25 ms·
The rise of fake engine noise
- jrochkind1 12y agoYou'd think some people would want to opt out of the fake/amplified engine noise, so they can drive in peace, listen to their stereo without interference, etc. but i guess making the amplified/fake engine noise an option would defeat the purpose.
- jrs235 12y agoI can see it now: Added option - reduced engine noise $500. Charging the buyer a one time fee to "disconnect a wire".
- click170 12y agoWhich will be illegal to disconnect yourself.
- mutagen 12y agoDMCA violation!
- cozuya 12y agoI see you're a BMW owner.
- Aissen 12y agoDon't worry, it won't be disconnect a wire, but change a bit in the compute unit and make sure the compute unit code and data are cryptographically signed and that its signature is verified by all other compute units so that you may not even start the engine should you decide to alter it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kw71 12y agoIs this article about engine or exhaust noise? I prefer quiet exhausts, and it's nice to hear the engine itself sometimes when I deliberately select too low a gear. I look at loud exhausts with disdain, and think they show childishness, insecurity or narcissism.
- Hortinstein 12y agoi read this and I want a new car so I can hack the acceleration sounds from Elite: Dangerous into my car. That games sounds design is incredible, here is a quick clip featuring some space acceleration: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DqIVbT6v5j0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DqIVbT6v5j0
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- georgeecollins 12y agoI hate the idea of a fake engine noise, but I drive a manual transmission and I know I use my ears a lot to know when to shift.
- scroy 12y agoFrom what I've read, that wouldn't be relevant for an electric vehicle, since there is no transmission. Or that might only be for the Tesla.
- zyxley 12y agoLiterally the entire reason for the transmission for a combustion engine is to make the relatively high minimum speed of an internal combustion work for lower road speeds, with the pleasant side effect of increasing torque at low speed. Electric motors have no need for one, because they have both variable speeds and generally tremendous amounts of torque to start with.
- Gracana 12y agoElectric motors tend to have wide useable rpm ranges, but their efficiency varies across the range, so a transmission is still useful. Scroll 2/3 of the way down this page to see a representative brushless DC motor performance curve, for example: http://www.johnsonelectric.com/en/resources-for-engineers/automotive-applications/motion-technology/ec-motor-brushless.html http://www.johnsonelectric.com/en/resources-for-engineers/au...
- mikeash 12y agoAC induction motors (typically what's used in electric cars) have a pretty flat efficiency curve. For example: http://powerelectronics.com/motion-systems/motors-efficiency-and-adjustable-speed-drives http://powerelectronics.com/motion-systems/motors-efficiency... There would be some minor efficiency gains from having multiple gears, but it's probably small enough that it would be hard to overcome the extra losses from having a more complex transmission. Note that technically electric cars do have a transmission. The motor wants to spin much faster than the tires, so you want a reduction gear to let them both live in the ranges where they're happy. It's a single-gear transmission, though, on every electric car I'm aware of.
- 13 12y agoAt some point the engine noise just becomes completely arbitrary. Avertisers will buy out your engine noise sounds, as you pass by in your Telsa furniture warehouse salesmen will scream from the engine compartment.
- zemvpferreira 12y agoEerily reminds me of "sales pitch", the Philip K Dick story where advertisers hijack your thoughts while you're commuting: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sales_Pitch_(short_story) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sales_Pitch_(short_story)
- Semiapies 12y agoNot quite the same thing, but related: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n17B_uFF4cA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n17B_uFF4cA
- upofadown 12y ago>Federal safety officials expect to finalize rules later this year requiring all hybrid and electric cars to play fake engine sounds to alert passersby, a change that experts estimate could prevent thousands of pedestrian and cyclist injuries. Yeah, because those pedestrian and cyclists should be responsible for staying out of the way of badly driven cars... Just think how safe things would be if we cranked things up so loud that drivers could hear other cars.
