9 ms·
I'm excited that Elon is taking steps to make this happen. Is it a good idea? will it work? will it be as cheap as his team estimated? will it be safe? Will pe
by grecy 12y ago
I'm excited that Elon is taking steps to make this happen.
Is it a good idea? will it work? will it be as cheap as his team estimated? will it be safe? Will people want to ride it? Will terrorists blow it up? Will earthquakes tear it apart? Will it make enough solar power to be self-sustaining?
Nobody knows for certain the answers to those and ten million other questions.
Elon is forging ahead to find out - rather that sitting around nay-saying.
Bravo. I wish there were more people in the world like this.
- NegativeK 12y agoThere's a phrase at one of Chicago's hackerspaces (and probably at many others): Just Fucking Do It. Talk is cheap. Implementation is hard (and more interesting); JFDI. Naysayers will naysay, but a thing that's done is more powerful than "Oh, well, you can't do that because"; JFDI. It also extends to telling people they don't need permission. If it won't be costly (in time or money) for other people to undo, you don't need to ask -- JFDI. Hyperloop seems really weird, but arguing with Elon Musk forging ahead is weirder.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> There's a phrase at one of Chicago's hackerspaces Pumping Station One [+] [+] http://pumpingstationone.org/ http://pumpingstationone.org/
- sigil 12y ago"Fuck it. Ship it." -- Betaworks Variations on a theme. http://www.startupvitamins.com/products/startup-poster-fuck-it-ship-it http://www.startupvitamins.com/products/startup-poster-fuck-...
- conjecTech 12y agops1?
- grecy 12y agoJFDI - I like that a lot. Thanks. I'm going to add more JFDI to my life.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- NegativeK 12y agoExtend it to how you interact with other people and it'll do weird (good) things. It's really easy to tell other people that they're doing something wrong, or that they should do something you want. If you expect them to say JFDI back, you'll start out with the opinion that their time is worth quite a bit.
- FlailFast 12y agoCan we call the conscious cultivation of this attitude the JFDI Mind Trick? :)
- julsonl 12y agoJust Effin Do It?
- thatsdeep 12y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/im14andthisisdeep/ https://www.reddit.com/r/im14andthisisdeep/
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Florin_Andrei 12y agoI agree with the sentiment, but in this case only someone with pockets as deep as Elon's can afford to JFDI.
- NegativeK 12y agoOf course. But if Elon Musk paid for a proposal and then said "Wellllll, someone else should build the prototype", he'd get a "JFDI".
- bane 12y agoThere's another related one: Get Shit Done (GSD). I suppose you could combine them to Just Fucking Get Shit Done JFGSD
- andrewchambers 12y agoI don't see how terrorists are any more of a threat than they are to any other rail line. Air flowing into the hyperloop due to a tunnel breach can be detected and signal all cars to stop automatically.
- threeseed 12y agoI agree. Terrorism is a ridiculously stupid argument to not do something. It's not like building skyscrapers and apartment complexes has ceased because of 9/11.
- seanflyon 12y agoI am almost universally opposed to the position that you would do something great, but are too afraid of terrorists, so I agree with your sentiment. That said, the faster you are going the harder it is to stop. I would much rather be in a conventional train heading towards a break in the tracks than in a hyperloop heading towards a break.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoIsn't Hyperloop a fail-safe design? If you blow a hole in it, the whole thing will start pressurizing and the air friction would slow things down fast (AFAIR pods ain't that aerodynamic, so as long as you shut down that powered air intake in front, it they'll be as aerodynamic as bricks).
- steffan 12y agoI'm sure that emergency friction braking could be implemented along with other aerodynamic measures to brake the pods at a rate probably only limited by the human occupants. More importantly, (never say never, but...) this will not actually be a high-value target for terrorism; the individual pods don't hold enough people to make for a significant death toll, the tube itself being of a uniform construction would be relatively easy to repair, and the system itself doesn't really hold any political or cultural significance of note. Keep in mind that it would have to compete with far more valuable targets as well - the ever-popular White House, Pentagon, various national airlines as well as soft but high profile targets like shopping malls, stadiums, movie theaters. The risk of terrorism for this mode of transportation is actually less than many others.
- erispoe 12y agoIt is cheap because it doesn't account for the hard part of building HSR: buying land, clearing legal hurdles, and indemnizing landowners. I would be happy to see Elon Musk come with a solution for that. We could use some creativity here.
- patcon 12y agoRight now it's politically, legally, and technologically uncertain. The first two are affected greatly by the last one, so I think this is the correct order of operations.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> It is cheap because it doesn't account for the hard part of building HSR: buying land, clearing legal hurdles, and indemnizing landowners. Also, because the termini proposed are not particularly close to the urban centers it is supposed to connect, avoiding the expense of connecting from where people actually are to where people are actually likely to want to go. Of course, that also limits its utility for its intended purpose.