6 ms·
Meant to Keep Mosquitos Out, Nets Are Used to Haul Fish In
- amelius 12y agoSolution: besides giving out mosquito nets, also give out fishing nets...
- wanderingstan 12y agoGiving out proper fishing nets would also enable over-fishing, but this could be the lesser of two evils. It reminds me of the calculus around giving addicts clean needles: it feels wrong to enable a destructive and illegal behavior, but the alternative is a net net worse outcome. (Pun intended.)
- brudgers 12y agoOver-fishing using nets is done on an industrial scale backed by capital from wealthy industrial and post-industrial economies. The family that fishes in the swamp is not the critical actor.
- cpwright 12y agoThe proper fishing nets won't have nearly the amount of bycatch as the malaria net used for fishing. The holes in the malaria net are small enough that mosquitos can't make it through. Holes in a fishing net are far larger, so will let very small fish or other creatures through.
- ipsin 12y agoThe article makes it pretty clear that overfishing is likely to wipe out local fish populations.
- brudgers 12y agoAs opposed to entire marine fisheries destroyed by industrialized fishing that puts tins of tuna on grocery shelves.
- sigzero 12y agoWhich has nothing to do with the article.
- schiffern 12y agoI beg to differ. The economic principles underlying both are the same — technology pushed the supply curve too far to the left, past the critical regeneration threshold (which must exist for any self-renewing resource). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HMmChiLZZHg#t=27m53s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HMmChiLZZHg#t=27m53s
- Zancarius 12y agoThe concern here isn't so much about fishing (though it may be a problem) as much as it is what the nets are treated with, which might affect fish populations, other species, and the very humans they're intended to protect. The article explicitly states that permethrin is highly toxic to cold-blooded animals, fish in particular, and could over-stress local populations. If the fish they don't catch die from exposure to insecticides, the situation is liable to get much worse. I understand why the nets were treated with insecticide, but it seems a bit foolhardy to have done so when there was a possibility the nets might not be used for their intended purpose. Although I suspect no one involved considered such a possibility, or if they did that it wouldn't be nearly as wide spread. I think this represents one of the major problems with our current means of providing foreign aid. Although well-meaning, providing mosquito nets to people in effort to protect them from a disease that is likely to kill them versus starving to death (which definitely will kill them), the people are going to address their immediate concerns first. I don't know what the solution is, but it seems that just attacking one particular problem at a time isn't working. I agree with other comments here that eliminating malaria probably means dealing with food stability and access to clean water first and foremost, then addressing malaria (in parallel, possibly). I respect the organizations that are trying to help, but the solutions don't come easily. But then you also have the other problem that these are impoverished, sometimes war-torn areas that have threats even beyond the scope of access to food and water...
- indrax 12y agoThis reminds me of a recent article about an abandoned flooded mall. Fish were added to control the mosquito population. So what happens to the mosquitoes when the fish population drops?
- Ygg2 12y agoThat's a non solution. Giving them nets and fishing nets will only make then sell the fishing nets and using the mosquito nets for their fishing needs. One solution is to look for another solution. Like a genetically modified mosquito that is inhospitable to malaria and outcompetes regular mosquito. Other is to try stabilizing the region.
- maaku 12y agoOr destroy all mosquitoes.
- DanBC 12y agoYou don't even need to do that. It's only one species of mosquito that is a problem.
- baddox 12y agoThe people who are currently giving starving people mosquito nets, and expressing surprise that they use them to get food, probably shouldn't try to stabilize the region economically, politically, or, heaven forbid, militarily.
- pvaldes 12y agoOther could be to create more faible mosquito nets that break easily under the forces used to fish, thus being useless as fishnets.
- hristov 12y agoThe solution is to make nets weaker so they break if used for fishing. You do not need a strong net for mosquitoes but you do need one for fishing. Also, maybe if there is real hunger provide food relief as well.
- Havoc 12y agoWelcome to Africa - one step forward two steps back.