- Mithaldu 12y agoThe worst part about that is that car noise is an actual ecological and "quality of life" threat, combated in many places by noise walls built around roads. Forcing cars to be loud is the worst possible decision that could be made.
- Sir_Substance 12y agoThe flip side is that modern cars can accelerate from the 5kph that they exit their driveway at to 50kph with no noticeable noise. I have almost been run over this way. Look to the left, no cars on the road, look to the right, no cars, look back to the left JESUS CHRIST. Hopefully automatic pedestrian detection will become standard in the next few years, but in the mean time I need to be able to hear your high speed death-ram when I'm not facing it. Perfectly happy for it to be something other than simulated engine noise, but I need an audible cue.
- abecedarius 12y agoI'm hard of hearing, and to first order I cannot ever hold a conversation in public in a city: outside it's cars, inside it's crowds and music. Once upon a time I looked forward to electric cars taking over; now I expect this regulation to persist long after there are good other solutions for safety.
- Coincoin 12y agoAlso, companies will try to differentiate their brand using this fake sound. So we will go from a mostly-bassy-white-but-still-annoying ICE noise to very specific and recognizable frequencies and tones that will make a misophonia sufferer want to kill themself.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- alricb 12y agoOn the Renault Clio, you can already choose the kind of engine noise you want from a menu.
- jameshart 12y agoThey could monetize that with microtransactions. 99c to download and install "1968 Ferrari Dino" or "Anakin's Podracer".
- JetSpiegel 12y agoSebulba for the whales, 100€
- jcromartie 12y agoNoise is just wasted energy that could be doing useful work unless, of course, you actually want the noise (like in a musical instrument). This is a really weird trend.
- meric 12y agoThere will be a set of circumstances where you will be resorting to beeps to alert pedestrians without engine noise. Time spent to contemplate whether to beep or not constantly may also be wasted time.
- derefr 12y agoLong before everyone has driverless cars—and not long after cars are silent enough for this sort of thing to matter—we'll have cars that are at least smart enough to know when there are pedestrians nearby and beep at them. (Or possibly even only play engine noise when approaching them.)
- eru 12y agoThe power in noise is actually fairly low. Like single digit watts low, for deafening noise.
- ars 12y agoYou are only looking at the energy in the noise itself. But to make that noise there is a ton of wasted energy in vibration, friction from gears, etc. Noise is a symptom of "slop" in an engine. It might be unavoidable, but it's still a symptom of wasted energy.
- eru 12y agoOh, definitely. Noise is often a symptom of wasted energy in a mechanical process. And even producing noise with a speaker is rather inefficient. You need hundreds of Watt input for single digit Watt output in the interesting frequencies.
- 12y ago
- baldeagle 12y agoI drive a Leaf and a Volt, both technically electric cars. The sprinting power of an electric is pretty good, I often take modded civics off the line (stoplight) in the Leaf; the point being that electric cars can quickly move to a spot you don't anticipate them. The Volt has a 'pedestrian warning horn' that, when engaged by the driver, gently and rapidly beeps the horn to draw attention to the Volt. Since it is engaged by the driver, however; it does little if the driver isn't paying attention. As a cyclist, I enjoy having good situational awareness, and electric cars can definitely be surprising when they pass you. Overall, though I enjoy the super quiet ride, I think we should require some warning noise (engine noise seems like a nice option) to alert other to the oncoming car. It makes it safer for the driver because people are less likely to do something unexpected, and safer for the other people because they have better situational awareness. Perhaps when automated car drivers are the norm, we can move to silent cars; since they will be more vigilant than a person could ever be.
- analog31 12y ago>>> As a cyclist, I enjoy having good situational awareness, and electric cars can definitely be surprising when they pass you. The car could have a bell and "on your left" speaker. ;-)
- maaku 12y agoA revving engine would be less disruptive. It's a noise that most of us filter out, except those in situations which make them on alert for oncoming traffic, e.g. pedestrians and cyclists.
