certificate as more private than one signed by a CA. I would much rather everyone signed their own certs and we use pinning and other, more decentralised strategies to track authentic certs than any kind of centralised model.
- desireco42 12y agoI am genuinely impressed with first few paragraphs, where they explain motivation for doing this, rarely in todays world you will see such noble intentions, I think this is one of the most beautiful things I read in a long time.
- hamoid 12y agoWould having a logo for privacy be a good idea? A logo we can place in all our websites? Together with some kind of sentence, like "I support privacy", or "healthy minds need privacy", or "privacy is a human need", or something better you can come up with? Is there one already?
- gitspirit 12y agoI've run search on this page for 'education' and I've not got a result. Education, Education and Education (as Location, location, location for real-estate). Worth repeating: E D U C A T I O N is the game!