- perlgeek 12y agoWelcome to the wealthy nation's interactions with Africa. To think "we" can tell people what problem they should solve (Malaria) when not even their food supply is secured, that's just hubris. Knowing Maslow's hierarchy of needs, it's Physiological needs (food) vs Safety needs (Malaria protection). And the former are more basic, so expecting anything else shows little foresight (easy to say in hindsight, I know).
- frozenport 12y agoWe solved other diseases without solving the food problem.
- erroneousfunk 12y agoYes, but you couldn't eat the vaccinations. This particular problem is caused by the safety solution also, accidentally, doubling as a means to procure food.
- lumpypua 12y agoWe need to work on both simultaneously, if only for our own safety. The eradication of smallpox was a major success in the 20th century and treating it in Africa was instrumental. It does no good to try and eliminate dangerous diseases if we leave reservoirs, just because those populations are not food secure. Obviously malaria has its own transmission dynamic that doesn't directly apply here, but for infectious disease generally (eg. ebola) African safety needs are an important part of our own safety.
- evanpw 12y agoFrom the article: "experts say that the vast majority of mosquito nets are used exactly the way they were intended". There's also good evidence that they work: http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/insecticide-treated-nets http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/ins.... If you don't buy that, then GiveWell's #2 charity just hands out cash to poor people in Africa. Those guys know what they're doing.
- scott_ci 12y agoI've heard public health people talk about the problem of giving away nets for free before, and that charging some amount of money seems to improve usage. It may be more than just the decision between starving and malaria, but also some psychology involved with getting free things.
- jsnathan 12y agoIt might improve usage per household which agrees to pay for the nets, but what about the people who refuse to buy them? Couldn't giving them out for free increase coverage even if the average usage is lower?
- schiffern 12y agoHow about… address the food insecurity first? The symptom is that people are misusing nets. The problem is that they have no sustainable food system.
- autokad 12y agoand then they have more people and need more food, need more support for their ecosystem because of the exploding population is destroying it, and now you have uneducated people so they need education assistance, schools etc, etc etc. it seems like it would never end
- schiffern 12y agoAny truly sustainable solution must address all these issues. You've hit on the fundamental challenge of complex systems — it's the interactions between components that determines the behavior, not the components themselves. I would strongly recommend the video I linked elsewhere in this thread, if only as a "crash course" in systems thinking. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HMmChiLZZHg#t=27m53s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HMmChiLZZHg#t=27m53s
- vinceguidry 12y agoThat turns out to be surprisingly hard to do as well. You can't just ship free food in, strongmen will capture it and put it to their own use. Nets, being less fungible in their value, are ultimately less likely to be misused.
- cmsmith 12y agoIt seems like there is an opportunity here for a mosquito net that won't work as a fishing net. Could a finer mesh be air-permeable enough but not water-permeable? Or a fabric which degrades in strength when saturated with water?
- nn3 12y agoOr just dissolves itself when soaked for too long. I'm sure there are technical solutions to this. Of course the problems first has to be acknowledged.
- baddox 12y agoThat's one way to look at it, I suppose, although what first occurred to me is that it seems like there is an opportunity here for purpose-built fishing nets, or another way to starving people to feed themselves.
- sighsighsigh 12y agoSigh. SIGH. How dare our charity be used for practicalities! We must over-engineer harder! Only our brilliance can save poor, poor Africa! Same nonsense I've been reading about since the 1800s. The Africans figured out how to deal with public health a long, long time ago: spread your villages and use air and time to isolate outbreaks. This has worked for longer than human history has been recorded. And this technique has survived countless imperial collapses as well. We simply wish to mold Africa into an urban scheme because we don't know how to bring "progress" without packing millions of people into city blocks. That causes disease spreading, which puts diminishing returns on the urban scheme. There's one city in Africa who loses about 1% GDP from city-based malaria alone. If you want to over architect something, the net isn't the problem. Learn to engage in feel-good progressivism without the dependency of industrial organization models. Billions of dollars to whoever figures it out first.