- analog31 12y agoQuite true. Also, my brain reacts to "on your left" by assuming that I can let my guard down, which would be the wrong reaction if it's a car.
- atonse 12y agoThis seems like the perfect use for something like a mini LIDAR you can mount on a bike that detects a car behind you and just lights up a couple of LEDs on the handlebars.
- jloughry 12y agoI want the Jetsons' car sound. My bother wants a Star Wars TIE fighter and my father in law would like the sound of a B-17, please.
- Semiapies 12y agoI've been telling people I want the Jetsons sound ever since I got a Prius. I can do without piping it into the cabin, though.
- maaku 12y agoI've always wanted the hovercar sound from Blade Runner, but I think I've found a new favorite with the TIE fighter :)
- ryanhuff 12y agoIt wouldn't sound so appealing to the driver without the Doppler effect applied.
- maaku 12y agoMaybe combine with the sensors of a driverless car -- anytime some jerk is approaching from behind at a reckless speed, play the TIE fighter noise adjusted to the circumstances of his relative speed and approach vector. You'll hear the Doppler as he overtakes and then cuts you off. If you're going to pipe engine noise into the compartment, at least make it useful.
- userbinator 12y agoI personally like the sound of a 2-stroke diesel - one of the types of engines that died out due to their much higher emissions: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mkH9QRaQJM0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mkH9QRaQJM0
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kylec 12y agoI have no problem with manufacturers including fake engine noise as a feature as long as it can be disabled by the customer.
- e40 12y agoPerhaps it should just be used when a pedestrian is near? It's bad enough worrying about cars that are making legal maneuvers, but when an electric car doesn't follow the rules, it's that much more dangerous.
- kylec 12y agoI think you might misunderstand the nature of the artificial sounds mentioned in this article. It's not talking about electric cars making noise for the benefit of pedestrians (although that does get a cursory mention), it's talking about manufacturers of pumping artificial car noises into the cabins of cars like the Ford Mustang and the BMW M5 for the enjoyment of the occupants of the vehicle.
- faster 12y agoThis reminds me of Kornbluth's story 'The Marching Morons' where cars are made noisy but slow so the morons will be stimulated but safe.
- tibbon 12y agoWhile maybe it's silly to do it electronically, thousands of people switch out the exhausts on their cars/motorcycles not often for increases in performance... but to have a different sound. Doing it electronically is new, but the concept of wanting a more 'powerful' sounding engine isn't.
- Gracana 12y agoThat's still derided by enthusiasts when it's taken to extremes, for instance a loud exhaust on an economy car fools no-one and will draw negative attention from most people. But below trying-too-hard territory, it is an authentic-feeling unleashing of your vehicle's inner beast, which is something the sound effects system will never be.
- transfire 12y ago"Federal safety officials expect to finalize rules later this year requiring all hybrid and electric cars to play fake engine sounds to alert passersby, a change that experts estimate could prevent thousands of pedestrian and cyclist injuries." My guess is that the main force behind this law is Big Oil using their lobbyists to slow the adoption of electric vehicles. If they were really concerned about pedestrians being hit by cars it would be illegal to wear headphones while walking. Instead of adding noise, which we already have too much of (I can hear cars on roads a mile away from my house) how about they require cars to send out a signal that an inexpensive device can pick up and thus locate the car. That way any pedestrian can actually see where all the cars are around them. I bet that kind of proactive action would have much better results then depending on people's inadvertent attention to background noise.
- noonespecial 12y ago100 years from now cars will still make a vestigial sound that is simply taken for granted and not really considered until some wise-ass at a party starts in "Funny story..."
- analog31 12y agoWe will have to explain the origin of the sound coming out of our car speakers to our kids, like we have to explain the floppy disk icon for saving a file.
- wanderingstan 12y agoA friend's young daughter asked him why the phone made a "funny sound" when taking a picture. She's never encountered a film camera or heard a real shutter click before.
- cbd1984 12y agoTo be fair, someone who has a lot of experience with film cameras could legitimately ask the same question. Why the hell would a completely different technology ape the noises of a previous generation?
- anvandare 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skeuomorph http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skeuomorph I guess in this case (with sound) it would be called skeuophone.
- lmm 12y agoIt's also that some countries legally required digital cameras to make noises when taking photos, to make surreptitious photography impossible.
- webwielder 12y agoThe phrase "the rise of" is really being abused these days.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoThis is hardly new. In college, we had a guest lecture from a mechanical engineer at $POPULAR_MOTORCYCLE_MANUFACTURER. He described how his team cooked up a new engine design that achieved some significant performance increase over the old design. Only problem? It didn't sound like a $POPULAR_MOTORCYCLE. The new engine was delayed for a year while they cooked up a mechanical noisemaker to adjust the sound.
- tacon 12y agoHarley Davidson filed for a sonic trademark on their engine sound back in 1994[0]. (I think it failed, not sure.) But it's pretty easy to reproduce the sound to remind people: Potato, potato, potato, potato, potato, ... [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_trademark http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_trademark
- m-i-l 12y agoAccording to http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2014-06/20/harley-davidson-electric-bike http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2014-06/20/harley-davids... they are working on a new sound for the electric Harley-Davidson.
- ska 12y agoIf I recall correctly The sound originally came from cost cutting engineering choices. Beyond the fairly tight angle (a little over 60 degrees) which gives you a asymmetric "gap" between ignitions, they simplifies the ignition timing so that it fired every stroke instead of every other stroke. So the exhaust strokes had a little ignition going on due to unspent fuel/air, giving the quieter sounds. Not a good design for efficiency but it sure gave them a distinctive idle.
- h43k3r 12y agoI don't know about other communities, but Formula 1 fans go and watch races because of sounds. The new rules in 2014 which introduced the v6 hybrid doesn't have a very loud sound and you can see the media reaction to it. Old cars used to have a v8 engine. Revs limiting is also one of the reason of low sound in 2014. If you want an comparision between the old sound and new sound, see the below mentioned youtube video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jS4Dh_EAfJI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jS4Dh_EAfJI News: http://www.theguardian.com/sport/blog/2014/mar/25/bernie-ecclestone-formula-one-cars-volume http://www.theguardian.com/sport/blog/2014/mar/25/bernie-ecc...
- snowwrestler 12y agoMy first reaction was that it's stupid and pointless. But my second reaction is that it's a clever culture hack that allows more efficient engines to make their way into typical "car lover" cars--so ultimately a good thing all around. Drivers get the sound they want, with better gas mileage, and the rest of us get cars that are quieter on the outside and produce less pollution. All enabled by a bit of digital audio.
- jacquesm 12y agoIn Amsterdam one of the bigger reasons given for the reduction of speeds on some roads is that it reduces the noise pollution. It would seem backwards to require cars to make more noise than they strictly have to. That said in mixed traffic situations it may save some lives, so essentially this proves all those guys that drove without dampers in their exhausts and bumper stickers saying 'loud pipes save lives' right after all. I think once the background noise of IC engines has disappeared and we can all hear normally again that this will pass, it's just the intermediate period when we can't hear the electric cars over the noise of the rest of the traffic.
- bri3d 12y agoMost of this noise is pumped into the car (to make the consumer happy), not out of the car. The two most common systems in use today are the car stereo (either amplifying the real engine's sound or by simply synchronizing a synthesis mechanism to the engine's load conditions) or a "sound pipe" which runs from the engine's air intake into the cabin ventilation system. This article strangely managed to conflate the two by bringing up external electronic car noisemakers, which are entirely unrelated in both purpose and execution to the noisemaking devices explained throughout the rest of the article.
- jacquesm 12y agoIf my car would make less noise I'd be happy. It totally baffles me why someone would want more useless noise in their lives rather than less if that's an option. Music is beautiful, artificial engine noise is just that: noise.