- themodelplumber 12y agoAs many problems as this particular net situation brings, it would be foolish to step back and blame first world efforts. Further education is sorely needed. As education seeps into these system, corruption and foolish decisions are eventually called to account. Africa is not a monolithic problem with identical inputs and outputs everywhere. Assistance from first-world countries does actually make a difference, and comes in many, many forms, from medical care to microloans to security assistance and psychological trauma support.
- nostromo 12y agoSometimes I feel that the western fascination with Malaria is a little misplaced. Actual Africans speak about Malaria like we speak about Influenza: a treatable illness that only kills the very old and very young. Actually Flu and Malaria kill roughly about the same number of people globally each year. Imagine if African billionaires showed up on our shores one day and started handing out respirators and face masks to Americans. "Just everyone wear these all winter and you won't catch the flu! So many lives would be saved!" We might use them to go fishing as well.
- smtddr 12y agoAs someone who is an American-born-Nigerian and my wife, born and raised in Nigeria, I can confirm this. My wife got malaria all the time in Nigeria, it was like a really bad cold or a flu in America. You get over it and move on. Only if your immune system is already compromised in some other way like old age or whatever malaria isn't really that big a deal among those who were strong and healthy before getting it. Instead of trying to stop malaria, focus on how they can get food. If they're well fed and strong/healthy, the malaria won't kill 'em just like it didn't kill my wife or any of her 5 siblings, or her university classmates, or my parents, or their siblings, etc. Now, there are those in Africa who don't have plenty to eat and/or have stressful daily lives that prevent getting a couple of days of rest. That is what allows malaria to kill so many. Just like the flu in America would kill a whole lot more often if there was a lack of food or inability to get consecutive days of rest.
- Mikeb85 12y agoYeah, my brother in law got Malaria in another tropical country, like a bad flu, recovered pretty quick. Certainly not as scary as people make it out to be (unless you're already in bad shape). One also has to remember the epidemic flu viruses that killed millions in the west in past centuries, yet now we barely care enough to get flu shots.
- sebastianavina 12y agobut, but, we are solving world problems!
- Luyt 12y agoWould this be a solution to the problem? -> Make mosquito nets that disintegrate when soaked in water.
- backlava 12y agoRain?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- swatow 12y agoI studied health economics a bit, and the article does a really good job of covering all the bases. This really isn't a question that can be answered with grand theories e.g. "Just give them money", "Africa needs low tech solutions" or "White people always create more problems" (actually the first theory might be true, I just haven't seen much specific evidence regarding malaria). A summary of the background facts are - Malaria is a big problem. - Mosquito nets prevent malaria - It's hard to get people to use mosquito nets. I think the key takeaways from the article are that (1) the proponents of mosquito nets aren't convinced that the scale of this problem is big enough to offset the overall positive effect of free mosquito nets. But (2) critics of mosquito nets suspect that proponents have too much psychologically (and financially?) invested in the mosquito net solution to consider alternatives. E.g. this interesting quote: >Dr. Lehman, the American physician on Lake Tanganyika, wonders if there might be better malaria solutions for waterside communities. Specially treated wall coverings? Custom-fit window screens? “Why is this question not being asked?” she said, a bit exasperated. “Is it that we don’t really want to know the answer?”
- intopieces 12y ago"The leading mosquito net manufacturers insist that their products are not dangerous. Still, many nets are labeled: 'Do not wash in a lake or a river.'" I'm interested to know what language this label was written in. Bemba? Nyanja? Moreover, where did the manufacturers intend for Zambians to wash the nets?
- sangnoir 12y agoGenerally nets are not supposed to be washed with untreated water (doing so will wash away the infused chemicals). If you are going to wash the net, you are supposed to wash it in a bucket or any small container with treated water to maintain potency.
- qj4714 12y agoI have travelled throughout Africa and looked at malaria activities and based on my experience using malaria nets for fishing is purely anecdotal. It is obviously not a good thing, but it is not a pervasive thing. Of interest, people also use malaria nets for gardening. They are used as a means to keeps bugs out of crops. The more complicated issue is whether people are using the nets properly. It takes discipline to correctly put the net over your body the entire night and sleep under it.