- WalterBright 12y agoThe sound of an approaching Merlin V12 at full throttle is the most thrilling sound in the world. http://www.amazon.com/Sigh-Merlin-Spitfire-Alex-Henshaw/dp/0947554831/ http://www.amazon.com/Sigh-Merlin-Spitfire-Alex-Henshaw/dp/0... "For anyone who has heard a Merlin engine on any aircraft, you will understand the title." No stereo has ever been able to reproduce that sound.
- ars 12y agoAm I the only one that associates loud noise with a weak engine? To me a powerful car just has an acceleration whine, and that's all. It's like a rocket exhaust: the "wilder" it is the weaker it is. A powerful, well tuned, rocket has a very sharp, and clean (i.e. not noisy) flame. Same with a car - if it's making a lot of noise, it's poorly tuned or designed.
- reustle 12y agoIt's not just you. It's also other people who don't have much experience with engine performance. Quieter mufflers restrict more airflow, something you don't want to do when you're trying to pass more fuel through a small engine.
- saosebastiao 12y agoI have plenty of experience with engine performance, and s/he was absolutely correct. An overly loud engine is is opening its valves too early or closing too late, and it can only be made quieter by restrictive mufflers. More modern and efficient engine designs, enabled by technologies such as variable valve timing, are quieter out of the valves because they convert more energy into motion instead of sound. Being quieter, they also have less pressure, and are less affected by muffler restrictiveness. Straight pipes might make a 1969 charger more powerful, but the effect on a modern V8 like the BMW N63 is negligible.
- lloeki 12y agoThe most dramatic example is VTEC, especially before variable cam phasing.
- jacquesm 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuned_exhaust http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuned_exhaust
- exDM69 12y agoTuned exhaust are only "in tune" at a particular rev range where the resonant frequency of the exhaust manifold is in sync with the engine combustion cycles. They're not widely used outside of racing applications, because a road vehicle has relatively wider rev range than a racing machine. And they're ridiculously loud. A vintage Cosworth DFV racing engine only "works" at 7000-9000 rpm (or 8000-10000 rpm for later models), a pre-turbo 2000s F1 car runs at 11000-15000 rpm to about 14000-20000 rpm (before rev limits were enforced). It's a really narrow band compared to a road car that can run from 1000-6000 rpm, ie. is useful on the entire rev range. All modern engines have well engineered exhaust manifolds, though, but they're not really "resonance charged" like a tuned racing exhaust.
- MRSallee 12y agoAs a motor vehicle enthusiast, I think it's important to distinguish "real noises intentionally amplified by physical audio routing" and "electronic recordings or audio processing played through speakers." I don't object to routing engine noises to the cabin to allow for a loud-feeling vehicle (without necessarily being loud to people outside the car). To me, this isn't fake. The driver experiences real engine noise, with efforts to circumvent sound-deadening that comes in modern cars. Playing recorded engine noises and/or digitally transforming sound is fake to me. It's a lie. I haven't driven a car that does this, but my guess is that it's noticeably simulated.
- witten 12y agoWhat if real engine noise is recorded in one part of the car, and then played back in the cabin?
- JetSpiegel 12y agoThe Coconut Effect will come into play.
- revisionzero 12y ago"I haven't driven a car that does this, but my guess is that it's noticeably simulated." According to the article, BMW does this, and I can say from first-hand experience in a newer model that it's not noticeably simulated.
- thedaniel 12y agoAnd folks are apparently already hacking their in-cabin sounds to sound like higher-performance models! (cf. http://jalopnik.com/someone-hacked-their-bmw-m135i-to-sound-like-an-m4-1680812516 http://jalopnik.com/someone-hacked-their-bmw-m135i-to-sound-... )
- cc438 12y agoAs neat as that sounds, I wonder what will happen when the amplifier and/or speakers start to give up the ghost in 5-10 years. I associate the word "BMW" with "wiring issues" so I'm skeptical of any system that requires unflinching reliability for the life of the car. The 2015 Mustang with the turbo 4 cylinder has a similar system but the functionality can't be deactivated or tweaked in any way. Can you imagine the frustration of listening to the acoustic meddling through a blown speaker that you can't disable? I had a Lincoln Mark VIII where the stock amplifier fried itself when I was on the highway. It blasted static with wildly varying pitch at full volume for 5 minutes before I could safely pull over and pull the fuse. It was literally maddening.
- Animats 12y agoThis may be a transient problem as people get used to new technology. It's like using Filmlook to put scratches and grain on HD video. The 2013 Lotus Evora, a series hybrid vehicle with an electric motor and a fixed gearbox, took this to the point of silliness. Not only did they provide fake engine sounds, they provided shift paddles and required the driver to shift software-simulated gears. They even provided a momentary loss of power during simulated gear shifting. (http://www.autoblog.com/2013/01/22/lotus-pondering-fake-shifting-for-evora-414e-plug-in-hybrid/ http://www.autoblog.com/2013/01/22/lotus-pondering-fake-shif...) The driver could select different sounds, or turn all this off and just let the electric motor do its thing, which yielded better acceleration. Here's a demo of all the sound options: (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H1CzoqEyACQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H1CzoqEyACQ). Options include simulated straight-6, American V-8, and V-12 engines, plus some turbine-like sounds. After some snickering from the automotive press, this feature was dropped from later models. Many electric cars already have an outside noise generator, mandated by law in the EU and US. These switch off above 25 MPH or so, so they don't contribute to freeway noise.
- joshu 12y agoThe evora isn't a hybrid. There was a hybrid version in Europe.
- gambiting 12y agoAs long as there is an option to turn all of it off, I don't have a single problem with it. It actually sounds quite cool.
- Fuxy 12y agoMy first thought to this article was where's the speaker so i can desolder it. I don't mind the gimmicks and trickery some people like the deception however I want to be able to get rid of it. However if it plays in the regular speaker system and there's no off button it will get annoying very quickly.
- Fuzzwah 12y ago
- mikepalmer 12y agoRecently drove a Tesla Model S P85D... best thing about it is that the torque is immediate and silent. Not only can you blow other cars away at lights, you can do it casually, with no noise or fuss. Car is here; put car over there. It's like piloting a UFO.
- aidenn0 12y agoThe article makes it sound like that is going to have to go away, if laws are passed to make electrics play fake engine noise.
- ferrari8608 12y agoI just wonder, why does it have to be engine noise in particular? If I saw a Tesla, Leaf, Volt, etc. I wouldn't expect any engine or exhaust noise. Beeping, maybe.
- Svip 12y agoBeeping? Like a lorry backing up? Even a low pitch beeping would become annoying pretty quickly. It should just be a sort of hum.
- ferrari8608 12y agoA hum would work just as well. I was just trying to think of a noise I would expect from an electric device, and beeping was the first thing that came to mind. It's better than coil whine at least.
- gpvos 12y agoLorries are switching to white noise instead of beeping, because humans hear that better. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fa28lIGuxq8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fa28lIGuxq8
- fizx 12y agoI'd love Tesla to license https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QdWswvLPdE0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QdWswvLPdE0
- gojomo 12y agoMy initial thought was: I wouldn't want any 'fake' noise, potentially hiding information in the (softer) real noise. But what if the noise is dynamically synthesized based on lots of info from the vehicle – perhaps not just its real noise/RPMs, but other qualities usually not usually sensed. Temperature and vibrations across multiple sampling-locations? Computed fuel-economy? Others? Maybe it's a good aural channel for real info!
- ionwake 12y agoGreat point
- mundacho 12y agoYet another example of skeuomorphism...
- cm2187 12y agoElectric cars do not pollute. We should force electric cars to emit some thick black smoke to ensure people do not get surprised! I don't know in what world these regulators live in, but in my world 80% of pedestrians are walking listening to an ipod/iphone/iwhatever. We already live in a society where pedestrians do not hear cars. But let's make sure cars remain a nuisance to anyone trying to sleep in a city!
- icebraining 12y agoI don't know in what world these regulators live in, but in my world 80% of pedestrians are walking listening to an ipod/iphone/iwhatever. We already live in a society where pedestrians do not hear cars. They've got that covered: http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2011/01/24/2_states_take_aim_at_distracted_walkers_runners/ http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2011/01/24/2_stat...
- seanp2k2 12y agoThe cars don't pollute, but odds are that the electricity they run on came from burning coal, and lithium batteries aren't exactly environmentally friendly to manufacture or recycle. The rare elements required for the electric motors and batteries aren't earth-friendly to mine or refine, either. But the car itself doesn't obviously emit any of this, so the public image it presents is great, hence their popularity. For me, wake me up when we have a diesel electric hybrid, since that's actually a very efficient tech which doesn't necessarily require any batteries and has been around for over 100 years (popular on ships / submarines / trains).
- cm2187 12y agoI don't disagree but I wasn't making a statement about the eco-friendlyness of electric cars, rather about a law defeating a technological improvement. Cars are by a large margin the largest source of nuisance in a city and for two reasons: noise and pollution. Electric cars are solving both.
- mikeash 12y agoIs that true? Tesla, for example, claims that their cars contain no rare earth elements. Lithium batteries are fairly benign in terms of the materials they use, and AC induction motors are not much more than clever arrangements of copper.
- jbu 12y agoCar ring-tones! yay! I want crazy frog on my tesla.
- iopq 12y agoWow, so I guess the movie "The Dilemma" was actually based on a true story. They do spend time optimizing engine noise!
- edpichler 12y agoI think all of this is normal. Sound is also an interface, for it connects one world to another. As in software, if you change drastically any interface, the users will not like at the first. That's why great changes needs to be done in small portions. With the past of years, these fake sounds can disappear of the industry, after the users get used to electric cars.
- duncanawoods 12y agoThere is some good discussion of synthetic car noises in Norman's "Design of everyday things". Sound is a hard to use interface that could still offer great usability advances if we work out to harness it properly. I see people asking "why not rely on the horn to alert pedestrians". The horn is the equivalent of shouting "oi" but engine sound is hugely rich source of information. We get: speed, direction, distance, acceleration, attitude (e.g. distinguish aggressive acceleration, panicked deceleration) and type of car (e.g. racer vs. town-car). Unlike a horn, we get this information at the times a horn would not be used i.e. the driver has not seen us and about to mow us down. Synthetic car noise must alert, orient but not annoy. Norman said the current United States National Highway Traffic Safety Administration spec for synthetic car noise is 250 pages long.
- oracle2025 12y agoClearly a first world problem. I especially like the "outrageous" language in the article: "built an lies", as if it was a major drama, ... honestly, who cares? ... But then I again, I do not even care to own a car.
- virmundi 12y agoFake engine noise would be nice. We drive in historical St. Augustine Fl. That is, for those who don't know, the oldest city in the US. As such it was built with extremely narrow streets. My hybrid silently rolls down the back alleys unnoticed by pedestrians. I've had to sit for 10 minutes because people would walk out in front of my car. Women with strollers. Old people talking. I've watched traditional cars. They have far less problem. There is a sense that hearing an engine means that someone wants out.
- imgabe 12y agoWe should really be taking this opportunity to make all cars sound like the cars on the Jetsons.
- JosephHatfield 12y agoWhen I first drove my 2012 VW Golf R, I was startled by how rumbly the engine sounded. Found out the sound was produced by a device called the soundaktor that was attached to the windshield frame. The device would send low-frequency vibrations to the windshield as needed to "enhance" the engine sound.
- embro 12y agoI have a Nissan Leaf so yes, there is no fake engine sound, only a sound in front at low speed to warn pedestrians. Not only I would not want a fake engine sound but I would be willing to pay more to have my car sound proof, with insulation or something, it would be quieter, colder in the summer and warmer in the winter.
- peterwwillis 12y agoConfession: I am a Luxury Ricer. When I bought my now 11-year-old Lexus, I was amazed by two aspects: how sporty and well controlled it was [for a luxury car], and how silent it was. It was literally more quiet than a Prius and it had an inline six. And I hated it. After a few months of hitting the gas and hearing nothing, I opened up the hood and ripped the tiny ram-air front inlet off the air intake. I also took apart the air box and gutted the parts that didn't affect the air filter. The result was a tiny but definitely noticeable engine roar when high-revving. It finally sounded about as mean as a Toyota Corolla. They can pry my engine noise from my cold, dead, ricer hands.
- mikeash 12y agoPriuses aren't really very quiet (at least on the inside) unless you're cruising at <60MPH or so, or decelerating. The engine gets pretty noisy when accelerating at any rate that isn't painfully slow, and the power output needed merely to maintain higher highway speeds gets pretty noisy. Noise is actually one of the big reasons I'm looking forward to switching from a Prius to a pure electric.
- joezydeco 12y agoThis reminds me of one particular TV set I was messing with recently. Pulling the HDMI cord on an input resulted in the screen showing static. Had to think about it for a second, but the static had to have been simulated by a piece of code to pretend that the input had gone missing.
- santacluster 12y agoApple had that feature, at least on my previous Air.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoWait, is that really deliberate for the DisplayPort-to-DVI adapter? I've always assumed that was some sort of serious hardware/software bug causing the coloured random noise.
- daxelrod 12y agoLots of discussion about this when JWZ noticed it on his TVs: http://www.jwz.org/blog/2012/01/snow-crash-simulated/ http://www.jwz.org/blog/2012/01/snow-crash-simulated/
- sp332 12y agoYoutube does that if a video doesn't load right.
- userbinator 12y agoThe digital TVs and monitors I've used would all show some variant of "No Signal. Check Signal Cable." in a little slowly-moving box that bounces around the screen. Perhaps some manufacturers thought that was not obvious enough to people accustomed to classic analogue TV.
- skywhopper 12y agoWeird. I would prefer the engine to be as quiet as possible. The proof of performance is in how the thing drives, not how it sounds. Tweaking the exhaust pipe on a car like the Mustang makes sense, but piping sound in through the speakers? As long as I can turn it off permanently.
- nmeofthestate 12y agoDifferent people have different preferences, and some sounds provoke an emotional response in some people. Not that weird.
- SyncTheory13 12y agoMy car has a "sound symposer" feature, and a 6-speed manual transmission. It has a tube coming off the engine, through a butterfly valve, then into the firewall of the car. The butterfly valve opens when the engine is under high load, so that the car is quiet normally, and loud if you get on it (inside). I really enjoy this feature, and have actually redirected the tubes past the valve so that the sound is always on 100% of the time. This allows me to hear the engine RPMs while shifting, instead of monitoring the RPM gauge. It also reminds me to be more mindful of fuel economy because I can hear when I'm wasting gas. I can understand a fully electronic sound being annoying - and the feature would annoy me on an electric car like a Tesla... But with the setup that mine has - I think people are just whining and that this article reeks of sensationalism. Also, it can be easily disabled in about five minutes by anybody who can watch some how-to videos on YouTube.
- whisty 12y agoHeinlein predicted this in The Cat Who Walks Through Walls
- matmann2001 12y agoI don't mind channeling the REAL engine noise into the car. Like the article said, it can be preferable to the sound of bumps in the road or whining of wind. And for car enthusiasts who actually work on their own cars, sound is a key part of detecting and diagnosing issues with the car. But they need to cut it out with the fake noise. That's just glamor and it's unnecessary. The only exception I would support is for electric cars, for the purpose of pedestrian safety.